Petition Seeks FDA Approval To Speak The
Truth
PETITION
June 20, 2003
| PETITIONERS: |
Wellness Lifestyles, Inc. and Life Extension Foundation
Buyers Club, Inc. |
| ADDRESS: |
c/o Emord & Associates, P.C.
5282 Lyngate Court
Burke, VA 22015 |
| SUBJECT: |
Petition for Amended Health Claim: Omega-3 Fatty Acids
and Coronary Heart Disease |
Food and Drug Administration
Office of Nutritional Products, Labeling, and Dietary
Supplements
HFS-800
5100 Paint Branch Parkway
College Park, MD 20740 |
Introduction and Statement of
Purpose
The undersigned, Wellness Lifestyles, Inc. and Life
Extension Foundation Buyers Club, Inc. (hereinafter
"Petitioners"), submit this petition pursuant to Sections
403(r)(3) and (r)(5)(D) of the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic
Act ("FDCA") (21 U.S.C. §§ 343(r)(3) and (r)(5)(D)
with respect to the relationship between the consumption of
omega-3 fatty acids [1] and coronary heart disease risk
reduction. Specifically, the Petitioners request that the
disclaimer on the current omega-3 fatty acids/coronary heart
disease health claim be removed. The amended claim is
contained in section V below. Attached hereto, and
constituting a part of this petition, are all of the items
specified in 21 C.F.R. § 101.70(f).
This petition presents a logical and valid evaluation of
the scientific studies and clinical trials published since FDA
allowed a revised version of the claim, [2] first submitted to
FDA by Julian M. Whitaker, M.D., et al. in their November 22,
1999 Comments to FDA (Docket No. 91N-0103), concerning omega-3
fatty acid's effect on reduction in the risk of coronary heart
disease. [3] Omega-3 fatty acids are lipids found in fish and
other marine life such as phytoplankton. See PDR
for Nutritional Supplements (2001) at 145 (Attached as Exhibit
1). They are known to have anti-arrythmic and
anti-inflammatory properties. See id. at
146; See also Exhibit 2 at 13. The mechanism by
which omega-3 fatty acids work in the cardiovascular system
may be attributable to the incorporation of omega-3 fatty
acids into the cell membranes of the heart. See
id. The attached scientific studies demonstrate that
consumption of omega-3 fatty acids, in foods and supplements,
may reduce the incidence of coronary heart disease.
See Exhibits 1 at 145-150. The current
scientific evidence in favor of the claim reveals the
disclaimer now required to be anachronistic and inaccurate.
See Expert Report of Dr. William Connor
(Attached as Exhibit 2). It thus misleads the public and
constitutes an unreasonable burden on protected speech.
See Zauderer v. Office of Disciplinary Counsel
of Supreme Court, 471 U.S. 626, 651 (1985) ("We recognize that
unjustified or unduly burdensome disclosure requirements might
offend the First Amendment by chilling protected commercial
speech."). The current disclaimer states that the scientific
evidence in support of the claim is not conclusive. As
explained below, it is now generally accepted in the
scientific community that omega-3 fatty acids do reduce the
risk of coronary artery disease and the science on the point
has established the risk reducing effected beyond reasonable
doubt. Accordingly, the claim should now be approved by FDA
under the significant scientific agreement standard or, if not
approved, at a minimum allowed without requiring the present
disclaimer.
The amended health claim responds to a major public health
concern in the United States: coronary heart disease [4],
which is a type of cardiovascular disease. [5] 21 C.F.R.
§ 101.75. Coronary heart disease is the leading cause of
death in the United States, with 710,760 deaths in 2000.
See "National Center for Health Statistics,
FASTATS 2000 on Heart Disease," Center for Disease Control, http://www.cdc.gov/nchs/fastats/heart.htm
(last visited June 5, 2003) (Attached as Exhibit 3). In the
U.S., one of every 5 deaths was from coronary heart disease in
2000. See "Heart Disease and Stroke
Statistics-2003 Update," American Heart Association at 12
(Attached as Exhibit 4). Hence, there were 2,400,000 American
deaths in the year 2000, with 1,415,000 of those deaths
attributed to cardiovascular disease. See
id. Of those cardiovascular disease-related deaths,
54% were attributed to coronary heart disease. See
id. at 8. According to the American Heart Association,
nearly 2,600 Americans die of cardiovascular disease each day,
or one death every thirty-three seconds. See
id.
This petition furthers national and HHS policies by
identifying a low cost means to help reduce the risk of
coronary heart disease. In addition, the petition furthers the
recently announced directive of the Office of Management and
Budget ("OMB") to HHS and USDA concerning the health benefits
of omega-3 fatty acids. In OMB's "prompt" letter of May 27,
2003 (Attached as Exhibit 5, wherein Dr. John D. Graham,
Administrator, Office of Information and Regulatory Affairs,
OMB, writes: "Both epidemiologic and clinical studies find
that an increase in consumption of omega-3 fatty acids results
in reduced deaths due to CHD."). Dr. John D. Graham, further
states: "The government should make this life-saving
information as widely available as possible." Id. The
truthful, succinct, and accurate health information conveyed
by the Petitioners' amended health claim will enable consumers
to make prudent and effective dietary choices, cognizant of
omega-3 fatty acids' coronary heart disease risk reducing
effects. Labeling conventional foods and dietary supplements
with the amended omega-3 fatty acids claim will inform
consumers at the point of sale of the strong scientific
evidence now extant concerning dietary means to lessen the
risk of coronary heart disease. [6]
Attached hereto and constituting a part of this petition
are the following:
A. Preliminary Requirements
1. Omega-3 Fatty Acids meet the definition of 21
C.F.R. § 101.14(a)
The Petitioners Seek FDA approval of the amended
claim for use on dietary supplements and foods containing
omega-3 fatty acids. Omega-3 fatty acids in foods and dietary
supplements meet the definition of a "substance" provided by
21 C.F.R. § 101.14(a): "Substance means a specific food
or component of food, regardless of whether the food is in
conventional food form or a dietary supplement that includes
vitamins, minerals, herbs, or other similar nutritional
substances." Omega-3 fatty acids are a group of
polyunsaturated fatty acids ("LCPUFA") comprised of
eicosapenaenoic acid ("EPA"), docosahexaneoic acid ("DHA"),
and linolenic acid ("LNA"). See Exhibit 1 at 145.
Omega-3 fatty acids are found in fish and other marine life.
See id. These fish oils are rich sources of
long-chain polyunsaturated fatty acids of the n-3 (omega-3)
type. See Exhibit 1 at 145. The amount of omega-3 fatty
acids in foods depends on the source, ranging from 0.2 grams
(in flounder) to 3.3 grams (in sardines). See Expert
report of Dr. Mary Enig, submitted to FDA on November 22, 1999
with Whitaker, et al. Comments at 12 reincorporated here by
reference (Attached as Exhibit 6). Of the numerous fish oils
present in cold water fish and other marine life, the two most
studied are: eicosapentaenoic acid (EPA; C20:5n-3) and
docosahexaenoic acid (DHA; C22:6n-3). See Exhibit 1 at
145. EPA contains five double bonds, while DHA contains six
double bonds. All double bonds are in the cis configuration.
See id. EPA and DHA are found naturally in the
form of tiacylglycerols or TAGs. Id. The DHA in the TAGs of
fish oil occurs primarily in the sn-2 position (i.e., the
middle carbon) of glycerol, while the distribution of EPA is
more randomly distributed over all three positions of
glycerol. See id. Omega-3 fatty acids are found
in most cold-water fish (i.e., tuna, salmon and mackerel),
fish oils (i.e., unhydrogenated menhaden oil), and fish liver
oils (i.e., cod liver oil). See Exhibit 6. Omega-3
fatty acids in dietary supplements are most commonly available
from fish liver oil (i.e., cod and shark), herring oil,
menhaden oil, salmon oil, and tuna oil. See id at 13.
The amounts of EPA and DHA vary depending on the fish source.
See id. A more concentrated type of fish oil is
also available in the form of a semi-synthetic ethyl ester
product that contains 85% EPA/DHA. For example, a one gram
ethyl ester capsule contains 490 mg of EPA ethyl ester and 350
mg of DHA ethyl ester. See Exhibit 1 at 149.
Thus, omega-3 fatty acids found in foods and dietary
supplements are a "substance" as defined by 21 C.F.R. §
101.14(a).
2. Omega-3 Fatty Acids meet the definition of 21
C.F.R. § 101.14(b)
The proposed health claims meet the relevant eligibility
requirements of 21 C.F.R. § 101.14(b). Section 101.14(b)
requires:
| (b) |
Eligibility. For a substance to be eligible
for a health claim: |
| (1) |
the substance must be associated with a
disease or health-related condition for which the general
U.S. population, or an identified U.S. population subgroup
(e.g., the elderly), is at risk, or, alternatively, the
petition submitted by the proponent of the claim otherwise
explains the prevalence of the disease or health-related
condition in the U.S. population and the relevance of the
claim in the context of the total daily diet and satisfies
the other requirements of this section. |
| (2) |
If the substance is to be consumed as a
component of a conventional food at decreased dietary
levels, the substance must be a nutrient listed in 21 U.S.C.
343(q)(1)(C) or (q)(1)(D), or one that the Food and Drug
Administration (FDA) has required to be included in the
label or labeling under 21 U.S.C. 343(q)(2)(A); or |
| (3) |
If the substance is to be consumed at other
than decreased dietary levels: |
| |
(i) |
The substance must, regardless of whether the food is a
conventional food or a dietary supplement, contribute taste,
aroma, or nutritive value, or any other technical effect
listed in § 170.3(o) of this chapter, to the food and
must retain that attribute when consumed at levels that are
necessary to justify a claim; and |
| |
(ii) |
The substance must be a food or a food ingredient or a
component of a food ingredient whose use at the levels
necessary to justify a claim has been demonstrated by the
proponent of the claim, to FDA's satisfaction, to be safe
and lawful under the applicable food safety provisions of
the Federal Food, Drug and Cosmetic Act. |
a. Omega-3 Fatty Acids are associated with a
disease affecting the general U.S. population
A "disease or health-related condition" means "damage to an
organ, part, structure, or system of the body such that it
does not function properly (e.g. cardiovascular disease), or a
state of health leading to such dysfunctioning (e.g.
hypertension); except that diseases resulting from essential
nutrient deficiencies (e.g., scurvy, pellagra) are not
included in this definition (claims pertaining to such
diseases are thereby not subject to § 101.13 or §
101.70)." 21 C.F.R. § 101.14(a)(5). The amended health
claim associates the substance, omega-3 fatty acids, with
reduction in the risk of coronary heart disease, a disease,
and states its anti-arrythmic activity.
Coronary heart disease is a cardiovascular disease
characterized by narrowing of the coronary arteries, which
prevents adequate amounts of blood and oxygen from reaching
the heart. [7] See "Coronary Heart Disease Explained,"
National Institutes of Health. http://nhlbisupport.com/chd1/chdexp.htm
(last visited June 9, 2003) (Attached as Exhibit 7). When the
heart is deprived of oxygen-carrying blood angina or heart
attack can result. See id. Coronary heart
disease is caused by both controllable factors (high blood
pressure, high cholesterol, smoking, obesity, physical
inactivity, and diabetes) and uncontrollable factors (gender,
heredity, and age). See "Facts about Coronary Heart
Disease," National Institutes of Health,
http://www.nhlbi.nih.gov/health/public/heart/other/chdfacts.htm
(last visited June 9, 2003) (Attached as Exhibit 8). Causal
factors may act together or in sequence to initiate or promote
the onset of coronary heart disease. See id.
Cardiovascular disease is the leading cause of death in the
United States. See Exhibits 3 5, 6 and 7.
Cardiovascular disease has been the number one killer in the
United States every year since 1900, with the exception of one
year: 1918. See Exhibit 4 at 5. In the U.S., one of
every 2.5 deaths is from cardiovascular disease. See
id. at 8. In 1997, fifteen million new cases of heart
disease were diagnosed. See Exhibit 3. In 2000, about
764,100 deaths were attributed to coronary heart disease, more
than 2,093 deaths per day. See Exhibit 4 at 5.
The National Heart, Blood, and Lung Institute estimates that
the direct and indirect costs for cardiovascular disease in
the year 2003 will be $351.8 billion. See Exhibit 4 at
5. The American Heart Association reports that in 1999, $26.3
billion in payments were made to Medicare beneficiaries for
hospital expenditures related to cardiovascular problems.
See id. at 7, citing Personal communication with
the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, 2002. In 1998,
$10.6 billion was paid to Medicare beneficiaries for coronary
heart disease alone ($10,428 per discharge for acute
myocardial infarction; $11,399 per discharge for coronary
atherosclerosis; and $3,617 per discharge for other coronary
heart disease claims). See id. at 12, citing
"Health Care Financing Review, Statistical Supplement [2000],"
Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services. Consequently,
reduction in coronary heart disease risk is a health and
economic policy necessity for the United States.
b. Omega-3 fatty acids contribute nutritive
value at the levels present in supplements
In accordance with section 101.14(b)(3)(i), omega-3 fatty
acids contribute nutritive value. While there is no Reference
Daily Intake (DRI) for omega-3 fatty acids, the nutritive
contribution of omega-3 fatty acids is widely recognized.
See Exhibits. 1-2 and 6. The PDR for Nutritional
Supplements includes anti-arrythmic and triglyceride-lowering
activities among omega-3 fatty acids' actions and states that
omega-3 fatty aicds may also have anti-inflammatory,
anti-thrombotic, and immunomodulatory activities. See
Exhibit 1 at 145; Exhibit 2 at 13.
Omega-3 fatty acids are naturally occurring lipids found in
fish and other marine life. See Exhibit 1 at 145.
Although the amount of EPA/DHA in foods and in dietary
supplements varies, omega-3 fatty acids from supplements have
been reported to be as bioavailable in humans as foods
containing omega-3 fatty acids. See Exhibit 1 at 147.
The amended health claim does not identify specific intake
quantities for omega-3 fatty acids. Studies have measured
omega-3 fatty acids supplementation to have nutritive value
from 200 mg to 28 grams a day. See Exhibits 2 and 6.
Omega-3 fatty acids are typically supplied in solid oral
dosage form in capsules containing 400 mg, 500 mg, 1000 mg,
1200 mg, or 2000 mg. See Exhibit 1 at 149. As mentioned
above, the omega-3 fatty acids content of food depends upon
the type of fish or marine life with per serving amounts
varying from 0.2 grams to 3.3 grams.
c. Omega-3 Fatty Acids are safe and lawful under
the FDCA
"For each such ingredient listed, the petitioner should
state how the ingredient complies with the requirements of
§ 101.14(b)(3)(ii), e.g., that its use is generally
recognized as safe (GRAS), listed as a food additive, or
authorized by a prior sanction issued by the agency, and what
the basis is for the GRAS claim, the food additive status, or
prior sanctioned status." 21 C.F.R. § 101.70(f)(A). In
accordance with section 101.13(b)(3)(ii), omega-3 fatty acids
are both a food and food ingredient and are safe and lawful at
the levels necessary to reduce the risk of coronary heart
disease. As mentioned above, omega-3 fatty acids are an
ingredient of common foods such as cold water fish and other
marine life (i.e., plankton). The FDCA deems dietary
supplements a food under 21 U.S.C. § 321(ff).
Accordingly, omega-3 fatty acids are both a food and a food
ingredient under 21 C.F.R. § 101.14(b)(3)(ii).
Omega-3 fatty acids are generally recognized as safe and
lawful at the levels necessary to reduce the risk of coronary
heart disease. General recognition of safety is based on the
views of experts qualified by scientific training and
experience to evaluate the safety of substances directly or
indirectly added to food. See 21 C.F.R. §
170.30(a). The basis for such views may be either (1)
scientific procedure or (2) in the case of a substance used in
food prior to January 1, 1958, through experience based on
common use in food. Id.
| Safe or safety means that there is a
reasonable certainty in the minds of competent scientists
that the substance is not harmful under the intended
conditions of use. It is impossible in the present state of
scientific knowledge to establish with complete certainty
the absolute harmlessness of the use of any substance.
Safety may be determined by scientific procedures or by
general recognition of safety. In determining safety, the
following factors shall be considered: |
| (1) |
the probable consumption of the substance and of any
substance formed in or on food because of its use. |
| (2) |
The cumulative effect of the substance in the diet,
taking into account any chemically or pharmacologically
related substance or substances in such diet. |
| (3) |
Safety factors which, in the opinion of experts
qualified by scientific training and experience to evaluate
the safety of food and food ingredients, are generally
recognized as appropriate. |
21 C.F.R. § 170.3(i).
Omega-3 fatty acids have been a naturally occurring
ingredient in foods consumed in the United States prior to
January 1, 1958. There is no evidence that omega-3 fatty acids
consumed either in foods or as dietary supplements have a
cumulative effect in the diet that is unsafe. See
Exhibit 1 at 149. Interactions may occur between omega-3 fatty
acid supplements and aspirin and other non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs and herbs (i.e., garlic and ginko
biloba). See Exhibit 1 at 149. The PDR for Nutritional
Supplements states that the most frequently reported adverse
reactions associated with consumption of omega-3 fatty acids
are increased susceptibility to bruising, nosebleeds,
hemoptysis, hematemesis, hematuria and blood in the stool.
See id. Nonetheless, the PDR states that most
people who consume omega-3 fatty acids and the above-named
drugs and herbs do not suffer from serious adverse reactions.
See id. [8] The PDR indicates no
contraindications associated with consumption of omega-3 fatty
acids. Id.
The maximum (safe) daily intake of omega-3 fatty acids is
generally well above the amount reasonably required to
accomplish the intended nutritive effect. 21 C.F.R. §
172.5. The PDR recommends a safe upper limit for omega-3 fatty
acids of 5 grams a day for those who have had successful
angioplasty and are trying to prevent restenodid; however, a
more conservative upper limit of 3 grams a day is recommended
for hypertensives who have not been previously treated.
See Exhibit 1 at 149. Nutritive effect in reducing the
risk of coronary heart disease has been recorded in daily
doses ranging from 1 to 28 grams per day, with most studies
supplementing at 6 grams per day. See id.;
See also Exhibits 2 and 6. Therefore, the amended
health claim complies with the safety and lawfulness
requirements of 21 C.F.R. § 101.14(b)(3)(ii).
In summary, since omega-3 fatty acids meet the requirements
set forth in 21 C.F.R. § 101.14(b), the preliminary
requirements of 21 C.F.R. § 101.70 are fully
satisfied.
B. Summary of Scientific Data Supporting the
Amended Claim
1. Significant scientific agreement exists to
support the amended claim
There is significant scientific agreement among experts who
study the effect of omega-3 fatty acids on coronary heart
disease that omega-3 fatty acids are an effective modifier of
the risk of coronary heart disease. See Exhibit 2 at 1;
Exhibit 6 at 11. The scientific literature shows that omega-3
fatty acids have triglyceride lowering, anti-arrhythmic,
anti-inflammatory and anti-thrombotic effects. See
Exhibit 1 at 145; Exhibit 2 at 13; Exhibit 6 at 11.
Although the mechanism of omega-3 fatty acids'
anti-arrythmic activity is not entirely clear, it has been
shown definitively to have beneficial physiological and
biochemical effects, such as: triglyceride lowering, raising
heart rate variability and reducing fatal arrythmias.
See Exhibit 1 at 146; and Exhibit 6 at 10-11. Omega-3
fatty acids have the ability to: (1) decrease adversely high
levels of triglycerides and very low density lipoproteins
(thus decreasing the risk of coronary heart disease, (2)
increase heart rate variability and thereby decrease the risk
of sudden death from heart attack, and (3) help prevent second
heart attack in individuals who have sustained a first heart
attack. See id. Human clinical trials and
epidemiological studies are discussed in the following
section.
2. Scientific evidence demonstrates the public
health benefits of Omega-3 fatty acids
Since 1999, when FDA requested comments on the relationship
between omega-3 fatty acids and coronary heart disease,
several major studies have been published that support the
claim and render the present required disclaimer unnecessary
and inaccurate. Since 2000, eight human clinical trials have
evaluated the effects of omega-3 fatty acids consumption on
the incidence of coronary heart disease. The most supportive
studies are the Harvard Physicians' Study and the Nurses'
Health Study. See Exhibit 2 at 2. Those studies
released reports last year concerning the effects of omega-3
fatty acids and the risk of sudden death and coronary heart
disease. See id. In that report, baseline blood
levels of long-chain n-3 fatty acids were inversely related to
the risk of sudden death. See id. Hence, there
was a reduced risk of sudden death in men who had higher blood
levels of n-3 fatty acids (EPA and DHA). Similar results were
found in the Nurses' Health Study. In that report, higher
intakes of omega-3 fatty acids lowered the risk of coronary
hear disease, especially for coronary heart disease deaths.
See id. at 3.
The next important clinical trial was the GISSI-PREVENZIONE
trial, which was a large clinical trial conducted on patients
who had experienced a myocardial infarction. See
id. at 4. The study was originally conducted in 1999;
however, it was reanalyzed in 2002. In that report, Marchioli,
et al. concluded that "the risk of sudden death was
significantly prevented by only three months of treatment with
fish oil and there was a 67% reduction in overall deaths." Id.
Hence, the benefits obtained from consumption of fish oil are
profound.
Earlier this year, the Cardiovascular Health Study of
Seattle, Washington, published its findings. The
population-based prospective cohort study followed 3,910
adults over the course of 9.5 years. See id. at
5. Mozaffarian, et al. found that "there was a 49% lower risk
of ischemic heart disease deaths and a 48% lower risk of
arrhythmic deaths among persons consuming tuna/other fish
three or more times per week compared to those consuming less
than once per month." Id. Thus, increased fish consumption
directly corresponds to decreased incidence of coronary heart
disease.
A review published in 2003 on behalf of the Nutrition
Committee of the American Heart Association made the following
recommendations: (1) patients without coronary heart disease
should consume a variety of preferably oily fish at least
twice per week and include foods rich in alpha linolenic acid
as well; (2) patients with documented coronary heart disease
should consume 1 gm of EPA plus DHA per day, preferably from
oily fish or supplements in consultation with a physician; and
(3) patients who need plasma triglyceride lowering should
consume 2-4 gm of EPA plus DHA per day, provided as fish oil
capsules under a physician's care. See id. at
6.
In addition, eight recent animal studies corroborate the
findings of the clinical trials. Id. at 11. Those animal
studies have shown the anti-arrhythmic effects of omega-3
fatty acids and conclude that "fish oil fatty acids are a
powerful but simple modality to prevent the 300,000 episodes
of sudden death occurring in the United States annually." Id.
at 12. The most important animal study conclusively found that
consumption of n-3 PUFA improved ventricular function by
reducing the oxygen required to produce a given work output.
See id. at 8
3. Scientific Summary Issues
a. Is there an optimum level of omega-3 fatty acids to
be consumed beyond which no benefit would be
expected?
Clinical trials have tested omega-3 fatty acids'
effectiveness with doses up to 28 grams per day. See
e.g., Exhibit 6 at 11. There is no evidence of an optimum
level of omega-3 fatty acids to be consumed beyond which no
benefit is expected.
b. Is there any level at which an adverse effect from
the substance or from foods containing the substance occurs
for any segment of the population?
There are no serious adverse events reported in conjunction
with consumption of omega-3 fatty acids supplements, even up
to 15 grams per day of omega-3 fatty acids for prolonged
periods of time. See Exhibit 1 at 149. Mild side
effects, such as: nausea, diarrhea, halitosis, eructation and
"fishy" smelling breath, skin and urine, have been reported.
See id. [9]
c. Are there certain populations that must receive
special consideration?
The PDR for Nutritional Supplements cautions that children,
diabetics, pregnant women and nursing mothers should consult a
physician before taking omega-3 fatty acids supplements.
See Exhibit 1 at 148.
d. What other nutritional or health factors (both
positive and negative) are important to consider when
consuming the substance?
Interactions may occur between omega-3 fatty acids
supplements and aspirin and other non-steroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs and herbs. See id. Those
interactions are rare, however, and are eliminated with a
lower dose amount of omega-3 fatty acids supplementation.
See id.
4. Potential effect of the use of the amended claim
on food consumption, including significant alterations in
eating habits and corresponding changes in nutrient
intakes
The amended claim may increase public intake of omega-3
fatty acids in foods and supplements, including by populations
at greater risk of coronary heart disease. The Petitioners do
not believe that the amended claim will have any deleterious
effect on food consumption or eating habits. The only change
in nutrient intake resulting from the amended claim would be
for those who choose to supplement their diets with omega-3
fatty acids. The effect on such people is expected to be
beneficial, reducing the risk of coronary heart disease,
including sudden death heart attacks and saving lives,
potentially as many as three hundred thousand per year.
See Exhibit 2 at 2.
5. Prevalence of the disease or health-related
condition in the U.S. population and the relevance of the
claim in the context of the total daily diet.
As discussed above, the amended health claim responds to a
major public health concern in the United States: the
incidence of and mortality caused by coronary heart disease.
21 C.F.R. § 101.75(b). Cardiovascular disease is the
leading cause of death in the United States. See
Exhibits 3, 5, 9 and 10. In the U.S., one of every 2.5 deaths
is from cardiovascular disease. In 2000, about 764,100 deaths
were attributed to coronary heart disease, more than 2,093
deaths per day. See Exhibit 5 at 5. Most studies have
shown omega-3 fatty acids supplementation to be effective in
coronary heart disease risk reduction at levels of 1-5 grams
per day, depending on the patient's condition. See
Exhibit 1 at 149; See also Exhibits 2 and 6. Thus,
omega-3 fatty acids offer a safe, inexpensive, readily
accessible means for reducing the risk of coronary heart
disease population wide.
C. Analytical Method
The amount of omega-3 fatty acids contained in a food or
dietary supplement that may be a candidate for bearing the
revised health claim can be ascertained by several gas
chromatography methods, including: the Association of Official
Analytical Chemists' (AOAC) Official Method #991.39: "Fatty
Acids in Encapsulated Fish Oils and Fish Oil Methyl and Ethyl
Esters." See Exhibit 9. The assay method described in
Exhibit 9 is applicable to finished products.
D. Proposed Amended Health
Claim
Petitioners propose that the approved model claim for
omega-3 fatty acids be amended by removing the disclaimer. The
claim would read as follows:
Consumption of omega-3 fatty acids may reduce the
risk of coronary heart disease.
Multiple studies have shown that consumption of omega-3
fatty acid-rich foods and dietary supplements reduce the risk
of coronary heart disease. Moreover, recent clinical trials
have proven to a near conclusive degree its safety and
efficacy for use by the general population.
E. Attachments
Attached are copies of the scientific studies (Exhibit 10)
and other information referenced in, and constituting the
basis for, this Petition. To the best of the Petitioners'
knowledge, all non-clinical studies relied upon were conducted
in compliance with the good laboratory practices regulations
set forth in 21 C.F.R. Part 58, and all clinical or other
human investigations relied upon were either conducted in
accordance with the requirements for institutional review set
forth at 21 C.F.R. Part 56 or were not subject to such
requirements in accordance with 21 C.F.R. § 56.104 or
56.105, and were conducted in conformance with the
requirements for informed consent set forth in 21 C.F.R.
§ 50 eq seq. See generally, 21 C.F.R. § 101.7
(c)-(d).
F. Environmental Impact
The requested health claim approval contained in this
petition is categorically excluded from the environmental
impact statement under 21 C.F.R. § 25.24.
G. Conclusion and Certification
For the foregoing reasons, the Petitioners request that the
FDA approve the amended health claim.
Any questions concerning this Petition may be directed to
Jonathan W. Emord, Esq. Emord & Associates, P.C., 5282
Lyngate Court, Burke, VA 22015, (202) 466-6937.
The undersigned certify on behalf of the Petitioners that,
to the best of their knowledge and belief, the Petition
includes all information and views on which the Petitioners
rely and is a representative and balanced submission that
includes unfavorable information as well as favorable
information known by the Petitioners to be pertinent to
evaluation of the proposed health claims.
| |
Sincerely, |
| |
WELLNESS LIFESTYLES, INC., |
| AND |
LIFE EXTENSION FOUNDATION BUYERS CLUB, INC. |
| |
By:___________________________ |
| |
Jonathan W. Emord
Andrea G. Ferrenz
Kathryn E. Balmford
Its Counsel |
Emord & Associates, P.C.
5282 Lyngate Court
Burke, VA 22015
P: (202) 466-6937
F: (202) 466-4938
Email: jemord@emord.com
Date submitted: June 23, 2003 |
|
|