Aug. 26--Despite the many chemotherapy drugs for ovarian cancer, none is fully
effective, which means the cancer commonly recurs. That poses challenges for
physicians, who must use knowledgeable guesswork to figure out a drug strategy
for each patient.
"With ovarian cancer, when it recurs, the best way to use the drugs is not well
defined," said Thomas C. Krivak, director of gynecologic oncology research at
Allegheny Health Network. "Some will use different combinations. If you have
three doctors, you will get three different combinations."
But in a step toward personalized medicine, a South Side company's test known as
ChemoFx analyzes chemotherapy-drug effectiveness on a patient's live cancer
cells to help identify the drug regimen with the best potential to fight the
Patients generally survive longer when the cancer is sensitive rather than
resistant to chemotherapeutic drugs. Unfortunately, in many types of cancer the
response rate is often about 25 percent. The challenge is determining cancer
sensitivity prior to treatment. While the test, developed by Precision
Therapeutics Inc., has been available for years, it's been unclear whether it
That is, until now.
A study published online in the journal Gynecologic Oncology shows that ChemoFx
-- approved for laboratory prognostic use and covered by Medicare -- is
effective in extending the lives of patients with ovarian cancer by 14 months.
That represents a 65 percent improvement in overall survival. Essentially, the
test was able to predict whether ovarian-cancer patients would live longer if
they took a particular chemotherapy.
The study, which involved Dr. Krivak, concludes that ChemoFx may be used as "a
very useful tool for optimizing treatment selection when there are multiple
clinically acceptable and equivalent treatments available."
If doctors can determine what chemotherapy drugs the patient's cancer cells
respond to, once the cancer returns, they can narrow treatment options and spare
the patient ineffective, toxic treatments that bring unwanted side effects, the
study indicates. It also would provide new treatment options for many more
patients. As the study says, the test can "assist clinicians in the optimal
prioritization of therapy."
The gist of the study, Dr. Krivak said, is that ChemoFx can be used to provide
better treatments for patients with ovarian cancer and extend their lives.
Live-cell samples from a biopsy, once sent to Precision's laboratory, undergo a
five-step process involving robotic automation. Cells are grown, then treated
with commonly used chemotherapies to determine sensitivity or resistance. A
report sent to the physician details which drugs or drug combinations were
The study involved 262 patients from 2004 to 2011 whose ovarian cancer had
recurred, with 55 percent whose cancers were sensitive and 45 percent whose
cancers were resistant to platinum-based chemotherapy drugs during the initial
round of treatment. Resistance and sensitivity are based on whether the cancer
returned earlier or later than six months.
Use of ChemoFx demonstrated improved progression-free survival and overall
survival for patients, regardless of whether they were judged to be sensitive or
resistant to platinum-based therapies, the study concludes.
"These are definitive results in a clinical study over an eight-year period and
involving more than 30 institutions nationally," said Sean McDonald, Precision
president and CEO. "Basically it showed that through the use of this test,
physicians can find the best therapy, and women lived 65 percent longer."
Robert W. Holloway, director of gynecologic oncology at Florida Hospital Cancer
Institute in Orlando, said the study doesn't mean outcomes for each future
patient automatically will improve, but it strongly suggests that choosing
sensitive drug therapy for the first treatment following cancer recurrence
"significantly improves survival, rather than selecting drugs purely based on
"When a less effective regimen is chosen first, the patient may progress with
symptomatic recurrences more quickly, decline in overall health faster and be
unable to try other therapies that could achieve short-term responses or disease
stabilization," he said.
The recurrence of ovarian cancer usually results in reduced quality of life
through bowel dysfunction, pain and an inability to maintain proper nutrition,
leading to generalized weakness and death.
"Getting a quick response [after the cancer recurs] means the patient might live
to fight another battle another day, hopefully in another year," said Dr.
Holloway, who did not participate in the study. "Losing the first battle of
recurrence often means cutting the war short."
With the test long approved for use, Mr. McDonald said the company has tested
more than 24,000 gynecological specimens sent to the lab by 1,500 doctors in the
past 2 1/2 years. "On average, when we receive a biopsy, the doc sends a list of
drugs he or she is considering, often nine or 10 chemotherapies."
For ovarian cancer, there are more than 20 approved chemotherapy drugs, "none of
which works particularly well, which clearly makes therapy decisions even more
complex for the physician and the patient," he said, noting the test's ability
to personalize the treatment for the patient's unique cancer.
The company is developing similar tests for lung and colon cancer with
confidence that "this technology will work across a wide range of cancers," Mr.
Fredric Price, West Penn Allegheny Health System director of gynecologic
oncology, said he's been using the test for several years to reduce patient
exposure to toxic drugs that aren't effective.
"I've been using it for decision-making but without much long-term data" on
whether the test was bringing improved outcomes, he said. "Now that we are
seeing the results ... we can see that it might make a difference."
Information obtained from tumor cells allows the physician to "tailor the
treatment to the patient's own biology."
"I've been waiting for this data to come out before using the test on a regular
basis," Dr. Price said. "I've been hoping that this information would come out.
There is value to it."
The holy grail in gynecological cancers remains early detection, which would
improve outcomes. That's yet to happen. But the test does mark an improvement in
cancer care, Dr. Price said.
"I would say these are cancers with a high likelihood of recurrence, but there
are more longtime survivors," he said.
Dr. Krivak said the hope is to turn ovarian cancer into a chronic rather than
"It's baby steps in cancer or a series of baby steps in finding the best
targeted chemotherapy," he said. "But this is one of the first steps in
customized patient care."
David Templeton: email@example.com or 412-263-1578.
(c)2013 the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette
Visit the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette at www.post-gazette.com
Distributed by MCT Information Services