| 
Cardiovascular Disease: Comprehensive
Analysis
Cardiovascular disease is rarely caused by a single frailty. Rather,
it is a multifaceted failure that includes physical, psychological, and
genetic weaknesses. Since cardiovascular disease remains the number one
killer in Western societies, there is more published scientific information
about its prevention and treatment than exists for other diseases. Overlooking
just one risk factor, such as elevated levels of C-reactive protein, fibrinogen,
or homocysteine, could lead to the development or worsening of the heart
and/or vascular disease. The Cardiovascular Disease protocol is the most
comprehensive chapter in this book; we urge persons concerned with the
disease to study the chapter carefully. This comprehensive analysis of
cardiovascular disease could be a book in and of itself. If you prefer
to review a more succinct version, refer to the protocol entitled Cardiovascular
Disease: Overview.
At least 68 million people in the United States suffer from some form
of heart disease, with an estimated 1.1 million Americans annually experiencing
an acute myocardial infarction (MI or heart attack). According to current
statistics released from the American Heart Association, cardiovascular
disease accounts for about 950,000 deaths annually (about 41% of total
mortality from all causes); coronary heart disease accounts for 460,000
of those deaths. In fact, one person dies every 33 seconds from heart
disease, culminating in about 2600 deaths every single day. Additionally,
the scope of this insidious health problem is worldwide. Globally, cardiovascular
disease accounts for almost 50% of all deaths (GSDL 2002).
Researchers reporting in the American Journal of Critical Care further
unsettled the scientific community when they declared that 50% of patients
with coronary artery disease do not have any of the traditional risk factors
(Futterman et al. 1998). In fact, 50% of all individuals 50 years or younger
who die from heart disease succumb without any established signs of heart
disease. Does this mean that traditional risk factors are no longer valid?
The intent of this material is to answer that question by providing a
comprehensive review of contemporary and novel risk factors that contribute
to cardiovascular disease and a complete dialogue regarding treatment
options available to patients.
| Traditional Risk and Predictive
Factors |
- Baldness
- Earlobe creases
- Smoking
- Hypertension
- Obesity
- Diabetes
- Thyroid disease
|
- Deranged lipids
- Stress
- Inherited weaknesses
- Gender susceptibility
- Sedentary lifestyle
- Gum disease
- Iron overload
|
BALDNESS
Male-pattern baldness is a subject of interest in regard to the incidence
of coronary heart disease (CHD). The Department of Medicine at Harvard
Medical School and Brigham and Women's Hospital conducted an 11-year study
involving 22,071 male physicians to determine the relationship between
baldness and CHD (Lotufo et al. 2000). The study evaluated the following
patterns of hair growth: no hair loss, frontal baldness only, and frontal
baldness with mild, moderate, or severe vertex balding. (Vertex refers
to the top of the head.) The Harvard study concluded that the risk of
CHD increased progressively throughout the different groups, with vertex
balding showing the greatest association. Vertex baldness appears to be
a valid marker for an increased risk of coronary heart disease, particularly
when clustered with other factors such as hypertension or hypercholesterolemia
(high cholesterol).
EARLOBE CREASES
About 1973, the association between diagonal earlobe creases and the
threat of an eventual heart attack was made. Chronic circulatory problems
allow the vascular bed in the earlobe to collapse and the telltale earlobe
crease to appear. More than 30 studies have been recorded in medical literature,
with one involving 264 patients from a university-based coronary care
unit or a catheterization laboratory who were followed for 10 years. Researchers
concluded that after adjusting for other risk factors, the presence of
a unilateral earlobe crease was associated with a 33% increase in the
risk of a heart attack; the risk increased to 77% when the earlobe crease
appeared bilaterally (Elliott et al. 1996).
Diagonal earlobe creases, appearing at a 45° downward angle toward
the shoulder, are a better predictor of sudden death from a heart attack
than age, smoking, obesity, elevated cholesterol levels, or a sedentary
lifestyle, particularly before the age of 80. The predictive value of
the diagonal earlobe crease does not apply to Asians, Native Americans,
or children with Beckwith's syndrome (a heredity disorder associated with
neonatal hypoglycemia and hyperinsulinism) (Elliott 1983). While earlobe
creases do not prove heart disease, the Mayo Clinic announced that out
of 121 patients, the earlobe crease plus symptoms of heart attack (i.e.,
chest pain) meant a heart attack about 90% of the time. Similar symptoms,
but without the earlobe crease, terminated in a noncoronary diagnosis
90% of the time (Pearson et al. 1982).
SMOKING
Kentucky and Tennessee have not only the highest rates of heart disease
deaths, but also the highest rates of cigarette smoking. Prolonged exposure
to cigarette smoke, either direct or secondhand, increases the risk of
dying from a heart attack or complications arising from atherosclerosis
by three- to fivefold. Much of the ill-omened health effects related to
smoking occur due to an increase in free-radical activity. Unfortunately,
as the population of free radicals increases, vitamin C (a powerful antioxidant)
decreases in the smoker.
The following reactions define the hardship cigarette smoking imposes
upon the cardiovascular system: increased heart rate (one cigarette can
increase the heart rate 20-25 beats a minute); disrupted circulation to
the legs and feet (it takes 6 hours for the circulation to return to normal
after just one cigarette); an increased need for oxygen; insulin resistance;
hypertension; and higher levels of adrenaline. Note: Smoking doubles the
blood levels of adrenaline. This results in vasoconstriction and platelet
aggregation, increasing the risk of both heart attacks and strokes.
Earl Mindell, R.Ph., Ph.D., warns that smokers have higher levels of
fibrinogen (Mindell 1998). Fibrinogen is necessary for the proper clotting
of blood, but abnormally high levels of fibrinogen can cause blood clots
to form spontaneously. It is judged that smoking accounts for half of
the vascular risks attributable to fibrinogen.
Cigarettes contain toxic substances (there are 4000 poisons in tobacco),
some of which inactivate vitamin B6, a nutrient extremely important in
homocysteine control. Homocysteine management is typically difficult in
smokers (consult Newer Risk Factors in this protocol for a complete discussion
regarding homocysteine; the Therapeutic Section of this protocol outlines
a detailed strategy to reduce homocysteine levels).
The Lancet added to the concerns surrounding smokers when it reported
that men with the lowest serum albumin levels have the highest rate of
death from various causes, including heart disease (Schatz et al. 2001).
Smoking lowers this predictive protein (Mindell 1998).
Data published in the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA),
indicate that the critical phase of cardiovascular disease is significantly
accelerated in smokers. The critical phase is marked by 60% coverage of
arterial surfaces with atheromatous materials. Although the ages were
hypothetically assigned, a smoker with normal blood pressure and cholesterol
levels reaches the critical phase 10 years earlier than the nonsmoker
and 20 years earlier if the smoker is also hypertensive (Grundy 1986).
It is estimated that each cigarette steals 8 minutes of life from a
smoker. This means that an individual smoking one pack a day loses a month
of life each year. Two packs clip 12-16 years off the life expectancy
of a lifetime smoker (Goldberg 1999).
However, it is important for a smoker to realize that the body has an
immense capacity for restoration. Within 24 hours of being tobacco-free,
the chance of heart attack decreases. Within 48 hours, nerve endings start
to regroup and breathing becomes noticeably improved. Within 2-3 months,
circulation improves and walking becomes easier. Lung capacity increases
up to 30% and energy levels rebound. After 1 year, the risk of a heart
attack is 50% less than the individual still smoking; within 2 years,
the risk of heart attack drops to ranges closely rivaling an individual
who has never smoked. Another bonus occurs as inflammation is reduced
and subsequently C-reactive protein (CRP), a newer cardiovascular risk
factor (discussed later in this protocol), decreases.
Although the body is resilient, it is extremely important that the smoker
not wait too long to embark upon recovery. For information pertaining
to nutrients that offer protection to a smoker, turn to the Bromelain,
Coenzyme Q10, Curcumin, Proanthocyanidins, Vitamin C, and Vitamin E subsections
in the Therapeutic section of this protocol.
HYPERTENSION
Hypertension, observed more in men and African Americans, is a disorder
characterized by blood pressure persistently exceeding 140/90 mmHg. Current
research indicates that an optimal blood pressure is below 120/80 mmHg.
It is important to note that damage to the vasculature can occur when
the blood pressure is moderately but chronically elevated. Some individuals
may not realize they are hypertensive because symptoms such as epistaxis
(nosebleed), tinnitus, dizziness, headache, blurred vision, and arrhythmias
are not always present.
Dr. Charles DeCarli (University of Kansas) found that men who had even
mildly elevated blood pressure 25 years earlier now have abnormal brain
signals and suffer from vascular disease and strokes more often than men
who had normal blood pressure in midlife. "Take care of risk factors
when you're young or they'll come back to haunt you," warns DeCarli.
The Archives of Internal Medicine reported the results of the most comprehensive
study to date, evaluating 10,874 Chicago men (ages 18-39 from 1967-1973)
concerning the long-term effects of high blood pressure. About 62% of
those studied had either high-normal blood pressure (systolic pressure
130-139 and diastolic pressure 85-89) or Stage I hypertension (systolic
pressure 140-159 and diastolic pressure 90-99).
Individuals with a high-normal blood pressure had a 34% increased risk
of dying from coronary heart disease and those with Stage I hypertension
a 50% higher risk. Life expectancy was shortened by 2.2 years for men
with high-normal blood pressure and by 4.1 years for those with Stage
I hypertension. Dr. David A. Meyerson (Johns Hopkins cardiologist and
spokesman for the American Heart Association) said the Chicago study affirms
the need for a population-wide effort for health promotion by lifestyle
modification; the commitment should begin early in life and continue lifelong.
Since the lifetime risk for hypertension among middle-aged and elderly
individuals is 90%, corrective intervention (at an earlier age) could
relieve a huge public health burden (Miura et al. 2001; Vasan et al. 2002).
Findings in the New England Journal of Medicine (exploring the role
of moderately elevated blood pressure as a forerunner of heart disease)
concurred with the results gathered from the Chicago hypertension trial
(Vasan 2001). The parameters describing moderately elevated blood pressure
were identical in both trials, that is, a systolic pressure of 130-139,
a diastolic blood pressure of 85-89, or both. The researchers tracked
6859 participants, noting a stepwise increase in cardiovascular events
among persons with higher base line blood pressure. Thus, the results
of various credible studies demonstrate that high-normal blood pressure
should not be taken lightly; a regime to counter even a slight rise in
blood pressure (exceeding optimal-normal levels) should be regarded as
essential to reducing cardiovascular risk.
Diastolic or Systolic: Which Poses
the
Greater Risk?
For decades it was thought that the diastolic (the lower blood pressure)
was the most critical measurement when diagnosing hypertension and assessing
blood pressure-induced vascular damage. The journal Hypertension renounced
this theory, reporting that systolic pressure is the crucial assessment,
not the diastolic, as previously considered (Izzo et al. 2000). (Systolic
pressure represents the maximum force exerted by the heart against the
blood vessels during the heart's pumping phase.) The difference between
the systolic and diastolic blood pressure is referred to as pulse pressure;
if the number chronically exceeds 60, advanced atherosclerosis is usually
present.
Types of Hypertension
While most cases of high blood pressure are classed as essential or primary
hypertension (meaning no known cause can be found for the elevation),
it is a misnomer to imply that unfounded hypertension is innocent. Any
sustained elevation of blood pressure can affect the intima (innermost
structure) of small blood vessels, the brain, the retina, the kidneys,
and the heart.
Secondary hypertension is frequently linked to primary diseases, such
as renal, pulmonary, endocrine, and vascular diseases. Malignant hypertension,
the most lethal form, is characterized by severely elevated blood pressure
that commonly damages major organs and the vascular system. Many patients
with this condition exhibit signs of hypokalemia (inadequate levels of
potassium in the bloodstream), alkalosis (blood pH >7.45), and excessive
aldosterone secretion (a hormone that conserves water and sodium and increases
potassium excretion).
How Does Hypertension Inflict Damage?
Hypertension increases the risk of cardiovascular disease by affecting
the performance of arteries. Normally, arteries expand and contract effortlessly
with each heartbeat. With sustained hypertension, the arterial walls become
thickened, inelastic, and resistant to blood flow. This process injures
arterial linings and accelerates plaque formation. Nonfunctional blocked
vessels are unable to expand to accommodate the flow of blood, and the
left ventricle is forced to pick up the slack. The endless exertion proves
too much, and the ventricle may become distended and hypertrophied. In
exhaustion, the pump eventually fails. The health of the left ventricle
is an extremely important assessment when evaluating the worthiness of
the heart.
Arterial damage is invitational to spasms occurring in the walls of
the arteries. The spasm further impedes the flow of blood, adding additional
challenge to the ailing heart as it works to move the blood against the
backflow. A lack of egress and the heart's aggressive action can cause
a weakened area in the arterial wall to balloon, forming an aneurysm.
The rupture of the artery can result in massive internal bleeding and
death. An aneurysm or stroke, angina pectoris, and myocardial infarction
are even more likely to occur if the individual has high cholesterol and/or
elevated blood pressure.
Watch Serum Creatinine Levels
Serum creatinine levels in hypertensive patients are an extremely important
marker, and unfortunately one frequently ignored. Creatinine is highly
reliable in predicting cardiac outcome in individuals with high blood
pressure. Researchers analyzed data from a massive study, involving 14
U.S. medical schools and 10,940 subjects. It was determined that 50% of
hypertensive individuals with creatinine levels of 2.5 mg/dL (or greater)
die within 8 years. According to Dr. Neil B. Shulman (principal investigator)
cardiac deaths begin to spiral when creatinine levels reach 1.7 mg/dL,
with fatalities mounting as creatinine increases. Although high levels
of creatinine frequently reflect kidney impairment, most individuals with
high creatinine die as a result of a heart attack or stroke, not renal
disease (Shulman 1989).
Syndrome X and Hypertension
Syndrome X, one of the newer cardiac risk factors, may best explain why
some individuals are not protected from heart disease when hypertension
is treated independently. Excesses of insulin, a hallmark of Syndrome
X, makes the sympathetic nervous system dominant and results in the release
of catecholamines, that is, dopamine, epinephrine, and norepinephrine,
which contribute to hypertension by diminishing blood vessel diameter.
Hyperinsulinemia also encourages the retention of salt and water, a process
that increases blood volume and blood pressure. About 50% of hypertensive
patients are insulin resistant and should be treated for hyperinsulinemia
(excess blood insulin) primarily rather than focusing on a symptom of
the syndrome, that is, high blood pressure. Gerald Reaven (professor emeritus
(active) of medicine at Stanford University) states that it is vital that
every healthy-heart program address the hypertension-Syndrome X association
or little success in shielding hypertensive patients from a heart attack
can be expected (Reaven 2000).
Blood Pressure Medication:
Often Disappointing
Patients are searching for alternatives to hypertension medications in
light of the information gathered from an 8-year study involving 117,534
people. Half of the individuals were given antihypertensive drugs and
the other half a placebo. The number of deaths at the end of the 8-year
study was about the same in each group; however, the side effects of the
drugs eroded the equality of the results. Additional information regarding
compliance/response rates among hypertensive patients using drugs to reduce
blood pressure may be found in the British Medical Journal (Nuesch et
al. 2001).
If an antihypertensive drug therapy is used, Cozaar or Hyzaar (angiotensin
II antagonists) appear to be safer and more effective than short-acting
calcium channel blockers. It should be noted that beta-blockers and diuretics
(antihypertensive treatments) have been associated with an increased risk
of developing diabetes by impairing insulin sensitivity. However, benefits
have been obtained using alpha-1-blockers (antihypertensive vasorelaxants)
in regard to increasing insulin sensitivity (Lithell 1996). Unfortunately,
the National Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute stopped one phase of a large
hypertension study because alpha-blockers were found less effective (even
dangerous) compared to more traditional drugs in reducing the incidence
of cardiovascular events. The troublesome results surfaced after gathering
statistics from the ALLHAT (Antihypertensive and Lipid Lowering Treatment
to Prevent Heart Attack Trial) study (ALLHAT 2000).
During the course of the ALLHAT study, it was found that subjects taking
doxazosin (Cardoxan, Carduran, and Dosan) had a 25% higher risk of death
from coronary heart disease, as well as nonfatal myocardial infarction,
peripheral artery disease, stroke, angina, and congestive heart failure.
The high numbers of cardiovascular events could chiefly be explained by
a doubled risk for congestive heart failure. The other significant finding
was that doxazosin was less effective (by an average of 3 mmHg) in controlling
systolic blood pressure compared to other drugs evaluated. The researchers
surmised that while this discovery may explain the higher risk for angina
(16%) and stroke (19%), it could not fully account for the doubling of
congestive heart failure (IHP Information for Health Professionals 2000).
The HOPE Project
On March 11, 2000 , a satellite symposium of the American College of Cardiology
Scientific Session was held during which several speakers discussed the
results of the Heart Outcomes Prevention Evaluation (HOPE) study. The
study represented a 6-year undertaking, assessing the value of ramipril
(an angiotensin-converting enzyme, or ACE inhibitor) in the prevention
and management of cardiovascular disease (Anon. 1993; Hall et al. 1997;
Doctors' Guide 1999). Ramipril, a generic of the drug Altace, is principally
used in the treatment of high blood pressure, but its benefits appear
far-reaching. During the study, researchers also sought to determine whether
vitamin E was more effective than a placebo in preventing major cardiovascular
outcomes (see the comments regarding the unfavorable review of vitamin
E).
| A brief explanation of the renin-angiotensin
system: |
| The juxtaglomerular cells in the kidneys
stimulate renin secretion when either blood volume or serum sodium
decreases. Renin (an enzyme) participates in the conversion of angiotensinogen
to angiotensin I, which is rapidly hydrolyzed to form the active compound
angiotensin II. The vasoconstrictive action of angiotensin II decreases
the glomerular filtration rate; the concomitant action of aldosterone,
a mineralocorticoid hormone produced by the adrenal cortex, promotes
sodium retention, causing blood volume and sodium reabsorption to
increase. Agents that inhibit the angiotensin-converting enzyme decrease
sodium and water retention, reduce blood pressure, improve cardiac
output, and typically decrease heart size. |
Some 9500 people from 270 hospitals in 19 countries participated in
the HOPE study. Included in the trial were those with evidence of coronary
artery disease, stroke or peripheral vascular disease, and high-risk patients
with diabetes. Subjects were randomized to one of four treatments: ramipril
alone, vitamin E alone, ramipril and vitamin E, or neither.
Dr. Salim Yusuf, Ph.D. (professor of medicine and director of the division
of cardiology, McMaster University ), reported that ramipril reduced the
risk of new heart attacks, strokes, and mortality by 20-25%. Diabetic
complications, heart failures, and the need for coronary revascularization
(reestablishing blood flow through surgical means) were significantly
reduced as well. Dr. Yusuf reported on another phase of the HOPE study,
that is, documenting the worth of vitamin E as a cardioprotector, announcing
that no advantage was observed with supplementation.
As frequently occurs when trial results are overwhelmingly in favor
of one treatment over others, the study was halted. The ramipril-treated
group received such an obvious benefit it was deemed unethical to withhold
the drug from the control group. In fact, Dr. Victor Dzau, M.D. (professor
of theory and practice of medicine at Harvard Medical School ), suggests
that it might be helpful (in certain cases) to use ACE inhibitors to reduce
risks of potentially costly medical problems even in the absence of hypertension.
According to Dr. Bertram Pitt (professor of internal medicine at the
University of Michigan ) the HOPE study confirms that the activation of
the renin-angiotensin system impacts the risk of a heart attack through
various pathways. For example, when angiotensin II is elevated, it affects
the transport of cholesterol into the vessel wall and its oxidation, as
well as increasing cytokines, inflammatory proteins. This begins a cycle
that involves high levels of low density lipoproteins (LDLs), increasing
angiotensin II, which, in turn, increases the oxidation of LDL cholesterol.
In addition, Dr. Dzau explains that within unstable atherosclerotic
plaque a great deal of inflammation has been observed, and inflammatory
cells produce angiotensin II. This situation is complicated by the fact
that angiotensin II also leads to inflammation. The result is a sequence
that constantly increases angiotensin production and inflammation, events
invitational to atherosclerosis and ischemic events. The power of ACE
inhibitors (such as ramipril) to prevent cardiovascular disease is partially
explained by their ability to interrupt these cycles.
Of tremendous interest was the finding that patients with diabetes experienced
a reduction in diabetic neuropathy and the progression of the diabetic
process while using ramipril. Over the 4.5 years of the HOPE study, the
number of patients who developed new diabetes in the ramipril group was
one-third that of the placebo group. If the ramipril-diabetes advantage
can be confirmed, it would indicate that the renin-angiotensin system
is also involved in the pathogenesis of diabetes. Bolstering the hypothesis,
Captopril (another ACE inhibitor) also resulted in improved insulin sensitivity.
A remarkable finding was that the benefit derived from ramipril was
independent of blood pressure modulation. A reduction of only 3 systolic
points and 1.8 diastolic points from a mean baseline of 138/76 was observed.
Nonetheless, a clear reduction in unwanted outcomes, that is, cardiovascular
deaths, myocardial infarctions, and strokes occurred in all blood pressure
categories. Dr. Yusuf speculates that 2 million people a year could be
spared a major cardiovascular event if ramipril were widely used.
Researchers were impressed with the absence of side effects during the
course of the trial. However, if a patient has hyperch lo r lemia (an
excess of chloride in the blood) or renal dysfunction, the physician should
be very careful about administering any ACE inhibitor. If ramipril is
to be used, 10 mg a day appears to be the optimal dosage. Hypertensive
patients should start at a lower dose, such as 2.5 mg, and gradually increase.
It is uncertain whether all ACE inhibitors are equal to ramipril in delivering
cardioprotection; the ACE inhibitor Quinapril failed in reducing ischemic
events, but researchers question whether the dosage was more in error
than the drug.
Comments regarding the unfavorable review
of vitamin E
Dr. Richard Passwater, a long-time vitamin E devotee, explains that the
length of time in which vitamin E is used determines its cardiovascular
defense. Dr. Passwater showed (1977) that taking 400 IU of vitamin E daily
for 10 years or more dramatically reduced the occurrence of heart disease
prior to 80 years of age. Also, the type and blend of vitamin E administered
can alter outcome. The Life Extension Foundation has long advocated a
complex of alpha-tocopherol (80%) with gamma-tocopherol (20%) for optimal
protection.
In contrast to the HOPE study, The Lancet reported the benefit of administering
800 IU a day of alpha-tocopherol (vitamin E) to individuals with preexisting
cardiovascular disease and on hemodialysis (Boaz et al. 2000). Increased
oxidative stress (imposed through dialysis) appears to increase cardiovascular
mortality. A total of 15 (16%) of the 97 patients assigned to vitamin
E and 33 (33%) of the 99 patients assigned to placebo had a primary endpoint.
Five (5.1%) patients assigned to vitamin E and 17 (17.2%) patients assigned
to placebo had myocardial infarctions.
A new Israeli study showed the incidence of a fatal heart attack was
43% lower in a vitamin E supplemented group compared to a placebo group.
Despite the reduced death rate from heart disease in the vitamin E group,
both vitamin E and placebo groups had approximately the same overall risk
of dying during the course of the trial. The increase in noncardiac deaths
(which included deaths from a car accident, surgery, and complications
following kidney transplantation) appears to be a distortion of statistics
(Austin 2002).
While bewildering to the consumer, varying dosages and blends of vitamin
E applied to diverse populations often result in dissimilar conclusions.
Turn to the Vitamin E subsection in the Therapeutic section to read about
Dr. Passwater's study, as well as current documentation supporting supplementation
to protect against cardiovascular disease.
The Therapeutic section also highlights numerous suggestions to treat
hypertension, including alpha-lipoic acid, L-arginine, calcium, coenzyme
Q10, essential fatty acids, garlic, hawthorn, magnesium, olive leaf extract,
policosanol, potassium, taurine, and vitamin C. Natural ACE inhibitors
are green tea, garlic, hawthorn, olive leaf, taurine, proanthocyanidins,
angelica, and ginkgo biloba. To read about the influence other conditions
have on hypertension, consult the following sections in this protocol:
Smoking, Obesity, Stress, Genetics, Fibrinolytic Activity, Homocysteine,
Syndrome X, Chelation Therapy, and Does Sodium Restriction Lower Blood
Pressure?
OBESITY
Excessive body weight is a risk factor in so many diseases that obesity
itself is now regarded as a disease. In the United States , 104.4 million
adults are overweight, and 42.5 million are obese. Considering these alarming
numbers, it is prudent to wonder when a troublesome weight problem is
no longer just an annoyance but a significant risk for heart disease.
Measuring body mass index (BMI) has helped physicians and patients answer
this question.
During the American Heart Association's 71st Scientific Session (in
1998), the guidelines for assessing the risks imposed by obesity (as measured
by BMI) were reported. This study was based on data from the Framingham
Heart Study and the Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey
(Edelsberg et al. 1998). The results follow in Figure 2.
The pattern of the fat distribution is another important prognosticator
of host vulnerability. For example, android obesity or male-pattern obesity
is characterized by central abdominal obesity. Android obesity, that is,
apple-shaped bodies, are historically associated with an increased risk
of hypertension, diabetes, hyperinsulinism, cardiovascular disease, and
premature death. Conversely, fat distribution confined primarily to the
hips and thighs--that is, gynoid or pear-shaped obesity--is more likely
to be regarded as benign and is common in females (Sardesai 1998).
| The Risk of Heart Disease
in Obese Individuals |
| MEN |
WOMEN |
Not obese
(BMI 22.5) = 35% risk |
Not obese
(BMI 22.5) = 25% risk |
Mildly obese
(BMI 27.5) = 38% risk |
Mildly obese
(BMI 27.5) = 29% risk |
Moderately obese
(BMI 32.5) = 42% risk |
Moderately obese
(BMI 32.5) = 32% risk |
Severely obese
(BMI 37.5) = 46% risk |
Severely obese
(BMI 37.5) = 37% risk |
BMI may be calculated as follows:
|
- Convert weight in pounds to kilograms by dividing total weight
by 2.2.
- Determine height and convert to inches.
- Convert height in inches to meters. 1 meter equals 39.37 inches.
(Height in inches 4 39.37 = height in meters.)
- Square the height in meters by multiplying it by itself.
|
| Divide weight in kilograms by height in
meters squared. |
| This calculation can be done by a weight
loss physician or over the phone by calling (800) 226-2370. |
The Risks of Obesity: The Benefits
of Weight Loss
Research has clarified the reasons that fatness increases cardiovascular
risks. Obesity forces the heart into intensive labor because useless pounds
must be serviced in the same fashion as valuable tissues and organs. The
risk of diabetes and hypertension increases almost 3 times in obese individuals.
For example, a weight gain of 10% can increase systolic blood pressure
by 6.5 mmHg and fasting blood glucose by 2 mg/dL. Blood cholesterol levels
typically increase by about 12 mg/dL for each 10% of weight gained and
HDL levels decrease (Family Practice Notebook 2000). Even a 5- to 10-pound
weight loss can provide significant health benefits such as lowered blood
pressure or improved blood glucose control in the diabetic (Chandler 2002).
Other factors increasing cardiovascular risk, such as excessive fibrinogen,
elevated C-reactive protein, and insulin resistance, often share a common
denominator, that is, obesity.
A 10- to 15-pound weight loss can also lessen the risk and progression
of Syndrome X. As weight drops, tissues become more insulin sensitive,
amending a primary identifiable trait in Syndrome X. Although not all
obese individuals develop Syndrome X, the more overweight one is, the
greater the risk of developing the syndrome and the clusters of disease
factors surrounding it (a discussion of Syndrome X as an antecedent to
cardiovascular disease may be found in the section devoted to Newer Cardiovascular
Risk Factors).
Overeating in the absence of obesity poses a cardiac risk, as well.
Reports from patients indicated that unusually heavy meals were often
consumed during a 26-hour period preceding a myocardial infarction (Lopez-Jimenez
et al. 2000).
Leptin in Obesity and Heart Disease
Leptin, a hormone produced by fat cells, increases with obesity and appears
to play a role in the vascular complications associated with overweight
conditions. The discovery of leptin (in the last decade) raised hopes
that it could be used as a drug to treat obesity. However, most obese
people were later found to have elevated levels of the hormone, making
leptin injections inappropriate. However, assessing leptin levels has
emerged as a means of screening for heart disease.
The journal Circulation showed that men with established heart disease
had blood leptin levels 16% higher than men considered heart healthy.
Every 30% increase in leptin increased the risk of a heart attack or a
vascular event 25% (Wallace et al. 2001). The association between leptin
and heart disease was observed regardless of BMI, suggesting that leptin
is a reliable marker for the amount of fat in the body. Body composition
(the comparative proportions of protein, fat, water, and mineral components
in the body) may thus be a better indicator of risk for heart disease
than overall obesity.
The levels of leptin, structurally a cytokine, rise in tandem with C-reactive
protein (CRP), a marker of blood vessel inflammation and itself a significant
heart risk. These findings imply that body fat influences CRP levels (Mercola
2002a) in addition to a myriad of other health problems.
JAMA recently reported that leptin has a stimulatory effect on platelet
aggregation (Nakata et al. 1999; Bodary et al. 2002). The identification
of a functional leptin receptor (OB-Rb) on platelets suggests a signaling
mechanism between fat cells and platelets. To test the hypothesis, researchers
examined mice deficient in leptin or the leptin receptor after a laboratory-induced
vascular injury. Leptin-deficient mice had a prolonged time to occlusion,
whereas leptin-deficient mice administered the hormone demonstrated a
significant reduction in the time to occlusive thrombosis. Since leptin
levels correlate well with adiposity, strategies aimed at weight reduction
should remain the first line of defense. Lastly, exercise training in
Type II diabetic subjects also reduced serum leptin levels independent
of changes in body fat mass, insulin, or glucocorticoids (Ishii et al.
2001).
It is apparent that individuals need to establish a sensible approach
to eating, that is, a program that can be comfortably maintained long
term, void of either binges or periods of starvation. To lose weight only
to regain it poses many health risks. For example, a decrease in HDL cholesterol
is often reported in women who chronically cycle their weight from highs
to lows (Olson 2000). Weight cyclers typically have 7% lower HDL cholesterol
than noncyclers (Olson et al. 2000). To read about dietary supplements
that may assist in weight loss, see the subsections relating to L-Carnitine,
Chromium, CLA, and nutrients that lower serum insulin levels in the Therapeutic
section of this protocol.
DIABETES
The degenerative process that accompanies diabetes significantly affects
the heart. Atherosclerosis tends to develop early, progress rapidly, and
be more virulent in the diabetic. Data released from the Framingham Study
showed a 2.4-fold increase in congestive heart failure in diabetic men
and a 5.1-fold increase in diabetic women over the course of the 18-year
study (Fein et al. 1994).
Diabetics are particularly susceptible to silent myocardial infarctions,
that is, an asymptomatic attack that interrupts the blood flow to coronary
arteries. More than 80% of people with diabetes die as a consequence of
cardiovascular diseases, especially heart attacks (Whitney et al. 1998).
High homocysteine levels also play a significant role in diabetes-induced
cardiovascular disease. In fact, hyperhomocysteinemia is considered a
reliable predictor of mortality among diabetic patients.
Typically, Type II diabetes develops because of a lack of insulin sensitivity
at the cellular level. As a result, the bloodstream becomes overloaded
with nonfunctional insulin and a glut of glucose. The reason for this
is that as glucose is increasingly unable to be used for energy metabolism
and accumulates in the blood, the pancreas secretes more insulin in a
futile attempt to restore normal glycemic control. After an extended period
of excess insulin secretion, the pancreas may lose its ability to produce
insulin, and the Type II diabetic may then become insulin dependent. When
insulin loses its sensitivity or receptivity, its metabolic disposition
changes, and insulin becomes more of an adversary than an advocate within
the host.
Much of the stress of diabetes is due to a constant state of flux, that
is, moving from hyperglycemia to hypoglycemia in a relatively short period
of time. Nondiabetics are spared glycemic-induced stress. For example,
most healthy individuals maintain postabsorptive blood glucose levels
of 90-100 mg/dL. Even after fasting or overeating, blood glucose levels
seldom fluctuate lower than 60 mg/dL or over 160 mg/dL (Pike et al. 1984).
It has been suggested that evolutionary success requires a staunch defense
of the range of blood sugar, since exceeding the limits at either end
produces dire circumstances. An unstable diabetic lacks the homeostatic
mechanisms that provide for intricate glucose balance, and as a result
the heart and circulatory system suffer.
Chronic hyperglycemia causes monocytes and adhesion molecules to bind
to vessel walls. In turn, cholesterol and other lipids are more easily
deposited. Lipids become disorganized, with more of the LDL cholesterol
and less of the beneficial HDL cholesterol appearing in the bloodstream
(Reaven 2000). As the volume of urine produced increases, life-saving
minerals are often excreted with urine. Without adequate mineral representation,
the heart can be forced into fatal arrhythmias. Hypertension, abnormal
coagulation, and obesity multiply the health concerns that frequently
plague diabetic patients.
During hypoglycemia, the ability of the nervous system to function decreases,
but the breakdown of fats increases. In this situation, fat assumes the
role of a glucose surrogate. Necessary as this mechanism is, it is not
without a disadvantage. Substitute pathways are not always well regulated,
and excess fats not used as an energy source may accumulate, contributing
to the atherogenic process.
The symptoms of hypoglycemia can mimic a heart attack, that is, dizziness,
fatigue, sweating, shakiness, lightheadedness, palpitations, and in some
cases, unconsciousness. Normal brain function requires 6 grams of glucose
an hour, which can be delivered only if arterial blood contains over 50
mg/dL of glucose (Pike et al. 1984). Although hypoglycemia is not a heart
attack, the stress imposed upon the heart can be significant.
To learn more about the impact that Obesity, Stress, Gender, and a Sedentary
Lifestyle have upon diabetes, consult those subsections in the Traditional
Risk Factors section of this protocol; other relative information may
be found in the Fibrinolytic Activity and Syndrome X subsections of Newer
Risk Factors (also in this protocol). For natural suggestions to benefit
a diabetic, read about Alpha-Lipoic Acid, L-Carnitine, Chromium, DHEA,
Essential Fatty Acids, Fiber, Garlic, Magnesium, Olive Leaf Extract, Selenium,
Vitamin A, Gamma-Tocopherol, Vitamin K, and Zinc in the Therapeutic section
of this protocol. The Diabetes protocol in this book should be thoroughly
studied by individuals with unstable blood glucose levels.
HYPERCHOLESTEROLEMIA AND
DERANGED LIPID PROFILES
Too much cholesterol is not good, but too little may not be good either.
The American Heart Association announced in 1999 (at the annual Stroke
Conference) that people with cholesterol levels less than 180 mg/dL doubled
their risk of hemorrhagic stroke compared to those with cholesterol levels
of 230 mg/dL; however, the risk of a stroke escalated as cholesterol levels
exceeded 230 mg/dL. It is estimated that high cholesterol levels account
for about 10-15% of ischemic strokes; low cholesterol may be a contributing
factor in nearly 7% of hemorrhagic strokes. The National Cholesterol Education
Program announced that cholesterol levels of approximately 200 mg/dL appear
ideal for stroke prevention (CNN 1999; Mercola 1999).
Nonetheless, opinions are still divided as to the magnitude of the hypocholesterolemic
risk. Until the quandary has been fully resolved, there are reasons to
be cautious about severely reducing dietary fat and serum cholesterol.
Recall that in foods, triglycerides carry the fat-soluble vitamins (including
vitamin K, an extremely important nutrient in normal blood coagulation)
(Whitney et al. 1998). In addition, some researchers believe that hypocholesterolemia
weakens cerebral arterial walls, making breakage under pressure more likely
(Hama 2001). (About 20% of all strokes result from cerebral hemorrhages.)
Various studies indicate that very low levels of cholesterol may also
increase the risk of death due to cancer, particularly leukemia and lung
cancer (Zyada et al. 1990; Telega et al. 2000).
Cholesterol is so important that the body produces from 800-1500 mg
each day to provide for the following metabolic processes:
- Cholesterol is present in every cell in the body, strengthening cell
walls and assisting in the exchange of nutrients and waste materials
across membranes.
- The central nervous system, composed of the brain and spinal cord,
contains nearly one-fourth of the body's store of cholesterol. As much
as 50% of myelin (the insulating sheath on many nerve fibers) is cholesterol.
Cholesterol is essential for the conduction of nerve impulses.
- Bile acids, formed from cholesterol, are vital for proper fat digestion.
- Cholesterol is the precursor of adrenal and reproductive steroid
hormones.
- Surface cholesterol makes the skin resistant to chemicals and disease
organisms, hindering entry through pores. Cholesterol stored in the
skin assists in converting sunlight to vitamin D.
Although high concentrations of total serum cholesterol are related
to mortality in individuals younger than 65 years, clinical trials have
failed (until recently) to look at large numbers of individuals (>
70 years of age) to assess their response to higher cholesterol levels.
According to data published in The Lancet, the risk imposed by hypercholesterolemia
decreases with age (Weverling-Rijnsburger et al. 1997; Schatz et al. 2001).
In fact, hypocholesterolemia (low cholesterol levels) appears associated
with higher death rates among elderly people, due to mortality from cancer
and infection. Therefore, administering a hypocholesterolemic drug to
senior subjects may actually increase their risk of succumbing through
other forms of degenerative disease.
Dr. Steven Whiting, dean of the Institute of Nutritional Science , explains
how cholesterol can change from an essential sterol to an atheromatous
material. Free radicals and hypertension can damage the inside of an artery,
causing a small rupture or tear to occur. The body recognizes the problem
and attempts to handle it with the materials available. Fibrin, a stringy,
insoluble protein, is the first material laid down at a wound sight. Fibrin
does what it must: seal or coat the damaged area in the artery. Unfortunately,
fibrin can grasp other bloodstream infiltrates in its web-like structure,
that is, collagen proteins and minerals that have precipitated out of
solution. According to Dr. Whiting, a significant bump in the arterial
pathway may have developed and then along comes cholesterol. Cholesterol
appears to add the final coat to the plaque, building up in the artery
(Whiting 1989).
Optimal Ranges of Blood Lipids
When levels of HDL (high density lipoproteins, also known as good cholesterol)
are elevated, cardiovascular disease is reduced. The HDL2 subfraction
is even more correlated with cardiac protection and longevity than total
HDL cholesterol (Sardesai 1998). Typically, low triglyceride/LDL levels
and high HDL levels place an individual in a better position cardiovascularly.
HDL levels are considered desirable in a range of 50-70 mg/dL.
Total cholesterol for most individuals appears best managed between
180-200 mg/dL. The "how low can you go" logic is not wise when
setting relevant cholesterol goals, considering the many functions assigned
to cholesterol and the unsettled questions surrounding the safety of very
low cholesterol levels.
The risk factors for heart disease are often calculated by dividing
total cholesterol by HDL. Assessment of the HDL-total cholesterol ratio
is not standardized, but according to Health and Wellness (Sixth Edition),
a value of 4.5 places the individual at an average risk; a ratio above
4.5 indicates an increased risk; and a ratio below 4.5 means a decreased
likelihood of developing heart disease (Edlin et al. 1999).
Most laboratories use a reference range of 90-130 mg/dL for LDL cholesterol,
but LDL appears optimal at 100 mg/dL or lower. Dr. Henry Ginsberg ( Columbia
University ) estimates that reducing LDL cholesterol 7% may translate
into a 15-20% reduction in risk of coronary heart disease (Ginsberg et
al. 1998). Note: LDL cholesterol is not measured directly; levels are
calculated using the following formula:
LDL = total cholesterol - HDL - (triglycerides
4 5).
Cholesterol tests indicating acceptable levels may convey a false sense
of security. Current research indicates that standard cholesterol tests
miss 50% of people at risk for heart attacks, due to the inability to
detect abnormally small cholesterol particles. Note: Syndrome X is characterized
by abnormal lipoprotein metabolism, showing smaller, denser LDL particles.
To read more about Syndrome X, please consult the Newer Risk Factors section
in this protocol.
LDL pattern B is the smallest and most susceptible to oxidation of all
forms of cholesterol. Both LDL pattern B and lipoprotein(a) increase the
risk of heart attack threefold; neither can be detected by standard cholesterol
tests. Without the detection of the smaller cholesterol subsets and the
appropriate treatment, plaque buildup progresses twice as fast. Trapped
LDL or lipoprotein(a) over time forms plaque with a fibrous cap. Unstable
plaque can rupture, which causes the blood to clot, increasing the risk
of sudden heart attacks or strokes. Laboratories providing total screening,
that is, testing for normal and abnormal-sized lipoproteins, should be
used for evaluations.
Triglyceride levels are usually regarded within a normal range at 30-199
mg/dL, but researchers have found that patients with clinical coronary
heart disease were less likely to experience new events if tri-glyceride
levels were below 101 mg/dL (Kreisberg et al. 2000). Most clinicians believe
that triglycerides are best maintained below 101 mg/dL in all subsets
of the population. Perhaps J.M. Gaziano ( Harvard Medical School ) led
the most startling study in regard to the risks imposed by deranged blood
lipids. The subjects with the highest ratio of triglycerides to HDL had
a 16-fold greater incidence of coronary events compared to those with
the lowest ratio (Gazinao et al. 1997).
Triglyceride levels rarely rise unless one has insulin resistance or
hyperinsulinemia, conditions often modifiable by controlling carbohydrates
in the diet. According to the data reported in Atherosclerosis, elevated
triglyceride levels usually modulate when less food is consumed, particularly
foods causing a rise in blood sugar levels, that is, bakery products,
pastas, and foods with added sugar (Stavenow et al. 1999; Atkins 2002).
Note: Other areas in this protocol relating to hyperlipidemia are heredity,
sedentary lifestyle, gum disease, hypothyroidism, hemochromatosis, fibrinogen,
Lp(a), homocysteine, Syndrome X, and C-reactive protein. Read about natural
lipid-reducing agents such as artichoke extract, L-carnitine, chromium,
conjugated linoleic acid, curcumin, DHEA, essential fatty acids, fiber,
garlic, ginger, grapefruit pectin, gugulipid, hawthorn, niacin, pantethine,
policosanol, poly-enylphosphatidylcholine, and tocotrienols in the Therapeutic
section of this protocol.
STRESS
More than one-quarter of a million heart episodes occur annually--that
is, palpitations, angina, arrhythmias, and heart attack--as a result of
a stressful experience. This is particularly evidenced when an ailing
heart struggling to keep pace with circulatory demands is forced to deal
with an emotional provocation. The journal Circulation reported that an
individual who is prone to anger is about 3 times more likely to have
a heart attack or sudden cardiac death than someone who is the least prone
to anger (Williams et al. 2000).
The journal Life Sciences offers an explanation for stress-related cardiovascular
events. Higher levels of homocysteine are associated with feelings of
aggression and rage in both men and women (Stoney et al. 2000). Individuals
may be spurred into erratic behavior by metabolic processes gone awry.
The modulation of homocysteine levels may allow a more docile individual
to emerge, less cardiac risk prone from two perspectives (less homocysteine
= less violent behavior and less cardiac disease). A comprehensive review
of homocysteine appears in the section devoted to Newer Risk Factors.
Vitamins and minerals to maintain healthy homocysteine levels are presented
in the Therapeutic section.
Type A individuals are also at a greater cardiovascular risk because
their lives are dominated by self-imposed stress. Work expectations are
driven by an unrelenting desire to achieve. An exaggerated sense of time
urgency prompts accelerated locomotion and faster decision-making. Cynicism,
hostility, and impatience snuff out many personal relationships and deny
the heart a much needed rest from disharmony.
Under stress, the sympathetic nervous system is alerted and the release
of adrenaline increases; ultimately, one's breathing, heartbeat, and blood
pressure also increase. Cardiac patients are often prescribed beta-adrenergic
blocking agents to calm the sympathetic nervous system, a gesture that
asks a drug to succeed where attempts at lifestyle changes may have failed.
Type D behavior, another variant having heart disease linkage, was described
in The Lancet (Denollet et al. 1996). Withheld and denied emotions, that
is, refusing to cry even when weeping is justified and a lack of social
connectedness (traits common to a type D personality), appear contributory
to heart disease and stroke.
During periods of mental or emotional arousal, a silent ischemic attack
(a decreased supply of oxygenated blood) can occur. Although asymptomatic,
severe heart damage may result. Unlike an angina attack, which is usually
prompted by physical exertion, more than three-fourths of silent ischemic
attacks are caused by mental arousal. There is also a definite link between
the hardening of the carotid artery and higher levels of stress (Barnett
1997).
A recent study of 2800 men and women over 55 years of age showed that
even minor depression can increase cardiac mortality 60%, while major
depression may actually triple the rate of cardiac-related deaths (Pennix
et al. 2001). There is also convincing evidence that depression significantly
increases the risk of mortality following a heart attack or coronary bypass
surgery (Baker et al. 2001).
Researchers explain the relationship between mindset and mortality,
pointing out that stress response to depression appears to trigger chronically
high cortisol levels, a hormone secreted by the adrenal glands (Pennix
et al. 1999a). Hormonal imbalances, in turn, can alter insulin resistance
and increase blood pressure, magnifying the risks imposed by a heart attack
or bypass surgery.
A study conducted at Duke University ( Durham , NC ) showed that men
with established heart disease who underwent 4 months of stress management
(1.5 hours weekly) experienced a significant reduction in clinical cardiovascular
events. The advantage was observed at the conclusion of counseling and
throughout 5 years of assessment, suggesting both economic as well as
clinical benefit (Blumenthal et al. 2002).
Stress protracts to so many traditional risk factors that emotions may
be the dominant issue in coronary health. Note the following risk factors
that share stress as their common bond.
- Stress can destroy sound eating habits by the uncaring selection
of inappropriate foodstuffs, eating hurriedly, or eating not because
of hunger but as a respite from a dismal situation. Stress is a strong
contributor to obesity, a factor in cardiovascular disease.
- Stress increases blood pressure. In studies involving 3000 Caucasians
with depression and anxiety (ages 23-64), these individuals were found
to have twice the risk of developing hypertension. The odds worsened
for African Americans, with the risk factor for hypertension increasing
more than 3 times during periods of unresolved stress. Even the companionship
of a pet has been shown to reduce stress and subsequently blood pressure
(Alexander et al. 1996; Beck et al. 1996).
- Stress makes blood glucose levels more difficult to control (Challem
et al. 2000). Diabetes, a long-established risk to heart health, has
been termed a disease fueled by emotions.
- Alternative Medical News reports that stress increases blood cholesterol
levels. Students preparing for exams, Indianapolis 500 drivers (following
the race), and accountants after the April 15 deadline show higher cholesterol
levels (Alternative Medical News staff 1995).
HEREDITY
Scientific testing has advanced genetic screening far beyond compiling
an oral history of ancestral successes and failures. Instead, geneticists
are looking for mutated genes that may be expressing themselves as contributors
to coronary artery disease. For example, 50% of suppressed HDL cholesterol
can be linked to genetic factors. A gene (ABC1), when mutated, appears
responsible for increasing the risk of heart disease by lowering levels
of HDL cholesterol. Michael Hayden (professor of medical genetics at the
University of British Columbia) reports that people with defects in ABC1
have just as much risk for heart disease because of too little HDL as
individuals with high levels of LDL cholesterol (Cosgrove 1999).
Assessing Apo-E Status
The apoE4 variant of apoprotein E is the most well-defined genetic trait
affecting poor LDL levels. According to Ronald Krauss, M.D., a double
allele (referred to as a double E4 genotype) is associated with high blood
cholesterol and an increased prevalence of cardiovascular disease (American
Heart Association 1998).
The apoE4 allele is very saturated fat sensitive, suggesting dietary
manipulation may be an advantage to those with this genetic fault. In
90% or more of the population, modest dietary cholesterol has very little
impact upon LDL cholesterol levels (Bland 2001). However, moderate dietary
cholesterol intake in apoE4 individuals can lead to significant increases
in plasma LDL levels. Jeff Bland, Ph.D., challenges that public health
recommendations do not address genotypes that alter dietary guidelines.
Recommendations to universally avoid cholesterol-rich foods prevent some
who are not cholesterol sensitive from eating a food that is a "pretty
good food," such as an egg.
There are three main alleles or variants of the apoE gene: E2, E3, and
E4. Every individual inherits two of these alleles: one from each parent.
Research has shown that each allele affects cholesterol metabolism differently.
Smoking appears to increase the risk of coronary heart disease in men
of all genotypes but particularly in men carrying the E4 allele. Researchers
hypothesize that the genetic-coronary link may be due to increased oxidation
of LDL cholesterol among smokers with this genotype. Compared to individuals
who carry two neutral E3 alleles, those who carry at least one E4 allele
tend to produce significantly more LDL cholesterol as well as more total
cholesterol; those who have at least one E2 allele typically produce less
LDL cholesterol (Humphries et al. 2001; Wang et al. 2001).
Establishing an apoE genotype in menopausal women sheds light on the
complex issues of estrogen replacement therapy (ERT) as a cardioprotector.
For example, women with the apoE-2 genotype (and using ERT) appeared to
benefit the most from the lipid-altering effects of hormones compared
to other genotypes. Menopausal women with the apoE-2 genotype (and not
using ERT) have the lowest levels of protective HDL cholesterol. If on
ERT, apoE-2 carriers have the highest HDL levels of all genotypes. This
study suggests that the apoE-2 genotype may predispose a woman's body
to produce more protective HDL cholesterol in response to ERT than those
of other types (Heikkinen et al. 1999).
The study also showed that women with the apoE-3 genotype (and using
ERT) had the highest levels of triglycerides. It appears women with the
apoE-3 genotype are more sensitive to the triglyceride-raising effects
of hormone therapy. A previous placebo-controlled study of over 150 postmenopausal
Finnish women found that LDL cholesterol levels in women with the apoE-4
genotype respond less favorably to ERT (Heikkinen et al. 1999).
Studies that fail to consider genotype may explain the wide disparity
in results regarding lipid levels and cardiovascular risk in postmenopausal
women receiving HRT. With recent advances in genetic testing, another
important piece of the puzzle is now available to help physicians predict
how hormone replacement therapy will impact each woman's cardiovascular
health (Kardia et al. 1999; von Muhlen et al. 2002).
Homocysteine: The Genetic Link
Compiling a family history of cardiovascular health is a common medical
assessment, looking particularly at the early onset of disease. Because
of an increasing awareness of the risks imposed by newer risk factors,
homocysteine is being factored into the genetic equation. With a gene
frequency between one in 70 and one in 200, elevated blood levels of homocysteine
may be more common than previously thought (Berwanger et al. 1995). Canadian
researchers estimate the inherited amino acid disorder (homocysteinemia)
is present in approximately 20% of coronary artery disease patients (Superko
et al. 1995).
There are multiple mechanisms involved in the pathogenesis of hyperhomocysteinemia,
including not only heterozygosity, but dietary factors as well (Kardaras
et al. 1995). Note: Heterozygous refers to inheriting a gene for a characteristic
from one parent and the alternative gene from the other parent. The offspring
of a heterozygous carrier (of a genetic disorder) has a 50% chance of
inheriting the gene associated with the trait. In support of the genetic
theory of hyperhomocysteinemia, epidemiological evidence has shown homocysteine
levels to be 45% lower in Westernized adult black South Africans than
in age-matched white adults, revealing racial genetic differences in homocysteine
metabolism (Vermaak et al. 1991).
About one-half of individuals with hyperhomocysteinemia respond favorably
to higher doses of vitamin B6 due to an inborn cystathionine-B-synthase
deficiency; others have a mutation in the methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase
gene (MTHFR), which controls the ability to convert folic acid into 5-methyl
tetra-hydrofolate, an active contributor in the methyl donation pathway
of the folate cycle (James et al. 1999). The disruption of this cycle
represents the domino effect, that is, when one system fails to perform,
others downstream are affected as well. In this case, homocysteine clearance
is disrupted and hyperhomo-cysteinemia, a powerful endangerment to cardiac
health, results. The genetic flaw is correctable by administering 5-methyltetrahydrofolate
supplements (the active form of folate) to bypass the metabolic block
(Bland 2000a).
Additional Inheritable Risks for
Degenerative Disease
- In 1991, researchers identified the gene responsible for hemochromatosis,
a predominantly genetic disease reflecting abnormal iron retention despite
eating an ordinary diet. Small numbers of individuals with hemochromatosis
acquire the condition through chronic iron supplementation or blood
transfusions, but the genetic form is most common. To learn more about
hemochromatosis (a significant threat to heart health), consult the
Iron Overload section.
- The journal Arteriosclerosis, Thrombosis and Vascular Biology reported
that carotid plaque was significantly more common in both men and women
whose parents died prematurely of coronary heart disease (CHD) than
in subjects with no familial history of early cardiac death (Zureik
et al. 1999).
- Lp(a) is frequently cited in medical literature as an important inheritable
cardiac risk factor for individuals without other apparent signs of
heart disease. Approximately 50% of children whose parents have elevated
Lp(a) will also have similar Lp(a) derangements (Superko 1996). Although
Lp(a) levels are influenced by heredity, this marker is often modifiable
by targeted nutritional intervention.
- Genetic factors can influence obesity and fat distribution. Laval
University (Quebec, Canada) determined that pairs of identical twins,
overfed by the same amount of calories, showed a similarity with respect
to body weight and percentage of fat, with about 3 times more variance
among pairs than within pairs. After adjustment for the gains in fat
mass, the within-pair similarity was particularly evident with respect
to the changes in regional fat distribution and amount of abdominal
visceral fat, with about 6 times as much variance among pairs as within
pairs. Researchers concluded that the tendency to store energy as either
fat or lean tissue is influenced by genetic factors (Bouchard et al.
1990).
- A condition known as Dunnigan-type familial partial lipodystrophy
(FPLD) bears striking similarities to Syndrome X. The gene mutation
responsible for FPLD causes weight gain in the abdomen as well as the
face and chest. Affected individuals have high insulin levels, high
blood pressure, high triglycerides, and low levels of HDL cholesterol.
A recent study confirmed that individuals with FPLD have 6 times the
risk of coronary heart disease compared to noncarrier relatives in a
control group, that is, 34.8% versus 5.9% at any age and 26.1% versus
0% before the age of 55. The average age of developing heart disease
was 46.5 years in individuals with FPLD, with the risk being greater
among women than in men. Four of 14 women (about 28%) with FPLD underwent
bypass surgery before the age of 55. In contrast, hospitalization data
from the general Canadian population in 1996 indicated that one woman
in 7350 had been hospitalized between the ages of 35-54 for coronary
bypass artery surgery (Canadian Institute for Health Information, http://www.cihi.ca;
Hegele 2001; Today's News 2001).
GENDER
At one time, cardiovascular disease was considered to be predominantly
a disease affecting men, not women. Statistics do not support this logic.
Studies have demonstrated that heart disease is the number one killer
for both men and women. Of the 1.1 million heart attacks reported annually,
about 500,000 occur among women.
The Framingham Study reported findings involving 5209 participants,
2873 of whom were women (Framingham Heart Study 1998). Results of the
study follow:
- In both men and women, coronary heart disease has exceeded that of
other cardiovascular illnesses, such as stroke or congestive heart failure.
- While coronary events occurred twice as often in men, with advancing
age the incidence of heart disease in women approaches that seen in
men. Menopause appears to be the interval associated with a significant
rise in coronary events, as well as a shift to more serious manifestations
of the disease.
- The New England Journal of Medicine reported that hormone replacement
therapy (HRT) in menopausal women with angiographic-determined heart
disease did not lower the progression of the disease (Nabulsi 1993;
Herrington et al. 2000). New guidelines issued by the American Heart
Association agreed that women with cardiovascular disease should not
be given HRT for the sole purpose of preventing future heart attacks.
In fact, HRT raised the risk of recurrent attack and death during the
first year of usage and thereafter lowered it only slightly (Mosca et
al. 2001). Although estrogen replacement therapy may be helpful in lowering
refractory lipoprotein(a) and high fibrinogen levels, it increases C-reactive
protein levels, making its benefit uncertain (please read the previous
section on Heredity and Assessing ApoE Status for extremely valuable
information regarding HRT in postmenopausal women).
- Coronary heart disease manifests itself differently in men and women.
In women, angina was the most common initial symptom, whereas in men,
myocardial infarction was the most frequent first coronary symptom.
- High triglycerides were more predictive of eventual heart disease
in women than in men. In fact, high triglycerides threaten the outcome
in diabetic women undergoing bypass surgery (Sprecher et al. 2000).
Elevations in C-reactive protein (CRP) are the single strongest predictor
of future vascular risk, according to the Women's Health Study. Women
with the highest levels of CRP in their blood had a fivefold increased
risk of future cardiovascular disease and a sevenfold increase in the
likelihood of a heart attack compared to those with low levels.
- When a heart attack was the first coronary event, nearly half were
unrecognized in women, compared to only a third undetected in men.
- Only 56% of women experiencing a heart attack can expect to live
another year, compared to 73% of male victims. Women under 50 years
of age are twice as likely to succumb following the attack compared
to similarly afflicted men. Statistics change with age, with men and
women between the ages of 60-69 showing similar survival patterns (Mukamal
et al. 2001): 27% of men who have a heart attack will likely have a
second attack within 6 years compared to 31% of women.
- Diabetes is a particularly strong coronary risk factor in women.
- The New England Journal of Medicine reported that the risk of myocardial
infarction increased among women who used second generation oral contraception,
that is, levonorgestrel. Although inconclusive, early trials indicate
third generation oral contraceptives, that is, desogestrel or gestodene,
may carry a lesser risk (Tanis et al. 2001).
- Many studies have demonstrated that men who are physically active
tend to live longer, illustrating a clear exercise-response curve, with
greater activity more effective than moderate. The New England Journal
of Medicine recently reported similar findings for women. Both walking
and vigorous exercise are associated with substantial reductions in
the incidence of cardiovascular events among postmenopausal women; prolonged
sitting is predictive of increased cardiovascular risk (Manson et al.
2002).
SEDENTARY LIFESTYLE
Scientists believe that a properly planned exercise program may be the
single greatest preventive measure against cardiovascular disease. However,
it is extremely important that the individual and the activity be properly
matched. Even among apparently fit persons, intense but sporadic exercise
actually increases the risk of a fatal heart attack. A singles tennis
match in an unprepared participant increases the risk of a heart attack
sixfold.
The exercise level need not be unpleasantly aggressive to be beneficial.
In the past, it was thought that an individual using exercise as a cardiovascular
protective should select an activity that produced a state of breathlessness
and participate in the action several times a week. It has now been determined
that cardiovascular strengthening can be obtained from low intensity activity
such as walking for 30 minutes a day. In fact, Dr. Shah Ebrahim, a British
cardiologist, states that sexually active men, that is, those engaging
in sex 3-4 times a week, reduce their risk of either a stroke or a heart
attack by half. Some researchers question whether the mild to moderate
energy expended during intercourse is the perk favoring a healthier cardiovascular
system or if it is the mindset that drives the sexual act.
The New England Journal of Medicine reported findings relating to the
impact of exercise upon 180 postmenopausal women (45-64 years) and 197
men (30-64 years) (Stefanick et al. 1998). The participants were divided
into four groups: diet plus exercise, diet alone, exercise alone, and
controls. LDL cholesterol levels in the diet-plus-exercise group were
significantly reduced compared to the three remaining groups. It is also
possible that exercise will alter the size of LDL particles. (Recall that
abnormally small LDL particles are highly susceptible to oxidation and
elude standard testing processes, misrepresenting the end results.)
Exercise reduces blood pressure and heart rate by influencing sympathetic
neural and hormonal activity. As epinephrine (adrenaline) and norepinephrine
levels are decreased, one's blood pressure and heart rate subsequently
decrease (Katona et al. 1982; Duncan et al. 1985; Smith et al. 1989).
The statistics support that a regular exercise program reduces the risk
of stroke, not only by lowering blood pressure, but also by increasing
peripheral circulation and oxygen delivery. These findings were confirmed
in a 10-year study, involving 14,101 Norwegian women (50-101 years of
age). The results showed that the risk of dying from stroke declined as
physical activity increased; the most active women had approximately 50%
lower risk of death from stroke across all age groups (Ellekjaer et al.
2000).
Excessive fibrinogen, a risk factor for cardiovascular disease, is impacted
by exercise. A study showed that exercise of moderate intensity increases
fibrinolytic activity by increasing tissue plasminogen activators. (Tissue
plasminogen activators break down fibrinogen, decreasing the risk of blood
clot formation.) The substantiation of this process occurred when 14 sedentary
men (average age 35) and 12 physically active men (average age 35) participated
in exercise sessions in the morning and evening at 50% maximal oxygen
consumption. The results of the study indicated that moderate-intensity
exercise increased the activity of tissue plasminogen activators in both
physically active and sedentary men, particularly during evening exercise.
C-reactive protein, another of the newer risk factors for cardiovascular
disease, also appears lowered by exercise (Szymanski et al. 1994; Ford
2002).
A sedentary lifestyle encourages weight gain and worsens Syndrome X,
a condition of insulin resistance and compensatory hyperinsulinemia (insulin
excess). Conversely, physical fitness increases cellular glucose responsiveness
and decreases the amount of insulin secreted after a carbohydrate load
(Challem et al. 2000). Exercise makes the vasculature less prone to damage
when insulin levels are unstable. The vulnerabilities associated with
Syndrome X, that is, diabetes, hypertension, hypertriglyceridemia, and
suppressed HDL levels are often modifiable by exercise-induced weight
loss.
If cardiovascular disease has manifested, a monitored exercise program
can assist in recovery. Exercise helps in building a new network of blood
vessels, naturally bypassing those impaired. The conclusion regarding
exercise is that it is never too late to reap the benefits from a properly
structured program. However, according to the Framingham Heart Study,
only recent physical activity makes a significant difference (Sherman
et al. 1999). Exercise undertaken earlier in life showed no sustained
cardioprotection.
Beneficial as physical activity is, even low-intensity exercise can
be a harbinger of free radicals; over -exercising can generate enough
free radicals to damage the DNA in white blood cells. The remedy is to
provide the system with adequate amounts of antioxidants before engaging
in physical activity. Also, sweating during exercise can drastically deplete
minerals. This phenomenon likely contributes to the numbers of sudden
deaths occurring among athletes and joggers. Lost body fluids and minerals
should be replaced immediately.
GUM DISEASE
Researchers are examining the role of gum disease in the genesis and
progression of heart disease. The inflammatory process, observed in the
lining of atherosclerotic blood vessels, appears to be paralleling chronic
inflammation observed in periodontal disease. The findings reported in
the American Journal of Epidemiology showed that fibrinogen and C-reactive
protein (coagulability and inflammatory markers) are increased in individuals
with periodontal disease (Wu et al. 2000). Dr. Wu and colleagues at State
University of New York reported that gum disease might also be related
to hypercholesterolemia, although a weaker link is found between elevated
cholesterol and gum disease than for the elevations in CRP and fibrinogen.
Bleeding, red, swollen gums are depictive of gingivitis, a condition
of inflammation and bone deterioration promulgated by bacteria. The American
Academy of Periodontology recently launched a media story showing that
people with periodontal disease are 200-300% more likely to experience
a heart attack than those with healthy gums. Allowing for multiple cardiac
risk factors, the researchers concluded that gum disease was a greater
risk for cardiovascular disease than hypertension (Genco 1997).
A pilot study (involving 38 heart attack patients matched to a comparable
group of 38 people without known heart disease) showed a dramatic correlation
between periodontal disease, CRP, and cardiac health: 85% of cardiac patients
presented with gum disease compared to only 29% in the control group.
Not only did the heart attack patients with periodontal disease have higher
levels of CRP than those without gum disease, the CRP levels were directly
related to the severity of the oral condition (Medscape Wire 2000) (to
read about the risks imposed by high levels of CRP, please turn to the
Newer Risk Factors section appearing in this protocol).
Should the gums be pulling away from the teeth and appear red, swollen,
or tender, seek immediate dental care. Other red flags are gums that bleed
while brushing, bad breath, or a discharge of pus. Turn to the Calcium,
Coenzyme Q10, and Vitamin C subsections in the Therapeutic section to
learn about maintaining healthy gum tissue and avoiding periodontal disease.
THYROID DISEASE
(HYPO- AND HYPERTHYROIDISM)
Seldom considered but often the source of disease, the thyroid gland
(a member of the endocrine system) should be evaluated in all cardiac
patients. A healthy thyroid gland benefits the heart by modulating basal
metabolic rate, improving one's mindset, lowering cholesterol and homocysteine
levels, and regulating one's heartbeat and circulation. As the following
dialog will exemplify, disease states are common when either over- or
underperformance of an organ occurs.
Hypothyroidism
Researchers became keenly aware of the importance of a healthy thyroid
gland after assessing the homocysteine and cholesterol levels in 7000
individuals from the general U.S. population (Morris et al. 2001). After
subdividing test participants into two groups (those with hypothyroidism
and those with normal thyroid function), researchers realized that about
two-thirds of those diagnosed with hypothyroidism had cholesterol levels
nearly 4 times higher than normal. Those who tested positive for hypothyroidism
were more likely to be white, female, and "slightly older."
Interestingly, an increase in plasma thyroxine concentrations (an iodine-containing
hormone secreted by the thyroid gland with the chief function of increasing
the rate of cell metabolism) typically precedes reductions in plasma cholesterol
levels.
Approximately 50% of individuals thyroid-impaired also had high homocysteine
levels compared to only 18% with a healthy gland. Researchers determined
that about 90% of hypothyroid subjects in the U.S. population are either
hyperhomocysteinemic or hypercholesterolemic; in contrast, only 31% of
individuals with normal thyroid function have similar physical complaints
(Morris et al. 2001).
The age groups affected by poor thyroid performance and cardiovascular
disease are widespread. For example, clinicians examining a group of heart
attack victims younger than 40 years of age found two common abnormalities:
(1) elevations in serum cholesterol levels and (2) reductions in basal
metabolic rate.
A 5-year study involving 347 patients (reported in the Journal of the
American Geriatric Society) evaluated the effects of thyroid therapy upon
atherosclerosis in a subset of the population 54.7-64.5 years old (Wren
1968): 132 of the individuals had experienced heart attacks, strokes,
angina pectoris, or disruption in peripheral circulation; the remaining
215 participants were asymptomatic but were considered high risks because
of the presence of electrocardiographic abnormalities, hypertension, diabetes,
or hypercholesterolemia.
Only 9% of the patients (31 of the total 347) tested positive for hypothyroid
conditions. Nonetheless, all were treated with thyroid extract, and substantial
clinical improvements occurred in a number of the patients. Of the 132
symptomatic patients, 29 of 41 with angina reported benefits that included
increased exercise tolerance, decreased frequency and severity of attacks,
and less need for nitroglycerin. Mean cholesterol levels fell by about
22%. During the 5-year study, 11 patients died, less than half of the
expected rate based on United States Life Tables (Barnes 1976).
How might poor thyroid function contribute to arteriosclerotic vascular
disease, that is, the hardening of the arteries? Researchers speculate
that hypothyroidism may slow or decrease the metabolic breakdown of fats
such as cholesterol. In addition, a dysfunctional thyroid gland may also
impair kidney function and interfere with the activity of a gene (methylenetetrahydrofolate
reductase) that the body depends on to process (remethylate) homocysteine.
Also, if the body fails to convert thyroxine (T4) to tri -iodothyronine
(T3), the body's most potent thyroid hormone, T3 becomes less available
in the bloodstream, while levels of reverse T3 (rT3), an inactive metabolite
of T3, tend to build up (Shanoudy et al. 2001). A low T3-rT3 ratio is
associated with a lesser ability of the left ventricle to pump blood and
is highly predictive of poorer short-term outcome in patients with severe
chronic heart failure.
In 1998, the American College of Physicians established guidelines for
maintaining thyroid health, recommending routine assessment of thyroid
simulating hormone (TSH) levels in all women over 50 years of age; women
ages 35 and older should be evaluated every 5 years.
In addition, a positive test for the thyroid peroxidase antibody (TPOAb)
can be an important early warning sign of emerging dysfunction (Stockigt
2002). Having either high TSH or a positive TPOAb raises the risk of progressing
to overt hypothyroidism eightfold; having both increases the risk 40-fold.
Note: Hypothyroidism affects more women than men, but the risk increases
with age for both men and women. In addition, women are about 5-10 times
more prone to hyperthyroidism than men.
The attempts to improve cardiovascular performance without factoring
in the possibility of a poorly functioning thyroid gland diminish the
chances of success. Conversely, remarkable improvements can be expected
if hypothyroidism exists and is treated as the primary condition provoking
lipid or vascular derangements.
Hyperthyroidism
Hyperthyroidism (an overactive thyroid gland) is also an endangerment
to cardiac health, forcing blood vessels into a chronic state of prolonged
excitability. Italian researchers measured vascular function (before and
after treatment for hyperthyroidism) and compared it to a control group
with a healthy thyroid gland. Researchers found that excess levels of
thyroid hormones had a strong negative impact on the function of the endothelium
(the inner lining of blood vessel walls), resulting in up -regulation
of blood flow through the circulatory route (Napoli et al. 2001).
Compared to individuals with normal thyroid function, hyperthyroid patients
produce significantly higher levels of nitric oxide, leading to increased
blood flow and dilation of blood vessels in a resting state. Hyperthyroid
patients, typically, show an exaggerated vascular reaction to the cardiac
effects of acetylcholine (a neurotransmitter) and norepinephrine (a stress
hormone synthesized by the adrenal medulla). Patients with overt hyperthyroidism
as well as those with subclinical disease who were given echocardiograms
showed that a supercharged thyroid gland caused the cardiovascular system
to show clear signs of parasympathetic withdrawal (Petretta et al. 2001).
Excitory instructions directed to the endothelium explain why even subclinical
thyroid dysfunction is an independent risk factor for heart disease. Endo-thelium,
stimulated by over-reactive thyroid messages, is implicated in both congestive
heart failure as well as heart attacks.
In the early stages of hyperthyroidism (when TSH levels are high, but
thyroid hormone levels are still normal), the heart may already be losing
its ability to calm itself. Over time, chronic excitability (leading to
increased blood circulation and heart rate) overworks the heart and literally
wears it out. Interestingly, when following treatment to resolve hyperthyroidism,
the vascular mechanics return to normal.
Illustrative of the value of a healthy thyroid gland, the National Health
and Nutrition Examination Survey showed that once the thyroid falters
in its performance, the heart may not be far behind (Rodriguez 2001).
The need for a thyroid evaluation is thus impossible to overstate. Identifying
and treating hypo- or hyperthyroidism can improve both the quality and
duration of life.
IRON OVERLOAD (HEMOCHROMATOSIS)
The research to determine the effects of iron excess on cardiovascular
health has had mixed findings. The Annals of Epidemiology reported that
no association between iron levels and mortality from cardiovascular disease
was found in data collected from NHANES II and the National Death Index
(Sempos et al. 2000). Reports published in two respected journals (Journal
of the American Heart Association and American Journal of Epidemiology)
chronicled an opposing view, showing that free iron corresponds to a greater
risk of fatal heart attacks and strokes by encouraging free-radical production
(Kiechl et al. 1997; Klipstein-Grobusch et al. 1999).
Just as the iron in your car can rust, the iron in your body is susceptible
to rust, or oxidation, a process that damages tissues and blood vessel
walls. Several studies have found that iron is most damaging to the heart
if LDL cholesterol levels are also high. This occurs as free iron oxidizes
LDL cholesterol, increasing the damage imposed upon the heart and vascular
system.
Hemochromatosis not only increases the oxidation process, but also reduces
antioxidants, including glutathione (Young et al. 1994). As glutathione
is depleted, free radicals (attacking in the cerebral region) can increase
stroke progression. Stroke patients with high blood ferritin (a measurement
of the total iron stored in the body) experienced greater post -stroke
trauma, that is, increased lethargy, aphasia, and unawareness (Davalos
et al. 2000).
An iron overload further complicates a cardiovascular outcome by contributing
to an irregular heartbeat, heart attacks, and heart failure. Every 1%
rise in blood iron increases the risk of heart disease 4% (Whitney et
al. 1998). Interestingly, iron-induced cardiac irregularities can affect
both young and senior subjects, even anemic patients.
Dr. Hidehiro Matsuoka ( Kurume Medical School in Japan ) says iron somehow
interferes with nitric oxide, a chemical that relaxes blood vessel walls,
allowing the blood to flow more freely. As iron levels increase, malondialdehyde
(a marker reflecting oxidation and impaired endothelial function) also
increases. Individuals with hemochromatosis who were appropriately treated
had lower levels of malon-dialdehyde, and their blood vessels performed
with greater normalcy (Tzonou et al. 1998; Fox 2002).
Patients with an iron overload are frequently advised to avoid foods
rich in vitamin C or vitamin C supplements because of the iron enhancing
factors associated with ascorbic acid. Some (with hemochromatosis) can
use 500 mg of buffered vitamin C, taken 3 times a day between meals, without
difficulty. Cast-iron cookware and iron-fortified foodstuffs should be
avoided, and meats and alcohol should be restricted. On the other hand,
coffee or tea consumed with meals assists in blocking iron absorption
from foods. Fruits (nonascorbic acid varieties) and vegetables are excellent
dietary choices for individuals with an iron overload. Simply withdrawing
iron-fortified foods from the diet can prompt dramatic changes in iron
levels.
Dispersed throughout the Therapeutic section are supplemental suggestions
to reduce iron overload, such as calcium, fiber, garlic, magnesium, vitamin
E, and green tea, but individuals wishing to protect themselves from iron
buildup may also want to consider a blood donation. Some individuals donate
the blood to themselves to ensure a healthy future supply, but this course
is only valuable if the individual is not anemic. Should anemia coexist
with hemochromatosis, drugs in the form of iron chelators may be prescribed.
Optimal iron levels appear to be <100 mcg/dL, although the standard
reference range is up to 180 mg/dL. Tests such as total iron binding capacity,
serum iron, and a DNA test called HLA-H, along with family history, are
other excellent screening tools for hemochromatosis.
Comment: Adequate amounts of iron are absolutely essential to good health,
but using iron supplements or iron fortified foods is not recommended
for men or postmenopausal women, unless diagnosed with an iron deficiency.
It is judged that approximately one of every 200 people actually has iron
overload disease. Read the sections devoted to Heredity and Chelation
Therapy in this protocol to learn more about hemochromatosis.
NEWER RISK FACTORS
In the last 25 years, the incidence of coronary fatalities has decreased
33%. This is due largely to avoiding the traditional risk factors. Dr.
Paul M. Ridker, M.D., M.P.H. (director of cardiovascular research at Brigham
and Women's Hospital in Boston , MA ), speculates that an auxiliary list
of newer predictive factors may significantly increase the numbers benefiting
from 21st century diagnostics and treatment (Ridker 1999a) (see Figure
3).
| Newer Predictive Factors |
| Fibrinogen (a marker for blood coagulability
and inflammation) |
| Fibrinolytic Activity (the regulation of
fibrinogen concentrations) |
| Lipoprotein(a) (a marker for impaired fibrinolysis
and plaque buildup) |
| Homocysteine (a marker for hypercoagulability
and vascular assault) |
| Syndrome X (a condition of insulin resistance
and hyperinsulinemia) |
| C-Reactive Protein (CRP) (an inflammatory
marker) |
Fibrinogen
Fibrinogen is a blood protein that plays a critical role in normal
and abnormal clot formation, a mechanism referred to as coagulation. A
process of checks and balances, an interaction between clotting factors
and naturally occurring anticoagulants, normally results in healthy levels
of fibrinogen and normal coagulation. If fibrinogen levels increase above
normal, however, a blood clot becomes a threat; if fibrinogen levels decrease
below normal, a hemorrhage can result. Although the reference range used
by most laboratories is 150-460 mg/dL, it is crucial to keep serum fibrinogen
under 300 mg/dL, a level considered safe.
The coagulation of blood depends upon a number of proteins found in
plasma, called clotting factors. Normally, clotting factors are inactive,
but following injury, they become activated. Exposed collagen or chemicals
released from injured tissues initiate a series of chemical reactions
that result in the production of prothrombin activators. Prothrombin activators
convert prothrombin to thrombin, which, in turn, converts fibrinogen to
fibrin (a network of protein fibers that can trap blood cells, bloodstream
infiltrates, and platelets). The risks multiply as materials become trapped
in the tangle. An atheromatous tumor (capable of continued growth) can
result in full occlusion (Whiting 1989; Seeley et al. 1991; Kohler et
al. 2000).
Fibrin may stimulate cell proliferation by providing a scaffold along
which cells migrate and by binding fibronectin, which stimulates cell
migration and adhesion. Fibrinogen thus encourages monocyte adhesion and
smooth muscle proliferation, further occluding the vessel. In advanced
plaque, fibrin may also be involved in the tight binding of LDL and the
accumulation of lipids (Smith 1986; Koenig 1999a).
Vascular closure represents only one facet of the risk: plaque is highly
susceptible to breakage and clot formation. About 700,000 heart attacks
and stroke deaths occur in the United States each year as a result of
a blood clot obstructing the delivery of blood to the heart or brain.
Reports in the New England Journal of Medicine showed that those with
high levels of fibrinogen were more than twice as likely to die of a heart
attack, but the risk of a stroke increases as well (Wilhelmsen et al.
1984; Packard et al. 2000).
A cohort of the large scale EUROSTROKE project (215 cases and 521 controls)
showed that fibrinogen was a powerful predictor of stroke, both fatal
and nonfatal events. After dividing subjects into four quartiles based
on fibrinogen levels, researchers found that the risk of stroke increased
nearly 50% for each ascending quartile. Fibrinogen increased the risk
of stroke independent of smoking status, but the odds ratio worsened with
higher systolic blood pressure. For example, the fibrinogen risk increased
from 1.21 among those with a systolic pressure below 120 mmHg to 1.99
among subjects with a systolic pressure of 160 mmHg or above (Bots 2002).
Fibrinogen also promotes the negative activity of platelets by encouraging
platelet aggregation (Koenig 1999b). In addition, German researchers determined
that fibrinogen deposition at the vessel wall promotes platelet adhesion
during ischemia (Massberg et al. 1999). Platelets, the smallest of blood
elements, are absolutely essential in sealing vascular injuries, whether
caused by a knife wound or hypertension. According to Dr. James Braly,
M.D., as long as the interior of the vessel is smooth, platelets are not
summoned into service; however, if trauma is detected, platelets rush
to the site, forming a plug to repair the wound. Once activated, platelets
do more than provide the materials for vascular repair. They also release
serotonin (a vasoconstrictor) and the powerful platelet aggregator thromboxane
A2, further adding to the risk of a thrombus (Braly 1985; Smith 1986;
Ernst et al. 1993).
Aortic stenosis is the abnormal narrowing of the valve between the left
ventricle and the aorta. The narrowing, or stenosis, is often associated
with calcification, a process that may involve fibrinogen (Levenson et
al. 1997). Fibrinogen appears to have an attraction for calcium; as fibrinogen
and calcium unite, the valvular diameter becomes smaller.
The Life Extension Foundation was the first research group to recognize
the importance of assessing fibrinogen as an independent risk factor for
cardiovascular disease. A study reported in the Journal of the American
College of Cardiology corroborated the Foundation's position on fibrinogen,
when nearly 400 male physicians participated in the Physicians' Health
Study (Ma et al. 1999). The blood fibrinogen levels of 199 subjects, who
experienced heart attacks during the study period, were compared with
those of 199 control subjects who did not suffer heart attacks. Individuals
having heart attacks had significantly higher fibrinogen levels compared
to those physicians with healthy fibrinogen levels. Several studies have
shown a stronger association between cardiovascular deaths and fibrinogen
levels than for cholesterol.
For example, a study involving 3043 patients with angina pectoris (who
underwent coronary angiography and were followed for 2 years) concluded
that higher baseline levels of fibrinogen were predictive of a heart attack
and likelihood of sudden cardiac death. In contrast, coronary risk was
low among patients with low fibrinogen concentrations despite increased
serum cholesterol levels (Thompson 1995). A similar study showed that
fibrinogen was directly associated with the presence of myocardial infarction
and an independent short-term predictor of mortality (Acevedo et al. 2002;
Bots et al. 2002; GSDL 2002).
Various factors influence plasma fibrinogen levels:
- Increased winter cardiovascular mortality is related to a cold weather
increase in fibrinogen. The exposure to cold increased fibrinogen 23-38%
over baseline (Woodhouse et al. 1997; Horan et al. 2001).
- Smokers and depressed individuals have higher levels of fibrinogen
(Mindell 1998; Castilla et al. 2002).
- Estrogen replacement therapy appears to attenuate normal age-related
increases in fibrinogen (Stefanick et al. 1995; el-Swefy et al. 2002).
Unfortunately, pharmaceutical drugs have not been of significant value
in reducing fibrinogen levels. The initial data suggested that Bezafibrate
(a European drug) reduced fibrinogen levels in patients with established
coronary heart disease. However, the Bezafibrate Infarction Prevention
Study yielded disappointing results, with no significant evidence of efficacy
in lowering fibrinogen (Behar 1999).
Anticoagulant therapy usually becomes the treatment of choice to reduce
fibrin. Warfarin (Coumadin) and heparin are often prescribed, but it is
difficult to administer enough of an anticoagulant to lessen the risk
of a blood clot without increasing the risk of a hemorrhage. Dispersed
throughout the Therapeutic section are products with fibrinolytic and
antiplatelet aggregating activity, such as aspirin, bromelain, curcumin,
essential fatty acids, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba, green tea, gugulipid,
niacin, pantethine, policosanol, proanthocyanidins, vitamin A, beta-carotene,
vitamin C, and vitamin E. A novel drug approach to reduce excess fibrinogen
is to take 400 mg of pentoxifylline twice daily.
To read about other factors affecting fibrinogen, consult the Obesity,
Sedentary Lifestyle, Gum Disease, Fibrinolytic Activity, and Link Between
Infection and Inflammation in Heart Disease sections in this protocol.
Fibrinolytic Activity
Balance between tissue plasminogen activators (t-PA) and plasminogen
inhibitors (PAI-1) controls activity in the fibrinolytic system. If the
fibrinolytic process is faulty, individuals can be classed as either hemorrhage
or thrombosis prone. Generally, increased PAI-1 concentrations reflect
impairment of the fibrinolytic process, with a reduction in plasmin formation
and an accumulation of fibrin, platelets, minerals, and lipids. This model
can predispose recurrent thrombosis. Recent data from animal and human
studies indicate that PAI-1 is preferentially produced in visceral adipose
tissue, a finding that explains the hypercoagulability associated with
obesity. In patients with PAI-1 deficiencies, a hemorrhage may be a concern
(Reilly et al. 1991; Farrehi et al. 1998; Kohler et al. 2000; Ridker 2000).
The New England Journal of Medicine reported that anomalies occurring
in t-PA and PAI-1 are likely to be critical factors underlying hyperinsulinemia
in ischemic heart disease (Despres et al. 1996; Ridker 2000). Barry Sears,
Ph.D., believes scientific evidence has rightly exposed hyperinsulinemia
as an indicator of an eventual heart attack (Sears 1995). Hyperinsulinemia
bestows some of its coronary damage by increasing the risk of hypertension
(twofold), hypertriglyceridemia (three- to fourfold), Type II diabetes
(five- to sixfold), and by diminishing HDL levels.
The research suggests that peripheral factors influence the clotting
of blood. For example, The Lancet reported that air travel increases the
risk of venous thrombosis by increasing prothrombin factors (Scurr et
al. 2000). Note: Venous thrombosis is a condition characterized by a blood
clot in a noninflamed vessel. Pain, swelling, and inflammation may follow
if the vein is significantly occluded.
Although blood clots loom as one of the dominant factors in cardiovascular
disease, the selection of supplements that favor fibrinolysis and discourage
platelet aggregation should be done sensibly. It is possible that the
cumulative value of nutrients that oppose blood clot formation could overcorrect
a condition, particularly if used in concert with prescribed blood thinners.
Note: For information regarding asymptomatic patients taking warfarin,
please consult the Vitamin K subsection in the Therapeutic section of
this protocol.
Lipoprotein(a) (Lp(a))
The peak time for the most damaging of heart attacks appears to
be between 6 a.m. and noon . The reason why is of deep concern to the
medical community. Some theorize that facing the challenges and urgencies
of a new day could be activating the sympathetic nervous system. Was the
"fight or flight" mentality too much stimulus for a cardiac
prone individual? Note: UCLA researchers speculate that if the sympathetic
nervous system is involved in the circadian pattern of sudden death, this
involvement reflects exaggerated morning end organ responsiveness to norepinephrine
(an adrenal medulla adrenergic hormone), not higher morning sympathetic
outflow (Middlekauff et al. 1995).
Japanese researchers took the question further and measured serum lipids
and clotting factors in two groups of men: those who suffered a heart
attack during the 6-hour morning "peak period" and those who
had a heart attack at other times during the day or night (Fujino et al.
2001). Morning heart attack victims were found to have significantly higher
levels of Lp(a), the only distinguishable factor compared to the other
group. There was also a tendency toward hypercoagulation, increasing the
risk for developing a life-threatening thrombus or clot. The conclusion
of the Japanese study was that increases in Lp(a) appear to be influencing
coagulation factors involved in the occurrence of morning heart attacks.
The physical character of Lp(a) adds to its complexities. For example,
Lp(a) is a distinctive serum lipoprotein composed of an apoB-containing
lipoprotein structure (virtually identical to LDL cholesterol) attached
by a single disulfide bond to a long carbohydrate-rich protein, apolipoprotein(a):
LDL + apo(a) = Lp(a).
Comment: apo(a) is remarkably similar to plasminogen, an inactive precursor
of plasmin (also called fibrinolysin), an agent capable of dissolving
fibrin (McClean et al. 1987; Hajjar et al. 1989; Harpel et al. 1989; Ridker
2000).
Because apo(a) is highly homogenous (having a likeness in form) with
plasminogen, it has been hypothesized that Lp(a) competes for plasminogen
that binds to fibrin and endothelial cell surfaces, thus inhibiting fibrinolysis.
Experimental work indicates that Lp(a) modulates fibrinolysis, inhibits
plasminogen binding to fibrin, and may also inhibit t-Pa, a clot-dissolving
substance produced naturally by cells in the walls of blood vessels. The
end result is a greater risk of blood clot formation, and thus heart attack
and stroke (Loscalzo et al. 1990; Ridker 2000; Caplice et al. 2001).
Complicating the atherosclerotic-Lp(a) mechanism, apo(a) has a sticky
"velcro" nature, causing it to easily tie up in blood vessels.
As apo(a) participates in vascular repair, its adhesiveness provides an
ideal trap for LDL, VLDL, and other bloodstream infiltrates, for example,
calcium. In layered fashion, circulating materials mount the debris, promoting
the growth of an atheromatous tumor. As plaque accumulates, greater amounts
of Lp(a) are observed at the site of the occlusion.
It should be noted that plaque formation is an essential response to
vascular injury. When a blood vessel has been damaged, repair is paramount.
If benign materials, such as vitamin C, are available to protect the vessel
from injury and to participate in vascular repair, the need for Lp(a)
is moot. Without adequate amounts of vitamin C, Lp(a) becomes indispensable
(Rath 1993).
There is a vast difference between the materials used to repair vascular
injuries. For example, vitamin C repairs the wound, leaving the vessel
wall smooth, but stronger; Lp(a) repairs the injury, leaving residual
trappings, a sticky compress, capable of continued growth. Although Lp(a)
has an important function in the body, Matthias Rath, M.D., considers
Lp(a) 10 times more dangerous than LDL cholesterol.
The risk of a major cardiovascular event nearly tripled among middle-aged
men (participating in a Lp(a)/heart study) whose Lp(a) levels fell within
the highest 20% of the study group compared to those with lower levels
(von Echardstein et al. 2001). The risks escalate even higher if Lp(a)
coexists with high LDL cholesterol, low HDL cholesterol, and hypertension.
Elevated Lp(a), above 30 mg/dL, has been noted in 20% of all thromboembolism
patients compared to 7% of healthy controls (von Depka et al. 2000). Lp(a)
may prove to be one of the most predictive of the risk factors for strokes,
re -stenosis (recurrent narrowing of a vessel), or heart attack following
either coronary bypass surgery or angioplasty. Recent studies also incriminated
Lp(a) in angina pectoris, citing accumulations of Lp(a) in the plaque
of unstable angina patients. Comment: According to the American Heart
Association, the lesions on artery walls contain substances that may interact
with Lp(a), leading to the buildup of fatty deposits (American Heart Association
2002).
Aortic stenosis, the narrowing of the valve separating the left ventricle
from the aorta, is often described as a calcification process. Lp(a) appears
to play a role in this process; as Lp(a) is deposited on the aortic valve,
it creates a binding site for calcium (Shavelle et al. 2002). Researchers
at the University of Washington (Seattle) hypothesized that HMG CoA reductase
inhibitors (statins) might slow aortic calcification: 28 patients receiving
statin therapy for approximately 2.6 years had a 62-63% lower rate of
aortic valve calcium accumulation; 44-49% fewer statin patients experienced
definite progression of the disease process (Shavelle 2002) (please consult
the section devoted to valvular disease for an in-depth discussion regarding
aortic stenosis).
The reference interval for Lp(a) is 0-30 mg/dL. Reference ranges are
valuable only as generic markers. Depending upon the test, risk may be
significantly increased as values reach upper or lower limits of normal.
Various reputable cardiologists strive for an Lp(a) less than 10 mg/dL
among patients (Sinatra 2002). Read about essential fatty acids, L-lysine,
L-proline, niacin, vitamin A, and vitamin C (nutrients that assist in
maintaining healthy Lp(a) levels) in the Therapeutic section of this material.
Introduction to Homocysteine
For a discussion relating to detoxification mechanisms and nutrients
to reduce homocysteine levels, consult the Homocysteine Lowering Nutrients
and Elimination Pathways subsections in the Therapeutic Section of this
protocol.
Although the dangers imposed by hyperhomocysteinemia are not a new discovery,
most of the medical community has until recently ignored homocysteine
as a cardiovascular risk. Decades ago, Kilmer McCully, M.D., pioneered
the homocysteine/cardiovascular hypothesis; the Life Extension Foundation
focused upon the dangers of homocysteine and outlined a vitamin protocol
to reduce hyperhomocysteinemia in an article released in November 1981
(Anti-Aging News pp. 85-86). Eric Braverman, M.D., joined the crusade,
describing homocysteine as a substance that is worse than cholesterol
(Braverman 1987).
Homocysteine is regarded as more dangerous than cholesterol because
homocysteine damages the artery and then oxidizes cholesterol before cholesterol
infiltrates the vessel. Craig Cooney, Ph.D., says that homocysteine is
now widely recognized by scientists as the single greatest biochemical
risk factor for heart disease, estimating that homocysteine may be a participant
in 90% of cardiovascular problems.
Although homocysteine's role in atherosclerosis and atherothrombosis
is confirmed, it should be noted that most naturally occurring substances
have purpose in physiology. The American Academy of Family Physicians
explains that homocysteine is typically changed into other amino acids
for use in the body's normal functions (American Family Physician 1997).
For example, homocysteine is an intermediate product of methionine metabolism.
Two pathways detoxify homocysteine, the remethylation pathway (which regenerates
methionine) and the trans -sulfuration pathway (which degrades homocysteine
into cysteine and then to taurine). The amino acids cysteine and taurine
are important nutrients for cardiac health, hepatic detoxification, cholesterol
excretion, bile salt formation, and glutathione production. Because homocysteine
is located at a critical metabolic crossroad, it either directly or indirectly
impacts the metabolism of all methyl - and sulfur groups occurring in
the body (Miller et al. 1997).
In addition, a select group of researchers contend that the residuals
(metabolites) of homocysteine appear to support adrenal gland function
and contribute to neurotransmitter synthesis and the regeneration of bones
and cartilage. If their undocumented speculations prove valid, it should
be strongly emphasized that homocysteine must be detoxified in order for
its byproducts to offer any biological advantage. If disposal systems
(remethylation and trans -sulfuration) are nonfunctional, allowing homocysteine
to accumulate, the results can be deadly. Remethylation and trans -sulfuration
are discussed in detail in the Therapeutic section of this protocol, under
the subsections Homocysteine Lowering Nutrients and Elimination Pathways.
The Hazards of Hyperhomocysteinemia
Experiments show that if homocysteine accumulates in the cell, all methylation
reactions are inhibited. Because methylation is used for so many body
processes (apart from homocysteine metabolism), if this system becomes
dysfunctional, essential pathways are foiled. For example, methylation
is fundamental to maintaining healthy DNA, lessening the possibility of
mutations and strand breaks. Since DNA strand breaks have been detected
in the biopsies of diseased cardiac tissue, it is suspected that strand
breaks fuel the progression of heart disease. In addition, DNA strand
breaks are associated with accelerated aging and a greater cancer risk
(Domagala et al. 1998; Seki et al. 1998).
If homocysteine is not detoxified and begins to accumulate, plaque builds
up in the endothelial cells lining the arteries through various mechanisms.
For example, homocysteine speeds the oxidation of cholesterol, which then
becomes bound to small, dense LDL particles. Macrophages then take up
the particles to become foam cells in plaque. The earliest detectable
lesion of atherosclerosis is the fatty streak (consisting of lipid-laden
foam cells that are macrophages that have migrated as monocytes from the
circulation into the subendothelial layer of the intima) that later become
fibrous plaque (Naruszewicz et al. 1994; Cranton et al. 2001). Dr. Kilmer
McCully, a crusader for the homocysteine theory of heart disease, says
that homocysteine plays a key role in every pathophysiological process
that leads to arteriosclerotic plaque (McCully 1996).
A heart attack or stroke is more likely to occur as homocysteine promotes
coagulation factors, favoring clot formation (Magott 1998). The European
Journal of Clinical Investigation reported that 40% of all stroke victims
have elevated homocysteine levels compared to only 6% of controls (Brattstrom
et al. 1992). Other studies chronicled similar findings: the elevations
in homocysteine in 16 of 38 patients with cerebrovascular disease (42%),
seven of 25 with peripheral vascular disease (28%), and 18 of 60 with
coronary vascular disease (30%) but in none of the 27 normal subjects
(Clarke et al. 1991).
In addition to causing cardiovascular disease by increasing the incidence
of blood clots, hyperhomocysteinemia triggers atherosclerosis by encouraging
smooth muscle cell proliferation, intimal-medial wall thickness, thromboxane
A2 activity, lipid abnormalities, and the binding of Lp(a) to fibrin (Magott
1998; Sandrick 2000).
Vascular integrity is compromised as homocysteine blocks production
of nitric oxide in the cells of blood vessel walls, causing vessels to
become less pliable and even more susceptible to plaque buildup (Boger
et al. 2000; Holton 2001). Scientists explain that vessels lose their
expansion capacities as homocysteine reduces nitric oxide's availability
(Tawakol et al. 2002). Homocysteine significantly hampers coronary microvascular
circulation by impairing dilation functions.
Drs. Allen Miller and Gregory Kelly explain that homocysteine facilitates
the generation of hydrogen peroxide. By creating oxidative damage to LDL
cholesterol and endothelial cell membranes, hydrogen peroxide can then
promote injury to vascular endothelium (Starkebaum et al. 1986; Stamler
et al. 1993; Miller et al. 1997). Nitric oxide (also known as endothelium-derived
relaxing factor) normally protects endothelial cells from damage by reacting
with homocyst eine, forming S-nitrosohomocysteine, which inhibits hydrogen
peroxide formation. However, as homocysteine levels increase, this protective
mechanism can become overloaded, allowing damage to the endothelial cells
to occur (Stamler et al. 1992, 1993, 1996).
Genes are also involved in homocysteine attack. This has a significant
impact upon the cardiovascular system, as homocysteine activates genes
in blood vessels, encouraging the coagulation process and the proliferation
of smooth muscles (Outinen et al. 1999).
Since homocysteine wields such a powerful cardiovascular blow from so
many different directions, it is estimated that a 3-unit increase in homocysteine
equates to a 35% increase in heart attack risk (Verhoef et al. 1996).
The risk becomes even greater if hyperhomocysteinemia occurs with other
risk factors. For example, a hypertensive woman with elevated homocysteine
levels has a 25-fold increased risk of vascular disease.
Other homocysteine/disease associations are:
- High concentrations of homocysteine and low levels of folate and
vitamin B6 are associated with an increased risk of extracranial carotid-artery
stenosis, particularly in the elderly (Selhub et al. 1995).
- Higher levels of homocysteine predispose deep venous thrombosis (den
Heijer et al. 1996).
- The link between hyperhomocysteinemia-hypercholesterolemia and hypothyroidism
is clearly drawn in the section devoted to Thyroid Disease appearing
in this protocol.
- Plasma homocysteine levels predictably increase with elevations in
creatinine. As chronic renal failure occurs, hyperhomocysteinemia is
frequently observed (Wilcken et al. 1979; Chauveau et al. 1993).
- Homocysteine metabolism is impaired in patients with Type II diabetes.
Intramuscular injections of 1000 mcg of methylcobalamin (a homocysteine-lowering
nutrient) once a day for 3 weeks reduced elevations of plasma homocysteine
in diabetic test subjects (Araki et al. 1993).
- While the focus of this protocol is upon cardiovascular disease,
it should be noted that individuals suffering with Alzheimer's disease,
depression, eye problems, liver damage, Crohn's disease, ulcerative
colitis, irritable bowel disease, pernicious anemia, and Parkinson's
disease often present with elevated homocysteine levels (Refsum et al.
1991; Savage et al. 1994; Mayer et al. 1996; Cattaneo et al. 1998; Clarke
et al. 1998; Romagnuolo et al. 2001; Duan et al. 2002).
- A large-scale prospective study of 4700 Norwegian men and women (65-67
years of age) showed that for each 5-millimol/L increase in plasma homocysteine
levels, the number of deaths from all causes jumped 49%. This included
a 50% increase in cardiovascular deaths, a 26% increase in cancer mortality,
and a 104% increase in noncancer and noncardiovascular fatalities (Vollset
et al. 2001).
Chronically high levels of homocysteine normally affect 30-40% of healthy
elderly people. But in older individuals with severe illnesses, the prevalence
of hyperhomocysteinemia may almost double. Based on a random testing of
600 hospitalized elderly patients (ages 65-102 years), researchers found
evidence of hyperhomocysteinemia in over 60% of those with serious chronic
conditions): 70% presented with vascular disease and 63% presented with
cognitive impairment (Ventura et al. 2001). Impaired kidney function,
the use of drugs (particularly diuretics), and malnutrition were suspected
as causes of age-related hyperhomocysteinemia. Of the senior population
in the United States , 67% have one or more vitamin levels within 15%
of the lower recommended range, suggesting the need for review of reference
values in elderly people.
While cholesterol does not normally pose a cardiac risk until levels
exceed 240 mg/dL, some researchers consider homocysteine so capricious
that even so-called normal levels may contribute to heart disease. Homocysteine
levels should be kept as low as possible, below 7 micromol/L of blood
plasma. Laboratories usually regard levels up to 15 micromol/L as normal,
but epidemiological data reveal that homocysteine levels above 6.3 reflect
a steep, progressive increase in the risk of a heart attack (Robinson
et al. 1995). Although the incidence of hypertension, thrombotic stroke,
peripheral vascular disease (gangrene), blood vessel toxicity, and the
risk of heart attack escalate as homocysteine levels increase, homocysteine
levels are not routinely evaluated in a cardiovascular work-up.
The Therapeutic section and the sections Homocysteine Lowering Nutrients
and Elimination Pathways detail a program to assist in managing hyperhomocysteinemia.
Note: Because of homocysteine's role in the metabolism of sulfur and methyl
groups, elevated levels of homocysteine would be expected to negatively
impact the biosynthesis of SAMe, carnitine, chondroitin sulfate, coenzyme
Q10, creatine, cysteine, dimethylglycine, glucosamine sulfate, glutathione,
melatonin, pantethine, phosphatidylcholine, and taurine. Many of these
substances are profiled in the Therapeutic section for their cardioprotection
and restorative qualities. The short supply of these agents could severely
disable cardiac performance (Miller 1997).
Syndrome X
For the past 20 years, eclectic physicians have judged Syndrome X to be
a powerful indicator of an eventual heart attack. For clarity, let it
be understood that a syndrome represents clusters of symptoms. In Syndrome
X, the symptoms are an inability to fully metabolize carbohydrates; hypertriglyceridemia;
reduced HDL levels; smaller, denser LDL particles; increased blood pressure;
visceral adiposity; disrupted coagulation factors; insulin resistance;
hyperinsulinemia; and, often, increased levels of uric acid. Note: For
years, high uric acid levels have been associated with cardiovascular
disease, but the relationship was poorly understood. Dr. Gerald Reaven
unraveled the link when he determined that elevations in uric acid are
often prompted by Syndrome X, a forerunner to heart disease (Fang et al.
2000).
Until hyperinsulinemia is diagnosed and a therapeutic course is charted,
the arteries are under severe attack and the risk of a blood clot increases.
Lesions, or wounds and injuries, damage the arteries; the attempts at
vascular repair corrode the vasculature with atheromatous material, blockading
and closing off vital circulatory routes. The population of sticky platelets
increases along with the production of free radicals. Lipogenesis (the
production and accumulation of fat in arterial tissue) encourages smooth
muscles in the vasculature to proliferate. Along with excessive amounts
of fibrinogen (a plasma protein that encourages the clotting of blood),
PAI-1 is induced, further increasing the likelihood of a blood clot. HMG-CoA
reductase, the rate-limiting enzyme involved in hepatic cholesterol production,
appears to be simulated in both diabetic and nondiabetic animal studies
amidst high levels of insulin (Dietschy et al. 1974).
Syndrome X interferes with glucose delivery, a consequence initiated
by insulin's nonresponsiveness at the receptor site on the cell. Normally,
ordinary levels of insulin will escort glucose into the cell, leaving
a bloodstream favoring neither hyper- or hypoglycemia. In Syndrome X,
the receptor turns a cold shoulder to the hormone, and insulin is no longer
able to deposit its cargo; as a result, glucose loads up in the bloodstream.
The pancreas is aware of the problem and attempts to resolve it by discharging
more and more insulin. The logic appears to be that since normal levels
of insulin cannot get the job done, perhaps greater and greater amounts
of circulating insulin will be able to drive glucose, the principal metabolic
fuel, into our 100 trillion cells.
In most cases of Type II diabetes, the problem is insulin resistance
and inadequate compensatory insulin; in Syndrome X, insulin resistance
and excessive amounts of insulin are the hallmarks. The vast difference
between the two conditions is that in Syndrome X, the pancreas does not
falter in its effort to pump out insulin (Reaven 2000). It sounds as if
the host has won, but the following reasons discredit this logic.
- The pancreas can tire in its endless effort to supply compensatory
insulin, and insulin-dependent diabetes will result.
- Hormones are powerful substances with an equally meaningful purpose.
When insulin is not used for its intended functions, insulin builds
up in the bloodstream, and from various perspectives, the risk of heart
disease increases.
For example, the Quebec Cardiovascular Study found that individuals
with elevated levels of triglycerides and LDL cholesterol, plus low HDL
cholesterol, had 4.4 times the risk of heart disease compared to men with
none of the risk factors. But the risk soars to 20-fold for men with a
triad of elevated fasting insulin, apolipoprotein B, and small, dense
LDL particles. According to Dr. Benoit Lamarche ( Laval University ),
hyperinsulinemia should not be overlooked as an independent risk factor
for ischemic heart disease. His case-controlled study of 91 patients and
105 controls found fasting insulin levels 18% higher in cases than controls.
For each 30% increase in insulin concentration, there was a 70% increase
in the risk of ischemic heart disease over 5 years (Despres et al. 1996;
Physician's Weekly 1998b).
Insulin growth factor-1 (IGF-1), a hormone that increases the body's
sensitivity to insulin and promotes clearance of glucose and toxic metabolites,
appears critical to surviving the crisis and aftermath of a heart attack
(Conti et al. 2001). Lower levels of IGF-1 during the early phase of a
myocardial infarction are associated with poorer clinical outcomes, arrhythmias,
ischemia, and death.
Italian researchers measured IGF-1 levels in the blood of patients within
24 hours of the onset of heart attack symptoms. IGF-1 (a hormone that
enhances the elasticity of blood vessels, strengthens heartbeat, and increases
blood flow) was about 5 times lower compared to healthy controls (47 ng/mL
versus 189 ng/mL). The transient reduction of IGF-1 during the early phase
of infarction appears to cause an acute worsening of insulin resistance.
A decline in IGF-1 is also linked to poorer prognosis following a heart
attack. Of the 23 patients evaluated regarding IGF-1 levels (postinfarction),
12 experienced adverse clinical events in the 90-day follow-up period.
The two individuals with the lowest IGF-1 levels died from the heart attack
or its complications. Negative end results were attributed to reduced
insulin sensitivity, glucose clearance, fat metabolism, and cardiac function.
Interestingly, infusing IGF-1 into rats (programmed to develop metabolic
syndrome) alleviated hyperphagia (overeating), obesity, hyperinsulinemia,
hyperleptinemia (excesses of a hormone frequently found in the bloodstream
of overweight, cardiac-prone individuals), and hypertension (Vickers et
al. 2001).
The IGF-1 system is regulated by various stimuli, including hormones,
growth factors, and nutritional status (Fu et al. 2001). For example,
IGF-1 increased when protein foods were emphasized in the diet, in combination
with adequate levels of vitamin D and calcium (Rizzoli et al. 2001).
Unfortunately, many physicians fail to consider insulin resistance as
a forerunner to Type II diabetes and cardiovascular disease. A fasting
blood glucose level above 115 mg/dL, triglycerides above 160 mg/dL, low
HDL cholesterol, blood pressure persistently over 140/90 mmHg, total cholesterol
above 240 mg/dL, and 10-15 pounds of extra weight are important evaluations
regarding the likelihood of insulin resistance (Challem et al. 2000).
A normal 2-hour postprandial glucose is generally between 70-139 mg/dL.
If fasting or 2-hour postprandial insulin levels are measured, a normal
range is 6-35 mcIU/mL. The Life Extension Foundation believes that fasting
insulin levels over 5 mcIU/mL may be a cause for concern, and respected
physicians and scientists are aligning with this projection.
Even if these tests are run, physicians often err in properly assessing
the cumulative values of multiple irregularities. The signs are all there,
but a failure to connect the dots can lead to a treatment that never addresses
the source of the ill health. Syndrome X is largely a nutritional disease
that is manageable with dietary corrections, reducing carbohydrates such
as sweets, pastas, and breads and instating good fats in carbohydrates'
place (consult the section entitled Essential Fatty Acids in this protocol
for a discussion regarding good and bad fats).
The Harvard University School of Public Health announced that women
between the ages of 38-63 increased their risk of heart attack by about
40% if their diet contained quantities of carbohydrates, particularly
refined carbohydrates (Liu et al. 2000). It has been determined that the
type of food selected and the quantity consumed determine how much insulin
must be supplied.
Dr. Gerald Reaven believes an appropriate breakdown of the food groups
should be about 45% of calories from carbohydrates, 40% from fat, and
15% from protein. Substituting appropriate fats for carbohydrates quiets
an insulin release from the pancreas, and a primary step in Syndrome X
has been averted. Dr. Reaven cautions that current dietary recommendations,
that is, replacing fats with carbohydrates, may be fine for some individuals,
but it is a grievous, even fatal, suggestion for those who are insulin
resistant (Reaven et al. 2000). Note: Nutritionists reviewing the concept
of macronutrient fractions stress the importance of selecting healthy
foods to supply requirements. Eating ad libitum from unwise food choices,
but within acceptable percentages, could still render the diet unhealthy
from many perspectives.
To read more about Syndrome X, consult the sections entitled Hypertension,
Obesity, Sedentary Lifestyle, Fibrinolytic Activity, and Beta-Blockers.
Also, the Therapeutic section has supplemental recommendations to assist
in controlling Syndrome X, including alpha-lipoic acid, conjugated linoleic
acid, DHEA, essential fatty acids, magnesium, vitamin A, and vitamin C.
C-Reactive Protein (CRP)
CRP is a marker for systemic inflammation that rises several hundredfold
in response to acute tissue injury but stays relatively stable in the
absence of inflammation. CRP appears in the serum before the erythrocyte
sedimentation rate begins to rise, often within 24-48 hours of the onset
of inflammation. Elevated CRP levels can indicate the presence of chronic
low-grade inflammation, with linkage to blood vessel damage and vascular
disease (Pasceri et al. 2000). High levels of CRP appear to alert mark
inflammatory processes that have the potential to disrupt fatty plaque
buildup inside blood vessels, causing a critical rupture; the end result
is a blood clot.
When CRP levels are factored in as a cardiovascular risk, along with
hypertension, diabetes, elevated cholesterol, family history, and BMI,
there is significant improvement in predicting cardiac health compared
with models that exclude CRP testing. Ten prospective studies (six in
the United States and four in Europe ) have consistently shown that hs-CRP
is a powerful predictor of a future first coronary event in apparently
healthy men and women. ("hs" refers to high sensitivity testing,
the only method able to discriminate the subtle differences in CRP in
a range that accurately predicts coronary risk.)
As new as CRP is to many as a risk factor in coronary artery disease,
Rudolf Virchow, a German pathologist (1821-1902), hypothesized that inflammation
was the causative factor in the atherogenic process. Decades later, scientists
confirmed that increased monocytes (white blood cells critical in early
plaque development) and macrophages (mononuclear phagocytic cells capable
of scavenging and ingesting dead tissue and degenerated cells) are present,
particularly at points of plaque rupture. It appears that CRP and several
other inflammatory markers may be elevated many years prior to a coronary
event.
However, data from the University of Texas Health Sciences Center indicate
that CRP is more than a measurable antecedent preceding a cardiac problem.
CRP, along with the cooperative efforts of an unidentified serum factor,
acts directly upon the blood vessels to activate adhesion molecules in
endothelial cells: the intercellular adhesion molecule (ICAM-1) and the
vascular cell adhesion molecule (VCAM-1). VCAM-1 appears to be an early
molecular marker of lesion-prone areas as a response to experimental hypercholesterolemia.
In humans, ICAM-1 and VCAM-I expression is increased in the endothelium
of atherosclerotic plaque. Researchers concluded that CRP appears intricately
involved in the inflammatory process, thus proving to be a potential target
for the treatment of atherosclerosis (Pasceri et al. 2000; Biomedical
Science 2001; Alvaro et al. 2002).
The journal Circulation reports that CRP appears able to affect the
activity of LDL cholesterol (increasing atherogenesis). The cycle begins
as stranded LDL is taken up by macrophages; macrophages, gorged with fats
contained in blood, become bloated and develop into foam cells. When foam
cells have reached their maximum load, they explode, discharging their
fatty contents into the blood vessel wall at the site of injury. The presence
of added fat signals the need for more macrophages to clean up the mess.
They stuff themselves, explode, and the cycle starts anew. Since native
LDL does not induce foam cell formation, CRP appears to ready LDL for
uptake by the macrophages, initiating the sequence (Braley 1985; Zwaka
et al. 2001).
In the Physicians' Health Study, middle-aged men deemed healthy at baseline
were evaluated over an 8-year period in regard to CRP levels and a cardiovascular
event. This study showed that those in the highest quartile of hs-CRP
had a twofold higher risk of (future) stroke, a threefold higher risk
of (future) heart attack, and a fourfold higher risk of (future) peripheral
vascular disease (Rifai et al. 2001a, 2001b). Stroke patients with the
highest CRP levels were nearly 2.4 times more likely to die within the
next year compared to patients with the lowest levels (DiNapoli et al.
2001). Another of hs-CRP's strengths is its ability to detect at-risk
patients with normal cholesterol levels.
The risk of stroke, according to data reported in the New England Journal
of Medicine, decreased among those using statin drugs (White et al. 2000).
The Cholesterol and Recurrent Events Trial concluded that pravastatin
(administered long term) appears to be doing more than reducing cholesterol,
perhaps acting as an anti-inflammatory. Another study (also published
in the New England Journal of Medicine) reported that pravastatin reduced
CRP levels after both 12- and 24-weeks' administration, independent of
LDL cholesterol levels. It appears statin therapy may prevent coronary
events among individuals with relatively low lipid levels but with elevated
levels of CRP (Ridker et al. 2001). Conversely, some drugs, including
hormone replacement therapy, actually increase CRP levels and the inflammatory
response.
Researchers hypothesized in the Journal of the American College of Cardiology
that the cytomegalovirus (CMV) (herpes-type viruses) may stimulate an
inflammatory response, reflected by elevated CRP levels. The journal Circulation
reported that older people who have IgG antibodies to the herpes simplex-I
virus experienced a twofold increase in the risk of a myocardial infarction
or coronary heart disease death. Since the relationship between CMV and
coronary heart disease is not observed in all people, researchers consider
the ability of individuals to control CMV inflammatory activities, the
variable in the progression to a myocardial infarction (Zhu et al. 1999;
Siscovick et al. 2000).
The infectious process in heart disease is chronicled in numerous studies,
but the microorganisms involved remain of interest. Subsequently, a group
of researchers from Johannes Gutenberg University (in Mainz , Germany
) evaluated 572 heart patients. They tested for antibodies in the bloodstream
that would show that the immune system had at some stage been exposed
to a variety of different viruses and bacteria. These included herpes
simplex-1 and -2, which cause cold sores and genital herpes; Epstein-Barr
virus, which causes mononucleosis, chlamydia, and flu virus; and Helicobacteria
pylori, which causes stomach ulcers. Then they looked at the patients
again 3 years later to see how many had survived. The death rate was 3.1%
in patients who tested positive for only a few of the viruses or bacteria,
9.8% for those with four or five, and 15% in those positive for six to
eight. Among those who had the most advanced artery hardening, 20% of
those exposed to between six and eight infections had died, compared to
7% of those with three or fewer (BBC 2002b).
Japanese researchers concentrated upon finding a method to distinguish
between bacterial and viral infection by measuring inflammatory markers,
among them C-reactive protein (CRP). They found that during the acute
stage of bacterial infections, CRP levels were moderately or highly increased,
whereas in viral infections, CRP levels were normal or slightly increased.
The researchers propose that the measurement of CRP (among various inflammatory
markers) during the acute phase of illness, that is, within 5 days of
onset, is of value to determine whether the infection is caused by a bacteria
or virus (Sasaki et al. 2002). For an opposing view regarding the association
between viruses and CRP levels, please consult the section entitled Link
Between Infections and Inflammation in Heart Disease in this protocol.
Figure 4 shows the risk factors associated with CRP (data extracted
from publications authored by Dr. Paul Ridker). It is important to note
that risk factors vary according to individual publications and may change
with future publications.
| Risk Factors Associated with
CRP |
|
RELATIVE RISK FOR:1 |
| MEN |
Future MI |
Future Stroke |
| CRP (mg/L) |
(heart attack) |
|
| >2.11 1.15-2.10 0.56-1.14 <0.55
|
2.9 2.6 1.7 1.0 |
1.9 1.9 1.7 1.0 |
| |
RELATIVE RISK FOR: |
| WOMEN |
Future MI |
Future Stroke |
| CRP (mg/L) |
(heart attack) |
|
| >7.3 |
5.5 |
5.5 |
| 3.8-7.3 |
3.5 |
3.5 |
| 1.5-3.7 |
2.7 |
2.7 |
| <1.5 |
1.0 |
1.0 |
1 Relative risk is
the ratio of the chance of a disease developing
among members of a population exposed to a factor compared to
a similar population not exposed to the factor. |
| Ridker et. al. (1998);
Ridker et. al. (1997). |
Current research indicates that persistent CRP elevation, lasting longer
than 96 hours following a successful coronary stent implantation, is predictive
of prolonged inflammation leading to re-stenosis (Gottsauner-Wolf et al.
2000). Patients who developed re -stenosis within the first 6 months had
increases in CRP levels for up to 96 hours following the procedure, although
their baseline CRP had been normal. Patients without re -stenosis displayed
an increased CRP level that was sustained for no longer than 48 hours
and subsequently decreased. Higher CRP levels appear predictive of less
satisfactory end results, following angioplasty and stent procedures.
Although many of the newer risk factors are not yet standardized, some
laboratories are using a CRP reference range of 0.24-1.69 mg/L. Recent
medical events resulting in tissue injury, infections, or inflammation
may increase CRP levels and, if not factored into clinical interpretations,
can distort results.
To read more about factors affecting CRP levels, consult the sections
referring to Smoking, Obesity, Sedentary Lifestyle, Gender, Gum Disease,
and The Link Between Infections and Inflammation in Heart Disease. Improved
glycemic control and normalizing blood pressure may also assist in reducing
inflammation and (subsequently) CRP levels.
CRP appears responsive to aspirin, DHEA, fish oil, pravastatin, vitamin
C, vitamin E, and vitamin K supplementation (consult the Therapeutic Section
to learn more about natural products). As research continues, it may be
found that many other nutrients and herbs known for their anti-inflammatory
properties are equally valuable in maintaining healthy CRP levels. Note:
CRP appears to reduce levels of vitamins A, C, and E, as well as carotenoids,
zinc, and selenium. Individuals with elevations in CRP may wish to emphasize
these nutrients for their contribution to cardiac health.
THE LINK BETWEEN INFECTIONS
AND
INFLAMMATION IN HEART DISEASE
Infections are of particular interest because of the increasing attention
paid to the role of inflammation in heart disease, according to David
S. Siscovick, M.D., professor of medicine and epidemiology at the University
of Washington . The data incriminate the infectious process in various
phases known to contribute to heart disease. For example, current research
suggests that infection may be an important determinant of fibrinogen
levels, offering one possible explanation for the association between
chronic or acute infection and vascular events (Woodhouse et al. 1997).
Many researchers class inflammation as worse than cholesterol at triggering
heart attacks. Note: Men
with hypercholesterolemia and inflammation have a significantly higher
risk of cardiovascular death (2.4) compared to those with only high cholesterol
levels (1.4) (Engstrom et al. 2002).
Dr. Paul Ridker ( Boston 's Brigham and Women's Hospital) recently explained
that everyone reaching middle age has some degree of fat buildup, that
is, plaque in the vasculature. New evidence suggests the plaque becomes
threatening if weakened by inflammation, which makes the buildup squishy
and fragile. Even a small lump can burst, promoting the formation of a
clot that in turn chokes off blood flow and causes a heart attack. Thus,
reducing the inflammatory process is of equal importance to lipid monitoring
in controlling the dangers of plaque (Associated Press 2002).
Researchers observed that mortality from ischemic heart disease markedly
increases during the flu season, particularly among the elderly. One reason
for this appears to be that patients with influenza A, a flu virus, tend
to have much higher levels of CRP. Researchers at Rochester General Hospital
and Rochester School of Medicine and Dentistry showed that CRP increased
370% during infection and that old age magnified the increase (Falsey
et al. 2001; Horan et al. 2001).
A higher white blood cell count, common when the body is fighting off
infection, is associated with an increased coronary risk by diminishing
blood flow to the heart muscle and encouraging blood clot formation. The
higher the white blood cell count, the greater the patient's risk of death
from a heart attack or of developing congestive heart failure (Barron
et al. 2000).
In fact, angina pectoris appears less a prognosticator of a forthcoming
heart attack than a febrile (flu-like, feverish) infection prior to the
attack. Peter Ammann, M.D. ( Switzerland ), stated that he has observed
significantly higher numbers of myocardial infarctions among patients
with febrile conditions, mainly of the upper airways, within 2 weeks prior
to infarction (Ammann et al. 2000; Healthlink 2000).
Bacteria appear to gain entry into the heart via immune cells, most
likely activated in the process of clearing infections from the respiratory
passages. The bacteria most suspected of initiating coronary problems
are Chlamydia pneumoniae, Pasteurella aerogenes, Enterococcus endocarditis,
Staphylococcus aureus, Enterococcus faecalis, Candida albicans, and Viridan
streptococcus. (Some researchers add H. pylori, a bacteria associated
with duodenal ulcers, peptic ulcers, and chronic gastritis, to the list.)
Tissue specimens from patients who had undergone a carotid endarterectomy
showed high levels of C. pneumoniae in 11 of 17 cases (64%). The American
Heart Association also reported that C. pneumoniae was found in the infected
arteries of autopsied cardiac patients. Dr. Tatu Juvonen ( Oulu University
Hospital in Finland ) explains that C. pneumoniae is a specific microbial
antigen that causes inflammation and atherosclerotic cells to proliferate
(Mosorin et al. 2000; Vink et al. 2001).
An alternative to this dismal situation may be antibiotic therapy, controlling
the inflammatory process attacking the vessel wall. An American study
of more than 16,000 British patients showed that people treated with two
types of antibiotics had a significantly reduced risk of heart attack.
Those treated with tetracyclines were at 30% less risk than patients not
given antibiotics, while those who took quinolones (antimicrobials) had
a 55% reduced risk. It appears antibiotics may act in the same fashion
as anti-inflammatory drugs, reducing inflammation in the arteries (BBC
News 1999, 2002a).
Inflammation appears to be an independent risk factor that may explain
cardiovascular disease in the presence of normal cholesterol, blood pressure,
and coronary arteries. MINC patients, individuals experiencing a myocardial
infarction with normal coronary arteries, should be at lower risk for
a cardiac event because they most often have normal electrocardiograms,
higher HDL levels, and no significant impairment in LDL cholesterol. Dr.
Ammann believes the trigger may be systemic inflammation or specific infective
agents, advancing a benign complaint to a life-threatening condition.
Interestingly, migraine headaches have also been observed as forerunners
to a heart attack in otherwise healthy individuals (Ammann et al. 2000;
HealthLink 2000).
IS ATRIAL FIBRILLATION PREDICTIVE
OF CARDIAC MORTALITY?
Atrial fibrillation, a condition shared by over 2 million Americans,
occurs when the atria, the upper chambers of the heart, beat faster than
the lower two chambers, the ventricles. Many problems can cause atrial
fibrillation, including a leaky heart valve, hypertension, obesity, stimulants
(including caffeine and alcohol), medications (such as sumatriptan, a
headache drug), and thyroid disorders. Dr. Robert Atkins, M.D., adds that
patients should be evaluated for heavy metal intoxication and mycoplasmal
infections, factors also capable of provoking atrial fibrillation.
Although not immediately life-threatening, atrial fibrillation may cause
up to a 30% reduction in cardiac output, resulting in shortness of breath,
fatigue, and reduced exercise capacity. In fact, the American Heart Association
no longer regards atrial fibrillation as a benign disorder. About 75,000
strokes related to atrial fibrillation occur each year in the United States
. Up to 23% of such patients die, and 44% experience significant neurologic
deficits. (The mortality rate from other causes of stroke is about 8%.)
Nonetheless, Dr. H.J. Crijns (University Hospital Gröningen, the
Netherlands), declares that even patients with heart failure should not
be in greater danger because of atrial fibrillation if the condition is
well managed (Kennedy 1999; Alpert 2000; Crijns et al. 2000).
Blood thinners are often prescribed for atrial fibrillation, but a program
based in natural medicine is also helpful. While full correction of the
chaotic rhythm associated with atrial fibrillation is often difficult
to achieve, nutritional supplements can lessen the risk of a blood clot.
Dr. William Campbell Douglass, M.D., states that vitamin E (800 IU daily),
cod liver oil capsules (4 daily), olive oil (1 tbsp daily), and bromelain
(about 750 mg 3 times a day on an empty stomach) have similar action to
Coumadin and aspirin, thinning the blood and reducing the risk of a thrombotic
event (Douglass 1996). Other heart nutrients such as CoQ10, hawthorn,
carnitine, taurine, magnesium, and ginkgo biloba are also important. To
read more about the supplements recommended for atrial fibrillation, please
consult the Therapeutic section of this protocol. Also refer to the Thrombosis
Prevention protocol in this book.
ARRHYTHMIA
An estimated 4 million Americans have recurring cardiac arrhythmias.
Arrhythmia is any change in the normal sequence of electrical impulses
in the heart that results in an abnormal rhythm. The heart might skip
a beat, beat irregularly, beat very slowly, or beat very fast. The symptoms
of a more serious arrhythmia and benign palpitations are very similar.
An arrhythmia might be brief and harmless or it might be associated with
cardiac disease. Therefore, arrhythmia should always be addressed by a
qualified physician because the end result can be quite dissimilar (although
not representative of the norm, some types of arrhythmias can be extremely
dangerous or even fatal). The major types of cardiac arrhythmias are:
- Tachycardia (a heart rate in excess of 100 beats per minute).
A reduction in parasympathetic tone or an increase in sympathetic stimulation
will increase the frequency of heartbeats. An elevation in body temperature
or a toxic condition can also result in tachycardia. The abnormally
fast heart rhythm of tachycardia can prove dangerous because the racing
rhythm interferes with the heart’s ability to contract properly
(Seeley et al. 1991; Ozdemir et al. 2003).
- Bradycardia (the ventricles beat at a rate less than 60
beats per minute). Bradycardia, even as low as 50 beats per minute,
can be normal in athletes and in individuals who lead a physically active
lifestyle (AHA 2002; NASPE 2002). In these people, regular exercise
maximizes the ability of the heart to pump blood efficiently, so fewer
heart contractions are required to supply the body's needs. In other
cases, bradycardia can be caused by excessive vagus nerve stimulation
(vagus stimulation is principally responsible for parasympathetic control
over the heart) (Merck Manuals 2003a). In addition, a dysfunctional
sinoatrial node (SA; specialized heart tissue that controls heartbeat),
as well as hypothyroidism, severe liver disase, hypothermia, and typhoid
fever can result in bradycardia. Medications including propranolol (Inderal),
atenolol (Tenormin), metoprolol (Toprol-XL), sotalol (Betapace), verapamil
(Calan, Isoptin, Verelan), and diltiazem (Cardizem, Dilacor-XR) can
slow the heart rate to bradycardia status (IH/HMS 2002; Stein 2003).
In some instances, the weak pace may indicate the heart is
not beating well enough to ensure adequate blood flow. Note:When
the parasympathetic nervous system is active, the heart rate tends to
be slower; conversely, the heart rate is accelerated when the sympathetic
nervous system is active.
- Sinus Arrhythmia (a normal increase in heart rate that
occurs during inspiration, the act of drawing air into the lungs). On
inspiration, there is a decrease in vagal tone (parsympathetic stimulation)
and an increase in sympathetic tone. This produces an increase in heart
rate. Conversely, on expiration there is an increase in vagal tone and
a decrease in sympathetic tone, resulting in a decrease in sinus rate.
Sinus arrhythmia (occurring most often in young healthy people) does
not result in symptoms and is generally classified as benign (Michaels
1995; MHI 1999).
- Paroxysmal Atrial Tachycardia (a sudden increase in heart
rate to 160–200 beats per minute that can last for only a few
seconds or for several hours). Paroxysmal atrial tachycardia starts
with a premature P wave that is superimposed on the T wave. The series
of early beats in the atria is responsible for the accelerated heart
rate. Paroxysmal atrial tachycardia (the most common form of arrhythmia
is children) is not regarded as a disease and is seldom life-threatening.
The episodes are usually more unpleasant than they are dangerous and
the prognosis is generally good. Note:The
P wave results from depolarization of the atrial myocardium and precedes
the onset of atrial contractions (atrial contraction begins at about
the middle of the P wave); the T wave represents repolariztion of the
ventricles (Seeley et al. 1991).
- Atrial Flutter (the atria beat more often than the ventricles).
This means that the atria have a shorter time to push all of their blood
into the ventricles and the ventricles may not fill with sufficient
blood. Depending upon how fast the atria are beating, the body may not
receive enough oxygen-rich blood. The faster the atria beat, the more
difficult it is for the body to receive ample oxygen. Atrial flutter
is subdivided into two types: typical and atypical. Typical atrial flutter
has a very characteristic electrocardiogram (ECG) pattern and is caused
by localized reentry with impulse pathways occupying large portions
of the right atrial wall. Because the circuit is fixed and accessible,
typical atrial flutter can often be treated by destroying a portion
of the circuit during a procedure known as ablation. Conversely, atypical
atrial flutter exhibits a more variable ECG pattern and more than one
circuit may be responsible. Atypical atrial flutter behaves much more
like atrial fibrillation (pounding heart rate or pulse, shortness of
breath, or dizziness) than does typical atrial flutter. Thyroid disorders,
heart valve disease, coronary artery disease, and heart failure as well
as a swelling or irritation near the heart are possibilties that can
provoke atrial flutter. If a fast atrial flutter goes untreated, the
body could become oxygen deprived. As a result, a heart attack or fluid
accumulation in the lungs are possible consequences. The sooner treatment
is begun, the better the chances are of avoiding serious cardiac or
respiratory endangerments (Seeley et al. 1991; PDR 1997).
- Atrial Fibrillation (the two small upper chambers of the
heart, the atria, quiver instead of beating effectively). Because blood
is not completely pumped out of the atria, blood may pool and clot.
If a piece of a blood clot in the atria leaves the heart and becomes
lodged in an artery in the brain, a stroke results. It is estimated
that about 15% of strokes occur in individuals experiencing atrial fibrillation.
An individual with atrial fibrillation does not always have blockages
in the arteries (coronary arteries) that serve the heart muscle or other
serious heart problems, but the odds favor a cardiac association. Chronic
hypertension (high blood pressure); abnormalities of the heart valves
(thin tissue flaps that keep blood flowing in one direction through
the heart); and abnormalities of the heart's pumping function are causes
of atrial fibrillation. About one third of individuals with atrial fibrillation
have no structural heart disease and no identifiable cause for their
heart rhythm problem. In these instances, atrial fibrillation may be
due to (1) microscopic abnormalities of the muscle of the atria; (2)
abnormalities within individual heart cells; (3) abnormal electrical
properties of groups of heart cells; and (4) exposure to heart stimulants
such as alcohol, caffeine, or too much thyroid hormone (Seeley et al.
1991; MC 2003).
- Ventricular Tachycardia (a rapid heart beat initiated within
the ventricles and characterized by three or more consecutive premature
ventricular beats known as ectopic beats). Ventricular tachycardia (occurring
in approximately 2 out of 10,000 individuals) is a potentially lethal
arrhythmia that can cause the heart to become unable to pump adequate
amounts of blood throughout the body. The heart rate might be between
160–240 beats per minute. Ventricular tachycardia can occur spontaneously
or it can develop as a complication of a heart attack, cardiomyopathy,
mitral valve prolapse, and myocarditis or after heart surgery. It may
also be a result of scar tissue formed following an earlier heart attack
or an undesired effect of anti-arrhythmic drugs. Disrupted blood chemistries
(a low potassium level), pH (acid/base) changes, or insufficient oxygenation
can trigger ventricular tachycardia. Re -entry (re-stimulation of the
electrical conductive pathway from a single initial stimulus) may also
be a mechanism in ventricular tachycardia. Sustained ventricular tachycardia
is dangerous because it can worsen until it becomes ventricular fibrillation
; —a form of cardiac arrest (Seeley et al.1991; Illustrated
Health Encyclopedia 2002; Merck Manual s 2003b).
- Ventricular Fibrillation (a pulseless arrhythmia with irregular
and chaotic electrical activity and ventricular contractions in which
the heart immediately loses its ability to function as a pump). Sudden
loss of cardiac output with subsequent tissue hypoperfusion (a process
that intensifies anaerobic metabolism and instigates the formation of
lactic acid which further deteriorates the systolic performance of the
myocardium) creates global tissue ischemia. The brain and myocardium
(the middle layer of the heart, consisting of cardiac muscle) are most
susceptible to injury. Without immediate emergency treatment (an electric
shock to restore normal rhythm), an individual loses consciousness within
seconds and dies within minutes. Ventricular fibrillation is the primary
cause of sudden cardiac death (Seeley et al. 1991; Kazzi et al. 2001).
Symptoms of more serious arrhythmias and symptoms of benign palpitations
can be very similar. Palpitations are often described as a sensation in
the chest and throat that the heart is flopping or pounding, seeming to
beat harder and faster than usual, or beating irregularly. Some individuals
experiencing palpitations report feeling faint, dizzy, or out of breath.
When no medical or cardiac cause can be found, lifestyle events such as
exercise, stress, or fear or using tobacco, caffeine, alcohol, cough and
cold remedies, or diet pills might be determined to be the cause of the
arrhythmia. Palpitations that recur, become sustained or uncomfortable,
or are associated with other symptoms require further investigation (Hendrickson
2001; DeRoin 2003; NHLBI 2003).
However, most individuals who experience heart palpitations have some
type of cardiac arrhythmia. Virtually any arrhythmia can cause palpitations.
The most common cardiac causes of palpitations are premature atrial complexes,
premature ventricular complexes, episodes of atrial fibrillation, and
episodes of supraventricular tachycardia. In some cases, palpitations
are caused by a more dangerous arrhythmia such as ventricular tachycardia.
Because life-threatening arrhythmias are usually seen in individuals with
underlying heart disease, it is especially important to identify the cause
of palpitations in individuals who have fundamental heart disease. The
same recommendation applies to palpitations in individuals who have significant
risk factors for heart disease: family history, tobacco habits, high cholesterol,
excess weight, or sedentary lifestyle (Fogoros 2003).
The Cardiac Cycle
Dysfunction in the heart's electrical conduction system can make the heart
beat too fast, too slow, or at an uneven rate. The cardiac cycle (the
period from the beginning of one heartbeat to the beginning of the next)
is the sequence of events that occurs when the heart beats. This cycle
is regulated by specialized cardiac muscle cells in the wall of the heart
that form the conduction system of the heart. The heart beats normally
when an electrical impulse from the SA node (sinoatrial node) moves uninterrupted
in a set pattern throughout the heart. The normal flow of an electrical
impulse is:
SA node → right atrium → AV node (atrioventricular node) →
atrioventricular bundles → bundle branches → special conducting
fibers (His-Purkinje system) → ventricles
The SA node, which functions as the pacemaker of the heart, is located
in the upper wall of the right atrium and initiates contractions of the
heart. Action potentials originate in the SA node and spread over the
right and left atria causing them to contract. A second area of the heart
called the atrioventricular node (AV node) is located in the lower portion
of the right atrium. When action potentials reach the AV node, they spread
slowly through the AV node and into a bundle of specialized cardiac muscle
called the bundle of His or atrioventricular bundle. The slow rate of
action potential conduction in the AV node allows the atria to complete
their contraction before action potentenials are delivered to the ventricles.
After the action potentials pass through the AV node, they are transmitted
rapidly through the atrioventricular bundle, which projects through the
connective tissue separating the atria from the ventricles, to two branches
of conduction tissue called the left and right bundle branches. At the
tips of the left and right bundle branches, the conducting tissue branches
further to many small bundles of Purkinje fibers. The Purkinje fibers
rapidly deliver action potentials to all the cardiac muscle of the ventricles.
As long as this exact route is followed, the heart pumps and beats regularly
(a normal heart rate, or number of contractions, is about 70–80
beats per minute) (Seeley et al. 1991; AHA 2002; NHLBI 2003).
Arrhythmia may also result from an abnormal impulse rate in the SA node
or when a condition called “heart block” exists. In heart
block, electrical signals are delayed, partially conducted, or completely
interrupted (NHLBI 2003).
Another common cause of arrhythmia is damage to the heart's "wiring"
resulting from decreased blood flow from clogged coronary arteries or
from heart muscle that died as a result of a heart attack (myocardial
infarction). Other factors affecting heart rhythm are ingested toxins,
congenital heart arrhythmia, anemia, thyroid conditions, hypoglycemia,
mitral valve prolapse, and high blood pressure (DeRoin 2003; THI 2003).
These underlying factors must also be treated to correct the arrhythmia.
Diagnostic tools used in arrhythmia are an electrocardiogram (ECG);
intracardiac electrophysiology study (EPS, a study that involves placing
wire electrodes within the heart to determine the characteristics of heart
arrhythmias); and tilt table examinations (tilt table study is mainly
used in diagnosing vasovagal syncope, a classic fainting episode). Once
serious arrhythmia is diagnosed, it might be treated with drugs; an implantable
device that sends electrical shocks or impulses to restore normal heart
rhythm, i.e., an implantable cardioverter defibrillator (ICD) or pacemaker;
or surgery that can remove misfiring heart tissue (radiofrequency and
surgical ablation) or create a new electrical pathway (maze surgery) (ACC
2002; DeRoin 2003; NHLBI 2003).
Frequently used anti-arrhythmic drugs are anticoagulants (warfarin);
sodium channel blockers (class I); beta-blockers (class II); potassium
channel blockers (class III); calcium channel blockers (class IV); and
digitalis (Chaudhry et al. 2000; ACC 2002). Almost all medications have
side effects including the antiarrhythmic drugs. One side effect is a
potentially life-threatening pro-arrhythmia (meaning the drug
itself causes arrhythmia). Because studies show that anti-arrhythmics
have no mortality benefit and can even increase mortality, patient benefit
vs. risk must be considered before using anti-arrhythmics (Brendorp et
al. 2002; Sanguinetti et al. 2003; Yamreudeewong et al. 2003). Overall
there is still no ideal anti-arrhythmic agent and drug selection remains
highly individualized (Tsikouris et al. 2001).
Arrhythmia and Myocardial Infarction
Patients are monitored very closely in a coronary intensive care unit
immediately following a myocardial infarction (MI) because this is
a time period when life-threatening dysrhythmias can develop. Life-saving
thrombolytic treatment that is used to open a clogged coronary artery
(“clot busters”) can also cause an increased risk of dysrhythmia.
Successfully opening an artery results in a sudden influx of blood (reperfusion)
into the blood-starved area of the heart. Reperfusion has the potential
to cause a fatal arrhythmia. In part, the culprit is thought to be a free-radical
reaction. Therefore, reducing the free-radical burden on the heart offers
potentially helpful benefits. In a post-MI setting, studies have demonstrated
the importance of cardio -protective treatment.
Natural Approaches
Compared to placebo, when coenzyme Q10 (120 mg daily) was given to patients
with acute MI, there was significant reduction in total arrhythmias and
symptoms of angina pectoris. There was also better left ventricular function.
Total cardiac events, including cardiac deaths and nonfatal infarction,
were also significantly reduced in the CoQ10 group compared to the placebo
group (15.0% vs. 30.9%) (Singh et al. 1998). Subsequent studies demonstrated
that CoQ10 significantly reduced serum lipoprotein(a) and decreased oxidative
stress overall. After 1 year of follow-up, even subjects receiving optimal
lipid-lowering therapy (lovastatin) had a significant reduction in total
and low-density lipoprotein (LDL) cholesterol compared to baseline levels.
Fatigue was found to be more common in the placebo group which did not
receive CoQ10 (Singh et al. 1999, 2003).
Omega-3 fatty acids (fish oil) given within 18 hours to patients with
acute MI also demonstrated protective benefits, and after 1 year of follow-up,
total cardiac events were significantly reduced (including nonfatal infarctions,
cardiac deaths, total cardiac arrhythmias, left ventricular enlargement,
and angina pectoris) (Singh et al. 1997). Other benefits provided by omega-3
fatty acids were reduced rates of heart attacks; reduced susceptibility
to sudden death from ventricular arrhythmia; and reduced inflammation
and lowered serum triglycerides (O’Keefe et al. 2000; De Caterina
et al. 2003; Lee et al. 2003). Lee et al. (2003) concluded that “the
use of omega-3 fatty acids should be considered as part of a comprehensive
secondary prevention strategy post-myocardial infarction.” Flaxseed,
perilla, and fish oils are sources of omega-3 fatty acids. Perilla oil
works well (Ezaki et al. 1999); does not have an unpleasant taste; and
does not cause the gastrointestinal side effects which limit the use of
fish oil for some. Note:Because EPA/DHA can
interfere with blood clotting, individuals with any type of hemorrhagic
disease related to excessive bleeding should consult their physician before
supplementing with fatty acids. In addition, individuals taking anticoagulant
drugs such as Coumadin should inform their physician that they are taking
EPA/DHA supplements. The dose of anticoagulant medication they are taking
might require adjustment based on template bleeding time tests.
Ensuring that the heart gets enough blood and protecting it from free
radical reactions are essential. Natural medicine offers tremendous possibilities
for individuals with arrhythmia, but it is important to remember that
no treatment should be undertaken without the guidance of a cardiologist
or physician trained in natural medicine as well as the approval of your
personal cardiologist or physician. In particular, close professional
medical supervision is essential with larger doses. Pregnant women should
never take any supplement without consulting their personal physician.
Additionally, persons with cardiac arrhythmias should avoid caffeine,
heavy alcohol intake, and saturated fats. Chelation therapy might also
be an option.
The Therapeutic Section of this protocol includes discussions
of numerous supplements that offer protective and supportive benefits
for individuals with arrhythmias: acetyl-L-carnitine, alpha lipoic
acid, angelica, bugleweed, coenzyme Q10, fish oil, garlic, Ginkgo biloba,
hawthorn, magnesium, olive leaf extract, perilla and flaxseed oil, potassium,
selenium, taurine, thiamine, and vitamin E.
WARNING: Some supplements are regarded as pro-arrhythmic in susceptible
individuals (e.g., Ma Huang and excessive dosages of supplemental choline).
Additionally, before supplementing with the nicotinic acid form of vitamin
B 3, cardiac patients with arrhythmias should consult with a physician
(NASPE 2003; NTC website).
CONGESTIVE HEART FAILURE
Congestive heart failure (CHF) reflects the heart's inability to pump
sufficient amounts of oxygenated blood to supply the body's needs. It
does not mean the heart has ceased to work, but rather that the heart's
pumping mechanism is performing inadequately. Conditions that damage the
heart, such as a heart attack, ischemic heart disease (a lack of oxygen
in tissue cells), cardiomyopathy (fibrous tissue partially replaces heart
muscle and blood no longer moves efficiently), alcohol abuse, rheumatic
fever, arrhythmias, pericarditis (inflammation of the thin sac covering
the heart), or drug toxicity can result in CHF. Symptoms of CHF are fluid
retention, fatigue, weakness, and unjustified dyspnea (shortness of breath
after slight exertion). In some cases, liver and kidney function are also
disrupted.
CHF occurs when the heart fails to adequately pump blood through the
largest organ of the human body, 65,000 miles of blood vessels (the vascular
system). This breakdown causes increased pressure in the circulatory system,
allowing fluid to escape from the bloodstream and accumulate in tissues
and organs. More than 100 years ago, CHF would have been diagnosed as
dropsy, an abnormal accumulation of a clear watery fluid in a body tissue
or cavity. Dropsy was the most common of all forms of heart problems until
the current epidemic of coronary diseases.
The heart is a two-sided instrument, having a right and left atrium
and a right and left ventricle. The atria of the heart receive blood from
veins and function as reservoirs before the blood enters the ventricles.
The ventricles are the major pumping chambers of the heart, ejecting blood
into the arteries and forcing it throughout the vascular system.
Just as there are two sides to the heart, there are two types of heart
failure (right-sided and left-sided). The right side of the heart has
the job of moving the blood through the pulmonary blood supply to the
lungs, where it picks up oxygen. If the failure occurs on the right side
of the heart, it means the right side is not keeping pace with the left
side and the blood accumulates in the vessels leading to the heart. Excess
fluid (as peripheral edema) occurs in the lower legs, ankles, and feet
(Atkins 1988).
In left-sided failure, the ventricle that normally pumps blood from
the lungs through the aorta to the body lags in its effort compared to
the right ventricle. Blood accumulates in the veins leading from the lungs,
and the lungs become congested. Terms such as pulmonary edema or fluid
in the lungs usually mean the left side of the heart is failing, allowing
the congestion. The patient may experience shortness of breath (most evidenced
upon exertion) or paroxysmal nocturnal dyspnea (shortness of breath occurring
after several hours of sleep). Often, left-sided and right-sided failures
coexist, meaning the patient may experience both at the same time. Acute
pulmonary edema can be fatal.
Traditional medicine treats CHF with diuretics and inotropic drugs that
increase the contractility of the heart. If overweight, a weight-loss
program will probably be recommended, as well as an individualized exercise
regime. Abstinence from tobacco, either direct or secondhand, is essential.
Experimental studies have shown that nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs
(NSAIDs) can lead to the development of congestive heart failure when
given to susceptible individuals. Researchers feel that there have been
few epidemiological investigations equal to the importance of this finding
(Page et al. 2000).
The Archives of Internal Medicine clarified the risks, reporting that
NSAIDs appear to cause fluid retention and an increase in blood pressure
in patients with prevalent heart failure. Patients who have had congestive
heart failure, angina, heart attacks, bypass surgery, or angioplasty with
stent placement should seriously consider safer alternatives. This warning
is not restricted to prescription NSAIDs but to over-the-counter anti-inflammatory
drugs as well (Feenstra et al. 2002).
Dispersed throughout the Therapeutic section of this protocol are numerous
supplemental suggestions to benefit the patient with CHF. (Read about
alpha-lipoic acid, L-arginine, L-carnitine, coenzyme Q10, hawthorn, vitamin
B6, selenium, taurine, and thiamine.) Diet also plays an important role.
For example, carbohydrate restriction exerts a diuretic effect, prompting
an immediate loss of salt and water. Removing water accumulations from
saturated tissue is of great advantage to individuals with high blood
pressure and congestive heart failure.
VALVULAR DISEASE
The purpose of heart valves is uncomplicated. Valves simply route the
blood in a forward direction, preventing its backward flow. Functioning
properly, valves are control devices, opening and closing with each beat
of the heart, warranting a healthy lap around the circulatory system.
But valves can be damaged by rheumatic fever, infections, injuries, tumors,
and calcification, hampering their ability to direct the blood supply.
Some valves, once injured, pose more serious health hazards than others.
Those include the mitral, aortic, and the tricuspid valves and are the
focus of this section of the protocol. Note: This material was collected
in part from the ACC/AHA Guidelines for the Management of Patients with
Valvular Heart Disease (Bonow et al. 1998).
Mitral Valve
The mitral valve, or bicuspid valve, is located between the left atrium
and the left ventricle. (The mitral valve is the only valve with two rather
than three cusps.) The mitral valve allows oxygenated blood to flow from
the left atrium into the left ventricle but prevents blood from flowing
back into the atrium. As blood is forced against the valve, it closes
the two cusps, allowing a smooth trajectory from the ventricle to the
aorta.
Mitral Valve Prolapse
Mitral valve prolapse (MVP), or floppy valve syndrome, is a slight deformity
in the valve separating the left atrium from the left ventricle, a condition
that affects 5-10% of the population. During MVP, one or both of the cusps
protrude back into the left atrium, causing the floppy valve appearance.
Mitral valve prolapse is fairly benign in most patients, but about 1-10%
of MVP patients have serious problems such as chest pain, arrhythmias,
and leakage of the valve, leading to congestive heart disease. Coenzyme
Q10 and magnesium (detailed in the Therapeutic section of this protocol)
are of significant advantage to individuals with MVP.
Mitral Valve Regurgitation
Mitral regurgitation, the backflow of blood from the left ventricle into
the left atrium, occurs because the valve is too leaky. The mitral valve
can become regurgitant for many reasons, including the aging process,
rheumatic valvular disease, endocarditis, chest trauma, or a previous
heart attack. Mild but chronic regurgitation does little to alter the
overall cardiac health of the patient, but if the condition is moderate
to severe, the left ventricle and left atrium can enlarge because of the
increased volume of blood. The enlargement of the left atrium can cause
symptoms of fatigue, pulmonary edema, atrial fibrillation, and atrial
thrombi. The enlargement of the left ventricle can lead to congestive
heart failure.
The leakage can be repaired by surgery and/or insertion of a metal ring
around the valve to assist in holding the valve in shape. If surgical
replacement is elected, the diseased valve is cut out and replaced with
a prosthetic heart valve.
Knowing when to perform the surgery is critical. The consequences of
waiting too long may negate any surgical advantage because of enlargement
and damage to the left ventricle. Leakiness occurring in a damaged valve
can actually make the job of the left ventricle easier. The effort expended
by the left ventricle when the valve is leaking is less than when the
valve is repaired. The weakened left ventricle may not be strong enough
to keep pace with the efficiency of the repaired or artificial valve.
Therefore, the first sign of left ventricular impairment may be the best
clue that it is time to consider surgery.
Mitral Valve Stenosis
Mitral stenosis occurs when the mitral valve is too tight, and the blood
cannot flow easily from the left atrium to the left ventricle. To compensate,
the left atrium will enlarge to develop the extra pressure to push the
blood into the ventricle. As pressure in the left atrium increases, blood
pools in pulmonary vessels. The excess blood then seeps out into the air
spaces of the lungs and shortness of breath results.
If the condition is mild, there is a minimal effect on the overall health
of the person. However, some patients experience significant symptoms
such as fatigue, dyspnea, orthopnea (requires sitting or standing to breathe
comfortably), and cyanosis (a bluish discoloration of the skin and mucous
membranes). Mitral valve stenosis can lead to atrial fibrillation, which
if not well managed increases the risk of stroke. People who have the
combination of atrial fibrillation and mitral stenosis have a high rate
of stroke, on the order of 5% per year.
Therapeutic options include balloon valvuloplasty (a procedure in which
one or more balloons are placed across a narrowed valve and inflated to
decrease the severity of stenosis), mitral commissurotomy (a procedure
to increase the size of the opening by separating adherent, thickened
leaflets), or replacement with a prosthetic valve. The two methods of
repair are not permanent; the valve will become stenotic in about 5-15
years. A mechanical prosthetic valve requires chronic anticoagulation
therapy.
Tricuspid Valve
The tricuspid valve has three main cusps and is situated between the right
atrium and the right ventricle of the heart. The right atrium receives
blood returning from the body and pushes the blood into the right ventricle.
As the right and left ventricles relax (during the diastolic phase of
the heartbeat), the tricuspid valve opens, allowing blood to enter the
ventricle. During the systolic phase of the heartbeat, both blood-filled
ventricles contract, pumping out their contents while the tricuspid and
mitral valves close to prevent any backflow.
Tricuspid Regurgitation
Tricuspid regurgitation is a condition in which the tricuspid valve becomes
leaky, allowing blood to flow backward from the right ventricle into the
right atrium. It can occur by itself or in combination with a disease
process that elevates right ventricular pressure.
When tricuspid regurgitation occurs by itself, perhaps due to subacute
bacterial endocarditis, regurgitation does not pose much of a problem.
But when tricuspid regurgitation occurs in union with mitral stenosis
or lung disease, fatigue, abdominal discomfort, nausea, and swelling of
the legs and feet result. If surgery is scheduled to correct another cardiac
problem, the tricuspid valve should be evaluated for surgical repair at
that time. Otherwise, medical treatment includes a low-salt diet, diuretics,
and digoxin.
Tricuspid Stenosis
Tricuspid stenosis is a condition in which the tricuspid valve is too
tight. Symptoms of tricuspid stenosis closely parallel those of tricuspid
regurgitation, that is, nausea, fatigue, abdominal discomfort, and swelling
of the legs and feet. Patients are frequently advised to follow a low-sodium
diet and to use diuretics; if atrial fibrillation develops, digitalis
may be prescribed. Balloon valvuloplasty or valve replacement is usually
recommended if medical treatment proves ineffective. Because the risk
of thrombus on the valve is higher in the tricuspid position than in the
mitral position, bioprosthetic valves are better than mechanical valves,
despite their limitations.
Aortic Valve
The aortic valve, composed of three semilunar cusps, is located between
the left ventricle and the aorta. The aortic valve prevents blood from
flowing back into the left ventricle from the aorta.
Aortic Stenosis
Aortic stenosis is a condition in which the aortic valve is too tight.
This means that the opening through which blood must flow is too small;
consequently, the left ventricle must generate higher pressure to maintain
normal blood flow. It usually takes decades for the condition to fully
develop. Not until the aortic valve area has narrowed to about one-fourth
of its normal size do circulatory problems become significant.
The most common cause of aortic stenosis in adults is a degenerative
calcification process that immobilizes the aortic valve cusps. The calcification
process can either decrease worthiness of the valve or result in total
fusion. Studies implicate a chronic inflammatory process in calcium buildup,
leading to aortic valvular stenosis. Therefore, long-term anti-inflammatory
therapy may be beneficial.
The degree of closure does not always correlate to symptoms. Thus, aortic
valve replacement is usually reserved for patients experiencing symptoms,
rather than those with narrowing who are asymptomatic. Eventually, angina,
syncope (fainting), and heart failure may develop. After the onset of
symptoms, the average survival is usually less than 2-3 years.
Fifty-one asymptomatic patients with severe aortic stenosis were followed
for an average of 17 months. During this period, two patients died (with
cardiac symptoms preceding their deaths). Other studies have shown similar
survival trends among asymptomatic patients. (Sudden death occasionally
occurs in the absence of symptoms, but the numbers are small, less than
1% per year.)
Once symptoms have become apparent, surgery becomes the patient's best
option. Not all experts agree on when to do valve replacement surgery
in asymptomatic patients with aortic stenosis. The rationale for early
surgery is that the first symptom of aortic stenosis can be sudden death.
In theory, the aortic valve can be replaced in almost all patients,
even octogenarians, who are otherwise in good health. Insertion of a prosthetic
aortic valve is associated with low perioperative morbidity and mortality;
complications arise at the rate of at least 2-3% a year, with death due
directly to the prosthesis at about 1% a year. Symptomatic but inoperable
patients are usually prescribed digitalis, diuretics, and an ACE (angiotensin
converting enzyme) inhibitor.
Aortic Regurgitation
Aortic regurgitation occurs when the blood flows from the aorta back into
the left ventricle. Some of the blood that should be flowing to the body
from the heart flows back into the left ventricle. As a result, the left
ventricle has to pump harder to move the blood though the circulatory
route and back to the heart. A few of the factors provoking aortic regurgitation
include congenital deformities, calcification, rheumatic fever, infective
endocarditis, systemic hypertension, and anorexic drugs.
Acute aortic regurgitation is a medical emergency. During acute, severe
aortic regurgitation, the left ventricle does not have time to make the
necessary adjustments to accommodate the backflow and, as a result, forward
stroke volume decreases. Tachycardia (a heartbeat over 100 beats a minute)
occurs as a compensatory mechanism, but the effort is usually not equal
to the task. Pulmonary edema and/or cardiogenic shock, a condition of
critically low cardiac output, can result. (About 80% of events involving
cardiogenic shock are fatal.)
Conversely, in chronic aortic regurgitation, a number of compensatory
adjustments occur, rendering aortic regurgitation less dangerous. In fact,
the majority of patients remain asymptomatic through this compensated
phase, which may last for decades. With time, the left ventricle progressively
enlarges and depressed myocardial contractility increases. This can progress
to the extent that the full benefits of surgical correction, that is,
recovery of left ventricular function and improved survival, are no longer
possible.
The results of several studies, involving 490 asymptomatic patients
with chronic aortic regurgitation who were followed for an average of
6.4 years, give a brief history regarding the developmental patterns of
the condition.
- The rate of progression to symptoms and/or left ventricle dysfunction
averaged 4.3% a year. (As the left ventricle goes, so goes the heart.)
- Sudden death occurred in six of the 490 patients (an average mortality
rate of < 0.2% a year).
Are Artificial Valves as Good
as
Natural Valves?
The replacement of diseased natural heart valves with artificial valve
can be life-saving, but the replacement valves are never considered as
good as healthy natural ones. There are two general types of valves: mechanical
and bioprosthetic (usually taken from pigs). The mechanical valves last
longer but require the patient to take anticoagulants. The bioprosthetic
valves do not require long-term anticoagulation therapy, but they frequently
must be replaced after about 10 years in adults. Their replacement comes
quicker in children and persons on kidney dialysis. The major risk of
prosthetic heart valves is stroke. Those taking anti-coagulants reduce
the incidence of stroke, but the risk is not totally eliminated.
The following natural products may be of value to patients with valvular
disease. The herbs profiled have one or more chemicals that convey the
biological property delineated and are subsequently not equal in therapeutic
strengths (Duke Database). Researchers state that carnitine may provide
independent benefit in ischemia when used as monotherapy, or additional
benefit when used in combination with conventional beta-blockers or calcium
antagonists (Jackson 2001). To learn more about the following supplements,
please consult the Therapeutic section.
- Vasodilators. Angelica, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba, hawthorn,
magnesium, niacin, and olive leaf
- ACE inhibitors. Angelica, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba, grape seed,
green tea, hawthorn, olive leaf, procyanidins, and taurine
- Calcium blocking properties. Angelica, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba,
grape seed, green tea, hawthorne , magnesium, and olive leaf
- Digitalis-like activity. Bugleweed and taurine
- Diuretic activity. Angelica, bugleweed, curcumin, garlic, ginger,
grape seed, green tea, hawthorn, olive leaf, taurine, vitamin B6, vitamin
C, and vitamin E
- Anti-inflammatories. Angelica, bromelain, bugleweed, chondroitin,
curcumin, DHEA, EFAs, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba, grape seed, green
tea, hawthorn, olive leaf, and vitamin C
- Beta-blocking activity. Grape seed, green tea, hawthorn, magnesium,
and taurine
Therapeutic Section
The following therapeutics are arranged alphabetically and not by order
of importance, providing greater accessibility to readers.
Alpha-Lipoic Acid (a.k.a. Thiotic
Acid)—beneficial in preventing and treating Syndrome X, has antioxidant
and antidiabetic activity, protects LDL cholesterol against oxidation,
lowers total cholesterol, is beneficial in congestive heart failure and
strokes, inhibits protein glycation, and stabilizes arrhythmias
Some researchers credit alpha-lipoic acid with being the principal supplement
for preventing and reversing Syndrome X. Lipoic acid earned this reputation
by increasing the burning of glucose. The mitochondria (the powerhouse
of the cell) are one of the benefactors of enhanced glucose utilization,
via the Krebs's cycle, a process that utilizes glucose, amino acids, and
fatty acids to yield high energy. Many of the B vitamins assist in maximizing
production from the Krebs's cycle, but perhaps none is as efficient as
lipoic acid (Challem et al. 2000).
Note: Free
radicals are produced as a byproduct of the energy generated during the
Krebs's cycle. Alpha-lipoic acid appears to quench free radicals that
are not contained during the reactions.
As glucose is provided to fuel the Krebs's cycle, blood glucose and
insulin levels decrease and simultaneously another perk occurs: insulin
sensitivity increases. Lipoic acid resulted in a 50% increase in insulin-stimulated
glucose disposal and a significant improvement in insulin sensitivity
compared to a nonsupplemented placebo group. Blood glucose levels often
drop 23-45% in lipoic acid-treated diabetic animals. The journal Hypertension
also reported alpha-lipoic acid, a thiol compound known to increase tissue
cysteine and glutathione levels, reduced systolic blood pressure in spontaneously
hypertensive rats (Jacob 1995, 1996, 1997; Vasdev et al. 2000).
Lipoic acid is of value in treating diabetic and nondiabetic subjects
with congestive heart failure. Researchers from Beijing University added
that lipoic acid, because of its free-radical scavenging effects, is able
to protect the myocardium from free-radical damage and subsequently decrease
the incidence of malignant arrhythmias (Gao et al. 1991). Antioxidants
are extremely important in cardiac health, for the heart is one of the
most susceptible of all organs to free-radical damage. (There are three
times more free radicals produced in aging hearts compared to young hearts.)
Alpha-lipoic acid is, in fact, regarded as the universal antioxidant
because it enhances the activity of other antioxidants. It acts like a
big brother in regard to vitamin E, coenzyme Q10, and vitamin C, assisting
in recycling these important antioxidants for continued service. Lipoic
acid's antioxidant qualities appear greater than vitamin E's because vitamin
E works only in the fatty parts of cells, whereas lipoic acid works in
both watery and fatty portions (Challem et al. 2000).
Stroke deaths dropped from 78% to 26% in lipoic acid animal studies
conducted by Lester Packer. The journal Stroke confirmed that alpha-lipoic
acid reduced stroke infarct volume and free-radical activity, inhibited
platelet-leukocyte activation and adhesion, and increased cerebral blood
flow (Clark et al. 2001).
Lipoic acid reduced the formation of glycosylated end products (AGEs)
(Jain et al. 1998). Glycation occurs when proteins react with sugar to
form AGEs. This process increases the risk of cardiovascular disease by
oxidizing LDL cholesterol and rendering blood vessels tough and inflexible.
This gradually affects the left ventricle, reducing its ability to pump
oxygen-rich blood into the circulation. Stiffness occurring in the myocardium
increases diastolic pressure, and arterial rigidity increases systolic
pressure. Also, glycosylated cholesterol-carrying proteins are no longer
capable of binding to receptors on liver cells to signal the cessation
of cholesterol manufacturing. A healthy cholesterol-carrying protein halts
the copious supply of cholesterol. Without this binding process, cholesterol
continues to be pumped out. Lipoic acid interrupts all of these processes
at the starting point, by inhibiting glycation.
Note: Although
a normal byproduct of oxidative metabolism, free radicals in excess are
considered germane to the onset of vascular disease. When out of control,
these highly unstable electrons can cause extensive damage to lipid membranes,
organelles, and DNA itself. But most all of nature is two-pronged, having
a good side as well as a bad. For example, free radicals participate in
many positive reactions, including mitochondrial respiration, prostaglandin
synthesis, platelet activation, and leukocyte-phagocytosis, (the engulfing
and destruction of microorganisms and cellular debris). It is thus extremely
important to supply sufficient nutrient cofactors to support endogenous
antioxidant enzyme systems (such as superoxide dismutase, catalase, and
glutathione peroxidase) but to retain enough free-radical oxidative activity
to carry on essential life processes (Sinatra 2001).
Some researchers believe 50-250 mg a day (in concert with other antioxidants)
may be sufficient to protect against Syndrome X. Most Life Extension members
have been taking between 250-500 mg a day of alpha-lipoic acid. If the
patient has unstable blood glucose levels, higher doses of lipoic acid
will be required. German practitioners frequently use 600 mg daily as
adjunctive therapy in coronary artery disease and 600-1800 mg of alpha-lipoic
acid to improve insulin sensitivity and diabetic conditions. Higher doses
should be administered with the help of a qualified physician who can
adjust insulin requirements as indicated. Note:
Dr. Lester Packer, in The Antioxidant
Miracle, recommends taking biotin supplements with alpha-lipoic acid when
the daily intake exceeds 100 mg. Alpha-lipoic acid may compete with biotin
and interfere with biotin's activities in the body.
Reader's guide to lipoic acid food
sources
Liver, yeast, spinach, broccoli, potatoes, and red meat.
Angelica (Angelica archangelica)—an
anti -anginal, anti-inflammatory calcium antagonist,
ACE inhibitor, and diuretic
Angelica, a member of the carrot family, contains 15 compounds considered
to be calcium channel blockers. One of the calcium antagonists in angelica
is, in fact, more potent than verapamil (Calan, Isoptin), a popular calcium
channel blocker prescribed for angina, atrial fibrillation, and spasms
occurring in the blood vessels (Duke 1997).
James Duke, Ph.D. (botanist), comments that it is well known that vegetarians
have a low incidence of heart disease. Usually their low-fat diet gets
the credit, but Dr. Duke speculates that it may be because they eat lots
of plants from the carrot family, such as carrots, celery, fennel, parsley,
and parsnips, which (like angelica) contain compounds with calcium channel
blocking activity. Calcium channel blockers (whether natural or pharmaceutical)
are powerful anti-anginals.
Angelica bestows its cardiac advantage through various pathways. For
example, angelica not only reduces the incidence of angina attacks, but
also regulates an erratic heartbeat. It has diuretic properties, making
it of value in the treatment of congestive heart failure and hypertension.
Chemicals contained in angelica exhibit another mechanism to reduce blood
pressure, that is, the inhibition of ACE, the angiotensin-converting enzyme
(Duke Database 1992).
Inflammation, one of the newer risk factors for heart disease, is also
reduced by angelica (read about the inflammation-heart disease connection
in the sections dedicated to Newer Risk Factors). A suggested angelica
dosage is 15-30 drops 1-3 times a day.
Comments: How many milligrams (mg) of herb are in a drop of extract?
According to Herb Pharm, a respected name in the herbal industry, the
milligrams represented by 1 milliliter of extract (about 30-40 drops)
from a dried herb are given by the herb-to-menstruum ratio (menstruum
is a solvent—a liquid that dissolves a solid). This number varies
for extracts made from fresh herbs due to the increased yield of these
extracts. Liquid extracts are more assimilable than powdered herbs so
the weights are not comparable. If trying to follow a recommendation,
the form of the recommendation (powdered herb, liquid extract, etc.) needs
to be considered. Quality and quantity are separate issues and even liquid
extracts cannot be accurately compared on a mg-to-mg basis. Many factors
determine the quality of an herbal extract, including the makeup of the
menstruum, extraction technique, and raw herb quality. The following is
only an approximate calculation, but it may be helpful:
1 mL is equal to about 33 drops of many extracts
1 mL of a 1:4 ratio contains extractives from gram of herb (0.25 gram
= 250 mg)
The strength ratio does not directly address quality. Quality is dependent
on other factors such as the quality of the herb, the plant part used,
special handling, the extraction process and technique, as well as storage.
Always follow dosage instructions (and caveats) appearing on the label.
L-Arginine—dilates blood
vessels, reduces blood pressure, replicates the activity of nitroglycerine,
and is needed to produce nitric oxide
L-arginine, along with a properly planned exercise program, assists in
amending abnormalities occurring in blood vessels. Individuals with congestive
heart failure often have blood vessels that fail to dilate in response
to certain drugs, a sign that the inner blood vessel wall, or endothelium,
is compromised.
A study reported in the American College of Cardiology concluded that
treatment with L-arginine produced a fourfold increase in blood vessel
dilation from 2.2-8.8% (Hambrecht et al. 2000). Regular forearm exercises
increased the dilation response by the same amount, but the combination
of L-arginine and exercise training resulted in an improvement from 2.9-12%.
Doses of 5.6-12.6 grams of arginine increased blood flow to the extremities
29%; the distance walked on a treadmill in 6 minutes increased 8% (Rector
et al. 1996).
Much of L-arginine's effectiveness comes by way of increasing nitric
oxide, a blood vessel dilator and clot buster produced in endothelial
cells by the enzyme nitric oxide synthase (Brunini et al. 2002). Nitric
oxide counteracts the vasoconstriction and platelet-aggregating effects
of the stress hormone adrenaline (epinephrine) and assists in maintaining
vascular elasticity. Nitric oxide (the endothelial relaxing factor) is
needed for expansion and contraction of the arterial system (Rohdewald
1999). L-arginine increases nitric oxide, but hypertension, hyperhomocysteinemia,
diabetes, and smoking decrease it.
Because of arginine's vasodilating properties, it is frequently used
as a treatment for angina pain and hypertension. Researchers at the University
of Southern California ( Los Angeles ) speculate that a defect in nitric
oxide production may be a possible mechanism of hypertensive disease (Campese
et al. 1997). Some cardiologists, in fact, recommend L-arginine over nitroglycerine,
since the two substances appear to replicate a similar vascular function:
the ability to relax smooth muscles and dilate blood vessels.
In their current book, The Arginine Solution, Drs. Robert Fried and
Woodson C. Merrell note that as people age and develop disorders such
as hypertension, hypercholesterolemia, and atherosclerosis, their ability
to make sufficient amounts of nitric oxide from arginine is impaired,
contributing to a decline in their cardiovascular health. Drs. Fried and
Merrell contend that increasing arginine intake addresses various cardiovascular
risks associated with decreased nitric oxide synthesis, often improving
symptomatic and clinical evaluations (Fried et al. 1999). A suggested
dosage is 2 grams before bedtime. Arginine caveat: Individuals who have
frequent herpes outbreaks may find arginine-rich foodstuffs or supplementation
contraindicated.
Reader's guide to arginine food sources
Most protein foods and carob, chocolate, nuts, seeds, beans, oats, peanuts,
and wheat and wheat germ.
Artichoke Extract—reduces
cholesterol and triglycerides
Artichoke (Cynara scolymus), a delicious table vegetable, has a reputation
that extends beyond culinary enhancement. It has long been used to improve
digestive and liver complaints, but more recently artichoke has become
popular as a hypolipidemic. Studies have shown that the more lipid correction
needed, the greater artichoke's cholesterol-lowering effects. Caffeoylquinic
acids and flavonoids, constituents of artichoke, appear to deliver much
of the plant's positive effects.
In a multicenter, placebo-controlled, randomized trial, 143 patients
with initial cholesterol levels greater than 280 mg/dL took either a placebo
or 450 mg of artichoke dry extract 4 times a day. After 6 weeks, those
taking the artichoke extract showed an 18.5% reduction in cholesterol
compared to a 5.6% reduction in the placebo group. LDL-cholesterol decreased
22.9% among those taking the artichoke extract and 6.3% in the placebo
group. The LDL/HDL ratio showed a decrease of 20.2% among the artichoke
users (Englisch et al. 2000). Another short-term study (6 weeks) showed
that artichoke reduced triglycerides from 214.97 mg/dL to 188.07 mg/dL
(Fintelmann 1996a, 1996b). There were no drug related adverse events during
the course of these studies, indicating an excellent tolerability.
Artichoke reduces cholesterol by decreasing the synthesis of cholesterol
in the liver and increasing the conversion of cholesterol to bile acids.
(Cholesterol is a building block for bile acids.) According to Michael
Murray, N.D., cholesterol levels are sometimes high because of the impaired
conversion of cholesterol to bile acids. Thus, low bile acid levels send
a powerful signal to the liver to provide more cholesterol. Artichoke
extract intercepts this signal, and the liver complies with less cholesterol
production ( Murray 1998b).
The flavonoid luteolin appears to be pivotal in the hypocholesterolemic
effects of artichoke. Statin drugs reduce cholesterol by competitively
inhibiting the binding of HMG-CoA reductase. Tocotrienols also degrade
this enzyme. Artichoke research has found no direct inhibition of HMG-CoA
reductase. Other enzymatic steps occurring later in the biosynthesis of
cholesterol appear unaffected. It seems luteolin inhibits cholesterol
below the level of HMG-CoA reductase and therefore spares coenzyme Q10
synthesis. Recall that the cholesterol cascade begins with acetyl-CoA
being converted to HMG-CoA. HMG-CoA reductase reduces HMG-CoA to mevalonic
acid. Mevalonic acid participates in several steps that reduce it to squalene.
Squalene is then converted to cholesterol (Murray 1998b; Sardesai 1998).
A suggested dosage is 1 capsule 3 times a day, containing 300 mg of
artichoke standardized to contain 13-18% caffeoylquinic acid. Note: The
American Journal of Clinical Nutrition recently reported that chlorogenic
acid, a component of black tea and coffee, could increase homocysteine
levels (Olthof et al. 2001). Chlorogenic acid also appears in artichoke
and would therefore be contraindicated in refractory hyperhomocysteinemia.
Lastly, individuals with gallstones or biliary tract obstruction should
not use artichoke.
Aspirin—reduces C-reactive
protein (CRP), platelet aggregation, and cardiac inflammation
Aspirin has been used for over a century to relieve pain; research suggests
that it may play an equally important role in heart health. A study involving
51,085 participants showed a total of 2284 cardiovascular endpoints occurring
during an aspirin trial. The risk of a first nonfatal heart attack was
reduced 32% among aspirin users compared to nonusers. The researchers
concluded that aspirin therapy could prevent a third of myocardial infarctions
occurring in apparently healthy individuals (Hebert et al. 2000). JAMA
also reported that aspirin usage was associated with reduced all-cause
mortality, particularly among older subjects with known coronary artery
disease and impaired exercise capacity (Gum et al. 2001).
Three studies looked at the incidence of stroke subtypes among aspirin
users. A 1.69-fold increase in the risk of hemorrhagic stroke occurred
among aspirin users, but no increase in ischemic strokes was noted. Secondary
prevention trials, evaluated by Drs. Patricia R. Hebert ( Yale University
) and Charles Hennekens ( University of Miami ) indicated that aspirin
therapy administered to 10,000 persons would prevent about 67 myocardial
infarctions and cause approximately 11 hemorrhagic strokes. In November
2001, the New England Journal of Medicine published that over a 2-year
period, no difference was found between aspirin and warfarin in the prevention
of recurrent ischemic stroke or death or in the rate of major hemorrhage
(Hebert et al. 2000; Mohr et al. 2001).
The drug disposition of aspirin is persuasive when applied to a cardiovascular
model. For example, low-dose aspirin (81 mg) appears to provide partial
protection against abnormal blood clot formation, having a 2-day lasting
effect on blood platelets. Platelets become less sticky and the risk of
a heart attack and transient ischemic attacks (TIAs) is subsequently reduced.
Aspirin exerts some of its cardioprotection by inhibiting the enzyme
cyclooxygenase, a trigger in the inflammatory process (Newmark et al.
2000). One molecule of aspirin will destroy the cyclooxygenase enzyme
for 4-6 hours (read the sections devoted to C-Reactive Protein and The
Link Between Infections and Inflammation in Heart Disease to learn how
the inflammatory process advances cardiac disease).
Aspirin appears to lower C-reactive protein (CRP). In the Physician's
Health Study, participants were randomly assigned at baseline to receive
323 mg of aspirin on alternate days and were then followed through first
myocardial infarction. The study showed that low dose aspirin reduced
heart attack risk by about 44% compared to the control group; the risk
was 55% lower than that of placebo-treated men with high CRP levels. The
results of this study suggest that in addition to aspirin's antagonism
toward platelet clumping, it may also attenuate thrombosis through anti-inflammatory
mechanisms (Physicians Weekly 1998a).
Aspirin significantly cut the death rate from cardiac disease among
2368 noninsulin-dependent diabetic patients with coronary artery disease.
(The aspirin benefit was greater among diabetic patients than nondiabetics.)
Diabetic patients using aspirin had a 10.9% mortality risk from cardiac
diseases, while diabetics not using aspirin had a 15.9% risk (Harpaz et
al. 1998).
The aspirin advantage extended to include carotid endarterectomy patients.
Individuals using low-dose aspirin (81-325 mg a day) reduced the risk
of myocardial infarction, stroke, and death for a 30-day to 3-month interval
following surgery. Individuals taking 650-1300 mg were not similarly protected,
illustrating that the dose can alter the end response (Taylor et al. 1999).
Current information indicates that aspirin can also reduce the level
of heart damage during a heart attack. When taking aspirin because one
believes they are experiencing an acute heart attack, the aspirin should
be chewed rather than swallowed and is best taken within 30 minutes of
the onset of symptoms.
In conclusion, the Antithrombotic Trialists' Collaboration (representing
a review of 287 studies involving 135,000 patients) announced that over
40,000 lives are lost worldwide every year because aspirin is underused.
According to the report, aspirin (or other antiplatelet drugs) is protective
in most patients at increased risk of occlusive vascular events, including
those with acute myocardial infarction or ischemic stroke, unstable or
stable angina, previous myocardial infarction, cerebral ischemia, peripheral
arterial disease, or atrial fibrillation (Antithrombotic Trialists' Collaboration
2002).
Aspirin (75-150 mg a day) appears to be an effective antiplatelet regimen
for long-term usage, but in acute settings, an initial loading dose of
at least 150 mg may be required. Adding a second antiplatelet drug to
aspirin may produce additional benefits in some clinical circumstances
(Antithrombotic Trialists' Collaboration 2002). Note: The New England
Journal of Medicine recently published that warfarin, in combination with
aspirin or given alone, was superior to aspirin alone in reducing the
incidence of composite events following an acute myocardial infarction.
Warfarin was, however, associated with a higher risk of bleeding (Hurlen
et al. 2002).
The American College of Chest Physicians suggests that all people over
50 years of age, with one cardiac risk factor and no condition that would
negate treatment, consider aspirin therapy. The cautionary includes those
individuals who have increased prothrombin time, disturbed gastric mucosa,
or hypertension. As acclaimed as low-dose aspirin is, studies have shown
that aspirin does not appear comprehensive enough to prevent a heart attack
if fibrinogen levels are excessively high. It should also be noted that
a concomitant administration of ibuprofen (but not rofecoxib, acetaminophen,
or diclofenac) antagonizes the platelet inhibition activity induced by
aspirin. Thus, treatment with ibuprofen in patients with increased cardiovascular
risk may limit the cardioprotective effects of aspirin (Catella-Lawson
et al. 2001).
Bromelain—is an anti-inflammatory,
reduces fibrinogen, lessens risk of blood clots, is beneficial in atrial
fibrillation, is hypotensive, relieves angina, and is basic to smokers
Bromelain, derived from pineapple (Ananas comusus), is regarded as a natural
anti-inflammatory, acting as a protein-digesting enzyme. Since the revelation
that inflammation may be causal to cardiovascular disease, bromelain has
attained new stature. Proteolytic enzymes work directly on the inflammation,
neutralizing and removing damaged cell tissue. The digesting nature of
bromelain suggests that it can also reduce atherosclerotic plaque accumulating
in arteries.
Bromelain lowers blood pressure, breaks down fibrinogen, and relieves
angina. It opposes platelet aggregation and is helpful in thrombophlebitis.
Many of bromelain's qualities make it particularly valuable to smokers
and patients with atrial fibrillation (Murray 1995c; Duke 1997).
A suggested bromelain dosage is 1/8-1/4 teaspoon taken between meals
to relieve inflammation. The strength of enzymes is often expressed as
milk-clotting units (MCU) and gelatin-digestive units (GDU) per gram.
One level teaspoon of Life Extension Bromelain Powder (2.9 grams) has
enzymatic strength of 3500 MCU or 2000 GDU. Bromelain tablets (500 mg)
are also available. Typically, bromelain is used 3 times a day.
Bugleweed (Lycopus virginicus)—is
a diuretic and has a digitalis mentality
Bugleweed has a reputation that dates to folk medicine. Historically,
herbalists used bugleweed to regulate the heart and improve circulation.
Bugleweed's repute is enduring, for practitioners still use the herb to
stabilize a rapid or irregular heart rhythm, whether the problem is functional
or organic.
Bugleweed is beneficial in the treatment of hypertension and congestive
heart failure, ridding water from edematous tissues and organs. It has
been called a natural digitalis, milder but with some of the same characteristics
as the drug. Bugleweed does not accumulate and is therefore considered
nontoxic (Santillo 1990; Ritchason 1995). A suggested dosage is 30-40
drops in a little water 2-4 times a day. (For an explanation regarding
milligrams per drop, turn to Angelica, appearing alphabetically in this
section.)
Calcium—is a hypotensive
mineral and an anti-arrhythmic, supports healthy bones around gum tissue,
and reduces iron overload
Minerals, although usually not considered as focal, are in many ways more
important to survival than vitamins. One can live longer with a vitamin
deficiency than with a mineral shortage (Whiting 1989). For example, a
deficiency of calcium, magnesium, or potassium can force the heart into
fatal cardiac arrhythmias. In addition, inadequate mineral intake appears
to have a correlation with hypertension. Hypertensive individuals may
be unwittingly contributing to the problem by consuming about 18% less
dietary calcium than normotensives.
Researchers at the Oregon Health Sciences found that supplemental dietary
calcium lowers blood pressure, whereas restricted-calcium diets tend to
elevate blood pressure (Geri Clark in Woman's Day). According to research
from the Indiana University School of Medicine, a unifying theory showing
how calcium reduces blood pressure is not available. A membrane stabilizing
effect, natriuresis (the excretion of greater than normal amounts of sodium
in the urine), and calcium's ability to control regulatory processes are
mechanisms debated (Luft et al. 1990). However, epidemiologic findings
suggest that there is a threshold for the protective effect of calcium,
below which the risk of hypertension increases at a greater rate. The
set point of this threshold may be about 700-800 mg a day, but other variants,
such as metabolic type, absorption rates, and genetics may modify this
dosage (McCarron et al. 1991).
Calcium is not a universal resolvent for hypertension (Meese et al.
1987). In some cases, clinicians report no significant hypotensive effect
in dosages as high as 2.5 grams a day. Patients wishing to try calcium
should not withdraw blood pressure medication abruptly but use the drug
in combination with calcium over a 3- to 6-month assessment period. During
this interval, watchful monitoring may allow a gradual reduction in medication.
According to information published in the journal Stroke, low dietary
calcium intake poses a significant risk for women in regard to heart disease
and stroke. Researchers analyzed the dietary intake of 85,764 women, compiled
from the Nurses' Health Study. After an adjustment for risk factors associated
with cardiovascular disease, calcium intake was significantly related
to the risk of stroke. Women with the lowest calcium intake (especially
from dairy sources) had the greatest risk of heart problems, perhaps because
of higher cholesterol levels and a tendency for blood cells to clump.
The increase in risk was limited to the lowest quintile of intake; intakes
of calcium greater than 600 mg a day did not appear to reduce risk of
stroke further (Iso et al. 1999).
Calcium is also of advantage in reducing iron overload. The American
Journal of Clinical Nutrition stated that 300 mg of elemental calcium,
taken with a meal, reduced the amount of iron absorbed from food by 40%
(Hallberg et al. 1998). Amounts larger than 300 mg did not further inhibit
iron absorption. Since some individuals become tolerant to calcium-induced
iron absorption blockage, it is important to have blood tests periodically
to evaluate sustained effectiveness. Calcium is also important in periodontal
disease by supporting healthy bone around gums (Balch, et al. 1997).
Calcium citrate is a good choice considering absorption, but calcium
citrate malate acid is about 30% better absorbed than calcium citrate.
Calcium bis-glycinate was shown to absorb 180% better than calcium citrate
and 21% better than calcium citrate malate. A suggested dosage is 1000
mg of elemental calcium a day.
Reader's guide to food sources of
calcium.
Milk and dairy products are frequently criticized, particularly those
that are homogenized. During homogenization, an enzyme appearing in milk
(xanthine oxidase) is broken down to a smaller size. The enzyme's altered
state allows entry into the bloodstream and a reaction to occur on arterial
walls. As a protective gesture, atheromatous materials are laid down at
the site of contact. In addition, milk is often challenged as a worthy
source of calcium. Its high phosphorous content and magnesium shortfall
are thought to impede calcium absorption. Dark green vegetables, salmon
(with bones), sardines, most nuts and seeds (especially sesame seeds),
blackstrap molasses, root vegetables, and liver are considered to be safer,
surer sources of calcium.
The interrelationship of factors acting
on absorption
The importance of providing an environment conducive to nutrient utilization
cannot be overstated. For example, in an alkaline medium, calcium forms
insoluble, nonabsorbable calcium phosphate. Conversely, hydrochloric acid
lowers the pH of the digestive tract, providing a favorable milieu for
absorption.
Nutrients also play a role, either supporting or opposing absorption.
For example, the amino acid lysine (found in milk products, eggs, meat,
fish, and fowl) enhances calcium absorption. Other calcium enhancers include
vitamin D, vitamin A, vitamin C, and magnesium.
Diets high in sugar alter calcium uptake; coffee, alcoholic beverages,
and phosphorous-rich soft drinks also promote increased calcium excretion.
Oxalic acid (found in almonds, beet greens, cashews, chard, cocoa, rhubarb,
soybeans, and spinach) retards calcium absorption by binding with calcium
in the intestines, producing insoluble, nonabsorbable salts. (Oxalic acid
is problematic only if the diet is persistently structured around these
foodstuffs.) Calcium and tetracycline form an insoluble complex that impairs
both mineral and drug absorption.
L-Carnitine—is an energizer
and hypolipidemic, aids weight loss, improves circulation, increases exercise
tolerance, and is beneficial treatment in angina, diabetes, congestive
heart failure, and cardiac arrhythmias
Robert Crayhon, nutritionist and author, considers carnitine the single
most important nutrient in regard to cardiac health. Carnitine, a coenzyme
similar to the family of B vitamins, is essential for the burning and
transport of long-chain fatty acids, the fuel for cardiac energy. Up to
70% of energy produced by muscles comes from the burning of fats. To expect
the normal functioning of heart muscles, the transport of carnitine into
tissues is critical (Crayhon 1998).
Lysine and cofactors yield about 25% of the carnitine the body needs
for optimal performance. The remaining 75% can come from the diet, if
dietary selections are made with a slant toward carnitine-rich protein
foods, especially mutton, lamb, and beef. Interestingly, protein foods,
those frequently shunned on a heart-healthy diet, raise HDL cholesterol
and increase carnitine levels (Crayhon 1998).
Carnitine is often effective in reducing the incidence of cardiac arrhythmias
and angina attacks. According to statistics, patients receiving L-carnitine
experienced fewer premature ventricular contractions at rest and improved
cardiac output (Cacciatore et al. 1991). But if oxygen levels decrease,
carnitine also decreases, and the patient may be in jeopardy from two
perspectives.
Patients with stable angina, who were evaluated by means of a stress
test, were able to exercise longer before abnormalities were detected
while on 900 mg of orally administered L-carnitine (Kamikawa et al. 1984).
Individuals acting as controls in the study and receiving a placebo experienced
distress at 6.4 minutes into the test, while individuals receiving carnitine
supplementation extended the period of symptom-free exercise to 8.8 minutes.
Researchers also state that carnitine may provide independent benefit
in ischemia, when used as monotherapy, or additional benefit when used
in combination with conventional beta-blockers or calcium antagonists
(Jackson 2001). Although research indicates carnitine may be an effective
adjunctive therapy, never discontinue cardiac medications without the
consent of your physician.
Carnitine, administered to individuals displaying heart trauma, substantially
lessened coronary damage and the risk of occlusion. Arterial plugs were
less likely to form as carnitine modulated lipids, with less of the objectionable
and more of the beneficial fats produced. After 4 months of carnitine
therapy, total cholesterol levels were reduced by about 20%, triglycerides
were reduced 28%, and HDL increased 12%. Triglycerides and HDL were more
responsive to carnitine supplementation if the diet contained no more
than 40% of calories from carbohydrates (Pola et al. 1980, 1983; Murray
1996b).
Carnitine is of value in treating congestive heart failure. A group
of 60 men and women (ages 48-73) were selected for a carnitine heart study,
having failed conventional treatment. Thirty of the patients were given
LPC (L-propionylcarnitine, 500 mg 3 times a day for 180 days), along with
their drug regime. At 30 days into the trial, the patients were evaluated
for improvement in exercise tolerance and left-ventricular ejection fraction.
Compared to controls, both parameters showed significant recovery at the
1-month interval, but improvement was even more pronounced at the 90-
and 180-day marks. Exercise tolerance improved 16.4% at 30 days, 22.9%
at 90 days, and 25.9% at 180 days; left-ventricular ejection fraction
progressively increased 8.4%, 11.6%, and 13.6% throughout the course of
the trial (Cacciatore et al. 1991; Mancini et al. 1992; Murray 1996d).
Note: L-carnitine has been approved by the FDA, under the name Carnitor,
as a therapy for congestive heart failure.
Glycosylated hemoglobin, HbA1c (a hemoglobin molecule chemically linked
to glucose), is a test used to evaluate glucose levels over the previous
6-8 weeks. The test measures glycosylation of hemoglobin in the red cells
over their lifetime of 90-120 days. HbA1c, for a nondiabetic, is normal
at 4-6%; for a diabetic, the goal is to maintain HbA1c less than 7% (7%
is an average of 150 mg/dL of glucose). It appears carnitine may have
the potential to assist in stabilizing blood glucose levels, so that peaks
and valleys are less troublesome to diabetic patients. Carnitine accomplishes
this by increasing glucose disposal and improving insulin sensitivity
(DeGaetano et al. 1999; Mingrone et al. 1999). A report published in JAMA
showed that a significant financial savings ($685-$950 annually) accrued
to diabetes within 1 year of improved HbA1c levels (Wagner et al. 2001).
Individuals who are at increased cardiac risk because of obesity may
find value in carnitine supplementation. Carnitine, especially when combined
with omega-3 fatty acids and a decrease in carbohydrate consumption, promotes
weight loss. If used for obesity, begin with 500 mg and gradually increase
dosage to 2 grams a day. If an individual is morbidly overweight, larger
doses, up to 4 grams a day, may be required (Crayhon 1998). Hypothyroidism,
a contributing factor to both obesity and coronary artery disease, frequently
parallels carnitine deficiencies.
Some practitioners report better cardiac management when using L-carnitine
fumarate, a less hygroscopic and more bioavailable form of the vitamin-like
nutrient. Others prefer LPC (L-propionylcarnitine) for the treatment of
angina. Acetyl-L-carnitine is touted because of its ability to energize,
a result of extremely efficient utilization. Because of the energizing
effects of acetyl-L-carnitine, Robert Crayhon, author of The Carnitine
Miracle, suggests it be taken no later than 3 p.m. to preserve a restful
night's sleep.
As with most supplements, dosage is subjective. Some individuals notice
increased energy with 1 gram of L-carnitine or 500 mg of acetyl-L-carnitine
a day. Clinical studies frequently use from 1500-3000 mg daily. Because
increased energy production begets a greater generation of free radicals,
carnitine should always be used with an antioxidant program.
Carnosine—is an antioxidant,
protects against strokes, and reduces AGEs
In January 2001, the Life Extension Foundation hailed carnosine as a substance
capable of slowing many of the processes involved in aging, including
cardiovascular degeneration. Carnosine, a combination of the amino acids
alanine and histidine, accomplishes this in part by playing a dual role
in regard to proteins. For example, it yields a protective effect through
antioxidant activity and also participates in the repair or removal of
damaged proteins. By quenching the destructive potential of the deadly
hydroxyl radical and impacting protein degradation that occurs as a result
of collagen crosslinking (glycation), carnosine offers significant protection
against vascular disease.
Glycation is a reaction that occurs when proteins react with glucose.
A series of reactions follow (including the oxidation process), terminating
in the formation of an advanced glycosylated end product (AGEs), a protein
the body cannot break down. These processes decrease vascular tone and
resiliency and are factors that influence the progression of cardiovascular
disease and hypertension. Glycated proteins produce 50-fold more free
radicals than nonglycated proteins; carnosine may be the most effective
antiglycating agent known (Durany et al. 1999).
Russian scientists set out to determine the effect of carnosine upon
rats programmed to develop strokes. The first experiment focused upon
carnosine as a revitalizer in hypoxic animals (those exposed to low oxygen
levels). When oxygen-deprived animals were revitalized with normal levels
of oxygen, the carnosine treated rats were able to stand after 4.3 minutes,
as compared to 6.3 minutes in the untreated group (Boldyrev 1997).
In the second study, a stroke was simulated in the animals by arterial
occlusion. The scientists found that carnosine acts as a neuroprotector
in the ischemic brain. Rats treated with carnosine displayed more normal
electrocardiograms, less lactate accumulation (a common measure of the
severity of injury), and better cerebral blood flow (Stvolinsky et al.
1999).
A suggested dosage is 1000-1500 mg daily. By taking at least 1000 mg
a day of supplemental carnosine, the enzyme carnosinase (an enzyme that
degrades carnosine) is overwhelmed, thus making the carnosine available
in the body. Carnosine should not be used during pregnancy or lactation.
Chondroitin Sulfate—is an
anti-inflammatory and antioxidant and inhibits LDL oxidation
Chondroitin sulfate (CS) is extremely popular in relieving the sore joints
of osteoarthritis. In 1968, Dr. Lester Morrison began a 6-year study to
determine its value as a cardio -protector. Dr. Morrison divided 120 patients
with coronary heart disease into two groups. Lifestyles were not altered
during the test period, that is, all participants continued with their
prescribed medication and appropriately designed diets. One group also
took 1500 mg a day of CS for 4 years, and then 750 mg for another 18 months.
After 6 years, four people in the CS group had died, compared to 13 in
the nontreated group. Most impressive was the finding that only six people
in the CS-treated group had acute cardiac incidents over the 6-year period,
while 42 patients in the group that did not receive CS had acute events
(Morrison et al. 1969; Morrison et al 1973; Anderson 2002).
Dr. Morrison speculates that the decrease in cardiovascular deaths could
be staggering if CS were routinely used by larger numbers of the population.
Although further research is needed, it appears CS delivers its cardiovascular
protection though anti-inflammatory and antioxidant pathways. A suggested
daily dose is one to three 400-mg tablets.
Chromium—modulates blood
glucose levels, lowers cholesterol, and is helpful in weight management
Of the 16 minerals currently deemed essential, none plays a more important
role in blood glucose control than chromium. However, the benefits of
chromium, a trace mineral, are not limited to modulating errant blood
glucose levels. Obesity, coronary heart disease, hypertension, and hyperlipidemia
often have a common denominator: insulin insensitivity, a condition worsened
by a chromium deficiency. It is estimated that 90% of Americans consume
less than the recommended amount of chromium each day, a shortfall that
may eventually terminate in some form of ill health. (Note: No recommended
dietary allowance (RDA) has been established for chromium, but the ESADDI
(estimated safe and adequate daily dietary intake) is 50-200 mcg.)
A group of 180 people with Type II diabetes participated in a study
to determine the worth of chromium picolinate (CrP) supplementation in
controlling unstable blood glucose levels. The individuals were divided
into the following three groups: (1) received only a placebo, (2) received
200 mcg daily of CrP, or (3) received 1000 mcg daily of CrP. Perhaps the
finding of greatest interest was the decrease in hemoglobin A1c levels
after 4 months (thus signifying increased glycemic control). Hemoglobin
A1c dropped from greater than 9% pretreatment to less than 7% in the 1000-mcg-a-day
treatment group. Chief Researcher Richard Anderson said: "Nearly
all of participants no longer had the classic signs of diabetes. Blood
sugar and insulin levels became normal. Most important, the gold standard
diagnostic measure of diabetes, blood levels of hemoglobin A1c, sank to
normal." This would be considered an optimal response with any diabetes
drug regimen (Anderson et al. 1997). Note: The beneficial effects of chromium
in individuals with diabetes were observed at levels higher than the upper
limit of the ESADDI.
Research is conflicting regarding weight loss with chromium supplementation.
While some studies renounce its value, a current study showed that 600
mcg of niacin-bound chromium given to "modestly dieting-exercising
African-American women" caused a significant loss of fat and sparing
of muscle compared to a placebo group (Crawford et al. 1999). Michael
Murray, N.D., reported that individuals using 400 mcg of chromium picolinate
for 2 1/2 months lost 4.6 pounds and added 1.1 pounds of muscle, for a
total weight loss of 3.5 pounds ( Murray 1996).
Typically, chromium decreases total cholesterol and triglycerides 10%
and increases HDL 2%. These changes are most observed if initial body
chromium levels are very low ( Murray 1996). For most individuals, 200-400
mcg of chromium (divided throughout the day) is adequate; higher (supervised)
doses may be required if used for Type II diabetes (turn to Niacin in
this section to read about the boost chromium gives niacin, requiring
lesser amounts of vitamin B3 to manage blood lipids).
Reader's guide to chromium food
sources, enhancers, and antagonists
Brewer's yeast, whole grains, mushrooms, corn and corn oil, dairy products,
potatoes, and dried beans are examples of chromium food sources; selenium,
vitamin E, and essential amino acids enhance its absorption; iron opposes
it.
Coenzyme Q10—lessens the incidence
of angina attacks, arrhythmias, cardiomyopathy, congestive heart failure,
heart valve irregularities, hypertension, mitral valve prolapse, and periodontal
disease; protects LDL cholesterol against oxidation; increases exercise
tolerance; burns unwanted fat; supports healthy cholesterol and triglyceride
levels; and is beneficial to smokers
Coenzyme Q10 (CoQ10) can be synthesized in the body, but individuals with
periodontal disease, hypertension, or cardiovascular diseases are frequently
deficient. Heart tissue biopsies in patients with various heart diseases
showed a CoQ10 deficiency in 50-75% of cases. A significant finding is
that cholesterol-lowering medications (as statin drugs) reduce CoQ10 levels.
A CoQ10 deficiency of 25% is associated with illness and a deficit of
75% is associated with death in animals (Bliznakov et al. 1988; Hattersley
1994).
The heart strengthening benefits of CoQ10 make it of significant value
in the treatment of congestive heart failure (CHF). Depending upon the
degree of cardiac impairment, CoQ10 can be used independently or added
to traditional medicine.
Administering CoQ10 (50-150 mg daily) for 90 days to 2664 patients with
CHF resulted in the following symptomatic and clinical improvements: cyanosis
(bluish skin color), 78.1%; edema, 78.6%; pulmonary crackle, 77.8%; dyspnea,
52.7%; palpitations, 75.4%; sweating, 79.8%; arrhythmia, 63.4%; and vertigo,
73.1%. Fifty-four percent of the patients observed a concurrent improvement
in several symptoms, which could be interpreted as an improvement in quality
of life (Baggio et al. 1994). A 1-year study involving 640 individuals
with CHF showed that patients using CoQ10 were healthier and required
less hospitalization (Morisco et al. 1993).
The ejection fraction (how fully the heart pumps the blood out), end
diastolic volume index (the adequacy of the heart to fill with blood),
cardiac index (the amount of blood pumped out, considering body size),
stroke volume (amount of blood pumped out on each beat of the heart),
and cardiac output (the amount of blood pumped out per minute) all improved
while using CoQ10 (Judy et al. 1984; Murray 1996). The improvement observed
in left ventricular function may prove valuable in preventing left ventricular
depression following coronary artery bypass and valvular surgery.
The effects of oral treatment with CoQ10 (120 mg a day) were compared
for 28 days in 73 (intervention group A) and 71 (placebo group B) patients
with acute myocardial infarction. Following treatment, angina pectoris
(9.5% versus 28.1%), total arrhythmias (9.5% versus 25.3%), and poor left
ventricular function (8.2% versus 22.5%) were significantly reduced in
the CoQ10 group compared to the placebo group. Total cardiac events, including
cardiac deaths and nonfatal infarctions, were also significantly reduced
in the CoQ10 group compared with the placebo group (15% versus 30.9%)
(Singh et al. 1998; Niibori et al. 1999).
Mitral valve prolapse is a common condition associated with a heart
murmur. It is often asymptomatic but can produce chest pain, arrhythmia,
or leakage of the valve, leading to congestive heart disease. Children
with mitral valve prolapse received CoQ10 (2 mg/kg a day) for 8 weeks
while eight received a placebo. This dosage proved highly effective in
returning heart function to normal in seven of the eight children; none
of the placebo-treated patients improved. However, relapse was common
among those who stopped taking the medication within 12-17 months but
rarely occurred in those who took CoQ10 for 19 months or more. (Oda et
al. 1984; Murray 1996b).
The following examples exemplify the breadth of CoQ10's credits:
- CoQ10 therapy is associated with a mean 25.4% increase in exercise
duration and a 14.3% increase in workload (Sacher et al. 1997).
- The frequency of angina attacks, a squeezing or pressure-like pain
in the chest, usually provoked by exercise, decreases by about 53% during
CoQ10 supplementation ( Murray 1995).
- CoQ10 has been reported to lower Lp(a), a powerful predictor of cardiac
health (Singh et al. 1999; Health Concerns 2002). To read more about
Lp(a), consult the section (in this protocol) dedicated to Newer Risk
Factors.
- CoQ10 inhibits oxidation of LDL cholesterol. CoQ10 accomplishes this
by attaching to LDL particles circulating in the bloodstream. Were there
more riders (CoQ10) than carriers (LDL) the oxidation of LDL cholesterol
would be less worrisome (Thomas et al. 1995; LEF 2000).
- CoQ10's antioxidant activities extend to protect the cells and lungs
of smokers. By aiding oxygen delivery, reducing platelet aggregation,
and hampering free-radical activity, the brain and heart have significantly
greater protection. In addition, current data provide direct evidence
for an interactive effect between exogenously administered vitamin E
and CoQ10 in terms of uptake and retention, and for a sparing effect
of CoQ10 on vitamin E. Vitamin E, in turn, plays a pivotal role in determining
tissue retention of exogenous CoQ10 (Ibrahim et al. 2000).
- Hypertensive patients demonstrated a significant improvement while
supplementing with CoQ10. Before treatment with CoQ10, most patients
were taking from 1-5 cardiac medications. During the study, overall
medication requirements dropped considerably: 43% stopped between 1-3
drugs. Typically, diastolic and systolic blood pressures drop by about
10% with CoQ10 therapy (Langsjoen et al. 1994; Lam 2001).
- Periodontal disease, a risk factor regarding heart health, responds
to CoQ10 supplementation. Gingival pocket depth, swelling, bleeding,
redness, pain, exudates, and looseness of teeth were significantly improved
using 50 mg of CoQ10 a day (Wilkinson et al. 1977; Murray 1996). The
herbs goldenseal and echinacea should accompany CoQ10 supplementation
to further reduce oral infection.
- For the dieter, CoQ10 is good news ( Murray 1996). Together with
a well-planned diet and exercise program, CoQ10 assists in shedding
unwanted pounds.
- CoQ10's ability to energize the heart is perhaps its chief attribute.
The heart is one of the most metabolically active organs in the body,
pumping approximately 2000 gallons of blood through 65,000 miles of
blood vessels, beating 100,000 times each day (American Heart Association
2002). According to Decker Weiss, N.M.D., the heart requires large amounts
of uninterrupted energy to fuel this unbelievable performance. The mitochondria
(supplying 95% of the body's total energy requirement) are represented
in large numbers (up to 2000 per heart cell).
- In addition to energy supply, CoQ10 is an important defense system
in tissues and muscles, particularly those having large numbers of mitochondria.
As the mitochondria produce energy to fuel cellular functions, a plethora
of free radicals results (Treatment and Research Newsletter 1998). Heart
cells have more CoQ10 than any other cells, a supply critical to ATP
production, cardiac function, and free-radical protection (Guyton et
al. 1996; Porth et al. 1998).
Despite the large body of clinical evidence demonstrating CoQ10 efficacy,
it is tragic that the majority of cardiac physicians still disregard its
potential. A suggested dosage is 30-400 mg a day, depending upon the degree
of cardiac support required. (Use CoQ10 in divided doses with meals containing
fat; use larger doses under physician supervision.)
Reader's guide to CoQ10 food sources
Beef, mackerel, salmon, sardines, peanuts, and spinach.
Conjugated Linoleic Acid (CLA)—aids
in fat loss, reduces cholesterol and triglycerides, and assists in the
utilization of beneficial fats
Some researchers regard the principal causal factor of obesity to be CLA
deficiency. CLA can be obtained from dietary choices such as turkey, lamb,
beef, and some fatty dairy products, but the current trend away from meats
and fats has caused levels of CLA to drop meaningfully (Ip et al, 1994).
CLA appears reliable in reducing body fat, while preserving lean body
tissue. CLA accomplishes this by increasing the basal metabolic rate and
impacting the distribution of fat, especially abdominal obesity. (Recall
that apple-shaped bodies are considered vulnerable in regard to heart
disease.) A Norwegian human study found that CLA-supplemented subjects
lost up to 20% of their body fat in 3 months without changing their diet,
while the control subjects on an average gained a slight amount of body
fat during the same period (Health-N-Energy 2000).
CLA displays hypolipidemic properties as well as the ability to reduce
arachidonic acid levels, an initiator of inflammatory leukotrienes (Liu
1998). (Leukotrienes are considered 1000 times more reactive than histamine.)
Researchers set out to determine the effects of CLA on the establishment
and progression of experimentally induced atherosclerosis in rabbits.
To establish atherosclerosis, New Zealand white rabbits were fed a diet
containing 0.1-0.2% of cholesterol for 90 days. Some groups were fed the
atherogenic diet and CLA. For effects on progression of atherosclerosis,
rabbits with established atherosclerosis were also included in the study.
At dietary levels as low as 0.1%, CLA inhibited atherogenesis; at dietary
levels of 1%, CLA caused substantial (30%) regression of established atherosclerosis.
This is the first example of substantial regression of atherosclerosis
being caused by diet alone (Kritchevsky et al. 2000).
Some question whether linoleic acid and CLA accomplish the same tasks.
Although the two acids are related, they appear to oppose one another
on factors that influence cardiac performance. While the linoleic acid
cascade has a greater tendency to stimulate fat formation, CLA inhibits
it. Cholesterol is more likely to be oxidized by various factors working
off the linoleic cascade, whereas CLA appears to stabilize cholesterol.
Laboratory animals, supplemented with CLA for 36 weeks at a dose 50
times higher than the suggested upper range for human consumption, completed
the study without signs of toxicity. A suggested dosage is three to four
1000-mg capsules taken early in the day.
Curcumin—is anti-inflammatory
and hypocholesterolemic, inhibits platelet aggregation, and is protective
to smokers
Curcumin, not to be mistaken for the herb cumin, is the yellow pigment
of turmeric (Curcuma longa) found in mustard and curry powder. Curcumin
has gained popularity because of its antioxidant and antiplatelet aggregating
qualities. Curcumin's ability to control platelet aggregation appears
directly related to thromboxane inhibition (a promoter of aggregation)
and an increase in prostacyclin activity, an inhibitor of aggregation
(Srivastava et al. 1985; Toda et al. 1985).
Curcumin is such a powerful antioxidant (comparable to vitamins C and
E) that it is considered protective to smokers, lessening free-radical
attack and cellular damage. Yet, its cardioprotection extends to reducing
blood lipid levels, particularly cholesterol. Rats fed 0.1% curcumin,
along with a cholesterol diet, had about one-half of the blood cholesterol
as rats fed equal amounts of cholesterol but without curcumin (Rao et
al. 1970).
Curcumin also possesses potent anti-inflammatory activity. It is, in
fact, comparable to cortisone and phenylbutazone in acute inflammatory
conditions and about one-half as effective in chronic models. As curcumin
reduces inflammation (a more recently established risk factor for cardiovascular
disease), fibrinolysis is promoted and leukotriene formation inhibited
(Arora et al. 1971; Chandra et al. 1972; Murray 1994).
A recommended dosage is 900 mg 1-2 times a day.
Dehydroepiandrosterone (DHEA)—is
anti-inflammatory and anti -lipidemic, increases hormonal levels, and
is beneficial in diabetes and Syndrome X
Low levels of DHEA, a steroid normally freely expressed in the human body,
are associated with inflammation and heart disease in men. DHEA delivers
much of its protection by acting as a prohormone, meaning it can bolster
lagging estrogenic or androgenic hormones. In fact, DHEA's value as an
anti -lipidemic appears due in part to its ability to increase estrogen
and testosterone levels. Studies show that DHEA reduced by 50% the expected
atherosclerotic buildup in rabbits fed a high-cholesterol diet. In men,
DHEA lowered total cholesterol and bad low-density-lipoprotein cholesterol
better than and more safely than the drugs clofibrate and gemfibrozil
(Smith 1998) (read about testosterone as a cardio -protector later in
this protocol).
Other anti -atherogenic properties of DHEA include inhibiting the activity
of fibroblasts (cells that proliferate at the site of chronic inflammation),
encouraging proinflammatory cytokine production. An imbalance of the cytokine
network appears to be involved in the development and progression of congestive
heart failure (CHF) (Yang et al. 2001). The greater the cardiac debility,
the more pronounced the imbalance. Note: A cytokine imbalance refers to
a shift toward greater levels of inflammatory cytokines combined with
inadequately raised or decreased levels of anti-inflammatory cytokines.
Pro -inflammatory cytokines interleukin-1b (IL-1b), interleukin-6 (IL-6),
and tumor necrosis factor-alpha (TNF-alpha) typically rise with age. High
levels of TNF-alpha are destructive to the heart muscle, while excesses
of IL-6 are associated with fibrinogen production and the instability
of atheromatous plaque (di Minno et al. 1992; Ikeda et al. 2001; Lindmark
et al. 2001). As DHEA suppresses the activity of IL-6 and TNF-alpha, inflammation
and the risk of clot formation significantly decrease (Kipper-Galperin
et al. 1999; Kaiser 2001).
Japanese researchers suggest screening for pro-inflammatory cytokines
and using the appropriate anti-inflammatory treatment to reduce the risk
of heart disease (Ikeda et al. 2001). By contrast, the use of nonsteroidal
anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs) actually increases the likelihood of
CHF. The use of NSAIDs (other than low-dose aspirin) in the previous week
was associated with a doubling of the odds of a hospital admission with
CHF. The use of NSAIDs by patients with a history of heart disease was
associated with an odds ratio of 10.5 for first admission with heart failure,
compared with 1.6 in those without such a history (Page et al. 2000).
Improved glucose control among diabetic rats supplemented with DHEA
indicates it may be of value to patients with diabetes and Syndrome X.
Research shows that serum DHEA levels fall when serum insulin levels rise
(Lukaczer 2000). Reducing carbohydrates to less than 40 grams a day (lessening
the incidence of an insulin surge) resulted in a 34% increase in DHEA.
Scientists thus speculate that DHEA might be the missing link in the insulin
resistance/hyperinsulinemia epidemic. Insulin appears to deliver its blow
to DHEA by inhibiting production and stimulating clearance (Nestler et
al. 1992).
DHEA, by incorporating into HDL and LDL cholesterol, protects against
oxidation. With age, cholesterol-bound DHEA becomes scarce, and compared
to younger people with adequate levels of DHEA, oxidation spirals. Another
hindrance to antioxidant defense occurs as superoxide dismutase (a powerful
antioxidant) becomes lethargic as DHEA levels dwindle (Bednarek-Tupikowska
et al. 2000). Japanese researchers also showed that DHEA prevented aggression
from increasing during times of mental stress, significantly reducing
levels of norepinephrine, a hormone synthesized by the adrenal medulla
(Sawazaki et al. 1999).
The Massachusetts Male Aging Study determined that in a sample analysis
of 1167 men, those with serum DHEA-S (DHEA-sulfate) in the lowest quartile
at baseline (< 1.6 mcg/mL) were significantly more likely to incur
ischemic heart disease (Feldman et al. 2001). Most studies show DHEA supplementation
to be of value in regard to the cardiac health of men, but the Rancho
Bernardo Study found DHEA-S levels were not significantly associated with
cardiovascular mortality in women (Khaw 1996).
A suggested DHEA dosage is 15-75 mg, taken early in the day (50 mg represents
a typical daily dose). Blood tests are valuable 3-6 weeks into therapy
to assist in assigning appropriate dosages. (Optimal DHEA levels for men
are between 400-560 mcg/dL; for women, the range is considered ideal at
350-430 mcg/dL.) It has been suggested that antioxidants such as green
tea, vitamin E, and N-acetyl-cysteine should accompany DHEA supplementation.
Yet, the threat of potentiating free-radical activity in the liver appears
roused only at much higher doses than are needed to provide the desired
effects.
Because DHEA invigorates hormonal systems, DHEA is not recommended for
men with prostate cancer or for women with estrogen-dependent cancer without
physician approval. (Recall that DHEA can be converted into testosterone
and estrogen.) Before starting DHEA therapy, men should know their serum
PSA (prostate specific antigen) level and should have passed a digital
rectal examination. DHEA does not cause prostate cancer, but since DHEA
can cause an increase in testosterone levels, the presence of an undetected
cancer should be ruled out before initiating the therapy.
Essential Fatty Acids—inhibits
platelet clumping; has antispasmodic activity; improves HDL-LDL ratio;
lessens risk of second heart attack, stroke, and re -stenosis following
angioplasty; inhibits cardiac arrhythmias; is hypotensive; reduces fibrinogen,
Lp(a), C-reactive protein (CRP), total cholesterol, and homocysteine;
improves insulin sensitivity; and is beneficial to dieters
The current mania regarding low fat diets is contributing to deficiencies
and imbalances of the essential fatty acids linoleic acid and alpha-linolenic
acid. The body cannot synthesize these fats and is dependent upon the
diet for their supply.
Some individuals support the premise that fats do little more than make
you fat and that they can be eliminated without upsetting metabolic processes.
In truth, fats initiate the transmission of vital messages, in part by
programming activity in the omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acid cascades. Instructions
received by prostaglandins (hormone-like substances produced from fatty
acids) encourage some prostaglandins to oppose and others to neutralize,
a process that holds the entire family in check. Prostaglandins are found
in virtually all cell membranes and control most metabolic functions.
Vital as they are, when out of balance, they can prove the undoing of
the host. For example, PGE2 is generally regarded as a less desirable
(even destructive) prostaglandin. (Although PGE2 can provoke an inflammatory
response, the body does need some PGE2 to maintain the mucosal integrity
of the intestinal wall.) On the other hand, PGE1 and PGE3 are good prostaglandins,
meaning they decrease the likelihood of platelets clumping and dilate
blood vessels, while exerting anti-inflammatory activity (Braly 1985).
Standard American Diet
The standard American diet is high in saturated fats and arachidonic acid
but frequently is deficient in alpha-linolenic acid, an omega-3 fatty
acid. Many Americans have an omega-6-omega-3 ratio of about 20-30:1. Clarifying
our departure from primitive diets, ancient kinsmen maintained a ratio
nearer 1:1. A more realistic ratio, according to Joseph Pizzorno, N.D.,
may be nearer 2:1 (Simopoulos 1999; Pizzorno 2001).
Dr. James Braley, M.D., cautions that a dietary departure from the omega-3
fatty acids can lead to an overproduction of PGE2, a pro-inflammatory,
platelet-aggregating prostaglandin. For this reason, diet and supplementation
should most often favor the lagging omega-3 fatty acids. When the omega-3s
are emphasized, arachidonic acid, the precursor to PGE2, is reduced (Braly
1985).
Illustrative of the importance of having more good prostaglandins than
bad, some researchers estimate that 30% or more of heart attacks occur
as a result of smooth muscles in the walls of the coronary arteries going
into spasm, causing disruption of oxygen supply to the heart. If oxygen
cutoff is not long lasting, a renewed delivery of oxygen begins and the
spasm ceases. PGE1 dilates the blood vessels, making them less prone to
spasm; conversely, PGE2 constricts blood vessels. Compounding the problem,
PGE2 is often released during heart spasm, further constricting the blood
vessels (Braly 1985).
Figure 5 illustrates the omega-6 and omega-3 cascades and the enzymes
delta-6- and delta-5-desaturase (rate controlling enzymes) that spur sequential
movement through the series. Recall that from arachidonic acid, the parent
of PGE2, leukotrienes are formed.
A functional delta-6-desaturase enzyme appears to be crucial to blood
pressure management. An example of this occurred when two trial groups,
selected from 25 nonobese participants with mild to moderate hypertension,
were given either linoleic acid (sunflower oil) and alpha-linolenic acid
(linseed oil) or their reduced forms, GLA (360 mg a day) and EPA (180
mg a day). The first group was delta-6-desaturase dependent; the second
group was not. After 8-12 weeks, the group receiving the GLA and EPA had
reduced their blood pressure by about 10%. Those in the first group, who
lacked the activity of delta-6-desaturase, experienced no significant
hypotensive benefit. This observation may indicate that the defective
desaturation of the essential fatty acids by the enzyme delta-6-desaturase
plays an important role in the etiology of essential hypertension (Venter
et al. 1988).
Diabetes, hypercholesterolemia, and nutritional deficiencies (zinc,
vitamin B6, and magnesium) can inhibit delta-6-desaturase activity. At
Comprehensive Cancer Care 2001, Joseph Pizzorno, N.D., prominent educator
and cofounder of Bastyr University, cited obesity, viral assaults, stress,
aging, alcohol, smoking, and trans fats as additional factors retarding
the efficacy of delta-6-desaturase (Pizzorno 2001). Individuals with a
sluggish delta-6-desaturase enzyme (about 10-20% of the population) should
use the fatty acid appearing downstream from the enzyme. (Figure 5 illustrates
this sequence.)
Modulates Lipids, but so Much More
Typically, both men and women observe an increase in HDL2, the most beneficial
of the HDL subtypes, after 6 months of omega-3 fatty acid supplementation.
The protective role of total HDL against coronary artery disease appears
primarily mediated through the HDL2 fraction (Bakogianni et al. 2001).
During the course of a recent study, HDL2 cholesterol rose 24% among those
eating a daily omega-3-rich fish meal and adhering to a restricted calorie
diet. Those who did not lose weight nonetheless experienced a 21% rise
in HDL2 cholesterol on the fish diet (Diets 2000). Recall that individuals
achieving longevity frequently display elevations in HDL2b cholesterol,
suggesting better cardiac function.
A number of studies have shown the protective value of fish consumption
in regard to averting coronary heart disease and the incidence of sudden
cardiac death. For example, a recent study reported data collected from
the Physicians' Health Study involving more than 22,000 men followed over
a 17-year time frame. Researchers tested the blood of 94 male study volunteers
who experienced an episode of sudden cardiac death (but in whom there
was no prior history of heart disease) against 184 matched control study
participants who did not experience a cardiac event.
On an average, men who died suddenly had lower levels of omega-3 fatty
acids. Among the men with the highest levels of omega-3 fatty acids in
the blood, there was a 72% reduction in the risk of sudden cardiac death
when compared to the men with the lowest levels of these substances in
their blood (Albert et al. 2002; Wascher 2002). Recall that 50% of people
who die suddenly of cardiac causes have no signs or symptoms of heart
disease; poor omega-3 representation may explain this worrisome statistic.
JAMA reported that women receive a similar cardiac advantage when eating
fish or using omega-3 fatty acids (Hu et al. 2002). During 16 years of
follow-up, there were 1513 incident cases of coronary heart disease (484
deaths and 1029 nonfatal myocardial infarctions) among 84,688 women (ages
34-59) participating in the Nurses' Health Study. Those who ate fish once
a week had a 30% lower risk of heart attack or death compared to those
who never ate fish. Interestingly, eating fish 5 times a week was only
slightly more beneficial, decreasing risk to 34%. JAMA also cited a 40-50%
reduction in strokes among middle-aged women who did not use aspirin but
regularly included fish in their diet (Iso et al. 2001a).
A meta-analysis (a method of evaluating statistical data based on results
of several independent studies) showed that omega-3 fatty acids reduce
the incidence of fatal heart attacks, even in patients with established
coronary heart disease (Bucher et al. 2002). Obviously, there are mechanisms
released through fatty acid consumption that go beyond regulating cholesterol
and triglycerides.
- Dr. Kilmer McCully, pioneer of the homocysteine-heart disease theory,
determined that fish oil lowers homocysteine levels. Clinicians and
researchers now affirm his work (Culp 2000).
- English researchers reported that fish oil decreased fibrinogen,
addressing a major pathological process leading to thrombotic occlusion.
A 7-year MAXEPA study concluded without indication of adverse side effects
(Saynor et al. 1992).
- Omega-3 fatty acids have been shown to lower Lp(a) (Herrmann et al.
1995; Shinozaki et al. 1996). Note: Cardiologists confess that (in some
cases) Lp(a) can be difficult to reduce. A targeted intervention program
often includes fish oil (1400 mg EPA and DHA), vitamin C (2-6 grams
daily), CoQ10 (60-120 mg daily), L-lysine (1000-3000 mg daily), L-proline
(500-1000 mg daily), and niacin. See the Niacin subsection of this section
for details regarding dosing instructions and caveats.
- Dr. Robert Atkins, a complementary physician with a background in
cardiology, believes that fatty acids are natural defibrillators, lessening
the incidence of cardiac arrhythmias and atrial fibrillation. Several
years ago, the Life Extension Foundation reported that omega-3 fatty
acids reduced the risk of second heart attack and stroke by inhibiting
cardiac arrhythmias, maintaining cardiac energy output, and reducing
thrombosis.
- DHA reduced 24-hour blood pressure (5.8 mmHg systolic and 3.3 mmHg
diastolic) and daytime/ambulatory blood pressure (3.5 mmHg systolic
and 2.0 mmHg diastolic) (Mori et al. 1999). For every absolute 1% increase
in blood alpha-linolenic acid, systolic and diastolic blood pressure
typically drop by about 5 mmHg.
- DHA lowered norepinephrine, a gesture that may protect the cardiovascular
system by reducing vasoconstriction and blood pressure (Sawazaki et
al. 1999).
- Data suggest that C-reactive protein (CRP) levels can be kept in
check by frequent consumption of fish or fish oils. For example, 269
patients underwent angiography for suspected coronary artery disease.
The subjects were also evaluated regarding CRP levels and fish consumption.
In addition, EPA and DHA levels were assayed in granulocytes (a type
of white blood cell). The researchers found that patients with one or
more coronary arteries blocked (50% or more) had significantly higher
CRP levels in their blood than patients with no significant blockages.
They also observed that high CRP levels correlated with low levels of
DHA in granulocytes. The level of DHA in granulocytes in turn was closely
related to fish consumption. The researchers concluded that DHA has
an anti-inflammatory effect that results in lower CRP levels and that
fish consumption may decrease the risk of coronary artery disease (Madsen
et al. 2001; International Health News, http://www.oilofpisces.com/atherosclerosis.html)
- After angioplasty, 194 patients were randomly assigned to receive
either 4.5 grams a day of fish oil (3150 mg of EPA and 1350 mg of DHA
for 6 months) or instructions to eat a low fat (25% of total calories),
low cholesterol diet (100 mg a day) without fish oil. At the end of
the trial, 36% of those not receiving the fish oil showed signs of re
-stenosis (closure of previously opened arteries). The rate of re-stenosis
in the fish oil group was about 19%. The study suggests, as do other
trials, that high-dose fish oil supplements may reduce the frequency
of re-stenosis following successful coronary angioplasty. Nonetheless,
Mark Milner, M.D., the lead researcher, said his preference for supplying
omega-3 fatty acids is fish consumption, not fish oil. Milner cited
concern for (potentially) hypocoagulative blood states as the mitigating
factor (Milner et al. 1989).
- The omega-3 fatty acids in fish oil help to balance the omega-6 fatty
acids normally abundantly supplied in Western diets. When these two
groups of fatty acids are out of balance, the body releases chemicals
that promote inflammation. People appear to produce more inflammatory
chemicals when experiencing psychological stress. With a fatty acid
imbalance, the inflammatory response to stress appears to be amplified
(Maes et al. 2000).
Information presented at the International Symposium on Gamma-Linolenic
Acid, San Diego (April 2000), showed that GLA (an omega-6 fatty acid)
lowered blood pressure in animal studies. According to French researcher
Jean Pierre Poisson, "Usually in pharmaceutical therapies we see
about a 10% reduction. In our case we saw blood pressure drop 6-16%."
Future research on humans is still needed, but Poisson concluded: "It
appears GLA is a very potent blood-pressure-reducing nutrient" (Engler
et al. 1998; Bioriginal Food and Science 2001).
A Texas researcher reported that GLA mitigates the growth of atherosclerotic
plaque in the arterial walls of animals. The research holds promise that
GLA supplementation (borage oil and evening primrose oil) may be equally
important in halting the atherosclerotic process in humans (Nigam 1999).
Balance: Always the Key
The need for balance regarding dietary fats is clearly evidenced in a
report appearing in the journal Circulation. Researchers found that low
levels of animal fat and protein increased the risk of hemorrhagic stroke
in hypertensive women 370% over women eating more dietary fat. The researchers
also noted that individuals with a very low intake of saturated fat may
develop structural impairment of the arteries. Although saturated fats
have been maligned for years, it now appears that some saturated fats,
that is, a balance among the family of fats is required for healthy arteries
and a reduced risk of hemorrhagic stroke (Iso et al. 2001b).
Trans Fats
Technology can transform a benign fat into a dangerous food product. This
occurs when fats are exposed to the hydrogenation process, saturating
the oil with hydrogen to improve stability, taste, and odor. Heating oils
at temperatures above 300°F has the same effect.
Hydrogenation turns liquid oils, such as corn, soybean, sunflower, sesame,
and cotton, into a semisolid shortening or margarine. (The harder the
fat, the more trans fats it contains.) This process changes a cis (a beneficial
fat) to a nonfunctional form (a trans fat) that can no longer participate
in prostaglandin production.
Hydrogenated fats deliver a serious blow by reducing activity in the
omega-6 and omega-3 cascades (probably by inhibiting the enzymes delta-6-desaturase
and delta-5-desaturase). This suggests that the consumption of partially
hydrogenated vegetable oils may have an adverse impact upon the relative
distribution of the final end products of the essential acids in terms
of prostaglandin concentrations. Also, as trans fatty acids increase in
the diet (replacing cis unsaturated fatty acids), LDL cholesterol is (typically)
raised, but the beneficial HDL cholesterol is decreased. Trans fatty acids
also increase Lp(a) levels relative to other fatty acids (Mensink et al.
1990, 1992; Zock et al. 1996).
A study involving 600 men (ages 64-87), determined that every 2% increase
in trans fatty acids increased the risk of developing coronary heart disease
25% over the next 10 years (Oomen el al. 2001). The influence of different
types of fats can also be observed in the progression of diabetes. For
example, the risk of diabetes was not increased among 84,204 women whose
intake of fats came chiefly from nuts, seeds, and avocados, but a 2% increase
in calories from trans fatty acids raised the risk of diabetes by about
39%. Conversely, a 5% increase in calories from polyunsaturated fats lowered
the risk of diabetes 37% (Salmeron et al. 2001; Mercola 2001b).
In 1993, doctors at Harvard Medical School found that women who ate
4 or more tsp of margarine a day had a 50% greater risk of developing
heart disease compared to women who ate margarine only rarely (Harvard
School of Public Health 2002). Although the amount of trans fatty acids
appearing in margarine and shortening has been reduced in the United States
, these damaging fats are still found in many other foods such as bakery
items and fast food products. Trans fats become a major part of American
diets when the 30 pounds of French fries consumed per capita are factored
into dietary analysis. Trans fats often hide on dietary labels as partially
hydrogenated fats. Learn to read labels and avoid trans fats.
Growing public awareness regarding the dangers imposed by trans fats
has prompted a reduction in their consumption. An example of the benefits
of eliminating trans fatty acids from the diet comes by way of a study
released from The Netherlands. An average 2.4% drop in trans fatty acid
consumption prompted a 23% decrease in coronary deaths and saved, it is
speculated, about 4600 lives (Oomen et al. 2001; Reuters Health 2001).
Beneficial to Those on Diets
Studies have shown that genetically obese people profit from essential
fatty acid supplementation. The weight loss in these individuals is gradual,
but reliable, even among those considered intractably obese.
Evening primrose oil, rich in gamma-linolenic acid, appears to stimulate
brown fat cells by producing PGE1. Brown fat is of particular advantage
in maintaining a desirable weight because it uses extra calories to provide
heat, preventing the deposit of unsightly white fat (Braly 1985).
Individual differences in amounts of brown fat have been theorized to
account for the ability (or inability) to maintain a desirable weight.
Brown fat is found primarily attached to large blood vessels in the thoracic
cavity, along certain ribs, the nape of the neck, armpits, and between
and below the shoulder blades. Without sufficient amounts of brown fat,
calories are not burned and as a result, overweight individuals may actually
gain weight on fewer calories. As a weight-deterrent, essential fatty
acids most benefit those who are more than 20% overweight (Braly 1985).
Essential Fatty Acids and Syndrome
X and Diabetes
Omega-3 fatty acids help maintain flexible cell membranes (Igal et al.
1997). This is important, for healthy membranes contain large numbers
of insulin receptors, increasing the surface areas available for insulin
binding. This is extremely important in diabetes and Syndrome X.
The Iowa Women's Health Study examined the relationship between dietary
fatty acids and Type II diabetes in a cohort of over 35,000 nondiabetic
women (ages 55-69). The study showed that women with the highest intake
of vegetable fat had a 22% lower risk of developing diabetes during the
11-year follow-up. Substituting polyunsaturated fats for saturated fats
reduced the incidence of diabetes by an average of 16%, regardless of
fiber intake, magnesium levels, obesity, physical exercise, or smoking
status (Meyer et al. 2001; LEF 2001).
Researchers (reporting in JAMA) showed that 120 nondiabetic, hypercholesterolemic
men receiving sim -vastatin (20 mg a day for 12 weeks) reduced their total
cholesterol 20.8%; LDL cholesterol 29.7%; triglycerides 13.6%; and apolipoprotein
B 22.4%. A 13% increase in insulin levels and a 14% increase in insulin
resistance, along with a loss of antioxidants (alpha-tocopherol dropped
16.2%, beta-carotene plummeted 19.5%, and CoQ10 fell 22%), minimized the
cardioprotective effects of simvastatin. Consuming a modified Mediterranean
diet (containing at least 4 grams a day of omega-3 fatty acids) potentiated
the cholesterol-lowering effects of simvastatin and counteracted the rise
in insulin levels. In addition, beta-carotene and CoQ10 levels were protected
(Jula et al. 2002).
What Are the Good Fats?
Individuals wishing to increase their consumption of beneficial fish and
marine life should consider scallops, shrimp, herring, mackerel, sea bass,
salmon, cod, sardines, tuna (fresh), whitefish, coldwater halibut, and
anchovies, varieties containing varying amounts of eicosapentaenoic acid
(EPA) and docosahexaenoic acid (DHA). From the plant kingdom, walnuts,
most beans, and according to Joseph Pizzorno, N.D. (Comprehensive Cancer
Care 2001), Brussels sprouts and all varieties of squash are also sources
of omega-3 fatty acids (Pizzorno 2001).
Poultry Science reported that three omega-3 enriched eggs provide about
the same amount of n-3 PUFAs as one meal containing fish. Researchers
found that the 3 eggs a day did not significantly increase total cholesterol
or LDL in most subjects. Typically, plasma triglycerides as well as platelet
aggregation decrease. LDL particle size tended to shift toward a less
atherogenic dimension, appearing less small and dense (Lewis et al. 2000).
Olive oil, an omega-9 fatty acid (a monounsaturated fat), is an excellent
choice for both salads and cooking. However, it is extremely difficult
to purchase oils in an ideal state, if shopping from a supermarket; a
better choice appears to be extra virgin olive oil in a lightproof container.
(Refrigerate the oil immediately after purchase.) Other sources of omega-9
fatty acids are almonds, pecans, cashews, filberts, and macadamias. Omega-9
contributes primarily to the structural elements of phosphatides. Phosphatides,
in turn, are necessary for cell membrane integrity.
Almond oil is currently reviewed better than canola oil (rape seed)
by various practitioners and researchers. Canola oil, belonging to the
mustard family, is derived from seeds of a plant considered (by some)
to be toxic. Canola oil, when processed, appears to become rancid very
quickly and may over time increase the incidence of heart disease. Refrigeration
does not appear to retard its oxidation (Fallon 2002). Canola oil proponents
still uphold its value, but until more questions are answered regarding
its safety, it seems wiser to select the tried and true olive oil.
According to Robert Erdmann, Ph.D., butter, in small amounts, is a better
choice than margarine. He added: "Butter may not only be highly nutritious
but may be an underexploited form of alternative health therapy"
(Erdmann 1990).
Supplemental Omega-6 and Omega-3 Fatty
Acids: What to Buy
To introduce the reader to various omega-6 and omega-3 fatty acids, the
following examples are given:
- Perilla oil, 1000-mg per capsule, provides 550-620 mg of alpha-linolenic
acid, a precursor to EPA and DHA. Use 6 softgels daily.
- Flaxseed oil (1000-mg softgels) provides 520-570 mg per capsule of
gamma-linolenic acid. Use 6 softgels a day.
- Super GLA/DHA provides 920 mg of GLA, 1000 mg of DHA, and 400 mg
of EPA. Use 6 capsules daily.
- Evening primrose oil is a source of GLA. Use one to two 1300-mg softgels
daily.
- Borage oil also supplies GLA. A 1300-mg softgel supplies 300 mg of
GLA. As a preventive, use 1-2 softgels a day and up to 5 a day as a
therapeutic.
N ote: Prothrombin time usually remains within a normal range when using
omega-3. As the number of platelets decreases, platelet size typically
increases; therefore, there is no overall decrease in platelet mass. The
New England Journal of Medicine reported that the blood-thinning functions
of fish oil are small compared to aspirin, but other researchers caution
that bleeding time could increase to inappropriate levels if baseline
platelet activity is impaired or fibrinogen concentrations are low (Katan
1995).
Fiber—is a hypolipidemic
and antidiabetic agent, aids in weight loss, and blocks iron absorption
The intake of dietary fiber among people living in Western countries is
low (about 17 grams a day in the United States ), according to the Third
National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey (NHANES). This is unfortunate,
for soluble fiber offers significant protection against a number of risk
factors associated with cardiovascular disease. For example, mucilages,
guar gum, psyllium powder, oat bran, and pectin reduce cholesterol levels.
Guar gum (5 grams with meals), psyllium powder (5 grams before meals),
or pectin (10 grams with meals) reduce fasting and postprandial blood
glucose, as well as insulin levels, in both healthy and diabetic subjects.
If taken with meals, soluble fibers (6-10 grams a day) reduce iron absorption
from foods, important to those with hemochromatosis or iron overload (Monnier
et al. 1980) (to read about hemochromatosis as a contributor to cardiovascular
disease, turn to Iron Overload in the section devoted to Traditional Risk
Factors).
Illustrative of the value of fiber, researchers from the Veterans Affairs
Medical Center , the University of Kentucky ( Lexington ), and the Procter
& Gamble Company ( Cincinnati , OH ) evaluated the effectiveness of
psyllium as a hypocholesterolemic and blood glucose modulator. Thirty-four
men with Type II diabetes and mild-to-moderate hypercholesterolemia were
randomly assigned to receive 5.1 grams of psyllium or a cellulose placebo
twice daily for 8 weeks. The psyllium group showed significant improvements
in glucose and lipid values compared with the placebo group. Serum total
and LDL-cholesterol concentrations were 8.9% and 13.0% lower, respectively,
in the psyllium group compared to the placebo group. All-day and post
-lunch postprandial glucose concentrations were 11.0% and 19.2% lower
in the psyllium group (Anderson et al. 1999). These impressive results
occur as fiber binds bile acids, cholesterol, and fats, preventing their
absorption. Short-chain fatty acids, products of fiber fermentation in
the colon, further inhibit cholesterol synthesis by the liver.
Studies in the New England Journal of Medicine confirmed the value of
a high fiber diet in improving glycemic control and reducing hyperinsulinemia
and plasma lipid levels in patients with Type II diabetes (Chandalia et
al. 2000). In a randomized, 6-week crossover study, 13 patients with Type
II diabetes were given diets containing either moderate or high amounts
of fiber. The moderate fiber allowance was 24 grams (8 grams of soluble
and 16 grams of insoluble), an amount compliant with guidelines established
by the ADA . The high-fiber diet consisted of 50 grams of fiber (25 grams
soluble and 25 grams insoluble).
During the sixth week of the high-fiber diet (as compared with the sixth
week of the ADA diet) the diet supplying 50 grams a day of fiber lowered
plasma glucose 10%, insulin concentrations 12%, total cholesterol 6.7%,
triglyceride levels 10.2%, VLDL 12.5%, and LDL cholesterol 6.3%. It is
speculated that the decrease in triglycerides and VLDL may be due more
to improved glycemic control than to a direct relationship with the fiber.
There was no significant difference between the two diets in terms of
HDL cholesterol levels. Note: The fiber-rich foods included in the study
were cantaloupe, grapefruit, raisins, oranges, papayas, lima beans, okra,
sweet potatoes, winter squash, zucchini, oat bran, and oatmeal.
Fiber is also of advantage to individuals who wish to lose weight. Bulk
tends to render a feeling of fullness, negating the desire to overeat.
An overweight individual should consider using bulk fibers stirred into
an 8-oz glass of water; drink the mixture about 20 minutes before meals.
Diabetics and those not accustomed to higher levels of fiber should
initially use the material cautiously. Fiber can significantly alter insulin
or sulfonylurea requirements and some individuals experience gastrointestinal
distress until the GI tract becomes better acquainted with the new material.
A suggested initial dosage is 1 tsp daily; gradually increase to 1 tsp
3 times daily.
Reader's guide to foods high in fiber
Grains are excellent sources of fiber, but many individuals find the addition
of cereal grains problematic due to food sensitivities. Vegetables and
fruits (raw and with peel intact) are pleasant fibrous additions to the
diet.
Garlic—acts as a hypotensive,
decreases fibrinogen, inhibits platelet aggregation, thins the blood,
protects against LDL oxidation and arterial wall damage, reduces the incidence
of arrhythmias, modestly reduces blood glucose levels, protects against
iron overload, and is vasodilating
The consensus surrounding the benefits of garlic as a hypolipidemic is
not unified. The Archives of Internal Medicine found garlic powder (900
mg a day for 12 weeks) to be ineffective in lowering blood lipids (Isaacsohn
et al. 1998). Researchers concede that variations in preparations could
be distorting results as well as gender. For example, women showed favorable
effects in terms of coronary heart disease risk factors (i.e., increases
in HDL-C and reductions in total cholesterol) using garlic oil, whereas
men had small adverse effects. There was a significant difference in the
garlic oil effect for glucose, with a reduction seen for men and an increase
for women (Zhang et al. 2001).
Interestingly, the American Journal of Natural Medicine reported that
4000 mg of fresh garlic (guaranteeing an allicin content of at least 10,000
mcg or a total allicin yield of 4000 mcg) typically lowers total cholesterol
levels 10-12%, triglycerides by about 15%, and LDL 15%, while increasing
HDL cholesterol levels 10% (Murray 1995a). Healthy human volunteers given
600 mg a day of a garlic preparation (providing 7.8 mg of allicin for
2 weeks) reduced lipoprotein oxidation 34% compared to controls. It should
be noted that garlic could cause a transient elevation in blood lipids,
as garlic unseats fats deposited in tissues. With continued garlic supplementation,
lipid stores complete the breakdown process and blood cholesterol levels
modulate.
While much of the research has focused on improving lipid levels, researchers
have isolated hypotensive factors in garlic as well. An analysis of published
and unpublished randomized, controlled trials (415 patients) showed that
600-900 mg a day of dried garlic powder may be of clinical value in subjects
with mild hypertension (Silagy et al. 1994). Other researchers have noted
a 5.5% decrease in systolic blood pressure and a modest reduction in diastolic
blood pressure in response to aged garlic extract (Steiner 1996).
Garlic, a sulfur-rich plant from the lily family, exerts its hypotensive
nature through the following pathways:
- Supplementation with aged garlic significantly reduced epinephrine,
a vasoconstricting hormone released from the adrenal medulla (Steiner
et al. 1998).
- Garlic moderately inhibited (both in vivo and in vitro) the activity
of ACE, an enzyme that increases blood pressure by catalyzing the conversion
of angiotensin I to angiotensin II. This sequence constricts blood vessels,
conserves water and sodium ions, and, unless interrupted, results in
an increase in blood pressure (Rietz et al. 1993).
- Garlic increases the activity of nitric oxide synthase, an enzyme
essential for nitric oxide synthesis (Morihara et al. 2002). Nitric
oxide, a relaxing factor, not only reduces blood pressure by acting
as a vasodilator, but also lessens platelet aggregation, suppresses
smooth muscle proliferation, reduces leukocyte adherence to vessel walls,
and has anti -anginal and antispasmodic activity.
- Garlic contains chemicals that act as calcium antagonists, reducing
blood pressure and lessening the incidence of arrhythmias (Duke Database
1992).
Garlic exhibits additional cardiovascular protection by thinning the
blood and acting as a fibrinolytic. German researchers reported successes
in treating ventricular tachycardia and fibrillation with garlic, as well
as the duration of arrhythmias (Isensee et al. 1993). Garlic also modestly
reduces blood glucose levels, while EDTA-garlic combinations appear to
decrease iron stores. Dosage suggestions are 1-2 Kyolic caplets (1000
mg) twice daily with meals or 2-8 capsules of Pure-Gar Caps (900 mg) daily
with food. (One Pure-Gar Cap contains 900 mg of garlic bulb powder extract
standardized to supply 9 mg of allicin, the highest potency available.)
Ginger—reduces cholesterol,
prevents blood clots, is an anti-inflammatory, and has chemical components
that are calcium antagonists, vasodilators, and ACE inhibitors
Ginger (Zingiber officinale) is reliable in treating a wide variety of
cardiovascular complaints. Among ginger's protective properties is its
ability to reduce cholesterol by promoting cholesterol excretion, impairing
cholesterol absorption, and encouraging bile secretion and bile acid production.
(Bile acid is a steroid acid of bile, produced during the metabolism of
cholesterol.) Ginger exerts some of its hypolipidemic effects by stimulating
cholesterol-7-alpha-hydroxylase, a rate-limiting enzyme of bile acid synthesis
(Srinivasan et al. 1991).
Researchers reported the effects of administering ginger (200 mg/kg
orally) to 61 cholesterol-fed rabbits (Bhandari et al. 1998). The marked
rise in cholesterol, triglycerides, lipoproteins, and phospholipids (which
normally follows 10 weeks of cholesterol feeding) was significantly reduced
by ginger. The favorable results obtained from ginger were comparable
to the hypolipidemic effects of the drug Lopid, known generically as gemfibrozil.
Various chemicals contained in ginger are calcium antagonists, vasodilators,
ACE inhibitors, and diuretics, suggesting additional value in reducing
blood pressure and the incidence of arrhythmias (Duke Database 1992).
Ginger reduces the likelihood of a blood clot through the following
mechanisms:
- Ginger, ginkgo, olive leaf, and garlic each contain chemicals that
inhibit platelet-activating factor, PAF (Duke Database 1992). Adequate
amounts of PAF are essential to coagulation and inflammatory processes;
excesses are associated with blood clot formation, stroke, and heart
disease.
- Thromboxane A-2, a platelet-aggregating factor, is inhibited more
by ginger than by either garlic or onions (Srivas 1984).
- Prostacylin, an inhibitor of platelet aggregation, is pressed into
service by ginger, a process that further reduces the likelihood of
blood clot formation (Backon 1986).
Although all of these effects are similar (blood clot reduction), a
study involving healthy volunteers showed no irregularities in blood coagulation
among participants receiving 2 grams of ginger a day (McCaleb et al. 2000).
Nonetheless, caution is indicated for those individuals with baseline
disturbances in platelet numbers or prothrombin time. Furthermore, the
activity of prescribed blood thinners may be heightened if used in concert
with ginger.
Ginger also appears to protect the heart during periods of inflammation.
(Recall that inflammation is considered a trigger in heart disease.) Ginger's
anti-inflammatory properties are due to interruption of the prostaglandin-leukotriene
cascade, blocking damaging prostaglandins but leaving beneficial prostaglandins
unaffected. Ginger root (gingerols) has been shown to inhibit cyclooxygenase
pathways, sharing anti-inflammatory traits with other popular COX-2 inhibitors
(Newmark et al. 2000; Faloon 2001).
A preventive dose of ginger is one to two 300-mg capsules 1-3 times
a day. Interestingly, a researcher recently recommended 10 grams (approximately
1 tsp a day) to reduce platelet aggregation (Bordia et al. 1997). A qualified
healthcare practitioner must monitor this dosage. JAMA published an article
raising a cautionary flag concerning the risk of cardiovascular events
among users of COX-2 inhibitors (such as Celebrex and Vioxx) (Mukherjee
et al. 2001). The FDA has also objected to claims and promotional activities
by Pharmacia Corporation minimizing the potentially serious risk of bleeding
associated with Celebrex (Fort 2001). It is hoped further prospective
evaluations will characterize and determine the magnitude of the risks.
In the interim, natural COX-2 inhibitors (including ginger) loom as welcome
alternatives.
Ginkgo Biloba—improves circulation
and memory; reduces platelet aggregation and excesses of fibrinogen; has
antioxidant and anti-inflammatory activity; prevents capillary fragility;
lessens angina attacks, dyspnea, and intermittent claudication; limits
brain damage following stroke; increases insulin secretion; and is a vasodilator
Ginkgo biloba is one of the oldest surviving species on earth. But this
ancient herb, renowned for its ability to retard aging, has survived the
test of time and is yielding remarkable benefits for millions of Americans
and Europeans. Heart, circulatory, and cognitive disorders are the principal
reasons individuals rely upon ginkgo. More than 300 clinical and experimental
studies have supported the worth of Ginkgo biloba.
- Ginkgo has won favor among the Chinese as a heart tonic by lessening
coronary demands for oxygen, thus reducing shortness of breath and chest
pain (Duke 1997).
- Ginkgo's antioxidant properties, particularly the flavones, assist
in strengthening blood vessel walls and improving tone and elasticity
(Joyeuz et al. 1995).
- Ginkgo is a vasodilator, making it useful in lowering blood pressure
and treating many forms of heart disease (120 mg a day at bedtime for
3 months reduced systolic blood pressure from 125 mmHg to 118 mmHg and
diastolic from 86 mmHg to 68 mmHg) (Kudolo 2000). Some of the chemicals
contained in ginkgo are ACE inhibitors, further explaining its hypotensive
nature (Duke Database 1992).
- Ginkgo is also an anti-inflammatory, adding additional merit to its
cardiac profile (Hopes 2000). Consult the section entitled Link Between
Infections and Inflammation in Heart Disease (in this protocol) to understand
the value of anti-inflammatories in a comprehensive cardiovascular program.
- Ginkgolide B infusions are comparable to standard anti -arrhythmic
drugs in controlling irregular heartbeats (Koltai et al. 1989).
- Patients with chronic cerebral vascular insufficiency typically respond
well to ginkgo biloba extract (GBE), reporting improvement in vertigo,
headache, ringing in the ears, and memory ( Murray 1995c).
- GBE also significantly improves the supply of blood to the limbs.
As resting blood flow and peripheral circulation improve, intermittent
claudication, a cramp-like pain in the calves, diminishes. In fact,
40 mg of GBE twice a day is from 10-45% more effective at controlling
intermittent claudication than pentoxifylline (Trental) (Duke 1997).
Varro Tyler, Ph.D. (dean and professor emeritus at Purdue University
), profiles ginkgo in his book Herbs of Choice as a treatment for peripheral
vascular disease and cerebral circulatory disturbances (Robbers 2000).
Ginkgo can, in fact, act as a prophylaxis against strokes by reducing
fragility of capillaries and counteracting erythrocyte and platelet hyperaggregability.
The nature of platelets is strongly influenced by platelet-activating
factor (PAF), which ginkgo inhibits.
The American Academy of Neurology reported that ginkgo reduced the extent
of brain damage caused by artificially induced strokes in mice (June-July
2000 edition). Mice receiving low-dose GBE 1 week prior to stroke reduced
the area in the brain that was affected by 30%. The journal Stroke concurred
that GBE reduced stroke infarct volume but noted the beneficial effect
appears to be dose related. In fact, researchers found that higher doses
had the potential for increasing the risk of intracerebral hemorrhage.
The combined clinical use of GBE with antiplatelet, anticoagulant, and
thrombolytic agents could potentially further increase the risk (Clark
et al. 2001).
Researchers recently reported a function of ginkgo biloba not frequently
credited to the herb, that is, an ability to increase insulin secretion.
A study was undertaken to determine the effect of GBE on glucose-stimulated
pancreatic beta-cell function in normal glucose-tolerant individuals:
20 participants (14 females and six males, ages 21-57) underwent a 2-hour,
75-gram oral glucose tolerance test before and after ingestion of GBE
(120 mg a day at bedtime). During the 3-month evaluation, both fasting
plasma insulin and C peptide (a biologically inactive residue of insulin
formation) increased. Dr. G.B. Kudolo (principal researcher) believes
the changes in the insulin-C peptide response curves are due to increased
production and secretion of insulin (Kudolo 2000).
N ote: Herbals that influence glycemic control by increasing insulin
secretion would be contraindicated in cases of existing hyperinsulinemia.
If insulin production declines to the point that hypoinsulinemia exists,
herbs that encourage insulin release would then be appropriate.
High quality GBE is typically standardized to contain a minimum of 24%
ginkgo flavone glycosides and 6% terpene lactones. Side effects are rare
when using the standardized extract; however, concomitant use with an
anticoagulant medication or administering GBE to individuals with prolonged
prothrombin time may make ginkgo inappropriate. (Ginkgo is not recommended
for pregnant or lactating women.) A dosing suggestion is 120-240 mg a
day. (A dose of 120 mg a day assists in reducing excessive fibrinogen
levels, i.e., levels greater than 300 mg/dL).
Grapefruit Pectin—is hypocholesterolemic
Grapefruit pectin and other food sources rich in soluble fibers are useful
adjuvants in the treatment of hypercholesterolemia. In fact, grapefruit
pectin, a stringy white fiber, appears equal to or more effective than
most popularly prescribed drugs for lowering cholesterol. Since grapefruit
pectin is highly soluble, the pectin is broken down in the small intestine
so that 100% of the fiber is utilized.
Illustrative of its potential, guinea pigs administered grapefruit pectin
reduced their cholesterol by greater than 40% over a 6-week period (Cerda
1994b). No side effects were noted, a vast departure from the potential
risks associated with many prescription drugs.
In addition, researchers found citrus pectin effective in reducing atheromatous
plaque. Substantiating its worth, an atherogenic diet was fed to a group
of microswine to induce hypercholesterolemia. Plasma cholesterol levels
rose rapidly and for 360 days were sustained at levels 6-12 times the
norm. Half of the microswine were then fed a diet containing 3% grapefruit
pectin; the remaining animals received the original diet. Animals were
slaughtered 270 days later, and the extent of atherosclerosis determined.
The mean surface area covered by plaque in the aorta was 13.6% in the
group not receiving pectin compared to 5.3% in the group receiving pectin.
Mean coronary artery narrowing was 45% without pectin and 24% with pectin
(Cerda et al. 1994a).
Human trials have also been gratifying. Hypercholesterolemic subjects
using no other cholesterol lowering agents and without lifestyle modification
significantly lowered total cholesterol and LDL while increasing HDL levels
(Cerda et al. 1988). Begin with less than 1 scoop of grapefruit pectin
(with meals) and gradually increase until 2-3 scoops are used daily. If
using grapefruit pectin tablets, use 1000 mg with meals.
Gugulipid—lowers total cholesterol,
LDL, and triglycerides; increases HDL cholesterol; regresses plaque formation;
opposes platelet aggregation; and has fibrinolytic activity
Numerous studies have demonstrated that gugulipid is beneficial to about
70% of individuals with disorganized lipid profiles, that is, elevations
in LDL and total cholesterol or triglycerides. Human clinical trials showed
gugulipid dropped total cholesterol levels by 14-27% in a 4- to 12-week
period and reduced triglycerides 22-30%. HDL cholesterol increased in
60% of cases considered gugulipid-responsive. In addition, gugulipid regressed
plaque formation, opposed platelet aggregation, and encouraged fibrinolysis.
Gugulipid is regarded as nontoxic, with liver and kidney function, blood
sugar control, and hematological parameters unaffected during clinical
trials (Agarwal et al. 1986; Nityanand et al. 1989; Murray 1995c).
Comparing gugulipid to clofibrate, hypercholesterolemic patients appeared
more responsive to gugulipid therapy, while patients with hypertriglyceridemia
responded better to clofibrate (Nityanand et al. 1989). A suggested dosage
is 500 mg (5% guggulsterone content) 3 times a day.
Hawthorn Berry (Crataegus oxyacantha)—normalizes
blood pressure; is beneficial to dieters and those with congestive heart
failure; prevents premature ventricular contractions and hypoxia; has
diuretic and antioxidant potential; lowers cholesterol; acts as a vasodilator;
is an ACE inhibitor, beta-blocker, and anti-inflammatory; increases exercise
tolerance; and reduces the incidence of tachycardia and palpitations
Dr. James Duke, botanist, says that when hawthorn is evaluated chemically,
it appears that the herb covers most of the cardiovascular bases. For
example, it contains a calcium-antagonist (magnesium), ACE inhibitors
(procyanidins), and beta-blockers (catechin, epicatechin, and procyanidins),
plus numerous diuretics, cholesterol-lowering compounds, anti-inflammatories,
and antioxidants (Duke 2000b).
The hawthorn berry is considered a smart herb with adaptogenic qualities
in regard to normalizing blood pressure. Hawthorn gains much of its hypotensive
and weight management properties through its diuretic action. Also, its
ACE inhibiting factors interrupt the renin-angiotensin sequence, resulting
in lower blood pressure and improved cardiac output (Duke 2000b). Clinicians
compare the effectiveness of hawthorn to Captopril, a drug prescribed
for congestive heart failure (CHF) and hypertension that also works by
inhibiting ACE. (Hawthorn, although helpful in blood pressure management,
should not be regarded as the sole therapeutic for hypertension.)
The bioflavonoid content of hawthorn appears to be responsible for much
of the herb's cardiac potential, that is, dilating blood vessels, enhancing
vitamin C absorption, and protecting against vascular breaks or leaks.
Bioflavonoids are powerful antioxidants that not only protect against
free-radical damage, but also increase oxygen delivery and blood flow
to the heart. This reduces the effort and stress imposed upon the heart
to circulate blood, and as an additional bonus, a reduction in blood pressure
usually occurs. The risk of stroke was, in fact, 73% lower among individuals
who consumed greater amounts of flavonoid-rich foods compared to individuals
who consumed less (Keli et al. 1996; Roanoke Times 1996).
During the Middle Ages, hawthorn was used to treat dropsy, a condition
now recognized as CHF. Today, European physicians still use hawthorn to
treat early signs of CHF, relying upon the herb to strengthen the heart
and the power of cardiac contractions. Drugs that have the ability to
power up the heart can cause cardiac irregularities; conversely, it appears
hawthorn can energize the heart without prompting arrhythmias. Hawthorn,
in fact, has a normalizing effect upon the heartbeat, lessening the incidence
of tachycardia (a heart rate greater than 100 beats per minute) and palpitations
(Santillo 1990).
Studies confirm the multiplicity of hawthorn's actions:
- Various clinicians report an excellent patient response, treating
valvular insufficiency, heart fibrillations, and hypoxia with hawthorn
(Santillo 1990; Ritchason 1995; Duke 1997).
- Hawthorn appears to stabilize heart rhythm and increase exercise
tolerance (Duke 1997). Problem-free exercise occurs as the heart becomes
stronger and less taxed by exertion.
- Hawthorn reduces cholesterol levels and the size of existing atherosclerotic
plaque (Wegrowski 1984).
Hawthorn is best used long-term because the active constituents do not
produce rapid results. It may take 4-8 weeks for improvement in subjective
complaints and increased exercise tolerance. Although it is regarded as
gentle and safe for chronic usage, a physician should evaluate the patient's
drug list before adding hawthorn to the total package. A dosage suggestion
is 250-900 mg daily.
Homocysteine-Lowering Nutrients
and Elimination Pathways
Homocysteine, a naturally occurring amino acid, is derived from methionine
and produced in small amounts by the body. When homocysteine is not detoxified
or reduced through metabolic processes (i.e., remethylation or trans -sulfuration)
and begins to accumulate, various biological failures occur. According
to some experts, homocysteine is now recognized as the single greatest
biochemical risk factor for heart disease (McCully 1996) (for an introduction
to homocysteine, consult Newer Risk Factors appearing earlier in this
protocol).
The published literature emphasizes that folic acid, vitamin B12, and
zinc (nutrient cofactors) and trimethylglycine (a methyl donor) are critical
to the remethylation of homocysteine, the most common detoxification pathway.
Remethylation occurs as methyl groups are donated to homocysteine to transform
it to methionine and S-adenosylmethionine (SAMe) (Porter et al. 1993;
Undas et al. 1993; Malinow et al. 1998; Baker-Racine 2002).
SAMe, the chief methyl donor, is crucial to the methylation process.
Initially, methionine reacts with ATP to produce SAMe. SAMe is then used
for methylation and a byproduct of this reaction, homocysteine, is recycled
back to methionine. This cyclic dance continues faultlessly, unless something
throws it out of sync.
Too much methionine will disrupt the delicate balance. Flesh foods and
dairy products are rich in methionine and require greater amounts of nutrient
cofactors to preserve the methylation process. Chronic inflammation, high
intensity exercise, and age can also put the brakes on methylation. When
this occurs, the cycle is broken, and homocysteine detoxification stagnates.
The problem comes full circle, as excessive amounts of homocysteine interfere
with the methylation process.
Trimethylglycine (TMG), also called betaine, emerges as one of the most
important nutrients to prevent and reverse existing heart disease, in
part by supporting remethylation (Baker-Racine 2002). TMG usually causes
a substantial lowering of homocysteine, but regular dosing must continue
to sustain the improvement. The dosage varies from one to eight 500-mg
tablets a day, depending upon the amount needed to maintain healthy levels
(below 7 micromol e/L of blood).
Choline, another methyl donor, can act independently (not requiring
cofactors) to lower homocysteine levels, but it only influences remethylation
in the liver and kidneys through conversion into TMG,, leaving the heart
and brain less protected. Methylating factors, as vitamin B12 and folic
acid, add additional protection.
The second means of homocysteine disposal is via the trans -sulfuration
pathway, a sequence dependent upon vitamin B6. This pathway converts homocysteine
to the powerful antioxidants cysteine and glutathione, but a deficiency
of the B6-dependent enzyme, cystathione-B-synthase, can hamper this process.
An alternative is to take larger doses of vitamin B6, but this course
is not without risk. Chronic megadose vitamin B6 supplementation (300-500
mg daily) can result in neurological symptoms that typically fade when
the dosage is reduced or discontinued. Careful monitoring to determine
the lowest vitamin B6 dose capable of controlling homocysteine levels
is essential.
Some individuals lack the enzyme necessary to convert vitamin B6 to
its active form (Robinson et al. 1995). In this case, use the biologically
active pyridoxal-5-phosphate to control elevations in homocysteine. Note:
Vitamin B6 is also a reliable diuretic, making it of particular advantage
to patients with high blood pressure and congestive heart failure.
For most individuals, hyperhomocysteinemia is a modifiable cardiovascular
risk factor. In fact, about one-half of individuals with hyperhomocysteinemia
respond favorably to vitamin B6 supplementation. Researchers selected
421 patients, mildly hyperhomo-cysteinemic, to determine their response
to vitamin B6 (250 mg daily). After 6 weeks of vitamin B6 supplementation,
56% of the patients had normal homocysteine levels. Non-normalized homocysteine
concentrations were treated with a combination of supplements, vitamin
B6 (250 mg daily) and/or folic acid (5 mg daily) and/or TMG (6 grams daily).
The more aggressive treatment normalized homocysteine levels in 95% of
the remaining cases (Franken et al. 1994).
Another 20% of hyperhomocysteinemic patients have a mutation in the
gene, methylenetetrahydrofolate reductase, disrupting the conversion of
folic acid to 5-methyltetrahydrofolate, an active contributor in the methyl
donation pathway of folate. In this incidence, it is necessary to use
5-methyltetrahydrofolate supplementation to bypass the metabolic block
(James et al. 1999; Bland 2000a) (additional information regarding methylenetetrahydrofolate
reductase appears in the section devoted to Heredity, one of the traditional
risk factors, in this protocol).
A Polish study showed that administering folic acid (5 mg a day), vitamin
B6 (300 mg a day), and B12 (1000 microgram a day) over an 8-week period
reduced benchmark homocysteine levels by one-half (from 20 micromol/L
to 10 micromol/L) and also reduced thrombin, an intermediate in the production
of fibrinogen (Undas et al. 1999). Individuals with low folate status,
regardless of age or sex, have a 69% greater risk of fatal heart disease
compared to individuals with higher levels (greater than 13.6 nanomol/L)
(Morrison 1996; Pirisi 2001; Tice et al. 2001). It is theorized that properly
administered folate might prevent as many as 13,500-50,000 premature deaths
annually (Boushey et al. 1995).
The New England Journal of Medicine reported that a combination of folic
acid, vitamin B12, and pyridoxine reduced homocysteine levels and also
the necessity for revascularization procedures. (Revascularization refers
to restoring adequate blood supply by means of a coronary bypass or angioplasty.)
Researchers concluded that this inexpensive nutritional therapy, with
minimal side effects, should be considered as adjunctive therapy for all
patients undergoing coronary angioplasty (Schnyder et al. 2001).
The American Journal of Clinical Nutrition reported that a chemical
component of coffee and black tea (chlorogenic acid) could raise plasma
homocysteine levels (Olthof et al. 2001). Another team of researchers
targeted unfiltered coffee as being most contributory to hyperhomocysteinemia
(Grubben et al. 2000). On the other hand, a diet rich in fruits and vegetables
may decrease the risk of heart disease (7-9%) by reducing blood levels
of homocysteine. Fresh and unaltered foods have a more reliable nutrient
bank and are capable of delivering more homocysteine-lowering vitamins
and minerals.
It should be noted that niacin may increase plasma homocysteine levels
(from 1-4 micromol/L) in some people (Desouza et al. 2002; Berkeley Heart
Lab, http://www.berkeleyheartlab.com/HCP/hcp_frequentlyaskedquestions_4.shtml).
Researchers at Pantox Laboratories ( California ) explain that niacin
appears to interfere with homocysteine clearance by depleting SAMe. Concurrent
TMG supplementation may represent a cost-effective way to prevent niacin-mediated
depletion of SAMe and thus avoid hepatotoxicity and possibly other adverse
niacin side effects (McCarty 2000).
Administering homocysteine-lowering nutrients is so individualized that
testing is essential to determine adequate dosages. To assume that homocysteine
is not a threat (because you have the B vitamins in your supplemental
protocol) is not a guarantee that the dosage is appropriate to render
protection. The following daily supplements (used alone or in combination)
have demonstrated homocysteine-lowering effectiveness: 500-9000 mg of
TMG, 800-5000 mcg of folic acid, 1000-3000 mcg of vitamin B12, 250-3000
mg of choline, 250-1000 mg of inositol, 30-90 mg of zinc, 100-500 mg of
vitamin B6, and 200-800 mg of SAMe. SAMe is of value in lowering homocysteine
levels only if folic acid and vitamins B6 and B12 are also present; without
nutrient cofactors, SAMe will eventually break down into homocysteine.
Note: Extremely important data were published showing that pretreatment
with 800 IU of vitamin E and 1000 mg of C (before an oral methionine load
to experimentally produce homocysteine) blocked the damaging effects of
hyperhomocysteinemia. Coagulation and circulating adhesion molecule levels
significantly increased after methionine ingestion alone but not after
methionine ingestion with vitamins (Nappo et al. 1999).
Reader's guide to food sources,
enhancers, and antagonists to homocysteine-lowering B vitamins
Medications to treat congestive heart failure commonly result in multiple
B vitamin deficiencies, disrupting disposal systems for homocysteine clearance
(Sinatra 2001). Also, B vitamins are considered unstable when exposed
to the heating process, but the following foods represent the most nutrient-dense
choices:
Vitamin B6 appears in most foodstuffs, but the best sources are brewer's
yeast, carrots, chicken, eggs, fish, meat, peas, spinach, sunflower seeds,
walnuts, and wheat germ.
Complimentary nutrients in regard to vitamin B6 absorption are the full
B complex, vitamin C, magnesium, potassium, and zinc. Antidepressants,
alcohol, coffee, exercise (to excess), estrogen therapy, and oral contraceptives
appear to either increase the need for vitamin B6 or reduce its status.
Diuretics and cortisone drugs block its absorption, and theophylline,
an oral bronchodilator, antagonizes pyridoxal phosphate synthesis (Ubbink
et al. 1996).
Vitamin B12, the most complex of the B vitamins, should be of special
interest to vegans who, after chronic abstinence from animal products,
can become seriously depleted in this nutrient. However, most vitamin
B12 deficiencies occur not because of inadequate dietary consumption,
but rather because of poor absorption. The intrinsic factor, a substance
secreted by the gastric mucosa, is essential for the absorption of B12,
transporting cyan o acobalamin (vitamin B12) across the membranes of the
ileum (the distal end of the small intestine).
Animal derivatives, eggs, fish and marine life, beef and pork, and milk
and dairy products are good sources of vitamin B12. Nutrients considered
B12 enhancers are others of the B complex (especially folic acid and vitamin
B6), vitamin C, iron, potassium, sodium, and calcium.
Medications to treat gout, anticoagulant drugs, and potassium supplements
may block the absorption of vitamin B12 from the digestive tract (Balch
et al. 1997). For optimal B12 utilization, avoid coffee, alcohol, smoking,
and laxatives.
Folate-rich foods are liver, wheat germ, legumes, green leafy vegetables,
beets, citrus fruits, most fish, pork, and whole grains. Fortification
of enriched grain products with folic acid is associated with a substantial
improvement in folate status in middle aged and older adults (Jacques
et al. 1999).
Folic acid is most efficient when combined with vitamin B12, biotin,
pantothenic acid, and vitamin C. According to the Committee on Dietary
Allowances, heat and oxidation (occurring during cooking and storage)
can destroy as much as half of the folate in foods. Sulfa drugs interfere
with the bacteria in the intestines that manufacture folic acid, and Streptomycin
totally destroys it. Methotrexate depletes folate, causing a transient
elevation in homocysteine, and phenytoin (an antiepileptic drug) interferes
with folate metabolism. Lastly, oral contraceptives, alcohol, coffee,
and smoking are also considered folic acid antagonists.
Magnesium—reduces blood pressure,
is a calcium antagonist, tempers the sympathetic nervous system, is beneficial
in arrhythmias and mitral valve prolapse, increases the number and sensitivity
of insulin receptors, has antidiabetic properties, encourages the methylation
process, prevents toxic buildup of homocysteine, reduces calcium levels,
is a vasodilator, and opposes platelet aggregation
Magnesium, a potent vasodilator, may prove to be a better hypotensive
in some individuals than calcium (50% of magnesium-depleted patients are
hypertensive, a condition often remediable with supplementation).
The British Medical Journal reported that magnesium supplementation
lowered blood pressure by a mean of 12/8 mmHg (systolic and diastolic
pressures) in 19 of 20 subjects (Dyckner et al. 1983). Magnesium reduces
blood vessel contractibility by regulating levels of bradykinin, angiotensin
II, prostaglandins, serotonin, epinephrine, norepinephrine, and dopamine;
as a result, vessels vasodilate and blood pressure decreases.
Besides being a hypotensive mineral, magnesium is absolutely essential
to proper cardiac function, allowing relaxation of the heart and supporting
normal heart rhythms. In a study of patients admitted to coronary care
units experiencing arrhythmias, 100% had complete resolution when administered
IV magnesium over a 5-hour period. Dr. Bart Chernow (a surgeon at Sinai
Hospital in Baltimore , MD ) reports that magnesium injections following
bypass surgery reduced heart rhythm irregularities 50%, without side effects
(Alternative Medical News staff). After 3 months of oral magnesium supplementation,
platelet-dependent thrombosis typically is reduced 35% in 75% of patients.
In a study in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition, researchers
from the U.S. Department of Agriculture reported the effects of a magnesium-deficient
diet on 22 healthy postmenopausal women ages 47-78. The women all ate
the same meals for 6 months as they lived together under close supervision,
taking in about 130 mg of dietary magnesium each day. Half the women also
took an additional 280 mg of magnesium in supplemental form for 81 days
while the other half received a placebo; during the second half of the
study period, the groups crossed over to the other treatment category.
The researchers assessed magnesium levels in urine and blood regularly,
as well as heartbeat patterns through electrocardiograms. Not surprisingly,
serum and urine concentrations of magnesium were lower on the controlled
diet, but heart rhythms were also significantly affected by lesser amounts
of magnesium. A lack of magnesium provoked the heart into rhythmic abnormalities,
as well as more frequent heartbeats. The researchers concluded that the
cardiac muscle is more sensitive to magnesium intake than skeletal muscle
and that a deficiency has the potential to cause dangerous cardiac irregularities
(Klevay et al. 2002).
Calcium channel blockers are popular as anti -arrhythmics and antispasmodics
(to read more about calcium channel blockers, consult the sections devoted
to Beta-Blockers and Calcium Channel Blockers appearing in this protocol).
By relaxing arterial smooth muscles and reducing stress on the myocardium
(the thick middle layer of the heart), magnesium delivers many of the
effects of a calcium channel blocker (Whitaker 1995b).
Magnesium turns off activity in the sympathetic nervous system. By blocking
the release of excitatory hormones (epinephrine and norepinephrine), the
"fight or flight" response of the sympathetic nervous system
is inhibited (Gonzalez 2000). Although the therapeutic profile of magnesium
is similar to a beta-blocker, the drug should not be abruptly stopped
and magnesium commenced; without a gradual withdrawal of the drug, a rebound
could occur, provoking a heart attack.
In mitral valve prolapse, the valve separating the left atrium from
the left ventricle protrudes into the left atrium. Of patients participating
in an evaluation, 85% were found to have low magnesium levels, suggesting
that a deficiency plays a role in the disturbance (Simoes-Fernandes et
al. 1985; Galland et al. 1986; Murray 1996). Numerous studies indicate
that magnesium lessens mitral valve prolapse symptoms, palpitations, fatigue,
breathing difficulties, and nonanginal chest pains. Others have observed
improvement in exercise tolerance and reduced stress within the heart
itself (Shechter et al. 2000). Comment: Low magnesium levels also are
associated with angina attacks in men. It appears that as magnesium status
drops, the frequency of angina attacks increases (Satake et al. 1996).
Too much calcium in the bloodstream may be a forerunner to aortic stenosis
(Bonow et al. 1998). Magnesium hinders the absorption of calcium; therefore
supplementing with at least 500 mg a day could inhibit the excesses of
calcium hardening the cusps of valves (for a comprehensive look at aortic
stenosis, consult the section of this protocol dedicated to Valvular Disease).
Magnesium plays an important role in the prevention and treatment of
Syndrome X and diabetes. It benefits these conditions by increasing the
number and sensitivity of insulin receptors (Waterfall 2000).
In addition, increased homocysteine concentrations cause abnormal metabolism
of magnesium in vascular smooth muscles cells, priming these cells for
homocysteine-induced atherogenesis, cerebral vaso-spasm, and stroke. Researchers
from State University of New York propose that vitamin B6, vitamin B12,
and folic acid, together with physiological levels of magnesium, are needed
to prevent magnesium depletion and occlusive cerebral vascular diseases
induced by homocysteinemia (Li et al. 1999).
Magnesium status is integral in various drug therapies. Recent controlled
studies have shown that treatment with magnesium significantly reduced
the frequency and complexity of ventricular arrhythmias in digoxin-treated
patients with congestive heart failure. In fact, magnesium improved the
efficacy of digoxin (digitalis) in slowing the ventricular response in
atrial fibrillation. The complex and potentially life-threatening interactions
between magnesium and some cardiovascular drugs suggest that magnesium
status should be carefully monitored in patients receiving cardiac pharmaceuticals
(Crippa et al. 1999).
Unfortunately, the test used by the majority of physicians to measure
magnesium levels is worse than useless, according to Dr. Sherry A. Rogers,
an environmental medicine specialist. Dr. Rogers refers to this test as
"the most dangerous test in medicine" for if it is used, it
too often shows misleading normal levels. The assumption that adequate
amounts of magnesium exist when, in fact, deficiency states exist may
be a fatal mistake. A study in the Journal of the American Medical Association
reported that about 90% of practicing physicians never think to check
magnesium levels, even in patients who are severely depleted (Whang et
al. 1990). Note: Magnesium deficiency is better detected by measuring
mono-nuclear blood cell magnesium, as opposed to serum levels.
A dosage suggestion is 500-1500 mg daily of magnesium bound to succinate,
citrate, or aspartate. Magnesium oxide, in larger doses, can cause loose
stool.
Reader's guide to magnesium-rich
foods, enhancers, and antagonists
Magnesium is found in most foods, particularly nuts, whole grains, legumes,
brown rice, dark green vegetables, and fish (Balch et al. 1997).
Magnesium enhancers include the B-complex (especially vitamin B6), vitamin
C, calcium, essential fatty acids, and essential amino acids. The body's
requirement for magnesium increases if using alcohol, taking higher amounts
of vitamin D, or if exposed to fluoride, tobacco, or unrelenting stress.
Cod liver oil, calcium (excessive intake), and iron decrease magnesium
absorption. Diuretics and chronic diarrhea can seriously deplete many
minerals, including magnesium.
Niacin (Vitamin B3)—lowers
Lp(a), reduces fibrinogen, normalizes blood lipids, and acts as a vasodilator
Nicotinic acid and nicotinamide are types of the vitamin niacin; although
related, they are different in their therapeutic delivery. Nicotinamide,
often marketed as a superior lipid-lowering version of niacin, actually
has little effect in lowering blood lipids (Segrest 2000). It is nicotinic
acid that modulates most all lipid parameters, lowering total cholesterol,
LDL, VLDL, Lp(a), and triglyceride levels, while increasing HDL cholesterol.
Nicotinic acid has, in fact, won favor with the FDA, adding it to a list
of other remedials capable of lowering triglycerides.
Because of niacin's broad-spectrum effectiveness against hyperlipidemia,
niacin can act independently or in concert with other drugs. Dr. B. Greg
Brown (of the University of Washington , Seattle ) reported to the American
Heart Association that a combination of a statin drug (which lowers LDL
cholesterol) and niacin (which raises HDL cholesterol) brought the progression
of atherosclerotic disease to a standstill. According to Brown, a niacin-simvastatin
combination resulted in a 70% reduction in heart attacks, strokes, and
other disease-related events. According to Brown, "This represents
twice the reduction seen with statins alone." Simvastatin (Zocor)
plus niacin increased HDL levels 30% over baseline, while Zocor alone
increased HDL only 7-10% (Kerr 2000). In addition, nicotinic acid can
act independently, accomplishing what no drug can currently do: lower
Lp(a); 1500 mg a day of niacin reduced Lp(a) an average of 20%; 3000 mg
a day reduced Lp(a) an average of 26% (Berkeley Heart Lab).
Niacin has properties that are the opposite of those of nicotine. Nicotine,
a toxic substance in tobacco, is a vasoconstrictor; niacin is a vasodilator.
Niacin's vasodilating quality makes it beneficial in the treatment of
hypertension and various forms of heart disease.
In 1991 a group of scientists found that small amounts of niacin in
combination with chromium, lowered cholesterol levels by an average of
14% and improved the total cholesterol-HDL ratio 7% (Urberg et al. 1987;
Cichoke 2001). This finding is valuable since niacin has some significant
side effects, making it less justifiable in large doses. Articles appearing
in the American Journal of Cardiology and the Journal of Cardiovascular
Risk confirmed niacin's hypolipidemic value and also reported that low-dose
niacin was effective in reducing plasma fibrinogen levels in subjects
with peripheral vascular disease (Philipp et al. 1998; Ma et al. 1999).
If used independently, 1-3 grams of niacin is sometimes required to
lower cholesterol levels, a dosage that can cause side effects ranging
from nuisance complaints to significant endangerments. Allergic-like reactions,
such as itching and flushing, are common, but niacin can also disrupt
liver function, causing elevations of liver enzymes.
Other risks associated with niacin:
- Individuals dosing with niacin may experience a rise in uric acid,
an increase that can bring on a gout attack (Goldberg 1998). Recall
that individuals with Syndrome X often present with higher levels of
uric acid.
- Niacin may interfere with folate and homocysteine metabolism and
actually increase plasma homocysteine levels (Desouza et al. 2002).
Dr. David Blankenhorn was the first to discover the niacin-homocysteine
connection at USC in the CLAS study. Niaspan, an extended-release niacin,
raised homocysteine levels in some, but not all people; the amount is
generally between 1-4 micromol/L and appears to be dose-dependent (Berkeley
Heart Lab).
- Niacin may deplete SAMe, a pivotal player in methylation. If niacin
does decrease SAMe, a likely consequence would be an elevation of plasma
homocysteine (McCarty 2000). Note: Concurrent TMG supplementation may
represent a cost-effective way to prevent niacin-mediated depletion
of SAMe and thus avoid hepatotoxicity (and possibly other adverse niacin
side effects). The lack of sufficient detoxification (due to SAMe depletion)
appears to explain many of the adverse effects associated with niacin
dosing.
- Niacin can also increase blood glucose levels. In nondiabetic patients,
1500 mg a day of Niaspan (an extended-release niacin) increased fasting
blood glucose levels 2.5-11% following a 2-hour glucose load. Using
3000 mg a day of immediate-release niacin, fasting blood glucose increased
4.1% and 11.6% following a 2-hour glucose load. The niacin effect in
Type II diabetic patients is currently under investigation (Berkeley
Heart Lab). However, it is speculated that individuals predisposed to
Type II diabetes may have a poorer response to niacin (in regard to
glucose management) compared to individuals without a diabetic inclination.
Considering these negatives, large-dose niacin may be too great a price
to pay for the benefits. If a decision is made to use high-dose niacin,
some practitioners report that an aspirin taken 30 minutes before the
dose markedly reduces some of the lesser side effects, for example, the
allergic-like symptoms.
Reader's guide to vitamin B3 sources,
enhancers, and antagonists.
Good sources of niacin are lean meats, whole grains, brewer's yeast, peanuts,
eggs, poultry, fish, and green, leafy vegetables. Milk; some cheeses,
for example, cheddar cheese; bananas; and turkey are good sources of tryptophan
(a precursor to niacin) (Braly 1985).
Vitamin B3 enhancers (in regard to absorption) are the B-complex (especially
vitamins B1, B2, and B6), vitamin C, magnesium, zinc, protein, and essential
fatty acids. Antagonists to niacin absorption are alcohol, coffee, excess
sugar, antibiotics, and steroids.
Olive Leaf Extract—according
to botanist James Duke, the cardiac properties found in olive leaf extract
include antioxidants, anti -aggregates, anti-arrhythmics, anti-inflammatories,
cyclooxygenase inhibitors, diuretics, hypotensives, vasodilators, antispasmo
d tics, antidiabetics, platelet activating factor inhibitors, weight modulators,
antiperiodontics, antihyperlipidemics, and plaque fighters
Olive leaf extract (Olea europaea), although historically regarded as
a medicinal for fever and malaria, is also valuable in the treatment of
cardiovascular disease. Olive leaf extract has been shown in both laboratory
and clinical settings to have antidiabetic, hypotensive, and vasodilating
properties (Petkov et al. 1972; Gonzalez et al. 1992; Fehri et al. 1994).
Researchers documented that an aqueous extract of olive leaves inhibits
ACE, the enzyme that converts angiotensin I to angiotensin II (Duke 1992).
The vasoconstricting nature of angiotensin II terminates in an increase
in blood pressure, a sequence that olive leaf extract disrupts.
According to Dr. Duke, chemicals contained in O. europaea are regarded
as calcium antagonists, diuretics, and anti-inflammatories. In addition,
olive leaf protects LDL cholesterol against oxidation and inhibits the
production of thromboxane A2 and platelet-activating factor (PAF). These
functions discourage vasoconstriction and platelet clumping (Duke 1992;
Petroni et al. 1995; Mindell 1998).
Chelation therapy, in conjunction with an aggressive supplemental program
that relied heavily upon olive leaf extract, has proved remedial among
select senior subjects who have suffered multiple heart attacks and arrhythmias.
A suggested dosage is one to two 500-mg olive leaf extract capsules, administered
3 times daily with meals.
Pantethine—reduces cholesterol,
discourages platelet clumping, and has antioxidant activity
Pantethine, a biologically active, intermediate form of pantothenic acid
(vitamin B5) and a precursor to coenzyme A, is a powerful natural pharmaceutical
that reduces cholesterol, increases heart muscle contractility, slows
the heart rate, and has antioxidant activity.
Pantethine (300 mg 3 times daily) reduced serum triglycerides 32%, total
cholesterol 19%, and LDL cholesterol 21%; HDL cholesterol levels increased
23% (Arsenio et al. 1986, Murray 1996b). Pantethine further reduces cardiovascular
risk by inhibiting platelet clumping and the production of the inflammation-producing
chemical, thromboxane A2 (CVR, http://www.thewayup.com/products/0012.htm).
A dosage suggestion is 300 mg 3 times a day.
Policosanol—is a hypocholesterolemic,
protects LDL cholesterol against oxidation, inhibits thromboxane and the
proliferation of vascular cells, discourages blood clot formation, inhibits
platelet aggregation, and increases exercise tolerance
Policosanol, derived from sugar cane, is a new face on the cholesterol
scene in the United States but is a popular hypocholesterolemic in other
countries (Mas et al. 1999). The main ingredient in sugar cane is octacos
anol, a long-chain fatty alcohol found in the waxy film that covers the
leaves and fruit of plants.
Policosanol represents an effective alternative to lowering cholesterol
for many people. For example, 10 mg a day of policosanol (over a 6- to
12-week period) lowered LDL cholesterol 20%, reduced total cholesterol
15%, and raised the beneficial HDL cholesterol 7-28%. Doubling the dose
(20 mg a day) resulted in the following lipid improvements: LDL cholesterol
reduced about 28%, total cholesterol about 20%, and HDL increased by 7-10%.
Triglycerides were unaffected. During the course of the trial, participants
continued on a low cholesterol diet.
The hypolipidemic effects of policosanol are comparable to many cholesterol-lowering
drugs (Prat et al. 1999). The results of a head-to-head study classing
popular hypocholester olemic drugs against policosanol follow in Figure
6.
Policosanol also outclassed the drugs in regard to increasing levels
of the beneficial HDL cholesterol. Yet, a combination of policosanol and
gemfibrozil (Lopid) was more hypocholesterolemic than either used singularly.
In fact, policosanol even upgraded the efficiency of bezafibrate, a once
touted fibrinogen-lowering drug that yielded disappointing results in
the Bezafibrate Infarction Prevention Study (Castano et al. 1998; Behar
1999). Bezafibrate in union with policosanol dramatically reduced LDL
and total cholesterol. In addition, policosanol appears to replicate another
of the objectives of statin drugs, reducing the proliferation of cells.
A telltale sign of a diseased vessel is that the smooth lining of the
vessel becomes thickened and overgrown with cells.
When comparing the value of a drug to a natural alternative, the safety
factors must be considered. Usually, the ramifications of a nutrient,
in contrast to a drug, are not side effects but side benefits. For example,
the oxidation of LDL cholesterol (a particularly destructive form of cholesterol
that creates chronic inflammation) is inhibited by policosanol. As less
inflammation and blood vessel destruction occur, fewer foam cells appear
(Noa et al. 1996). Conversely, if the oxidation of LDL is not inhibited,
metalloproteinase enzymes are aroused, further damaging the vasculature
by interfering with the protective nature of HDL cholesterol.
Policosanol combines well with aspirin to inhibit the formation of clots,
with each influencing the activity of different platelets (Arruzazabala
et al. 1997; Carbajal et al. 1998). The synergistic approach provides
more comprehensive protection against platelet aggregation. Another factor
in blood clot formation, thromboxane, is repressed after a couple of weeks
of policosanol therapy.
Policosanol users can expect an improvement in exercise tolerance. When
patients with heart disease were given 10 mg a day of policosanol, exercise
capacity and oxygen uptake increased, but ischemia decreased. The improvement
in treadmill-ECG tests confirmed that policosanol benefits heart patients,
but healthy, physically active individuals also reported increases in
exercise tolerance and strength (Stusser et al. 1998). Policosanol not
only improved cardiovascular capacity, but also protected against atherosclerotic
lesions (thickened fatty streaks in the vasculature).
Policosanol does not appear to interfere with other heart medications.
However, it may potentiate the effects of propranolol, a beta-blocker
used to treat hypertension. The 10-mg dose has had more than 2 years of
clinical testing with no significant ill effects noted, except some patients
reported an unexpected weight loss. Blood tests (after about 2 months
of policosanol therapy) will allow the individual to adjust the dose commensurate
with need. Some individuals will need only 5-10 mg of policosanol to maintain
healthy cholesterol levels; others will require 20 mg a day. Note:
Policosanol has undergone as many clinical
trials as most drugs.
Polyenylphosphatidylcholine (PPC)—is
a hypolipidemic, improves exercise tolerance and apoB/apoA-1 ratio, lessens
angina attacks, and increases levels of HDL2b
Phosphatidylcholine, the main component of lecithin (a soy product), has
a long history as a preventive in arteriosclerosis, cardiovascular disease,
and brain derangements. PPC, a newer, polyunsaturated soy derivative,
has shown extraordinary promise in managing hypercholesterolemia. It appears
that PPC delivers its value by traversing into cholesterol, where direct
modulation of the substance occurs. In a study involving 100 participants,
PPC lowered total LDL cholesterol by about 15%, reduced triglycerides
32%, and raised HDL levels by about 10% (Klimov et al. 1995; Jordon 2000).
| Comparison of Policosanol
to Classic Drug Therapy |
| CHOLESTEROL-LOWERING AGENT |
DOSAGE |
LIPOPROTEIN EVALUATED |
AMOUNT REDUCED |
| Lovastatin (Mevacor) |
20 mg |
LDL Cholesterol |
22% |
| Simvastatin (Zocor) |
10 mg |
LDL Cholesterol |
15% |
| Policosanol |
10 mg |
LDL Cholesterol |
24% |
PPC significantly increased apolipoprotein A-1 and only slightly increased
apolipoprotein B, while decreasing postprandial triglycerides, VLDL, and
IDL (Klimov et al. 1995; Zeman et al. 1995). A apoB is a cholesterol particle
that is believed to promote heart disease by affecting how cholesterol
is transported in arteries and other tissues. It is found not only in
LDL cholesterol, but also in VLDL and IDL, other potentially bad cholesterols.
On the other hand, apoA-1 is a protective, anti -atherogenic particle
found in the highly beneficial HDL cholesterol. Researchers concluded
that PPC appeared to be an appropriate supplement for patients with decreased
concentrations of HDL cholesterol and plasma apoA-1.
The Lancet recently reported the results of a 5 1/2-year trial (the
AMORIS, Apoliprotein-Related Mortality Risk Study) evaluating the cardiovascular
health of 175,553 men and women. Although all conventional markers were
assessed (triglycerides, total cholesterol, and LDL-HDL cholesterol ratio),
persons with the greatest absolute risk of dying from a heart attack tended
to have the highest ratios of apoB to apoA-1 (Srinivasan et al. 2001;
Walldius et al. 2001; GSDL 2001).
Over the course of the study, 864 men and 359 women died from acute
myocardial infarctions. When researchers compared their blood results,
the apoB : -apoA-1 ratio was the strongest predictor of fatal heart attacks.
Men with the highest apoB and lowest apoA-1 levels were nearly 4 times
as likely to experience a deadly heart attack compared to those with a
favorable apo ratio. (In women the relative risk was threefold greater.)
apoB proved to be a stronger predictor of risk than LDL cholesterol in
both sexes.
The study also showed that the apo ratio remained a strong marker in
all age groups, including those patients over age 70, a group in which
total cholesterol levels are not considered to be accurate risk indicators
for heart attack. Assessing apoB : -apoA-1 ratio appears to identify high-risk
individuals who have normal-to-low LDL cholesterol, as well as those with
diabetes and insulin resistance. Recall that PPC's credits include increasing
the desirable apoA-1.
PPC has a positive effect upon HDL levels, particularly the most protective
of the HDL family, HDL2b. Individuals attaining longevity often display
HDL differentials favoring HDL2b, suggesting that this subfraction renders,
among other health benefits, greater cardio -protection. Another of the
restorative capacities of PPC is its ability to increase exercise tolerance
(Klimov et al. 1995).
Alcohol in moderation appears to prevent atherosclerosis. Heavy drinking
has the opposite effect, in part by promoting oxidation of LDL cholesterol.
Administering PPC at 2.8 grams/1000 kcal to baboons made alcoholic for
experimentation lessened the expected ethanol-induced increase in LDL
oxidation (Navder et al. 1999).
Russian researchers compare PPC to niacin in the treatment of angina
and hyperlipidemia. While nicotinic acid is a reliable hypocholesterolemic,
the clusters of annoying symptoms (flushing and itching) and less benign
side effects (liver disruption and GI disturbance) discredit megadose
usage in some individuals. Conversely, PPC therapy has no contraindications,
side effects, or drug interactions. A suggested dosage is two 900-mg capsules
daily.
Potassium—reduces blood
pressure, maintains fluid balance, encourages parasympathetic nervous
system, and increases insulin sensitivity
Potassium, considered by some to be the major electrolyte, is found almost
exclusively in the intracellular fluids of the cell. Sodium is found in
the extracellular fluid, but it is equilibrium between potassium and sodium
that determines fluid balance and blood pressure regulation. A high potassium-low
sodium intake reduces the blood vessel constricting effects of adrenaline,
a hormone associated with sympathetic nervous system arousal; the result
is lower blood pressure.
Adults (37 in number) with diastolic blood pressure less than 110 mmHg
participated in a crossover trial of 32 weeks ' duration to determine
the hypotensive nature of minerals. Sixty mmol/day of potassium (about
2.5 grams) reduced systolic pressure by an average of 12 mmHg and decreased
diastolic pressure 16 mmHg (Patki et al. 1990; Murray 1996). Comment:
Results of the DASH study illustrate the necessity for providing adequate
amounts of potassium, magnesium, and calcium to control blood pressure.
To read more about the study, please turn to the subsection entitled,
Does Sodium Restriction Lower Blood Pressure? in this protocol (Bland
2000b).
Hypertensive individuals over 65 years of age may find particular value
in potassium, since medications are not always as effective among senior
subjects. Administering 2.5 grams a day of potassium for 4 weeks to 18
untreated elderly hypertensive patients resulted in a systolic drop of
12 mmHg and a diastolic reduction of 7 mmHG. All entered the study with
systolic blood pressure greater than 160 mmHg and diastolic pressure greater
than 95 mmHg (Fotherby 1992; Murray 1996). The results were impressive
considering the brevity of the study and the fact that potassium's value
is cumulative, meaning a greater response is generally seen with longer
supplementation.
Researchers at the Johns Hopkins University School of Medicine advocate
increasing potassium to treat and prevent hypertension. A group of seven
medical researchers reviewed 33 randomized, controlled trials involving
over 2600 participants. The researchers concluded that increased potassium
intake is effective in lowering both systolic and diastolic blood pressure
(systolic blood pressure dropped an average of 3.11 mmHg and diastolic
was reduced 1.97 mmHg) (Whelton et al. 1997).
The hypotensive nature of potassium benefited a group of rats made stroke-prone
for experimentation. The rats were divided into two groups. Only 2% of
the potassium-supplemented group experienced a fatal stroke, compared
to 83% of the untreated group (Alternative Medical News Staff). Cardiologists
report using 400 mg of magnesium, 500-1000 mg of calcium, and 500-1000
mg of potassium to treat patients with arrhythmias (Sinatra 1997).
Several factors influence potassium levels. For example, insulin therapy
appears to cause a potassium deficiency. Conversely, a diabetic supplementing
with potassium may observe increased insulin secretions and responsiveness,
reducing insulin requirements. Physical exertion (producing heavy perspiration)
or diarrhea and vomiting (resulting in loss of body fluids) can cause
a mineral depletion. Always replace minerals, for if not replaced, heart
function can quickly depreciate. Symptoms of potassium deficiency are
weakness, fatigue, mental confusion, and heart disturbances ( Murray 1996).
While the results of potassium studies are impressive, it must be noted
that though self-poisoning is uncommon, the consequences are often fatal
(Colledge 1988). Potassium supplementation in the form of oral potassium
tablets is generally not needed if you are on a good anti-aging diet that
includes several servings of fruits and vegetables per day (The estimated
safe and adequate daily dietary intake of potassium, as set by the Committee
on Recommended Daily Allowances, is 1.9 grams to 5.6 grams per day.)
Most individuals can tolerate excesses of potassium, but individuals
taking digitalis, potassium-sparing diuretics, and ACE inhibitors, or
individuals with diagnosed kidney disease, should never supplement unless
physician prescribed. This cautionary is valid for anyone considering
therapeutic dosages of potassium. Due to the potential side effects of
potassium on cardiac function, the FDA limits the amount of potassium
permitted in nutritional supplements to 99 mg per serving.
Recall that many foods offer reliable potassium stores; subsequently,
eating from foods delineated in the potassium food source section should
be especially important to individuals with hypertension and cardiac irregularities.
It becomes increasingly difficult, however, to provide adequate levels
of potassium if taking a diuretic. Patients are commonly told to replace
potassium by consuming potassium-rich foodstuffs. Yet, if every milligram
of potassium in a banana were retained, it would require eating an entire
stock of bananas every day to offset the potassium lost during diuretic
therapy (Cuneo et al. 1985; Alternative Medical News Staff).
Reader's guide to potassium food sources, enhancers, and antagonists:
Potassium is abundant in most food selections, e.g., 1 banana has 440
mg, 1 medium orange (263 mg), 1 medium peach (308 mg), cup of apricots
(318 mg), avocado (680 mg), cantaloupe (341 mg), cup cooked lima beans
(581 mg), 1 medium potato (782 mg), 1 medium raw tomato (444 mg), 1 stalk
of celery (130 mg), 3 ounces of light chicken (350 mg), 3 ounces of cod
(345 mg), 3 ounces of flounder (498 mg), and 3 ounces of salmon (378 mg).
Asparagus, carrots, spinach, apples, plums, strawberries, watermelon,
roast beef, pork, haddock, and tuna are other reliable sources.
Potassium enhancers (regarding absorption) are vitamin B6, calcium,
magnesium, and essential fatty acids. Antagonists to potassium include
excesses of sodium, sugar, stress, alcohol, and coffee, plus steroids,
diuretics, and laxatives.
Proanthocyanidins—are antioxidants,
ACE inhibitors, and beneficial to smokers; reduce platelet aggregation,
protect endothelium against white blood cell adherence, increase exercise
tolerance
Many names aptly describe the flavonoids found in pine bark, grape seed,
citrus peel, lemon tree bark, peanuts, and cranberries. The scientific
community once referred to this entire family as pycnogenols, a term now
considered outdated. Today pycnogenols are recognized by terms such as
proanthocyanidins, oligomeric proanthocyanidin complexes (OPCs), or procyanidolic
oligomers (PCOs). In the United States , Pycnogenol is a registered trademark
for Horphag Ltd. of Switzerland , identifying a PCO derived from French
maritime pine trees.
Much discussion as to whether pine bark or grape seed extract delivers
the most medicinal advantage still leaves the question unresolved. Dr.
Michael Murray states that while both are excellent sources of proanthocyanidins,
grape seed extracts are available that contain from 92-95% PCO content;
pine bark extracts vary from 80-85%. An overwhelming majority of the published
clinical and experimental trials over the past 20 years have been performed
using the grape seed extract, not the extract of pine bark ( Murray 1995b).
Peter Rohdewald, Ph.D., reported that nitric oxide (NO) became the molecule
of the year in 1993 when, among other functions, it was determined that
NO was a powerful vasodilator (Rohdewald 1999). NO is produced in the
endothelial cells from arginine, a process controlled by the enzyme, endothelial
nitric oxide synthase. Scientists became additionally excited when it
was determined that PCOs stimulate endo-thelial nitric oxide synthase,
producing more NO. This action counteracts the vasoconstricting effects
of the stress hormone adrenaline and also diminishes the threat of platelets
clumping.
Studies indicate that PCOs may be an alternative to aspirin. Among 180
post -stroke patients receiving 500 mg a day of aspirin for 2 years, 21%
were forced to stop medication because of side effects; more than 41%
experienced an increase in bleeding time. John D. Folts ( University of
Wisconsin ) reported that flavonoids benefited laboratory monkeys, reducing
the incidence of platelet aggregation and blocked arteries with efficiency
equal to or greater than aspirin. Adrenaline can completely wipe out the
positive effects of aspirin, but it has no degrading effect on flavonoids.
PCOs offer neither GI toxicity nor an effect on coagulation, suggesting
a better risk-benefit ratio compared to aspirin (Folts 1997; Watson 1999;
Duke 2000b).
Research cited in The Lancet showed an inverse relationship between
flavonoid intake and the risk of heart attack, that is, the more flavonoids
ingested, the less the incidence of heart disease (Hertog et al. 1993).
PCOs provide some of the most beneficial classes of plant flavonoids available.
Consider the multiple pathways PCOs employ to protect against heart
disease:
- Inhibits ACE (the angiotensin-converting enzyme) (Duke 2000b). This
means that the production of angiotensin II (a vasoconstricting compound)
is blocked and sodium and water retention decreases. These actions decrease
blood pressure and improve cardiac output; a decrease in heart size
usually follows.
- Protects the endothelium from leukocyte adherence, a process that
lessens the threat of occlusion (Cooke et al. 1997; Rohdewald 1999).
- Increases intracellular vitamin C levels, a function that strengthens
capillary and blood vessel walls (Schwitters et al. 1993; Murray 1995b).
- Appears to offer about 50 times more antioxidant protection than
vitamin C or vitamin E, an action that assists in shielding LDL cholesterol
from the cardiac damaging oxidation process ( Murray 1995b).
- Lowers blood cholesterol levels, even shrinking the size of cholesterol
deposits appearing in the arteries of laboratory animals (Wegrowski
et al. 1984).
- Increases treadmill endurance (improvement confirmed by electrocardiograms
and stress tests) and reduces myocardial ischemia and cardiovascular
deterioration (Petry et al. 2001).
- Regarded as beta-adrenergic receptor blockers, reducing sympathetic
nervous system activity and the "fight or flight syndrome"
(Duke Database 1992).
- Reports from the Institute of Pharmaceutical Chemistry ( Germany
) indicate that PCOs lower platelet aggregation in heavy smokers without
increasing the risk of bleeding (Rohdewald 1999). Tests confirm that
the platelet aggregation index was reduced to levels closely challenging
those found in nonsmokers, in part by inhibiting the synthesis of thromboxane,
a compound derived from inflammatory prostaglandins , that increases
platelet aggregation (Putter et al. 1999).
For most individuals, 100 mg daily of PCO (grape seed-skin extract)
appears adequate. Therapeutic doses are 150-300 mg a day.
Note: While
proanthocyanidins do not prolong bleeding time when used independently,
if used with anticoagulant drugs, caution is advised.
Selenium—prevents ventricular
tachycardia, is a hypolipidemic, and improves diabetic symptoms, congestive
heart failure, and cardiomyopathy
Cardiomyopathy is defined as any disease that affects the structure and
function of the heart. For example, the heart may become disabled as fibrous
tissue partially replaces the heart muscle; the fibrous tissue degrades
the heart's performance, and the blood no longer moves efficiently. The
World Health Organization recognizes cardiomyopathy as a selenium deficiency.
In addition, French researchers showed that chronic heart failure (associated
with oxidative stress) appears to be relieved by selenium supplementation.
Selenium may play a role in the clinical severity of the disease, rather
than in the degree of left ventricular dysfunction (de Lorgeril 2001).
Selenium limited the incidence of ventricular tachycardia—that
is, at least three consecutive ventricle complexes with the heart rate
more than 100 beats a minute—from 91% in the control group to 36%
in the selenium-treated group; irreversible ventricular fibrillation was
reduced from 45% in the control group to 0% in the selenium group (Tanguy
et al. 1998). Luoma et al. (1984) noted that 97 mcg of selenium a day
increased the ratio of HDL : -LDL cholesterol, while inhibiting platelet
aggregation. It is reported that a 1% increase in HDL reduces the risk
of a heart attack or stroke 4%.
Korpela et al. (1989), in a 6-month double-blind trial involving 81
heart attack patients, found that 100 mcg of selenium reduced the number
of cardiovascular events to one nonfatal heart attack, while the group
not receiving the selenium suffered four fatal heart attacks and two nonfatal
heart attacks. Among men free of stroke at the outset, low serum selenium
was associated significantly with stroke mortality, an adjusted relative
risk of 3.7 (Virtamo et al. 1985).
Selenium brought blood glucose levels, malondiald ehyde (a breakdown
product of peroxidized polyunsaturated lipids), and glutathione concentrations
to near control levels in almost all diabetic patients. A suggested dosage
is 200-300 mcg daily.
Reader's guide to selenium food
sources, enhancers, and antagonists
Quantities found in foods are dependent upon the selenium content of the
soil, but typically whole grains, wheat germ, broccoli, onions, tomatoes,
Brazil nuts, brewer's yeast, garlic, eggs, and seafood are classed as
selenium sources.
Selenium enhancers include most antioxidants and essential fatty acids.
Antagonists to selenium absorption are heavy metals (mercury and cadmium),
excesses of iron, saturated and trans fats, unresolved stress, and indulgences
in alcohol and tobacco.
Taurine—has hypotensive
and diuretic activity, tempers the sympathetic nervous system, is beneficial
in CHF and arrhythmias, and has digitalis-like mentality
Taurine is the most important and abundant of the amino acids in the heart,
surpassing the combined quantity of all the others. Under high stress
conditions—hypertension and many forms of heart disease—the
need for taurine increases to compensate for either an accompanying impairment
of taurine metabolism or increased requirements. Dr. H. Kohaski and colleagues
( Japan ) suggest that entry-level taurine may have been low and, as the
stress of hypertension progresses, taurine levels drop even lower (Kahashi
1983; Braverman et al.1987).
Taurine has a diuretic action that benefits hypertensive individuals,
as well as patients with congestive heart failure. Taurine elicits much
of its diuretic action by preserving potassium and magnesium and by promoting
sodium excretion (Atkins 1996b).
Taurine also reduces blood pressure by acting as an antagonist to the
blood pressure-increasing effect of angiotensin, a circulating protein
that is activated by renin, a hormone secreted by the juxtaglomerular
cells in the kidneys in response to a drop in blood pressure (Braverman
et al. 1987). When both blood and urine taurine levels decrease, renin
is activated and angiotensin is formed. As a result blood vessels vasoconstrict,
water and salt are retained, and blood pressure increases. Taurine suppresses
renin and breaks the renin-angiotensin feedback loop. Dr. Robert Atkins,
a complementary physician with a creditable cardiology background, amplifies
the positive results of scientific literature, stating that taurine would
be his choice were he selecting a single nutrient to treat hypertension.
Dr. Y. Yamori (a Japanese researcher who established an amino acid-stroke
association) studied a strain of rats, genetically susceptible to strokes.
Yamori found the rats had a much lower incidence of stroke, dropping from
90% to 20%, if their diet was supplemented with methionine, taurine, and
lysine (Yamori et al. 1983; Braverman et al. 1987).
Japanese researchers found that 3 grams of taurine, administered daily
to patients with congestive heart failure, was more effective than 30
mg of CoQ10 (Azuma et al. 1992). The Japanese, who use taurine widely
in the treatment of various forms of heart disease, found that 4 grams
of taurine, given for 4 weeks, brought relief to 19 of 24 patients with
congestive heart failure. Taurine appears to act much like the drug digitalis,
increasing the contractility of cardiac muscle and the force of the pumping
action.
Taurine appears to impact cardiac arrhythmias through various pathways.
For example, some forms of cardiac irregularities are helped by taurine
because it regulates membrane excitability and scavenges free radicals.
In addition, taurine protects potassium levels inside heart cells, which,
when imbalanced, can cause electrical instability and cardiac arrhythmias
(Braverman 1987; Chahine et al. 1998).
Some types of premature ventricular contractions and arrhythmias respond
to taurine because the amino acid tends to dampen activity in the sympathetic
nervous system (SNS) and the outpouring of epinephrine. As the SNS is
quieted, the heart tends to beat less aggressively and the blood pressure
is lowered. Lastly, Lebanese researchers showed that the incidence of
ventricular fibrillation and ventricular tachycardia were significantly
reduced when taurine therapy was utilized (Braverman 1987; Chahine et
al. 1998). A suggested dosage is 1500-4000 mg daily.
Testo sterone—modulates
cholesterol levels, dilates blood vessels, improves circulation, lessens
angina attacks, and reduces blood pressure
Testosterone, a muscle-building hormone, appears to do far more than promote
the development of male secondary sexual characteristics. There are, in
fact, many testosterone-receptor sites in the heart that play a role in
maintaining heart muscle protein synthesis and strength (Bricout et al.
1994).
If testosterone levels are normal, cholesterol is more easily managed,
and blood has an easier route as it flows through dilated vessels. One
study showed that circulation to the heart improved 68.8% in patients
receiving testosterone therapy (Wu et al. 1993). A testosterone delivery
patch applied to men with low testosterone levels increased exercise time
on a treadmill and (according to trial participants) increased quality
of life. Improved emotional health (important to the heart) and a decrease
in the incidence of angina attacks reflect some of the benefits of upgrading
testosterone levels (English et al. 2000).
Typically, fibrinogen, triglycerides, and insulin levels are higher
if testosterone levels are low (Marin 1995; Kryger 2002). In addition,
the elasticity of the coronary arteries diminishes, contributing to the
development of arteriosclerosis. Blood pressure increases, but the growth
hormone decreases, further weakening the heart muscle. Abdominal fat,
the most dangerous form of obesity, increases.
Physicians who check for testosterone deficiencies or testosterone-estrogen
imbalances have in some cases been able to discontinue cardiac and hypertension
medications. Improved EKGs confirm subjective reports of improvement.
Since testosterone testing is noninvasive, the risk-benefit ratio swings
heavily in favor of testing. For information about safely increasing testosterone
levels, refer to the Male Hormone or Female Hormone Modulation protocols.
Thiamine (Vitamin B1)— is
beneficial in some forms of cardiac arrhythmias, palpitations, enlarged
heart, elevated venous pressure, and congestive heart disease
Cardiac arrhythmia refers to a deviation from the normal pattern of the
heartbeat. Arrhythmias can be caused by a variety of underlying medical
conditions that should be addressed by a qualified cardiologist. Arrhythmias
are not always clinically significant because rather benign events can
spur healthy hearts to enter irregular patterns of beating. Yet, arrhythmias
should be taken seriously, and a diagnosis made as to the causative factors
provoking the disturbed beat. Stress, electrolyte imbalance, ischemia,
hypoxia, ventricular enlargement, occlusions, an insulin rush, or derangement
in the autonomic nervous system can drive a heart into irregular rhythms.
Since thiamine has proved correctional for some types of arrhythmias,
there appears to be linkage between irregular heartbeats and beriberi,
a disease caused by a deficiency of or an inability to assimilate thiamine.
Cultures that depended upon rice, a high carbohydrate food, as a dietary
mainstay found the milling process, that is, the removal of the brown
coat rich in thiamine, to be their undoing. Beriberi swept through the
population with epidemic force.
Cardiac arrhythmias may manifest among heavy drinkers as thiamine deficiencies
occur, and symptoms of beriberi appear. But, heavy imbibers are not the
only individuals susceptible to thiamine deficiency. Infirm individuals,
as well as those who are elderly and malnourished, are at particular risk.
Long-term diuretic usage can also contribute to a thiamine deficiency
through urinary loss. It is not uncommon for heart palpitations, deranged
heart rhythms, and elevated venous pressure to occur as patients become
thiamine deficient (Whiting 1989). Additional cardiovascular manifestations
of wet beriberi are myocardial lesions, sodium and water retention, and
biventricular myocardial failure. Typically, clinical improvement occurs
quickly following vitamin B1 therapy (Blanc et al. 2000).
In 1995, 30 patients with severe heart failure and taking furosemide
(Lasix, a diuretic) were enrolled in a heart study. Although furosemide
was unsuccessful in improving their cardiac condition, 200 mg of thiamine
(a day) dramatically improved heart function (Shimon et al. 1995). Some
patients may experience improvement from 200-250 mg a day; other individuals
may require 500-1000 mg daily. (A full spectrum vitamin B supplement should
always accompany single B vitamin supplementation.)
Reader's guide to vitamin B1 food
sources, enhancers, and antagonists.
Lean pork, wheat germ, and whole grains (particularly brown rice) are
considered to be excellent sources of thiamine. Meat, poultry, egg yolk,
fish, legumes, peas, sunflower seeds, nuts, and brewer's yeast represent
other good thiamine choices.
Vitamin B1 enhancers are all others of the B complex, vitamin C, vitamin
E, and manganese. Alcohol, coffee, antacids, and excesses of sugar and
refined carbohydrates decrease thiamine absorption.
Tocotrienols—are antioxidants,
decrease platelet aggregation, and have act like statin mentality drugs
Tocotrienols have been until recently the lesser known half of vitamin
E. A major functional difference between tocotrienols and tocopherols
appears to be the ability of tocotrienols to more aptly decrease cholesterol
synthesis in the liver. Both tocotrienols and tocopherols appear to be
potent antioxidants, with some research demonstrating greater antioxidant
protection and less oxidative damage when supplementing with tocotrienols
(Serbinova et al. 1991).
Cholesterol lowering statin drugs—Lipitor, Lescol, Mevacor, Pravachol,
and Zocor—operate at the level of 3-hydroxy-3 methylglutar o yl
coenzyme A (HMG-CoA) reductase. HMG-CoA reductase is a rate-limiting enzyme
that participates in cholesterol synthesis. The cholesterol cascade occurs
as follows: (1) acetyl-CoA is converted to HMG-CoA, (2) HMG-CoA is reduced
to mevalonic acid by the enzyme HMG-CoA reductase, and (3) several steps
convert mevalonic acid to squalene and then to cholesterol.
Tocotrienols, particularly gamma and delta, accelerate the degradation
of HMG-CoA reductase, altering the functionality of the enzyme responsible
for cholesterol synthesis (Parker et al. 1993). The statin drugs, though
acting at the level of HMG-CoA reductase, approach the enzyme differently.
Statin drugs do not degrade the enzyme but competitively inhibit its binding.
The inhibition of the binding mechanism leads to a higher production of
HMG-CoA reductase, which may explain the side effects, such as liver toxicity,
associated with statin usage.
Studies indicate that roughly 75% of hypercholesterolemic individuals
respond favorably to tocotrienol supplementation. The most impressive
cholesterol reductions occur when tocotrienol supplements are combined
with dietary changes (a high fiber/low fat diet). In a 12-week double-blind
trial, those who responded to tocotrienol therapy saw a reduction of approximately
23% in total cholesterol and a 32% reduction in LDL cholesterol using
dietary modification plus tocotrienol supplements. Tocotrienols alone
yielded a 16% decrease in total cholesterol and a 21% decrease in LDL
cholesterol (Quereshi et al. 1993; ACCM 1998). HDL levels do not appear
to respond to tocotrienol supplementation, but apo-B, a protein component
found in LDL, VLDL, and IDL cholesterol, is lowered. Thromboxanes are
also considered toco-trienol responsive (Qureshi et al. 1997).
The Kenneth Jordan Heart Research Foundation ( New Jersey ) reported
the results of 50 patients with narrowing of the carotid artery who that
were treated with either a placebo or tocotrienols: 25 patients (some
with carotid stenosis greater than 49%) received 650 mg of tocotrienols
plus tocopherols; a control group of 25 patients, with comparable closure,
received a placebo. Each group was evaluated every 6 months for the first
year and every year thereafter with ultrasonography. In the placebo group,
15 patients showed worsening of the stenosis, eight remained stable, and
two showed some level of improvement. In the tocotrienol plus tocopherol
group, three patients showed minor worsening, 12 remained stable, but
10 patients showed regression of stenosis. Participants experienced a
simultaneous drop in triglycerides and LDL cholesterol (Papas undated;
Tomeo et al. 1995; Watkins et al.1998).
The late Karl Folkers, a pioneer in CoQ10 research, observed that drugs
inhibiting HMG-CoA reductase activity cause a simultaneous decrease in
CoQ10 levels (Folkers et al. 1990). The reason for this is that the HMG-CoA
enzyme also plays a role in CoQ10 synthesis. Individuals using either
statin drugs or tocotrienols may wish to increase their intake of CoQ10;
a decrease in CoQ10 could negate any benefit garnered from a hypocholesterolemic
drug.
According to Andreas M. Papas, Ph.D., appropriate tocotrienol dosages
are as follows: 100 IU of mixed tocopherols and 100 IU of tocotrienols
if young and healthy and without a family history of heart disease; 200
IU of mixed tocopherols and 200 IU of toco-trienols for young adults with
some cardiac risk factors or healthy people up to 50 years of age without
risk factors; 400 IU of mixed tocopherols and 400 IU of tocotrienols for
people who have a personal or family history of chronic heart disease.
The latter dosage includes senior subjects and those under severe stress
and eating a poor diet.
Vitamin A and Beta-Carotene—lower
fibrinogen levels and heart disease risks and increase insulin sensitivity
Dexter Morris, M.D. ( University of North Carolina ), says that phytochemicals
keep your heart healthy. "The 60-80 age group has a much greater
risk of heart disease than younger people do. If your diet is rich in
fruits and vegetables, you can reduce risk," according to Morris.
In a study begun in 1973, researchers kept track of 1883 men ages 35-59
who that had high cholesterol levels. Over the next 20 years, the men
who had the highest levels of carotenoids in their blood had 60% fewer
heart attacks and deaths (Morris 2001).
Dr. J.E. Manson of the Women's Hospital in Boston reported that those
taking 25,000 IU of beta-carotene daily had 22% fewer heart problems and
strokes than those taking less than 10,000 IU daily (Friend 1991; Passwater
undated). Dr. Monika Eichholzer (scientist at the University of Bern,
Switzerland) reported similar findings after tracking 2974 people for
12 years. The relative risk of ischemic heart disease was increased (1.53%)
among those lowest in plasma carotene concentrations (Eichholzer et al.
1992).
High vitamin A and beta-carotene serum levels have been reported to
reduce fibrinogen levels in humans and animals (Green 1997). Animals fed
a vitamin A-deficient diet have an impaired ability to break down fibrinogen,
but when injected with vitamin A, they produce tissue plasminogen activators
that break down fibrinogen, reducing the risk of clot formation.
Vitamin A is beneficial to individuals with Syndrome X and diabetes.
A study involving 52 patients indicated that vitamin A enhanced insulin-mediated
glucose disposal (Facchini et al. 1996a). Since beta-carotene must be
converted in the body to vitamin A, an adaptation some individuals lack,
diabetics may do better using vitamin A rather than beta-carotene.
It should be noted that the protection of beta-carotene is not absolute.
In fact, if the individual is consuming greater amounts of alcohol, beta-carotene
may actually increase the risk of intracerebral hemorrhage (Leppala et
al. 2000). A blend of phytoextracts (alpha-carotene, beta-carotene, lutein,
and lycopene) appears to offer more comprehensive cardiac protection than
using beta-carotene alone.
For example, individuals participating in the Toulouse study who had
higher blood levels of lutein also had a lower incidence of coronary artery
disease (Howard et al. 1996). The Los Angeles Atherosclerosis study uncovered
a relationship between thickenings in the carotid arteries (an indicator
of systemic atherosclerosis) and blood levels of lutein (Dwyer et al.
2001). Participants with the highest blood levels of lutein showed virtually
no artery wall thickening, while those with the lowest lutein levels showed
increased arterial thickness. In addition, lutein reduces the oxidation
of LDL cholesterol, a declaration the Life Extension Foundation first
made to members in 1985.
A current Finnish study evaluated 725 middle-aged men free of coronary
heart disease and stroke at the study baseline. Men in the lowest quartile
of serum levels of lycopene had a 3.3-fold risk of an acute coronary event
or stroke compared with other trial participants with higher lycopene
levels. In a second study, the same researchers assessed the association
between plasma concentrations of lycopene and intima-media thickness (IMT)
of the common carotid artery wall in 520 asymptomatic men and women. After
adjusting for common cardiovascular risk factors, low plasma levels of
lycopene were associated with an 18% increase in IMT in men as compared
with men in whom plasma levels were higher than median. In women, the
difference did not remain significant after the adjustments (Rissenen
et al. 2002).
German researchers reported that plasma levels of alpha-carotene may
represent a marker of atherosclerosis in humans. Measuring alpha-carotene
levels (among other antioxidants) may be of clinical importance as a practical
approach to assess atherogenesis and/or its risk (Kontush et al. 1996).
Some individuals are susceptible to vitamin A toxicity even when the
dosage is low. This occurs because of a challenged liver and fewer detoxification
mechanisms. Beta-carotene, on the other hand, is generally regarded as
nontoxic (to read more about vitamin A toxicity, consult Appendix A).
Appropriate dosages for most individuals are 5000 IU of beta-carotene
and/or 10,000 IU of vitamin A daily. Several supplements are available
that provide the carotenoids alpha-carotene, beta-carotene, lutein, and
lycopene.
Reader's guide to vitamin A food
sources, enhancers, and agonists.
The richest sources of vitamin A are foods of animal origin, i.e., liver,
fish liver oil, milk and milk products, butter, and eggs. Yellow fruits
and green and yellow vegetables will also help meet vitamin A requirements.
Enhancers to vitamin A absorption are vitamin C, calcium, magnesium,
vitamin E, B complex, choline, and essential fatty acids. Vitamin A antagonists
are laxatives and some cholesterol-lowering drugs (Questran). Coffee,
alcohol, excess iron supplementation, sugar, tobacco, and mineral oil
can also interfere with vitamin A absorption. Food sources of lutein are
kale, Brussels sprouts, corn, collards, spinach, and egg yolks. Egg yolks
have tiny amounts of lutein—about 0.2 mg a per yolk—because
chickens eat corn (Carper 2002). Lycopene is present in tomatoes and several
other red fruits.
Vitamin C—lessens risk of
stroke and heart attack; strengthens blood vessels; reduces blood pressure,
fibrinogen levels, Lp(a), inflammation, and C-reactive protein (CRP);
promotes gingival healing; is a reliable antioxidant and diuretic; and
is highly beneficial to smokers and those exposed to secondhand smoke
Linus Pauling, a Nobel Prize winner, showed that the body often forms
atherosclerotic plaque to repair a wound inflicted upon an artery. When
adequate amounts of vitamin C are available, an injured artery is repaired
without involving atheromatous materials. In the absence of adequate levels
of vitamin C, Lp(a), acting as a surrogate for vitamin C, must participate
in the repair. Lp(a) does what it must, but the health of the artery is
compromised as plaque is added to the vessel. If ascorbate levels had
been adequate, Lp(a) would not have been necessary; without adequate vitamin
C, the need for Lp(a) is enormous.
Vitamin C Lowers Lp(a)
Kathie M. Dalessandri, M.S., M.D., was inspired by a report appearing
in the Archives of Internal Medicine relating to the ability of vitamin
C to lower Lp(a). Dr. Dalessandri, a general surgeon in Point Reyes Station,
CA, was displeased with her own Lp(a) levels. She was well aware of the
dangers associated with Lp(a), particularly when linked with other risk
factors as a family history of heart disease. Dr. Dalessandri (53 years
old at the time) was taking hormone replacement therapy and niacin, but
the niacin became problematic and had to be discontinued. After reviewing
the literature, she decided upon 3 grams a day of both ascorbic acid and
L-lysine monohydrochloride as a natural regime against the elevated Lp(a).
Dr. Dalessandri reports that her Lp(a) dropped 14 mg/dL, a reduction of
48% after 6 months. She was also pleased that she was able to take vitamin
C and lysine without side effects (Dalessandri 2001).
Matthias Rath, M.D., in Eradicating Heart Disease, says that animals
do not have heart attacks and strokes because their bodies manufacture
vitamin C, a genetic adaptation humans lack. Most mammals produce impressive
amounts of vitamin C, the human equivalency of 2000-13,000 mg daily. Under
periods of stress the same animal's needs for vitamin C may skyrocket,
but the body complies by producing prodigious amounts. Man cannot adapt
to stress with the same efficiency as lower animals because of a lack
of L-gulonolactone oxidase, an enzyme needed to produce vitamin C from
glucose. Dr. Rath states that because of this genetic flaw and inadequate
dietary vitamin C, cardiovascular disease can emerge as a form of early
scurvy (Rath 1993).
An ascorbic acid deficit contributes to the development of vascular
lesions (wounds or injuries) by altering collagen metabolism (Rath 1993).
Vitamin C produces many collagen molecules, supporting a strong and elastic
blood vessel wall. Over time, arterial collagen must be replenished. If
vitamin C is not present in large enough quantities, collagen is not produced,
and blood vessels become thin and weak.
Vitamin C levels are lower in patients who have had heart attacks, both
fatal and nonfatal events. Randomly selected Finnish men (1605 individuals
who were 42-60 years old) entered a study evidencing no signs of preexisting
heart disease. Among men with a vitamin C deficiency, 13.2% had a heart
attack compared to 3.8% who were not vitamin C deficient. After adjusting
for other confounding factors, men who were deficient in vitamin C had
3.5 times more heart attacks than men who were not vitamin C deficient
(Nyyssonen et al. 1997).
The most significant report emanated from UCLA, where it was announced
that men who took 300-400 mg of vitamin C a day lived 6 years longer than
those who received less than 50 mg daily. The study (which evaluated 11,348
participants over a 10-year period) showed that long-term, high vitamin
C intake extended average lifespan and reduced mortality from cardiovascular
disease 45% (Enstrom et al. 1992; Hansen 2000).
Researchers from the Boston University School of Medicine reported that
vitamin C appears effective in lowering mild cases of hypertension. The
patients lowered systolic and diastolic blood pressure by about 9% with
a daily dose of 500 mg of ascorbic acid (Stauth 2001). The value of vitamin
C as a hypotensive nutrient may come by way of its antioxidant activity,
possibly by protecting the body's supply of NO, a vasodilator. (Free radicals
appear to lower NO levels.) Depriving test animals of antioxidants, such
as vitamin C, glutathione, and vitamin E, resulted in oxidative stress
and higher blood pressure.
The heart is one of the most vulnerable of all organs to free-radical
oxidative stress. Vitamin C can respond to this risk by exerting its antioxidant
properties, acting independently, or by prompting the production of other
antioxidants. For example, 3 grams of vitamin C increased white blood
cell glutathione levels fourfold and plasma glutathione levels eightfold
(Jain et al. 1994; Murray 1996b).
Vitamin C is beneficial in reducing fibrinogen levels. In a report published
in the journal Atherosclerosis, heart disease patients were given either
1000 or 2000 mg a day of vitamin C to assess its effect on the breakdown
of fibrinogen. At 1000 mg a day, there was no significant change in fibrinolytic
activity. At 2000 mg of vitamin C a day, fibrinolytic activity increased
62.5% (Bordia 1980).
Inflammation, a newer risk factor for heart disease, is reduced by vitamin
C. Each winter (in most countries) there is a 15-30% increase in deaths
from cardiovascular and respiratory disease. Researchers in the United
Kingdom followed 96 men and women for 1 year to assess the impact of winter
stress upon the heart and circulatory system. It appears some of the increase
in winter cardiovascular mortality may be related not only to a rise in
fibrinogen, but also to an increase in other inflammatory markers, such
as C-reactive protein. This cycle may be spurred as winter infections
increase and vitamin C intake (because of less availability of fruits
and vegetables) decreases. The conclusion of the study was that vitamin
C might be able to influence cardiovascular risk and the resulting thrombotic
tendency by modulating the inflammatory response to infection (Woodhouse
et al. 1997).
Vitamin C appears to lessen the negative effects of many other risk
factors, including stress, diseased gums, unhealthy diet, and smoking.
Smoking severely depletes the body of vitamin C; vitamin C, on the other
hand, destroys free radicals produced in smoke and protects against endothelial
dysfunction. Even secondhand smoke breaks down blood antioxidant defenses
and accelerates lipid peroxidation, which leads to an accumulation of
LDL cholesterol (Tribble et al. 1993). Vitamin C should be a part of an
individual's nutritional fortress against the ravages of both firsthand
and passive smoke.
A dosage suggestion is 6 grams daily in divided dosages. (A loose stool
may result from higher doses of vitamin C. Should this occur simply reduce
the dose to a level that is not problematic to the bowel.) Under periods
of stress, a great deal more vitamin C can be taken without bowel derangement.
Reader's guide to vitamin C food
sources, enhancers, and antagonists.
Vegetables and fresh, uncooked fruits (especially citrus) are vitamin
C-rich sources. Raw foods represent excellent choices, having escaped
the rigors of processing and preparation.
All vitamins and minerals work synergistically to enhance vitamin C
absorption, particularly the bioflavonoids. Alcohol, coffee, sulfa drugs,
antibiotics, analgesics, antidepressants, anticoagulants, oral contraceptives,
and steroids can drain vitamin C from the body. Smoking seriously depletes
vitamin C levels.
Vitamin D—reduces heart
disease risk in women
It was reported at the 42nd annual conference on Cardiovascular Disease
and Epidemiology Prevention (in Honolulu , HI , on April 23, 2002 ) that
women who take vitamin D supplements lowered their risk of death from
heart disease by one-third. The finding was an unexpected dividend extracted
from an osteoporosis trial to determine the incidence of bone fracture
in nearly 10,000 older women. From the trial participants, 4200 women
reported taking vitamin D supplements at the onset of the study; another
733 reported a prior history of supplementation. After tracking the women
for an average of nearly 11 years, researchers found that the risk of
heart disease death was 31% lower in those taking vitamin D at the time
of the study (Mercola 2002b).
Recent studies indicate that moderate or severe hypovitaminosis D was
present in 66% of patients taking daily vitamin D in amounts less than
the recommended dosage for their age; 37% of the patients taking daily
vitamin D in excess of the recommended amount for their age were nonetheless
still deficient. Thus, experts recommend at least 400 IU of vitamin D
a day; if the individual is elderly and not participating in outdoor activities
(and sunlight exposure), 800 IU a day is recommended (Thomas et al. 2000).
Vitamin E—prevents plaque
formation, protects LDL from oxidation, strengthens blood vessels, reduces
blood viscosity and platelet aggregation, is helpful in atrial and ventricular
fibrillation, is an antioxidant and antidiabetic nutrient, improves insulin
sensitivity, is protective to smokers, reduces C-reactive protein, has
diuretic activity, and is beneficial to those with hemochromatosis
Dr. Richard Passwater commented in June 2001 that good research is timeless.
The following is an example of an excellent study that should not be lost
in the archives. In 1974, Dr. Passwater enrolled 17,894 persons (ages
50-98) in a study to determine the effects of long-term vitamin E supplementation.
He found the length of time the individual used vitamin E was more important
than the amount of the nutrient used. The trend was especially apparent
beyond 9 years of usage. Taking 400 IU of vitamin E daily for 10 years
or more strikingly reduced the occurrence of heart disease prior to 80
years of age (Passwater 1977).
An ongoing study involving 87,245 nurses (ages 34-59) and 39,910 male
health professionals (ages 40-75) showed a significant relationship between
the use of vitamin E supplements and a reduced risk of heart disease (Rimm
et al.1993; Stampfer et al. 1993). A study reported in The Lancet may
have eclipsed all others, showing that 2002 individuals with documented
heart disease (supplemented with 400-800 IU of vitamin E daily) reduced
their risk of nonfatal heart attacks 77% (Stephens 1996; Challem 2001).
These dramatic results occur in part because vitamin E prevents white
blood cells from adhering to arterial walls. Researchers from the University
of Texas Southwestern Medical Center explain that when monocytes are suppressed
from bonding to the artery, a primary step in arterial closure has been
averted (Devaraj et al. 2000a).
According to researchers at Georgetown University Medical School , vitamin
E also renders the blood less sticky and platelets less prone to clump.
In animal models of endothelial dysfunction, vitamin E improved the activity
of endothelium-derived nitric oxide; this effect was not dependent upon
the antioxidant protection of LDL cholesterol. Instead, it appears vitamin
E inhibits platelet aggregation through a mechanism that involves protein
kinase C inhibition, not its antioxidant activity as previously suspected
(Freedman et al. 2001).
French scientists found that alpha-tocopherol supplementation prevented
lethal ventricular arrhythmias associated with ischemia and reperfusion.
In addition, animals with coronary arteries occluded for experimentation
experienced a significant decrease in the ventricular fibrillation threshold;
animals similarly occluded, but vitamin E supplemented, realized no decrease
in the threshold (Dzhaparidze et al. 1986; Fuenmayor et al. 1989; Sebbag
et al. 1994). Comment: Ventricular tachycardia represents at least three
consecutive ventricular complexes with a heart rate of more than 100 beats
a minute. Ventricular fibrillation is a cardiac arrhythmia marked by rapid,
disorganized depolarizations of the ventricular myocardium. Blood pressure
falls to zero, resulting in unconsciousness; without defibrillation and
resuscitation, death can promptly ensue.
According to Ron Kennedy, M.D., atrial fibrillation is a condition in
which the regular pumping function of the atria is replaced by a disorganized,
ineffective quivering caused by the chaotic conduction of electrical signals
through the upper chambers of the heart. The patient has various corrective
options, including anti -arrhythmic drugs, anticoagulants, radio-frequency
ablation, a pacemaker, and, according to Dr. Kennedy, high-dose (2000
IU a day) vitamin E. Recall that vitamin E reduces blood viscosity and
platelet aggregation. If the patient is receiving anticoagulant therapy
and wishes to add vitamin E, close monitoring by a physician is essential
to avoid compromising the clotting mechanism (Kennedy 1999).
Researchers from the University of Naples reported encouraging data
regarding pharmacological doses (about 900 mg a day) of vitamin E administered
to elderly patients with coronary heart disease and insulin resistance.
Lower fasting and 2-hour blood glucose levels, reduced plasma insulin
and triglyceride concentrations, and an improved HDL : -LDL ratio indicate
vitamin E is useful in stabilizing insulin-resistant patients with coronary
heart disease (Paolisso et al. 1995).
According to Dr s. Ishwarlal Jialal and Dr. Sridevi Deveraj (University
of Texas Southwestern Medical Center at Dallas ), diabetics have increased
inflammation and are more prone to cardiovascular disease (Deveraj et
al. 2000). It appears that V vitamin E, by decreasing inflammation, may
contribute to a reduction in cardiovascular disease in both diabetic and
nondiabetic subjects. Vitamin E lowered levels of IL-6 50% ; and 1200
IU of vitamin E reduced C-reactive protein (CRP) 30% (Devaraj et al. 2000b;
O'Brien 2001). CRP levels remained constant 2 months postsupplementation.
For an in-depth review of CRP, consult the CRP subsection under the sections
Newer Risk Factors and The Link Between Infections and Inflammation in
Heart Disease, in this protocol.
Vitamin E appears to be decreased in patients with hereditary hemochromatosis
or iron overload. Iron loading, in experimental studies, significantly
decreases hepatic and plasma vitamin E, a shortage amenable with supplementation.
Free-radical index markers increase three- to fivefold in an iron-loaded
liver, but supplementation with vitamin E has been shown to reduce levels
by about 50% (Brown et al. 1996).
Free radicals activate a gene that encourages overgrowth of smooth muscles
in the blood vessel walls, a process that can contribute to closure (Gonzalez-Flecha
2002). Vitamin E, a reliable antioxidant, has the opposite effect, that
is, it turns off the gene responsible for smooth muscle proliferation.
Vitamin E's antioxidant powers extend to protect the cells and organs
(particularly the lungs) from damage caused by smoking.
Vitamin E has (for decades) been credited (for decades) with diuretic
activity, stimulating urine excretion ( Davis 1965). This action is of
a significant advantage to patients with edematous tissues and elevated
blood pressure.
The type and blend of vitamin E used affects the end results. Studies
have shown that alpha-tocopherol may not protect as aggressively against
coronary heart disease unless it is combined with the gamma-tocopherol
form. Both alpha-tocopherol and gamma-tocopherol can decrease platelet
aggregation, inhibit blood clot formation, protect LDL cholesterol against
oxidation, and increase endogenous SOD production (an enzyme with antioxidant
activity); gamma-tocopherol, however, shows greater activity on each function.
Unfortunately, gamma-tocopherol has a couple of factors working against
its utilization. For example, gamma-tocopherol can be obtained from foodstuffs,
but it is poorly retained, and much of it is excreted in urine after being
metabolized by the liver. Furthermore, a protein, referred to as alpha-tocopherol
transfer protein, identifies and selectively chooses alpha-tocopherol
over other forms of vitamin E. As a result, alpha-tocopherol is found
more abundantly in lipids, blood, and body tissues. This scenario does
not allow for maximum protection against free-radical attack.
It is strongly recommended that individuals relying upon the cardio
-protective effects of vitamin E include (as part of their intake) the
gamma-tocopherol form, but the complexing process determines the benefit.
A union of alpha-tocopherol (80%) with gamma-tocopherol (20%) appears
ideal; too much alpha-tocopherol may oppose the antioxidant qualities
of gamma-tocopherol.
In addition, the hypolipidemic value of toco-trienols, the lesser known
half of vitamin E, should not be overlooked. The most dramatic cholesterol
reduction is seen when tocotrienol supplements are combined with dietary
changes (a high-fiber, low-fat diet). In a 12-week, double-blind trial,
those who responded to tocotrienol therapy saw a reduction of approximately
23% in total cholesterol and 32% in LDL cholesterol using dietary modification
plus toco-trienol supplements. Tocotrienols alone yielded a 16% decrease
in total cholesterol and a 21% decrease in LDL cholesterol (Quereshi et
al. 1993; ACCM 1998). apo-B, a protein component found in LDL, VLDL, and
IDL cholesterol also appears to be tocotrienol responsive (Qureshi et
al. 1997).
Tocotrienols degrade the enzyme 3-hydroxy-3-methylgulutaryl coenzyme
A reductase, a the rate-limiting enzyme that participates in cholesterol
synthesis. Researchers credited this function as being the mechanism delivering
tocotrienol's hypolipidemic edge (Qureshi et al. 2001). A team of researchers
from Switzerland reported greater hypolipidemic value when using gamma-tocotrienol
rather than a mixture of tocotrienols (Raederstorff et al. 2002). To read
more about tocotrienols and dosing recommendations, please consult the
Tocotrienols subsection appearing earlier in this section.
A suggested dosage of vitamin E is 400-1200 IU a day. Comment: Initially,
blood pressure rose in approximately one-third of hypertensive individuals
treated with vitamin E (Shute 1976). Therefore, individuals who are hypertensive
should use 100 IU a day for 1 month and add 100 IU each month until 400
IU a day is reached (Balch et al. 1997). Because of the reductions in
blood glucose levels, diabetic individuals wishing to use vitamin E should
begin with low dosages. Gradually increase the dosage, allowing for appropriate
insulin or drug adjustments. Lastly, Pracon, Inc., a hospital outcomes
analysis firm in Reston , VA , estimated that healthcare expenses could
be reduced $7.7 billion annually if the public regularly took vitamin
E supplements.
Reader's guide to vitamin E food
sources, enhancers, and antagonists.
Vitamin E is found in wheat germ, whole grains (brown rice, cornmeal,
oatmeal, and wheat), vegetable oils (soybean, corn, and cottonseed), egg
yolk, butter, milk fat, meat (especially liver), dark green leafy vegetables,
legumes, nuts, and seeds.
Vitamin E enhancers are vitamin A, B complex vitamins, vitamin C, magnesium,
manganese, selenium, inositol, and essential fatty acids. For optimal
vitamin E absorption, excessive fat intake should be avoided, as well
as birth control pills and the chronic use of mineral oil.
Vitamin K—modulates calcium
levels; reduces inflammation, C-reactive protein (CRP), IL-6, the risk
of thrombosis, and the progression to valvular stenosis; and has a role
in glucose management
As important as calcium is as a hypotensive and antiarrhythmic mineral,
it has a detrimental side if it seeps into arteries. Arterial calcification,
common to the aging process, is a risk factor leading to the development
of heart disease, atherosclerosis, and mitral and aortic valve stenosis.
Researchers recently reported the results of a comprehensive study evaluating
2213 individuals over a 10.4-year period in regard to coronary calcium
levels. Those with a calcium score in the fourth quartile were 3.7 times
more likely to die over the 10 years than were individuals in the first
quartile (Buenano et al. 2000).
Harvard Medical School announced that about 25% of adults over 65 years
of age have arterial calcification, increasing their risk of severe heart
disease 50% (Harvard Heart Letter 1999). However, the Framingham Heart
Study determined that the risks imposed by thoracic aortic calcification
are not restricted to senior subjects; 35-year-old men with aortic calcification
had 7 times the risk of dying of a sudden heart attack (Witteman et al.
1990).
The cumulative results of 8 years of research determined that women
with severe kyphosis (increased convexity in the curvature of the thoracic
spine) increased their risk of pulmonary death (likely a blood clot) by
2.6 times. Compared with women who were fracture-free, those with one
or more vertebral fractures had a 1.23 times greater mortality rate. Mortality
increased as the number of fractures increased (Kado et al. 1999).
It was also noted that women with atherosclerotic calcification had
7% less bone mass. Dutch researchers connected the dots and determined
that postmenopausal women with calcification in bone tissue and atherosclerotic
vessels had diminished vitamin K levels. It was concluded that vitamin
K status affects the mineralization process in both bone and atherosclerotic
plaque (Jie et al. 1996).
Vitamin K, an underutilized fat-soluble vitamin, overcomes the pathological
effects of a calcium imbalance by promoting the deposition of calcium
in its primary site (bone) and out of arterial walls.
Note: Because
of the number of individuals using anticoagulants, it is important to
note that warfarin (Coumadin) caused extensive arterial calcification
in laboratory animals (Howe et al. 2000). Humans on long-term warfarin
therapy may be at an increased risk for developing arterial calcification
due to a drug-induced vitamin K deficiency.
So interrelated is bone loss to cardiovascular disease that measuring
bone density has become a predictive factor for cardiovascular health.
If bone density deviates one standard from the norm, the risk of stroke
increases 3 times (Mitchell 2000). Vitamin K thus emerges as a star player
in cardiovascular health, keeping calcium in bones and out of arteries
and valves. Note: Be aware that the risks imposed by low bone density
have no gender preference. Low bone density is a strong and independent
predictor of all-cause and cardiovascular mortality in both men and women
(Trivedi et al. 2001).
A group of animals with induced atherosclerosis were given vitamin K
(100 mg/kg of body weight), vitamin E (40mg/kg), or a placebo to assess
reversal of the atherosclerotic process. At the conclusion of the study,
the control group showed aortic calcium of 17.5 microns/mg; those receiving
vitamin K had approximately 1 micron/mg of calcium, and vitamin E reduced
it even further (Seyama et al. 1999) (for more information relating to
valvular calcification, consult the section devoted to Valvular Disease
in this protocol).
With age, the levels of IL-6 increase. This creates an imbalance between
anti-inflammatory and pro-inflammatory cytokines (Ferrucci et al. 1999).
Disproportionate numbers of good and bad cytokines increase inflammation,
as well as bone degradation.
IL-6 is germane to this untoward sequence, promoting not only the inflammatory
process, but also bone resorption, that is, the loss of substance from
the skeletal system (Paule 2001). Vitamin K reduces the levels of IL-6;
subsequently, the assault targeted at bone, as well as inflammation (a
risk factor for both cardiovascular disease and cancer) is reduced (Reddi
et al. 1995). Since C-reactive protein (CRP) is synthesized in response
to IL-6, it appears vitamin K may be valuable in reducing elevations in
CRP, as well.
Japanese researchers also found that a vitamin K deficiency can mimic
the symptoms of diabetes. (The pancreas, which produces insulin, has the
second highest levels of vitamin K in the body.) Low levels of vitamin
K appear to induce a tendency toward a poor early insulin response and
late hyperinsulinemia, following a glucose load in laboratory animals
(Sakamoto et al. 1999). Lastly, vitamin K's antioxidant powers are rated
(by some) as superior to either vitamin E or coenzyme Q10, other highly
respected free-radical fighters (Mukai et al. 1993).
Typically, vitamin K would not be indicated if a patient is on anticoagulant
therapy. However, The Lancet reported that asymptomatic patients on warfarin
should consider low-dose vitamin K if blood-clotting time, as measured
by the international normalized ratio (INR), is 4.5-10.0 (Crowther et
al. 2000). Follow-up studies to determine the success of vitamin K therapy
(1 mg a per day) showed that 4% of the patients who received vitamin K
therapy had bleeding episodes, compared with 17% of those in the placebo
group. The conclusion of the study was that low-dose vitamin K, an inexpensive
intervention without known toxicity, might prevent a hemorrhage in patients
on warfarin therapy.
A suggested vitamin K dosage for patients not on anticoagulant therapy
is 10 mg a per day.
Reader's guide to vitamin K food
sources and antagonists
Friendly bacteria in the intestines synthesize the majority of vitamin
K. However, persistent low-grade levels of intestinal bacteria in the
small intestine could hamper vitamin K synthesis. Acidophilus cultures
in the form of yogurt or kefir serve not only as a good food source, but
also ensure that sufficient friendly intestinal flora are present for
vitamin K production.
Green leafy vegetables are vitamin K-rich; other sources include alfalfa,
egg yolks, blackstrap molasses, asparagus, Brussels sprouts, cauliflower,
oatmeal, and rye. Antibiotics increase the need for vitamin K, and vitamin
E (doses greater than 600 IU) antagonizes vitamin K activity.
The calcium paradox
It is important to look at the ways calcium can become an atheromatous
material. Most body stores of calcium are found in the bones and teeth,
and 1% is found in the bloodstream. This 1% performs so many vital functions,
including cardiac health, that the body vigorously defends this minute
percentage. If inadequate calcium is available, vitamin D is mobilized
in the kidney and rushes to the intestinal wall to pull more calcium into
the bloodstream. If inadequate amounts of vitamin D are available, the
parathyroid gland delivers a message to bones to release calcium. Because
the calcium mass in the bone is so great, it is easy for too much of the
mineral to be extracted, overwhelming the amount needed in the blood.
After compensating for deficiencies, the excess calcium ties up binds
in soft tissues, the lining of arteries, and brain tissue.
Poor calcium regulation also affects arterial plaque, causing it to
become harder but more brittle (Harvard Heart Letter 1999). This occurs
as calcium deposits in the blood attach to cholesterol deposits on the
walls of arteries, making an almost impenetrable union (Shappell 2000).
This process further narrows the artery, causing symptoms ranging from
fainting spells to sudden death due to abrupt changes in blood pressure
(Doss 2001).
It is important to grasp that excesses of calcium (potentiating arterial
disease) come essentially from the bone. Furthermore, the results of a
test indicating adequate blood calcium levels can be totally misleading,
for the supply may have been extracted from the skeletal system. Because
secondary pathways, important in maintaining homeostasis, are not well
- regulated, it is imperative to maintain adequate calcium levels without
summoning the parathyroid gland into service.
Zinc—is important in weight
and blood pressure management, regulates glucose and insulin levels, and
increases testosterone
Zinc, the second most abundant trace mineral in the body, is important
in glucose and insulin management, as well as weight control. Individuals
with the lowest dietary intake of zinc showed the greatest prevalence
of coronary artery disease, diabetes, and obesity; conversely, as patients
made corrections to include more zinc in their dietary program, blood
pressure, blood glucose, triglycerides, and central abdominal obesity
decreased (Challem et al. 2000).
Zinc is a vital component of insulin, but its worth extends to the cellular
receptors, where zinc increases insulin sensitivity. When zinc levels
are too low, the pancreas cannot supply enough insulin to control blood
glucose levels, and the amount that is produced is less functional (Challem
2000).
However, the emphasis is upon correcting a zinc deficiency, not dosing
at will. The journal Diabetes reported that administering large doses
of zinc sulfate (220 mg 3 times a day, 90 mg of actual zinc) increased
fasting blood glucose levels in Type II diabetic patients from an average
of 177 mg/dL to -207 mg/dL (Raz et al. 1989). Glycosylated hemoglobin
levels also increased among a group of Type I diabetics receiving 50 mg
of zinc a day (Cunningham et al. 1994). Considering these poor statistics,
if prediabetic or diabetic, use no more than 35 mg of zinc a day without
close blood glucose monitoring.
Zinc assists in controlling weight through various mechanisms. According
to Jack Challem (the nutrition reporter), zinc is a copper antagonist
(meaning it competes with copper for intestinal absorption). Challem states
that this is significant because in test tube and animal experiments,
excess copper increases fat (or triglyceride) synthesis from sugar. Zinc
supplementation lowers copper levels, so it may decrease the synthesis
of triglycerides, which show up as either triglycerides in the bloodstream
or fat on the body (Challem 2000).
Lower androgen levels have an adverse effect on lipid metabolism, coagulative
function, and insulin sensitivity. For the cardiovascular patient with
low testosterone levels, a healthier heart profile may emerge with either
testosterone therapy or supplementation to increase androgen levels (Xu
et al. 2001). The benefits of zinc as an androgen potentiator were exemplified
when 22 men with chronically low testosterone levels were given 50 mg
of zinc sulfate daily for 45-50 days to promote fertility. (The 22 had
experienced infertility longer than 5 years.) All 22 experienced a significant
increase in testosterone levels during zinc therapy. In fact, nine of
the 22 wives became pregnant during the study (Netter et al. 1981).
It appears that zinc therapy, although beneficial to most, is not risk-free.
Occasionally, emphasizing zinc without copper can lead to copper-deficiency
anemia, lower levels of HDL, and higher levels of LDL cholesterol; for
some, the lack of balance between the two trace minerals can result in
an irregular heartbeat (Klevay 1975). Copper is not risk-free either:
it can potentiate free-radical activity.
Epidemiologic and metabolic data are convincing concerning the theory
that a zinc-copper imbalance is a major factor in the etiology of coronary
heart disease. For this reason, if consuming over 50 mg of zinc daily,
2 mg of copper is recommended several times a week. Since copper is widely
distributed in selected foods, such as poultry, organ meats, shellfish,
oysters, chocolate, nuts, dried legumes, and cereals, 2 mg a per day can
usually be obtained by favoring dietary selections from this list.
Reader's guide to zinc food sources,
enhancers, and antagonists.
Zinc content is highest in flesh foods, such as meats, poultry, liver,
and oysters. Legumes and whole grain products are also sources of zinc,
but larger quantities must be consumed to deliver significant amounts.
Other good sources of zinc per kilocalorie ( according to Whitney et al.
1998) are spinach, broccoli, green peas, green beans, tomato juice, plain
yogurt, Swiss cheese, tofu, shrimp, and crab.
Vitamins A, B3, B6, and C, as well as calcium, copper, magnesium, essential
fatty acids, and essential amino acids enhance zinc absorption. Alcohol,
oral contraceptives, excesses of copper and calcium, saturated and trans
fats, steroids, obesity, and smoking interfere with zinc utilization.
Diarrhea, kidney disease, cirrhosis of the liver, and diabetes can also
contribute to a zinc deficiency.
AUXILiARY FACTORS THAT AFFECT
CARDIOVASCULAR HEALTH
Anemia—a predictor of death
from acute heart attack
Anemia reflects a reduction below normal in the number of red blood cells,
hemoglobin level, or hematocrit (a measure of the packed cell volume of
red cells in blood). Hematocrit has emerged as an extremely important
assessment in targeting individuals at high risk of succumbing to a heart
attack (Wu et al. 2001).
Note: A
normal hematocrit is between 36-50%; below 36% indicates anemia.
A study reported in the New England Journal of Medicine evaluated 78,974
patients, ages 65 and older, who were hospitalized with acute myocardial
infarction. Patients were categorized according to hematocrit upon admission.
Researchers considered the prognostic value of hematocrit percentages
as well as the impact of blood transfusions on 30-day mortality. Their
findings follow:
| Hematocrit Percentages as Predictor of
Cardiac Survival |
| Hematocrit 5.0%-24.0% = 78% chance of
patient dying within 30 days |
| Hematocrit 24.1%-27.0% = 52% chance of
patient dying within 30 days |
| Hematocrit 30.1%-33.0% = 31% chance of
patient dying within 30 days |
| Hematocrit >33.1% = No increased risk
|
| Reduction in Cardiac Mortality Following
Transfusion |
| Note: Transfusion
benefits with increased severity of anemia. |
| Patients with hematocrit < 24% reduced
mortality 64% with transfusion. |
| Patients with hematocrit 24.1-27% reduced
mortality 31%. |
| Patients with hematocrit 27.1-30% reduced
mortality 25%. |
It should be emphasized that transfusion therapy is only effective in
reducing cardiac mortality among anemic patients; mortality actually increased
when transfusions were given to nonanemic patients.
Does Sodium Restriction Lower
Blood Pressure?
An evaluation of a hypertensive patient should include measuring plasma
renin activity (PRA) to determine if renin is a factor in the pathogenesis
of elevated blood pressure. In order to stimulate renin release, the individual
is told to follow a diet very low in sodium for 3 days prior to the test.
Normal values of adult plasma renin, measured in an upright position and
sodium-depleted, are 2.9-10.8 ng/mL an hour.
Renin is an enzyme secreted by the juxtaglomerular apparatus of the
kidney in response to many cardiovascular factors, such as a fall in blood
pressure, reduced plasma volume, and/or sodium depletion. In an attempt
to maintain homeostasis, renin is released, increasing the conversion
of angiotensinogen to angiotensin I. Angiotensin I is then converted to
angiotensin II, which in turn causes an increase in aldosterone secretion,
a sequence that increases peripheral vascular resistance and blood pressure.
Patients with low renin levels respond best to sodium restriction and
diuretic therapy. Those with high baseline renin levels will not respond
to sodium restriction. According to Jeff Bland, Ph.D., most individuals
who have essential hypertension are not salt sensitive. Putting those
individuals on a rigorous salt-restricted diet has little impact on their
hypertension. Conversely, if an individual is salt sensitive, sodium restriction
will have a profound effect upon modulating blood pressure. This is an
example of matching an appropriate dietary program with the right genotype
(Bland 2000b).
Acknowledging that dietary salt appears to account s for a minor but
only a minor segment of increased blood pressure in hypertensive people,
it has been proposed that a the larger segment of essential hypertension
is caused by enhanced renal sodium retention prompted by hyperinsulinemia.
Insulin resistance may also play a role by altering internal sodium and
potassium distribution in a direction associated with increased peripheral
vascular resistance (Zavaroni et al. 1992; Lukaczer 2000). Researchers
were able to demonstrate that blood pressure increased or decreased when
lesser or greater amounts of insulin were administered to obese, hypertensive
patients (Tedde et al. 1989; Randeree et al. 1992).
The most effective dietary treatment for hypertension appears to be
weight loss and a dietary intervention to increase calcium, magnesium,
and potassium intake. Results of the Dietary Approaches to Stop Hypertension
(DASH) study showed that a diet rich in fruits, vegetables, and low-fat
dairy products significantly lowered blood pressure. These foods are excellent
sources of potassium, magnesium, and calcium, accounting for the success
of the diet. In the study, blood pressure was reduced by 5.6 mmHg and
2.8 mmHg (systolic and diastolic pressures), making dietary intervention
comparable to first generation antihypertensives. Weight loss and dietary
manipulation appears to control hypertension in nearly one-half of individuals
with high blood pressure (Bland 2000a).
Can What You Drink Make a Difference?
Alcohol.
Endorsing alcohol consumption is difficult considering the number of health
risks imposed by drinking. But when considering the health of the heart
and vascular system, statistics appear to flip in favor of moderate alcohol
consumption. Studies involving atherosclerosis (disease authenticated
by cardiac catheterization or autopsy) show less arterial closure among
persons who consume moderate amounts of alcohol. A moderate drinker, in
fact, decreases the possibility of heart disease by 30-50% (Gaziano 1993;
Pearson 1996). This is true for both men and women, particularly imbibers
middle-aged or older.
As encouraging as this information is, the line is extremely narrow
in regard to the amount of alcohol one can consume and still reap benefits.
For example, teetotalers or occasional drinkers lose the alcohol advantage
because of inconsistent consumption. Conversely, persons consuming 3 or
more drinks a day experience a rapid rise in total morbidity, that is,
cardiomyopathy, hypertension, and hyperhomocysteinemia, as well as mortality.
The bottom line indicates that nondrinkers, as well as individuals who
aggressively imbibe, have a higher risk of succumbing from heart disease
than an individual consuming 1-2 drinks a day (Rimm et al. 1996).
It is speculated that about 50% of the protective nature of alcohol
is due to alcohol's ability to increase HDL cholesterol (Gordon et al.
1981). An additional edge comes by reducing blood glucose and insulin
levels (Facchini et al. 1994). It appears that no advantage is gained
from alcohol in regard to lowering either blood pressure or LDL cholesterol
levels, but the blood clotting mechanism is altered by alcohol consumption
(Renaud et al. 1992; Ridker et al. 1994). It is debatable how alcohol
accomplishes this. Perhaps it is by influencing coagulation factors, such
as PAI-1, t-PA, and the activity of platelets.
Reports appearing in The Lancet added to the benefits obtained from
alcohol, citing the antioxidants found in red wine and dark beer (Maxwell
et al. 1994). Antioxidants, regardless of their source, always play heroic
roles in heart health. Interestingly, alcohol is still able to convey
a cardiovascular advantage, even in light of a poor diet or cigarette
smoking.
Is alcohol the utopia we are all searching for? Probably not, considering
the dangers imposed by excessive consumption. Persons with a personal
or family history of alcoholism and those with hypertriglyceridemia, pancreatitis,
liver disease, certain blood disorders, or hypertension, as well as pregnant
women, are not candidates for either beginning or continuing to drink
alcohol. Those on diets should not forget that alcohol is a significant
source of calories as well as carbohydrates. It is also important to recall
that drug and alcohol interactions can be fatal. Yet, after acknowledging
the negatives, if current consumers of alcohol all abstained from drinking,
about 80,000 additional heart deaths would occur annually (Pearson et
al. 1994). Although the research is compelling, alcohol should never be
considered to be a treatment for either Syndrome X or heart disease.
Green Tea
The pleasure of a cup of green tea is well accepted, but it appears to
accomplish far more than satisfy the palate. Published literature confirms
the hypolipidemic nature of green tea, reporting decreases in triglycerides
and LDL cholesterol, while increasing the beneficial HDL cholesterol.
In addition, green tea suppressed the oxidation of LDL cholesterol, further
deterring the atherosclerotic process (Chan et al. 1999).
Some researchers liken green tea to aspirin because of similar therapeutic
qualities. Information published in Beyond Aspirin (Newmark et al. 2000),
states that green tea contains salicylic acid, a naturally occurring COX-2
inhibitor. Green tea, like aspirin, inhibits thromboxane A2; the inhibition
of thromboxane A2 lessens the risks of blood clot formation and the dangers
imposed by arterial constriction.
Heart attacks and strokes are less likely to occur if neither fibrinogen
levels nor the activity of platelet-activating factor (PAF) become excessive.
Green tea lowers fibrinogen levels and is a PAF inhibitor. A 4-year study
involving 5910 Japanese women (ages 40 and older) showed twice as many
strokes among trial participants who used less green tea (less than 5
cups a day) than in those who used more (greater than or equal to 5 cups
daily) (Sato et al. 1989).
A cup of green tea appears to be beneficial to hypertensives through
various mechanisms. The loss of arterial elasticity (arteriosclerosis)
is one cause of high blood pressure. Youthful arteries expand and contract
in compliance with the heartbeat to move blood to peripheral sites. Damaged
vessels are unable to participate in this ritual. Green tea (by inhibiting
thromboxane) reduces arterial constriction and consequently blood pressure
is reduced. Also many antihypertensive drugs are ACE inhibitors, meaning
angiotensin pathways are disrupted. Without interruption of this feedback
loop, blood vessels vasoconstrict, water is retained, and blood pressure
increases. Green tea breaks this sequence, acting as a natural (although
mild) ACE inhibitor (Duke Database 1992; Faloon 2000).
The 1st International Symposium on Green Tea (September 22, 1989) reported
that green tea reduces blood glucose levels. During the ensuing years,
the Life Extension Foundation has frequently informed members that green
tea reduces the expected glucose and insulin rise after a carbohydrate
load. It should also be noted that green tea contains chemicals regarded
as beta-adrenergic receptor blockers, anti-inflammatories, diuretics,
and calcium antagonists, proving beneficial in arrhythmias and hypertension
(Duke Database 1992).
Green tea, an antioxidant, helps remove excess iron from the liver (Carper
2001). Individuals with hemochromatosis should drink several cups or use
two to four 300-mg capsules a day. (Each capsule should provide 95% active
polyphenols.) Note: Research suggests that decaffeinated green tea has
a different therapeutic disposition than that containing caffeine and
may be more effective in reducing iron overload. Caffeine drinks are not
appropriate for sympathetic dominant individuals and those taking beta-adrenergic
drugs.
As similar as green tea and aspirin are in their defensive mechanisms,
it would not be wise for an individual, relying on aspirin as a cardio-protective,
to depend only on green tea to the exclusion of aspirin.
Nuts: A Heart Food
According to a report published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition,
one of the most unexpected and novel findings in nutritional epidemiology
in the past 5 years has been that nut consumption protects against ischemic
heart disease (IHD) (Sabate 1999). Phytonutrients in nuts, such as luteolin
(a flavonoid), tocotrienols, fiber, fatty acids, amino acids, and vitamins
and minerals, appear to work synergistically to provide heart protection,
lower blood pressure, reduce the risk of stroke, and increase longevity.
The protective effect of nuts applies to men and women (both black and
Caucasian), all age groups, smokers, and sedentary individuals.
Of the tree nuts, walnuts are unique because they are a rich source
of linolenic acid. Almonds are a good source of vitamin E and calcium;
peanuts provide folate (important in controlling homocysteine) and resveratrol
(inhibits blood clots and the inflammatory process). Nuts are also good
sources of arginine and fiber (Kris-Etherton 1999).
The Adventist's Health Study reported that individuals who ate nuts
1-4 times a week reduced their risk of acute myocardial infarction 22%
(Fraser et al. 1992). Eating nuts more than 5 times a week resulted in
a 51% lower cardiac risk compared to individuals who consumed nuts less
than 1 time a week. Persons consuming nuts more than 5 times a week reduced
their lifetime IHD risk 12%, and men who developed the disease did so
5.6 years later than men who consumed nuts infrequently.
In 1993, the New England Journal of Medicine published results of a
walnut study conducted at Loma Linda University . All trial participants
conformed to the National Cholesterol Education Program Step 1 Diet, except
that 20% of the calories of one diet were derived from walnuts, offset
by lesser amounts of fatty foods. Both diets contained identical foods
and macronutrients, except for the addition of walnuts in the test diet.
At the conclusion of the study, participants eating the walnut diet
had total cholesterol levels 22.4 mg/dL (12.4%) lower and LDL cholesterol
levels 18.2 mg/dL (16.3%) lower than those consuming the control diet.
Blood pressure was unaffected on either diet. Researchers noted that subjects
on the walnut diet, despite increased energy intake, did not gain weight
(Sabate et al. 1993). Comment: Nuts, in general, are healthy foods, but
select those not roasted at high temperatures in oils of uncertain quality.
The Journal of the American Medical Association recently expanded the
potential benefits of higher nut and peanut butter consumption, showing
a significantly reduced risk for Type II diabetes among women who regularly
include nuts in their diet (Jiang et al. 2002).
Autonomic Balancing: Right Messages,
Good Results
The autonomic nervous system, consisting of the parasympathetic (PNS)
and the sympathetic divisions (SNS), play major roles in heart function.
For example, when the PNS is active, heartbeat, blood pressure, and respiration
rate tend to be decreased, as well as the activity of the adrenal glands.
Conversely, when the SNS is dominant, the brain alerts the adrenal glands
(small organs located on top of the kidneys) to supply adrenaline, the
stress hormone. Adrenaline rushes through the bloodstream to all tissues,
organs, and glands, heightening their responsiveness. Subsequently, blood
pressure, heart rate, blood glucose levels, respiration, and perspiration
increase. It is referred to as the "fight or flight" division
because a general state of excitement and preparedness is evidenced.
If the individual is healthy, an adrenaline surge is inconsequential.
But, if the heart is diseased or damaged, the sympathetic stimuli can
be dangerous, even deadly. Type A individuals often live with chronic
stimulation of the SNS, a burdening handicap to long-term survival. Note:
Interesting data released from the Stanford University School of Medicine
showed that insulin-resistant individuals, with compensatory hyperinsulinemia,
have a higher nocturnal heart rate, a finding consistent with the possibility
that increased heart rates are secondary to insulin-induced sympathetic
activity (Facchini et al. 1996b).
Although each of us is born with a propensity toward a sympathetic,
parasympathetic, or balanced response from the autonomic nervous system
(ANS), Dr. Nicholas Gonzalez (an authority on autonomic balancing) is
finding that chemical pollutants and life-style abuses can shift balance
and disrupt the natural tendency of the individual. If either division
becomes abrasively dominant, the risks imposed upon the heart can be meaningful.
For example, if the PNS becomes overly dominant, the risks are as genuine
as if the SNS were over -expressed. A heart receiving its instructions
from the PNS may become a bit passive, and cardiac output lethargic. Unable
to cope with a one-sided response from the ANS, the heart can make fatal
errors.
The SNS and PNS are a two-neuron system, meaning that two sets of nerves
interconnect in the ganglion. Minerals play an extremely important role
in the message sent to organs and glands from the ANS. For example, Dr.
Gonzalez explains that magnesium blocks transmission between the two nerves
and the ganglion and is regarded as the very best turn-off for sympathetic
arousal. On the other hand, calcium arouses activity in the SNS. Potassium,
although not a sympathetic toner, acts directly upon the PNS, encouraging
increased responsiveness. Exercise quiets the SNS, burning off sympathetic
hormones and making stronger parasympathetic expression.
The pH of a parasympathetic dominant tends to be alkaline; the pH of
a sympathetic dominant migrates toward acidity. This principle may best
explain the benefit some cardiac patients gain when eating a predominantly
fruit and vegetable diet, with protein sources limited to smaller amounts
of fish and chicken. The alkalinity of a plant-based diet makes the response
from the PNS stronger and the activity in the SNS more subdued. Conversely,
red meat turns on the SNS and is beneficial to an individual with an overactive
parasympathetic response. In fact, Dr. Gonzalez feels a cholesterol level
between 210-220 mg/dL is fitting for a parasympathetic because the cholesterol
then assumes the nature of a powerful antioxidant.
A cardiac patient should seek counsel with a physician who can determine
metabolic type. A physician who can make this determination will also
make cohesive choices regarding supplements, diet, and exercise, eliminating
conflicting messages being delivered to the heart. Note: Tapes of Dr.
Gonzalez's lectures, addressing the ANS in-depth, may be purchased from
Conference Recording Service Inc., (800) 647-1110 or at www.conferencerecording.com.
Although the lectures focus on treating cancer, the tapes are extremely
interesting and informative.
Beta-Blockers
Since over-expression of the adrenergic system (increasing sympathetic
activity) can provoke an irregular heartbeat, scientists have searched
for drugs that could block its activity. Propranolol became the granddaddy
of the family of beta-blockers and is one of the most prescribed drugs
in America for arrhythmias, hypertension, and angina pectoris.
Beta-blockers bind to specific receptors on nerve endings in an effort
to control blood pressure, anxiety, and arrhythmias occurring before or
after a heart attack. The binding process blocks the effects of impulses
transmitted by the adrenergic postganglionic fibers of the SNS. As beta-blockers
compete with epinephrine (also known as adrenaline) for receptor sites,
the excit atory nature of epinephrine is curtailed. Beta-adrenergic receptors
are located mainly in the heart, lungs, kidneys, and blood vessels (PDR
1999).
Conventional cardiologists conducting propranolol studies reported satisfaction
with beta-blockers, citing fewer second heart attacks among users and
a 26% reduction in heart mortality. Many patients were less pleased with
beta-blockers, describing clinical depression, erectile dysfunction, and
fatigue as compromising factors. Also, beta-blockers have been associated
with an increased risk of developing diabetes by impairing insulin sensitivity.
Newer beta-blocking drugs such as Toprol are now considered superior to
p Propranolol.
Calcium Channel Blockers
The heart is controlled by tiny electrical impulses that regulate the
heart, not unlike a pacemaker. Calcium plays a key role in regulating
the heart's response to these electrical signals. It flows between the
heart cells and surrounding fluid through a sort of chemical turnstile,
or calcium channel. The more calcium that gets through the turnstile before
the electrical signal is received, the more strongly the heart contracts,
an effort that increases the heart's workload. Calcium channel blockers
do not totally block movement through the turnstile, but they significantly
slows it down. For some, this process lessens the labor required of a
damaged heart, signaling it to slow down and take it easy. Because calcium
channel blockers dilate the arteries and reduce resistance to blood flow,
they are also widely used to control hypertension. The FDA first approved
calcium channel blockers in 1982 for the purpose of treating arrhythmias.
While most of the literature (cautiously) supports calcium channel blockers,
a few clinicians adamantly oppose their usage. According to Gabe Mirkin,
M.D., calcium channel blockers are classified as short-, intermediate-,
and long-acting. Older studies showed that short- and intermediate-acting
calcium channel blockers might increase the risk of heart attacks; a more
recent study showed that longer-acting calcium channel blockers might
as well (Estacio et al. 1998). Patients were followed for 67 months, at
which time the Drug and Safety Monitoring Committee detected a significant
difference in the rate of heart attacks among patients treated with nisoldipine
(a long-acting calcium channel blocker) compared with those treated with
enalapril (an ACE inhibitor). The termination of nisoldipine treatment
was recommended, and patients receiving nisoldipine were switched to enalapril.
Professor Bruce Psaty ( University of Washington ) reported that the
risk of a heart attack increased up to 60% among 2655 hypertensive patients
taking calcium channel blockers (Psaty et al. 1995). In addition, The
Lancet reported that calcium channel blockers, often hailed as an ace
in cardiac pharmacology, appear to increase the risk of developing cancer
(Pahor et al. 1996). Among 5000 men and women enrolled in a verapamil,
diltiazem, and nifedipine study, the risk of cancer increased by about
72% (Atkins 1996c).
Other side effects associated with both calcium channel blockers and
beta-blockers are congestive heart failure , (CHF), lightheadedness, fatigue,
low blood pressure, shortness of breath, and bradycardia (heartbeat less
than 60 beats a minute). Although not enough studies exist to prove that
calcium channel blockers cause heart attacks or increase the risk of cancer,
the research is strong enough for doctors to use calcium channel blockers
with the utmost caution (Mirkin 2002b).
Dispersed throughout the Therapeutic section are a few of the herbs
(containing one or more chemicals) considered beta-adrenergic receptor
blockers or calcium antagonists. The literature also supports magnesium
as a SNS inhibitor as well as a calcium antagonist (Whitaker 1995b; Duke
2000; Gonzalez 2000). Researchers state that carnitine may provide independent
benefit in ischemia when used as monotherapy or additional benefit when
used in combination with conventional beta-blockers or calcium antagonists
(Jackson 2001). Never should drug therapy be stopped and a nutraceutical
started without counsel with a qualified physician.
Calcium blocking activity
Angelica, garlic, ginger, ginkgo biloba, grape seed, green tea (Camellia
sinensis), hawthorn, magnesium, and olive leaf
Beta-blocking activity
Grape seed, green tea, hawthorn, and magnesium
RISK FACTORS ASSOCIATED WITH
PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
Many people are unaware that there may be risks associated with taking
commonly prescribed prescription medications. In addition, once-daily
dosing of certain drugs such as anti-hypertensive agents may not provide
24-hour protection against arterial damage. Individuals who are currently
taking any of the medications described in this section are urged to discuss
alternative treatment options with their physician.
Nitroglycerin Drugs and Angina
Angina is a sudden intense pain in the chest that is often accompanied
by a feeling of suffocation. Angina is caused by a momentary lack of adequate
blood supply to the heart muscle. Individuals who have occluded coronary
arteries often experience periodic bouts of angina.
Nitroglycerin temporarily dilates blood vessels and reduces workload
on the heart. As early as 1879, nitroglycerin was administered to an angina
patient (Kipple 1993). Nitroglycerin worked so well that nitroglycerin
and other "nitrate" drugs have been used as standard angina
therapy ever since. Unfortunately, while these nitrate drugs do provide
temporary relief from angina, regular use of nitrate drugs may increase
the risk of a future heart attack.
A startling new finding came from a Japanese study that involved 518
patients with suspected coronary artery disease (Murakami et al. 2002).
The patients were categorized into groups based on their degree of endothelial
dysfunction (a measurement of inner arterial wall damage) and the use
of nitrate drugs.
These 518 patients were followed for 45 months to ascertain which patients
were more likely to experience major cardiovascular events. As expected,
patients with severe endothelial dysfunction had significantly more heart
attacks, strokes, bypass surgeries, congestive heart failure, etc. However,
the surprising finding was that those who regularly used nitrate drugs
were 2.42 times more likely to experience major cardiovascular events.
The researchers concluded that the effects of nitrate drugs accelerated
atherogenic processes and endothelial dysfunction and that use of nitrate
drugs caused future cardiovascular events (Murakami et al. 2002).
Millions of Americans with coronary artery disease have been prescribed
nitrate drugs. However, there is now evidence that nitrate drugs actually
accelerate arterial wall damage (endothelial dysfunction) and thus contribute
to progression of coronary artery disease--the very disorder that the
nitrate drugs have been prescribed to alleviate.
Angina patients who rely on nitrate drugs should bring this new information
to the attention of their physician. It is important to note that occasional
use of a nitrate drug to relieve angina symptoms was not shown to be dangerous
in the most recent study. It was the regular use of a nitrate or nitroglycerin
drug that increased the risk of heart attack by 2.42 times within a 45-month
period (Murakami et al. 2002).
| Commonly Prescribed Nitrate Drugs |
| A 2002 study indicating danger from nitrate
drugs referred to regular use rather than occasional use (Murakami
et al. 2002). It is highly unlikely that occasional use of a nitrate
drug to relieve angina symptoms would cause a problem. However, regular
use of a nitrate or nitroglycerin drug more than doubled the risk
of heart attack or other pathological vascular event. Commonly prescribed
nitrate and nitroglycerin drugs are: |
| Isosorbide Nitro-Dur Transdermal Infusion |
| Isosorbide Dinitrate Nitrolingual Pump
Spray |
| Isosorbide Mononitrate Nitrostat tablets |
Nitroglycerin patches Minitran Transdermal
Delivery
System |
For information about an FDA-approved technique that has been shown
to safely reduce angina symptoms, refer to "A Non-Invasive Alternative
to Coronary Bypass Surgery" in the May 2003 issue of Life Extension
Magazine (pp. 54-60). This article may also be accessed at www.lef.org.
Dietary supplements that have been shown to help protect against endothelial
dysfunction include:
- Folic acid (Title et al. 2000a; Woo et al. 2002)
- Vitamin C (Richartz et al. 2001; Pullin et al. 2002)
- Vitamin E (Title et al. 2000b; Raghuveer et al. 2001)
- Arginine (Maxwell et al. 2000; Kawano et al. 2002; Lekakis et al.
2002)
- Taurine (Wang et al. 1996; Fennessy et al. 2003)
- Fish oil (Chin et al. 1994; Morita et al. 2001;
Goodfellow et al. 2000)
It should be pointed out that if left untreated, endothelial dysfunction
may become so severe that it will not be possible to reverse it with currently
available therapies.
The term endothelial dysfunction is increasingly being described in
scientific journals as a significant underlying cause of most forms of
cardiovascular disease, including hypertension, atherosclerosis, and congestive
heart failure.
Class I Anti-Arrhythmic Drugs Kill
Thousands
In the June 1995 issue of Life Extension Magazine, an article exposed
the dangers of a class of anti-arrhythmic drugs the FDA had approved to
prevent lethal heart arrhythmias (LEF 1995). In this 1995 article, evidence
was introduced that the FDA knew of the risks these drugs posed, but had
approved them anyway. When the FDA was confronted with accusations that
these drugs had been improperly approved, the reply was that the FDA had
a theory that these drugs would save the lives of more people by preventing
abnormal heartbeats than the drugs would kill by causing abnormal heartbeats.
The problem was that the FDA had no evidence that these drugs would save
even a single life.
Even after a large study conducted by the National Heart, Lung and Blood
Institute showed that anti-arrhythmic drugs had killed large numbers of
Americans, the FDA's response was not to remove the drugs, but to merely
suggest changes in the labeling of the drugs (CAST 1989; NHLBI. 2002).
True to its word, the FDA did mandate a change in the labeling of at
least one of these anti-arrhythmic drugs (Tambocor®). On page 1889
of the year 2003 Physician's Desk Reference, a large warning box appears
containing the following statement:
"An excessive mortality or non-fatal cardiac arrest was seen in
patients treated with Tambocor compared with that seen in patients assigned
to a carefully matched placebo-treated group. This rate was 16/315 (5.1%)
for Tambocor and 7/309 (2.3%) for the matched placebo."
What this warning means is that if you take Tambocor (flecainide), your
risk of dying or experiencing a heart attack is more than double compared
to taking a placebo.
The sordid history of the FDA's approval of Tambocor and other lethal
Class I anti-arrhythmic drugs is chronicled in the book Deadly Medicine
by Thomas J. Moore (1995).
Are You Taking the Proper Anti-Hypertensive
Medication?
The Life Extension Foundation has repeatedly warned persons with high
blood pressure (hypertension) to not depend on one-a-day dosing of anti-hypertensive
drugs because many of these drugs do not provide complete 24-hour protection.
When an anti-hypertensive drug wears off, the patient is vulnerable to
having a stroke. One solution to this problem is to take a lower dose
of the anti-hypertensive drug twice a day, even though the FDA claims
that one-a-day dosing is adequate.
Failure to keep blood pressure at optimal low levels (below 120/85)
dramatically increases mortality risk. The United States government states
that blood pressure readings as high as 140/90 are acceptable (CDC 2002),
but published results of human studies clearly show that maintaining levels
below 120/85 confer longevity and protection against heart attack and
stroke (Stamler et al. 1993; Stamler 1999).
The best-selling anti-hypertensive drugs in the United States are not
necessarily the most effective. Advertising by drug companies and physician
"force-of-habit" prescribing often result in hypertensive individuals
taking drugs that do not provide optimal blood pressure-lowering effects.
Life Extension long ago recommended a class of anti-hypertension drugs
known as angiotensi on II receptor blockers. Some of the first drugs approved
in this class w here Cozaar® and Hyzaar® and Life Extension has
suggested them as first line therapy. The only drawback to these drugs
was that they did not provide consistent one-a-day protection.
A new drug in this class is called Benicar®. A recent study indicated
that Benicar may be the first drug to provide true 24-hour blood pressure
reduction (Neutel et al. 2002). A typical starting dose of Benicar is
20 mg a day. For patients requiring further reduction in blood pressure,
the dose can be increased to 40 mg a day after 2 weeks.
Optimal control of hypertension requires blood pressure checks throughout
the day. This is the only way to be certain an anti-hypertensive drug
is not wearing off, endangering the arterial system. Even if you take
Benicar, it is still critical to verify that it is actually keeping your
blood pressure suppressed during an entire 24-hour period.
INVASIVE VERSUS NONINVASIVE
TESTING AND HEART PROCEDURES
Facts to Consider Before a Final
Decision Is Made
Invasive heart treatment ranks ninth among the top 10 causes of death.
Because of the obvious seriousness of any procedure involving the heart,
consenting to invasive testing and surgery should be made rationally rather
than emotionally. The intent of this protocol is not to steer the patient
in regard to cardiac testing and treatment but rather to enlighten the
reader concerning both options and risks. Fortunately, researchers have
removed many of the uncertainties from the dilemma.
The detection of a heart problem can be made by several noninvasive
tests, medical history, physical examination, electrocardiogram, stress
tests, blood tests, and an echocardiogram. An echocardiogram provides
a graphic outline of the movements of the heart structures, showing the
valves and the action of blood flowing through them, the ability of the
left ventricle to pump blood, the thickness of the walls of the heart
, (considering thickness), and an assessment of the membrane around the
heart (the pericardium). It does not show the coronary arteries well enough
to determine blood circulation directly to the heart. For this evaluation,
the echocardiogram should be combined with a cardiac stress test. This
combination will show the workings of the various parts of the heart during
stress compared to rest.
The blood tests are valuable because they confirm or refute uncertainties
arising from early-stage diagnosis of a heart attack. Creatine kinase
(CK), a small fraction of the CK enzyme an isozyme(CK-MB), and troponins
are heart damage markers or cardiac enzymes measurable in the blood. CK-MB
shows an increase above normal about 6 hours after the onset of a heart
attack. It typically reaches its peak level within 9-30 hours and usually
returns to normal within 48-72 hours (Cardiac Biomarkers 2000).
Blood tests to measure troponins, specifically troponin T (cTnT) and
troponin I (cTnI)--cardiac muscle proteins--have been developed. These
proteins control the interaction between actin and myosin, muscle proteins
that contract or squeeze the heart muscle. Identifying troponins specific
to heart muscle allowed for the development of blood assays that can detect
heart muscle injury with great sensitivity and specificity. The normally
low level of cTnT and cTnI increases substantially within 4-6 hours of
heart muscle damage. Peak levels occur at 14-20 hours, usually returning
to normal 5-7 days later (American Heart Association 2000; Cardiac Biomarkers
2000; Sobki et al. 2000).
It is now considered possible to use troponin testing to identify individuals
at either low or high risk for a coronary event. Even modestly elevated
troponin levels are associated with larger numbers of tiny coronary artery
blood clots, complex arterial lesions, and impaired blood flow through
the vasculature.
Compared to patients with the lowest levels of troponin T, those with
the highest troponin T levels are almost 13 times more likely to die over
a 37-month period (Lindahl et al. 2000). The type of troponin blood test
used by most clinical laboratories is troponin I. If levels exceed 0.4
ng/mL, antiplatelet and antithrombotic therapy should be considered. Nutrients
with an antiplatelet and antithrombotic therapeutic profile are highlighted
in the Therapeutic section of this protocol.
Researchers at University of Texas Southwestern Medical Center (Dallas)
have discovered another impressive cardiac marker, brain natriuretic peptide
(BNP), showing remarkable accuracy in regard to predicting cardiac morbidity
and mortality. BNP is a neurohormone synthesized in the muscular wall
of the left ventricle of the heart that is released into the circulation
in response to ventricular dilation and pressure overload. BNP, a counter
-regulatory hormone, promotes excretion of salt by the kidneys and dilates
blood vessels.
To determine the predictive value of BNP, 2525 patients were enrolled
in a study (half having experienced a heart attack and the other half
displaying unstable angina or chest pains). After a 30-day analysis, the
researchers found that levels of BNP were higher among patients who died.
Also, it was observed that patients with higher BNP were more likely to
have a new or recurrent heart attack, develop heart failure, or experience
progression of the disease process. Even in patients who had no detectable
heart damage from a previous attack, elevated BNP levels identified individuals
at high risk of dying or developing life-threatening cardiac complications
(de Lemos et al. 2001).
Angiograms
An angiogram, referred to as cardiac catheterization, is a mechanism in
which coronary arteries are luminated by injections of dye, a process
that aids in diagnosing blocked arteries. A catheter is introduced through
an incision into a large vein, usually of an arm or a leg, and threaded
through the circulatory system to the heart. As the dye wends its way
through the vasculature, blockages are detected by changes in flow rate
at points of occlusion. An angiogram is a popular diagnostic tool, but
it is not without risks. It is possible that the catheter will damage
the artery or loosen a piece of plaque lining the artery wall. The dislodged
plaque can block the flow of blood, causing a stroke. Thrombophlebitis,
local infection, and cardiac arrhythmias are other valid concerns.
Data reported in the JAMA debated the relevancy of widespread angiogram
usage (Graboys et al. 1987, 1992). A study chronicled 168 patients who
were advised to have an angiogram to determine the need for either angioplasty
or cardiac surgery: 80%, or 134, of the 168 patients who were evaluated
noninvasively were determined not to need catheterization. From the 168
patients, an annual fatal heart attack of 1.1% was observed over a 5-year
period compared to a 5-10% mortality rate from coronary bypass surgery
and a 1-2% mortality rate from angioplasty. The conclusion of the published
report was that noninvasive testing to access the heart's performance
is a better and safer determinant of a suitable therapeutic program than
searching for blocked arteries. If the patient fails some of the noninvasive
tests, an angiogram is warranted to determine the need for surgery ( Murray
1999).
Magnetic Resonance Imaging
Up to 70% of heart attacks occur in blood vessels that appear normal on
an angiogram. The journal Circulation reported that plaque without any
calcium deposits is not detectable by angiograms or CT scans, but it is
the most common cause of sudden death from a heart attack. While calcification
may lead to a more extensive form of heart disease, it is less likely
to lead to a heart attack (Fayad et al. 2000, LEF 2000).
Fatty buildup on arterial walls, although not detectable by an angiogram,
can result in a small fraction of plaque breaking free. The circulating
particle ultimately increases the risk of a heart attack or stroke.
A special type of MRI, with a sensitive screening technique, is promising
in regard to detecting even a slight buildup in coronary arteries, including
plaque without calcium deposits. This is especially praiseworthy since
coronary arteries are very small and the constant movement of the heart
makes a clear image difficult. The newer technique, black blood imaging,
blacks out the blood and produces an image of just the artery. Besides
being of much greater advantage in diagnosing early-stage heart disease,
this process is noninvasive. It is hoped that this newer, more responsible
means of assessing the health of coronary arteries will become part of
a routine check-up (Fayad et al. 2000).
Coronary Bypass Surgery
Blocked arteries are not always prognosticators of an impending heart
attack. The Coronary Artery Surgery Study (CASS) demonstrated that heart
patients with healthy hearts, but with one, two, or three of the heart
vessels blocked, did amazingly well without heart surgery. The number
of blockages did not alter the 1% a year death rate observed in the study
groups (Hueb 1989; Alderman et al. 1990).
A study conducted by researchers in Iowa and published in the New England
Journal of Medicine evaluated the efficiency of arteries that were 96%
blocked (diagnosis made by angiogram) (White et al. 1984; CASS Principle
Investigators, 1983, 1984). The researchers found that arteries blocked
96% had a greater thrust of blood than similar arteries only 40% blocked.
The conclusion of the report was that the degree of closure did not correlate
to the briskness of blood flow. Michael Murray, N.D., states that the
most critical assessment regarding the heart's performance is how well
the left ventricular pump is working, not necessarily the degree of closure
( Murray 1999).
It seems that aggressive procedures to open the vessels do not influence
the course of the disease, except in the most advanced stages of atherosclerosis.
Bypass appears most helpful when the ejection fraction is less than 40%.
Many bypass procedures are performed when the ejection fraction is greater
than 50%, a percentage that appears adequate for meeting the demands of
circulation. (White et al. 1984; Winslow et al.1988; Murray 1999).
A study by Harvard Medical School 's Department of Public Health revealed
that 84% of patients who obtained a second opinion after being scheduled
to undergo a heart bypass procedure were told that they did not need it.
During the study's 2-year follow-up, there were no deaths in the group
who canceled their surgeries based upon the second opinion (Perlmutter
2002). Often individuals undergoing the surgery live no longer and with
no more quality than a matched group of patients treated without surgery.
Conversely, if coronary bypass surgery or angioplasty is appropriately
advised, the procedures definitely increase long-term survival and give
symptomatic relief to about 85% of patients (Murray 1999).
Although coronary bypass surgery can bring relief to many patients,
the procedure is weighted with danger and chance. Infections, problems
with blood coagulation, nerve damage, and the possibility of a heart attack
or stroke are risks that must be factored into the patient's final decision.
According to Harvard researchers, up to 30% of patients have their heart
arteries reclog badly in just a year. Few patients survive 10 years without
needing retreatment, and high risk patients--such as those who already
have undergone repeat surgery--reclog at even greater rates. It should
be noted that morbidity and mortality rates vary considerably between
hospitals. If considering any heart procedure, ask for an analysis of
patient outcome.
Steven Whiting, Ph.D., states that although the odds of surviving bypass
surgery have improved since the operation was first introduced, the risk
of experiencing a decline in mental function following surgery has remained
consistent since the 1980s. Signals of this type of decline may include
difficulty following directions, mood swings, and short tempers. Many
doctors have downplayed the importance of alterations in intellectual
abilities that occur in about 50-80% of patients following bypass surgery,
believing the decline to be temporary. It now appears a transient display
of incompetency may predict an increased risk of intellectual instability
several years later.
Researchers (reporting in the New England Journal of Medicine) followed
261 bypass patients for 5 years. Enrollees in the study underwent intellectual
testing before and after surgery, as well as at the 6-week, 6-month, and
5-year interval. Intellectual function declined by 20-53% considering
presurgical and postsurgical mental status. The decline was 36% at 6 weeks
and 24% at 6 months. In 5 years after surgery, 41% of the patients had
experienced neurocognitive impairment. The researchers concluded that
an intellectual decline in patients following heart surgery was significantly
associated with diminished mental abilities 5 years postsurgery (Newman
2001).
Angioplasty
In 1977, Dr. Andreas Gruentzig introduced the procedure known as balloon
angioplasty, and by 1980 balloon angioplasty had become a popular cardiac
option. Angioplasty is used 3-10 times more often in the United States
than in other developed nations.
Balloon angioplasty widens coronary arteries by inserting a specially
designed catheter (a long, thin, bendable tube) with a balloon on its
tip into a blocked coronary artery. After centering the tip of the catheter
in the blocked area, the balloon is inflated, stretching the artery and
compressing the plaque. The arteries do not fully constrict, which leaves
a larger opening than before. Unfortunately, any procedure using an arterial
catheter may cause plaque to be dislodged (resulting in a cardiovascular
event) or the wall of an artery to be torn. Other concerns associated
with angioplasty are arterial spasms and blood clots, fluid accumulation
in the lungs, and impaired kidney function.
From the University of Giessen ( Germany ) comes a detailed analysis
of 300 patients who underwent primary angioplasty for an acute myocardial
infarction. At 1 year, 34% had experienced a cardiac event, 23% required
repeat angioplasty, and 6% had died from cardiac disease (Peterson et
al. 1994; Noninvasive Heart Center, http://www.heartprotect.com/mortality-stats.shtml;
Waldecker et al. 1995).
Dr. Eric Peterson (and associates) at Duke University Medical Center
reported the following survival statistics among various age groups undergoing
angioplasty:
| Mortality After Angioplasty
in 225,915 Patients |
| Ages |
30 Day |
1 Year |
| |
% |
% |
| 65-69 |
2.1 |
5.2 |
| 70-74 |
3.0 |
7.3 |
| 75-79 |
4.6 |
10.9 |
| > 80 |
7.8 |
17.3 |
Chart extracted
from material provided by The Noninvasive Heart Center, 2550 Fifth
Avenue, Suite 706 , San Diego , California 92103 hhwayne@heartprotect.com
(619) 544-0200. |
After collaborating with several universities, Ian Gilchrist, M.D.,
cardiologist at the Penn State Milton S. Hershey Medical Center ( Philadelphia
, PA ), announced that 178 angioplasty patients (from a total of 2064
subjects) experienced a heart attack, required additional surgery, or
died, and 82% of those numbers patients experienced the trauma within
18 hours of the procedure. Gilchrist said that despite efforts to minimize
risk, angioplasty complications are nonetheless common (Gilchrist et al.
2000).
The original focus of the trial was to establish the worthiness and
dosage of eptifibatide, an IV platelet inhibitor. Dr. James Tcheng ( A
associate P professor of M medicine at Duke University Medical Center
, Durham , NC ) reported that eptifibatide, a cost-effective drug, reduced
the risk of major complications during angioplasty 40% in the first 48
hours following the procedure. While evaluating the worth of eptifibatide
(a landmark study in itself) researchers were able to target the period
requiring greatest watchfulness among angioplasty patients.
Angioplasty vs. Thrombolytic Therapy
For Acute Heart Attack
An interesting study with far-reaching implications compared primary angioplasty
to intravenous thrombolytic therapy for acute myocardial infarctions (heart
attacks). An example of a thrombolytic is streptokinase (Streptase), which
enhances the conversion of plasminogen to the fibrinolytic enzyme plasmin.
Plasmin has a high specificity for fibrin and the particular ability to
dissolve formed fibrin clots. Other drugs used to open clogged arteries
during and after a heart attack are t-PA (Activase) and anistreplase (Eminase).
Angioplasty is fully described in the preceding section.
Most cases of acute myocardial infarctions are caused by thrombotic
occlusion of a ruptured plaque, diminishing blood circulation. Earlier
research suggested there might be a time frame in human beings during
which restoration of blood flow in the infarct-related artery might limit
infarct size (Reimer et al. 1977). Research verified the concept, showing
that timely reperfusion (a procedure in which blocked arteries are opened
to reestablish forward flow of blood) resulted in less heart muscle damage
and enhanced survival (Davies et al. 1985). The period from symptom onset
to thrombolytic administration was related to reduced infarct size and
mortality, with the greatest benefits within the first several hours following
early symptoms. From these observations arose the premise that "time
is muscle," establishing the need for swift treatment in progressive
cardiac care (FTTCG 1994).
Based on its widespread availability, intravenous thrombolytic therapy
has been the standard care for patients with acute myocardial infarction.
Despite its popularity, thrombolytic therapy has limitations. Of those
patients deemed candidates for anticoagulants, 10 to 15% had persistent
occlusion or re-occlusion of the infarct-related artery. Consequently,
primary percutaneous transluminal coronary angioplasty (primary PTCA)
has been advocated as a better treatment for patients with acute myocardial
infarction.
Proponents cited higher rates of opened vessels and improved blood flow
to the heart among users of PTCA. In addition, avoiding thrombolytic administration
virtually eliminates the approximate 1% risk of intracranial hemorrhage
inherent with systemic clot-reducing procedures (Stone et al. 2001a).
Naysayers (in turn) point ed out negatives associated with primary angioplasty,
citing excessive delays to treatment compared with thrombolytic therapy,
unproven results in large clinical trials, and a lack of widespread availability
of treatment centers.
Yet, 22 trials (involving 6889 patients) demonstrated that for every
1000 patients treated with primary angioplasty (rather than thrombolytic
therapy) an additional 20 lives were saved, 43 rei -nfarctions were prevented,
10 less strokes occurred, and 13 intracranial hemorrhages were avoided
(meta-analysis by Ellen C. Keeley, University of Texas Southwestern, and
Cindy L. Grines, William Beaumont Hospital in Detroit). The angioplasty
advantage was still observed even if the patient had to be transported
(by 3 hour ambulance trip) to a center equipped to perform the procedure.
(It typically takes about 2 hours to mobilize the medical team to perform
the angiography and angioplasty in the United States compared to 60 to
90 minutes in European hospitals) (Cannon et al. 2000; Weaver et al. 2000).
Despite the inherent delays apparent with angioplasty, the evidence
that primary PTCA offers advantage compared to thrombolytic therapy appears
convincing. Optimizing angioplasty with coronary stents and drug regimens
has significantly improved the early safety profile and long-term results
of percutaneous intervention in acute myocardial infarctions (Stone et
al. 2002).
In conclusion, The Lancet recently described the CAPTIM trial (a current
appraisal of the worth of angioplasty compared to thrombolytic therapy).
In CAPTIM, 840 patients (within 6 hours of the onset of a heart attack)
were randomized to fibrinolysis with accelerated doses of tissue plasminogen
activators or to primary PTCA. Because of funding woes and slow enrollment,
the trial ended before the planned recruitment of 1200 patients was reached
(the number needed to demonstrate a 40% relative reduction in 30-day composite
endpoints). Even so, the results demonstrated a trend toward a 24% reduction
in the occurrence of adverse events (Bonnefoy et al. 2002).
Survival trends were similar between patients undergoing angioplasty
and those receiving thrombolytic therapy, but the lower-risk population
initially enrolled in the study appeared to explain the similarity in
mortality statistics. (The survival benefit of primary angioplasty is
mostly seen in high-risk patients, such as the elderly, and those with
anterior myocardial infarction, or in shock [Stone et al. 2001b; Zahn
et al. 2001]). The lack of a survival benefit in low-risk patients does
not diminish the clinical relevance of fewer strokes, rei -nfarctions,
a reduction in urgent revascularization procedures, and shorter hospital
stays with primary PTCA, compared to fibrinolytic therapies.
Some advocate facilitated primary PTCA trials, i.e., combining thrombolysis
with primary PTCA. However, the additional costs and bleeding complications
that will certainly accrue by adding thrombolytic therapy before primary
angioplasty cannot be dismissed without evidence of overriding benefit.
To date, four modest-sized randomized trials have found facilitated PTCA
either inferior to or no better than primary PTCA alone.
PTCA enthusiasts avow that (currently) the best therapy for most patients
with developing acute heart attack should no longer be debated: administer
antiplatelet therapy (aspirin, a thienopyridine, and possibly abciximab),
and transfer the patient for primary PTCA to an experienced center, regardless
of whether the nearest catheterization suite is three floors or three
hours away. To do less, they caution, can no longer be considered standard
care (Stone 2002). Comment: According to Dr. Philip O'Dowd, the thienopyridines
(clopidogrel and ticlopidine) are slightly more effective than aspirin
in preventing morbid vascular events in certain patients (O'Dowd http://www.brown.edu/Departments/Clinical_Neurosciences/articles/po401.html).
Angioplasty Among Diabetics
Although about 700,000 angioplasties are performed annually in the United
States , the procedure is not a worthy consideration for everyone. Patients
with diabetes mellitus, who are in need of revascularization, have better
survival odds with coronary artery bypass grafting (CABG) compared to
angioplasty, according to study findings published in the Journal of the
American College of Cardiology (Bari Investigators 2000). According to
Dr. Katherine M. Detre ( University of Pittsburgh ): "Diabetic patients
did very much worse in both respects, heart attacks and mortality, when
undergoing angioplasty." For diabetics, the 7-year survival rate
was 76.4% in the CABG group and 55.7% in the angioplasty group. Among
non-diabetics, the survival rates were 86.4% in the CABG group and 86.8%
in the angioplasty group.
Does Multivessel Stenting Improve
Odds?
More than 80% of patients worldwide are treated with endovascular prostheses
during coronary procedures. So great are the numbers, Martin Leon, M.D.,
refers to the year 2000 as the era of the stent frenzy. A stent is a rod
or threadlike device inserted within a closed or partially closed artery
to allow adequate blood flow through the vessel ( Leon 1998).
According to Korean researchers, the excitement regarding stents appears
to be justified. In fact, research suggests that some patients with coronary
artery disease may be excellent candidates for multivessel coronary artery
stenting, instead of bypass surgery. Dr. Seung-Jung Park ( University
of Ulsan , Seoul ) reviewed observational data, evaluating 200 patients
with multivessel coronary artery disease and normal left ventricular function.
Half of the patients underwent bypass surgery and the other half had multivessel
stenting. Complete revascularization, the restoration of blood flow, was
achieved in 95% of the patients who had bypass surgery and in 69% of the
stent group. Over a 21-month follow-up period, survival in the two groups
was similar (99% for the stent group and 97% for the bypass group), but
a higher incidence of angina recurrence and target lesion revascularization
occurred in the stent group (Kim et al. 2000).
What Is Brachytherapy?
Because re -stenosis (closure) is a major concern after angioplasty, strategies
that will benefit patients prone to vascular re -closure are being developed.
Vascular brachytherapy, the placement of intracoronary radioactive sources,
has dramatically lowered neo - (new) intimal growth patterns following
angioplasty trauma.
A Scripps research team in LaJolla , California , headed by Dr. Paul
S. Teirstein, inserted a ribbon of radioactive pellets into the artery
for 20-45 minutes to help prevent the growth of scar tissue. In a preliminary
clinical study conducted by Teirstein and colleagues, the incidence of
in-stent re -stenosis (at the 6-month follow-up) declined from 54% without
intra-coronary radiation to 17% with radiation, a difference of almost
70%. At 3-year follow-up, re -stenosis was reduced by 48% (a significant
reduction considering the time frame). The need for repeat revascularization
procedures was reduced 74% (from 45% to 12%) at 6 months. The clinical
efficacy observed at 6 months was maintained at the 3-year follow-up (Teirstein
et al. 2000; Carrington 2000).
Research carried out at the Division of Cardiology ( Washington Hospital
Center ) showed overwhelmingly that gamma-radiation therapy delivers impressive
results. For example, at 6 months, the in-stent re -stenosis rate was
21% among 60 patients assigned brachytherapy compared to 44% in a control
group. At 12 months, the rate of revascularization of the target lesion
was 70% less among the persons receiving gamma-radiation therapy; the
incidence of a major cardiac event was 49% less (Waksman et al. 2002).
The one-time exposure to radiation does no apparent harm to heart tissue
or the artery. The Journal of the American Heart Association reported
that an assessment of the procedure at the 3-year interval indicated it
was both safe and effective. However, Dr. Teirstein cautions that until
much longer follow-ups demonstrate the benefits and safety of the radiation
technique, it would be premature to recommend radiation therapy for the
first line of treatment for patients with clogged coronary arteries (Teirstein
et al. 2000). In the interim, major hospitals are gearing for brachytherapy
as an option for patients with chronic coronary artery disease who are
subject to adhesions following cardiac procedures.
Chelation Therapy: Is It a Bonafide
Alternative to Heart Surgery?
Chelation therapy represents to some a safe, effective, and relatively
inexpensive treatment to restore blood flow through atherosclerotic vessels.
The word chelation is derived from a Greek translation meaning "claw-like,"
or capable of expunging accumulated atheromatous materials from the body.
During chelation, ethylenediaminetetraacetic acid (EDTA), a synthetic
amino acid drug, is intravenously infused, along with other nutrients,
to enact the extraction process. EDTA encircles and holds elements, passing
them from the body in urine. With progressive treatments, accumulated
pollutants are exhumed from body stores, along with materials that encourage
free-radical damage and cellular breakdown. The heart-related conditions
currently treatable with chelation therapy include arteriosclerosis and
atherosclerosis, angina pectoris, hypertension, transient ischemic attacks,
circulatory diseases, hemochromatosis, and Type II diabetes (Walker 1990;
Powell et al. 1999).
Historically, chelation had an inception quite different from that of
an anti -arteriosclerotic. EDTA's first medicinal usage appears to have
been around 1941 when it was used to extract lead accumulations. A decade
later, Dr. Norman Clarke (director of research at Providence Hospital
in Detroit ) observed that patients treated for lead poisoning with chelation
therapy had a simultaneous cessation of angina attacks. This chance beginning
introduced EDTA to a few cardiovascular physicians who were searching
for alternatives, apart from heart surgery, to remove plaque from diseased
arteries.
Chelation therapy has had many deterrents along its controversial pathway.
Even today, the American Heart Association, after reviewing the literature
in regard to chelation and arteriosclerotic heart disease, has announced
that the scientific evidence does not demonstrate any benefit from the
therapy. The American Medical Association compared its effectiveness to
that of a sugar pill. JAMA recently reported that based on exercise time
to ischemia and exercise capacity, there is no evidence to support a chelation
benefit in patients with ischemic heart disease, stable angina, or a positive
treadmill test for ischemia (Knudtson et al. 2002).
Chelation supporters quickly rose to the accusation, among them Dr.
Elmer Cranton, author of Bypassing Bypass. Dr. Cranton referred to the
JAMA report as "sham science," citing statistical errors and
patient disparities as compromising factors. One-third of the patients
did not have angina, according to Cranton, and almost twice as many patients
in the placebo group received antianginal drugs--and angina was supposedly
one of the endpoints. Cranton avows that the study was inadequate to show
any response, beneficial or otherwise. Researchers agreed (in part), citing
the need for larger trials with a broad range of patients.
Dr. Terry Chappell (former president of ACAM) enrolled 32 physicians
who were using the standard ACAM chelation protocol--20-30 treatments
of EDTA, oral nutritional supplements, and lifestyle changes--in a study
to assess the cardiovascular value of treatment. All of the patients participating
in the study were appropriately diagnosed with vascular disease before
the therapy began. Objective testing was done before and after each treatment.
The results showed that chelation therapy (in union with supplements and
lifestyle intervention) was yielding positive results. The patients, 1086
of 1241, or 88%, reported subjective betterment improvement; physicians
reported "significant clinical improvement" ( Walker 1990).
Dr. Morton Walker, author of The Chelation Way, reminds us that an aspirin
is less than one-third as safe as IV EDTA at supra p harmaceutical doses.
The LD50 of aspirin is only 558 mg/kg in humans, while EDTA's LD50 is
2000 mg/kg. Note: LD50 indicates the pharmaceutical term lethal dose 50,
or the dose of a substance that is fatal to 50% of test animals. Dr. Walker,
a staunch advocate of chelation therapy, believes that the danger of death
from bypass surgery is about 6000 times greater than from chelation therapy
( Walker 1990).
The success of chelation therapy appears directly related to the refusion
of minerals withdrawn during the extraction process. A physician trained
in autonomic balancing, a process described earlier in the material, appears
essential to the success or failure of the process.
Dr. Edward Olszewer and associates published two reports (a retrospective
analysis of 2870 patients with vascular and other chronic degenerative
diseases and a single-blind, crossover study of a small group of patients
with peripheral vascular disease) suggesting a beneficial effect from
chelation. In the former study, objective testing indicated marked or
good improvement in 87% of patients. In the latter study, all 10 subjects
receiving chelation benefited (Olszewer et al. 1988, 1990). Note: The
National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine and the National
Heart, Lung, and Blood Institute have launched the first large-scale clinical
trial to determine the safety and efficacy of EDTA chelation therapy in
individuals with confirmed coronary artery disease. Plans for the 5-year
study, involving over 2300 patients at more than 100 research sites across
the country, are currently being finalized.
Coronary Gene Therapy
Coronary gene therapy is another alternative to either angioplasty or
coronary artery bypass surgery for high risk patients. Gene therapy increases
the options of individuals who have failed drug treatment and appear to
be poor candidates for aggressive surgical procedures. A battery of tests
confirms the acceptability of a patient wishing to be enrolled in the
gene program.
During coronary gene therapy, x-ray imaging allows the gene for the
human vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF2) to be delivered to the
heart via a catheter inserted through a puncture in the inguinal (groin)
region. A needle is advanced out of the catheter and used to inject DNA
into the inner wall of the heart, a sequence that produces the vascular
endothelial growth factor and stimulates the growth of new blood vessels.
Data reported in the New York Times (August 29, 1999) suggest that VEGF2
is capable of invoking the growth of new blood vessels, with some individuals
experiencing regrowth in about 60% of the area previously occluded. Although
the process is constantly being advanced and refined, many patients have
successfully undergone the treatment since 1998.
Two concerns researchers had concerning gene therapy were that blood
vessel growth factors might nourish the blood supply of undetected cancers
and cause damaging overgrowth of vessels in tissues such as the retina
of the eye. Dr. Timothy Henry ( Hennepin County Medical Center , Minneapolis
) reported that among 106 patients enrolled in a VEGF trial, four patients
in the placebo group developed cancer compared with one patient in the
low dose VEGF group and none in the high dose group. Overall mortality
was 3% in the placebo group, 6% in the low dose VEGF group, and 0% in
the high dose group. The incidence of myocardial infarction was 3% in
the placebo patients, 0% in the low dose group, and 6% in the high dose
VEGF group.
Currently, there appears to be no retinal damage in diabetic patients
who have undergone the procedure. These results are preliminary and inconclusive,
but early assessments deem VEGF therapy a burgeoning alternative to either
bypass surgery or angioplasty for coronary and vascular disease. For more
information concerning coronary gene therapy, contact St. Elizabeth's
Medical Center of Boston at (888) 311-GENE.
EVIDENCE THAT CARDIAC CELLS
DIVIDE AFTER A HEART ATTACK
Most tissues and organs are equipped to deal with injury more efficiently
than the heart. For example, the mending of broken bones and renewal of
injured skin is so mundane they are taken for granted. Until recently,
it was thought that myocytes (muscle cells) of the adult heart were incapable
of self-renewal; once damaged, always damaged, without hope of regeneration.
Reports published in the New England Journal of Medicine indicate this
may not be the case (Beltrami et al. 2001).
Researchers looked at heart muscle cells from the hearts of 13 deceased
patients, 4-12 days after their heart attack. These findings were compared
to the hearts of 10 patients who had not died of cardiovascular disease.
Samples of heart tissue were taken from the area near the site of the
heart attack and from a site more distant from the damage. Scientists
found that the number of myocytes multiplying in diseased hearts was 70
times higher in the border zone and 24 times higher in the remote area.
The presence of cell division in the nondiseased portion of the heart
suggests a continuous turnover of cells during the lifespan of the organism.
It is now thought that cardiac muscle cells can reproduce, advancing the
premise that this process may be a component of the growth reserve of
the human heart. The ramifications of this re |