| 
Cancer: Gene Therapies, Stem Cells, Telomeres,
and Cytokines
The media reports on many medical breakthroughs but usually issues a
disclaimer stating that it will take many years before the discovery becomes
part of standard practice. Interestingly, there are steps a cancer patient
can take right now to gain access to this state-of-the-art knowledge.
In some instances, a patient will have to travel to a research facility.
In other cases, these therapies can be incorporated into a cancer treatment
program utilizing existing therapeutic approaches.
We describe some of these exciting advances in this protocol and reveal
how cancer patients may take advantage of them today. It is important
to caution that the information provided in this chapter is highly technical
and some lay readers may have difficulty fully understanding it.
How Genes Control Cancer
Cells
One of the main categories of genes responsible for cancer includes those
that (when working properly) suppress the development of malignancies.
Various cancers result from the loss or malfunction of the key regulatory
proteins that tumor suppressor genes encode, primarily p53 and pRB proteins.
(pRB is named from retinoblastoma, the type of tumor in which its gene,
RB, was first identified.) In its active form, pRB serves as a brake on
DNA replication, blocking the activity of another protein (E2F) which
promotes the synthesis of DNA. Loss of pRB protein therefore leads to
uncontrolled E2F action and rampant cell division. Research indicates
the RB gene is mutated in about 40% of human cancers, rendering its protein
inactive (Oliff et al. 1996).
Another infinitely important regulatory molecule is the p53 protein.
Often called the guardian of the genome, p53 prevents replication of damaged
DNA in normal cells and promotes suicide or apoptosis of cells with abnormal
DNA (Oliff et al. 1996). Faulty p53 molecules allow cells (carrying damaged
DNA) to survive when they would normally die and to replicate when they
would normally stop. Cell cycle constraints are when pass, repair, and
apoptotic mechanisms falter and disturbed cells pass mutations down to
offspring. Thus, a lack of p53 regulation promotes the spontaneous emergence
of mutant cells, a cellular distortion that is an invitation to cancer
(Greenblatt et al. 1994).
Researchers compared the expression of more than 7000 genes and found
that about 30 genes are activated by p53; the 14 most often stimulated
by p53 are involved in cell regulation. The inactivation of the p53 gene
is observed in about 50% of all solid tumors, affording prognostic and
therapeutic implications. For example, researchers from the Mayo Clinic
announced that analyzing p53 gene mutations identifies a subset of breast
cancer patients who, despite lack of conventional indications of poor
prognosis, are at high risk of early disease recurrence and death (Blaszyk
et al. 2000).
Therapeutically, studies demonstrate that injecting wild type p53 into
a malignant cell has positive effects when the p53 gene is either absent
or mutated. In a 3-month study, nine men with advanced lung cancer (displaying
a mutation in the tumor suppressor gene p53) were injected with healthy
copies (genetically engineered) once a day for 5 days. The lung tumors
treated with the p53 solution stopped growing in three patients; regression
occurred in another three. Although all of the subjects eventually failed
treatment, the major finding from the study, that is, "proof of principle,"
suggests that gene therapy can be an effective way to halt tumor cell
growth (Modica et al. 1996). This therapeutic approach may have a potential
application in at least 50% of all human tumors.
The highest frequency of p53 mutations reported in human cancers are
lung, 56%; colon, 50%; esophagus, 45%; ovary, pancreas, and skin, 44%;
stomach, 41%; head and neck, 37%; bladder, 34%; prostate, 30%; and breast,
endometrial, and mesothelioma, 22% (Greenblatt et al. 1994). Nearly 20%
of women treated for ovarian cancer develop other tumors beyond the abdomen.
A mutation in the p53 tumor suppressor gene appears to predispose some
women with ovarian cancer to distant and rapid tumor spread, according
to data from the University of Iowa Health Care Study .
A mutant p53 gene seems able to escape destruction even when confronted
with normally lethal concentrations of cytotoxic drugs and ionizing radiation
(Buttitta et al. 1997). Furthermore, a dysfunctional p53 gene affects
the outcome of traditional therapies because toxic treatments depend upon
DNA damage and p53-induced cell death. The p53 gene induces cells to kill
themselves by producing free radicals (charged molecules) causing cellular
oxidation. Oxidation damages protein as well as the membranes and eventually
the cell dies ( Choisy-Rossi et al 1998).
The character and therapeutic value of p53 is illustrated in the following
studies:
- The tumors of 30 patients were directly injected with the p53 gene.
Among 17 patients with nonresectable tumors, five stabilized and two
exhibited partial regression (defined as at least a 50% reduction in
the size of the mass). Among the 13 patients with resectable tumors,
three died of their cancer, and five (38%) remained free of disease
for 6 months post injection ( Kigawa et al. 2000).
- Progesterone induces apoptosis and markedly upregulates p53 expression
in ovarian cell lines. It is, thus, suspected that p53 plays a significant
role in progesterone-induced apoptosis (Bu et al. 1997).
- Australian researchers found that interactions between telomerase
and p53 indicate the activity of telomerase may be regulated by p53;
downregulation of p53 would (in turn) favor upregulation of telomerase
activity in cancer cell development (Li et al. 1999). Please consult
the Telomere/Telomerase Connection appearing later in this protocol
for additional information.
- Vitamin E, in combination with vitamins A and C, led to a four-fold
reduction in p53 mutations (Brotzman et al. 1999).
Part of the body's natural defense against cancer may have a downside.
Mice with high activity of the tumor-suppressing p53 gene had low rates
of cancer, but aged prematurely. The surprise finding suggests that aging
might occur, in part, because of the body's innate vigilance against cancer.
Mutant mice with "revved up" p53 were more resistant to cancer
than normal mice, but despite this protection, the mutant mice had (roughly)
a 20% shorter lifespan. Instead of cancer, the animals experienced bone
thinning, organ breakdown, vulnerability to physical stress, and the equivalent
of sagging skin and balding in humans. Researchers speculate that hyperactivity
in the p53 gene may disable the body's reserve of stem cells sooner than
normal. This would keep primitive cells from replenishing certain body
tissues and lead to premature tissue degeneration (Ferbeyre et al. 2002).
Protein Kinase Inhibitors
According to the Laboratory of Molecular Biophysics, of the hundreds of
protein kinases in the human genome, only about 27 protein kinase structures
have been solved to date. Yet, so important are the family of kinases,
oncogenes that encode (program) protein kinases are under ongoing study
for their participation in cancer (Johnson 2002). In normal cells, protein
kinases are involved in signals sent between the cell membrane and the
nucleus, regulating progression through the cell cycle. Protein kinases
control these processes by activating other proteins in response to stimuli.
Mutated kinase genes have been found in a number of malignancies, including
chronic myelogenous leukemia and breast and bladder cancers.
Kinases can lead to cancer though various pathways including overproduction,
an event caused by mutations in the control regions of their genes. Compared
to normal cells, tumor cells often overproduce kinases, encouraging the
cell to divide. A commonly overproduced kinase in cancerous tissue is
the receptor for epidermal growth factor (EGF), an upregulation strongly
favoring cancer.
Kinases can also contribute to cancer if their structure is abnormal.
Many tumor cells possess protein kinases that (because of a structural
defect) are permanently turned on, goading the cell into division. Examples
of kinases that behave abnormally in certain human cancers are the Abl,
Src, and cyclin-dependent kinases (Oliff et al. 1996).
Obviously, an inhibitor of dysfunctional kinases is a worthy cancer therapy
research objective. The challenge is finding a substance that can distinguish
one kinase from another. Many of the protein kinases in mammalian cells
have similar structures, particularly in biochemically active regions.
Hence, an inhibitor of any single protein kinase might disrupt the activity
of others, that is, an unrelated kinase crucial to normal cell function.
Despite limitations, pharmaceutical researchers have synthesized and
tested a number of kinase inhibitors. Most target the kinases themselves,
but others attack at the genetic level (preventing the kinases from being
formed). Remarkably, kinase inhibitors can be quite selective. In the
test tube, some find their intended target 1000 times more frequently
than they do unrelated kinases. More important are findings that several
of these compounds inhibit the growth of cancer cells possessing mutated
kinase genes.
Various natural agents appear able to inhibit protein kinase activity:
- Flavonoid analogues inhibit protein-tyrosine kinase. The most active
substance used in this study was compound 17c, which is approximately
one order greater in potency than quercetin. After a series of reduction
mechanisms, 3-(alkoxycarbonyl)-2-arylflavones is produced and then converted
to a variety of flavonoids, including 17c (Cushman et al. 1991).
- Genistein and daidzein, isoflavones found in soy, are specific inhibitors
of protein tyrosine kinase (PTK). By modulating pathways involved in
signal transduction, isoflavones acting upon PTK put the brakes on rapidly
dividing cells (Bland 2001).
- Oxidants selectively react with the regulatory center of protein kinase
C (PKC), signaling tumor promotion and cell growth. In contrast, antioxidants
(selenium and polyphenolic agents, such as curcumin, and vitamin E analogues)
inhibit cellular PKC activity and thus interfere with the action of
tumor promoters (Gopalakrishna et al. 2000). Other polyphenolic phytochemicals,
that is, the constituents of green tea and resveratrol, respond similarly,
displaying significant PKC inhibition (Stoner et al. 1995; Atten et
al. 2001).
- As protein kinase C (PKC) is stimulated, tumor activity in the colon
increases. Retinol, retinoic acid, and beta-carotene (in nanomolar concentrations)
block stimulation of PKC. At higher doses, retinol and retinoic acid
can stimulate kinase activity; beta-carotene does not have this effect
and could thus be useful in the prevention and treatment of colorectal
cancer (Kahl-Rainer et al. 1994).
This growing body of knowledge about the effect of kinases on cell regulatory
genes helps explain why soy extracts (genistein and daidzein), curcumin,
beta-carotene, and certain types of vitamin E have anticancer effects.
The problem is that we don't have precise data to predict how a particular
dose of a protein kinase C inhibiting agent will affect gene
expression on cancer cells. There are findings, however, from related
studies indicating that the following doses of nutrients might be beneficial
in suppressing protein kinase C that is involved in controlling
cancer cell propagation:
- Curcumin, 3600 mg a day
- Genistein, 2700 mg a day
- Tocopheryl succinate, 800 mg a day
- Beta-carotene, 25,000 IU a day
- Retinal palmitate, 25,000 IU a day
The Telomere/Telomerase
Connection
One of the crucial features that distinguish a cancer cell from a normal
cell is its ability to divide indefinitely. Telomerase, an enzyme in the
cell nucleus, is intricately involved in the cancer process through interactions
with telomeres, the protective structures at the ends of chromosomes.
In most normal human cells, the action of telomerase is repressed and
subsequently telomeres shorten progressively with each cell division.
In contrast, most human tumors utilize telomerase, resulting in stabilized
telomere length. For tumor cells to proliferate, they must maintain the
telomeres. Thus, cancer cells turn on genes responsible for telomerase
production which in humans normally ceases after birth. Suppressing telomerase
is an obvious target for the development of anticancer therapies (Hahn
et al. 1999).
Telomerase is composed of at least two units: hTR and hTRT, genes whose
activity correlate with the malignancy and metastatic potential of the
tumor. The combination of hTR and hTRT activates telomerase, lengthening
telomeres and extending the cell's replicative lifespan. hTR and hTRT
were detected in 85% and 82% of primary tumors, respectively; in surrounding,
healthier tissue, the positive incidence of hTR/hTRT was only ~3% (Bodnar
et al. 1998; Yuan et al. 2000).
Because telomerase activity is increased in the vast majority of human
tumors (about 90%), its gene product appears to be the first molecule
common to all tumors (Cairns et al. 2000; Minev et al. 2000). In analyzing
human cancers, the positive frequency of hTR and hTRT was overwhelmingly
displayed in cancers of the breast, colon, gallbladder, lung, stomach,
and esophagus. Telomere length and telomerase activity are also evidenced
in chronic lymphocytic leukemia, often proving predictive of survival
(Bechter et al. 1998). In addition, multiple myeloma patients with high
levels of telomerase activity were also found to have a significantly
shorter survival time. Telomerase, thus, is proving a reliable marker
for the proliferating capacity and tumor mass of cancer patients (Shiratsuchi
et al. 2002).
Retinoids employ two different pathways to impact telomerase activity;
the second means (downregulating hTRT) results in a suppression of telomerase
that develops slowly during 2 weeks of retinoic acid therapy, terminating
in telomere shortening, growth arrest, and cell death. Telomerase expression
is an efficient and selective target of retinoids in the therapy of tumors
(Pendino et al. 2001).
Retinoids are not alone in their capacity to inhibit telomerase.
- Epigallocatechin gallate (EGCG), a green tea catechin, strongly and
directly inhibited telomerase (Naasani et al. 1998).
- Antioxidants reduce telomerase activity ( Liu et al 2002)
- Administering NSAIDs (indomethacin and ibuprofen) resulted in a dose-dependent
reduction in telomerase activity (Thurnher et al. 2001).
- Scientists from USCD School of Medicine and Cancer Center in corroboration
with the Institute Pasteur in Paris are successfully using telomerase
in a prototype vaccine to activate cytotoxic T-lymphocytes. By immunizing
lymphocytes against telomerase, killer cells targeting telomerase are
generated. The vaccine specifically targets the hTRT peptide, and the
proliferative patterns common to immortal cells are destroyed (Zanetti
et al. 2000). Researchers ( University of California ) suggest that
hTRT has the potential to serve as a universal cancer vaccine (Minev
et al. 2000).
Two pharmaceutical groups (Geron Corporation and Ribozyme Pharmaceuticals)
have joined forces to elaborate GRN163, a short, modified oligonucleotide
designed as a telomerase antagonist. A Geron Corporation spokesperson
said that inhibiting telomerase represents a novel mechanism for the treatment
of cancer with potentially broader utility and greater selectivity against
cancer cells than currently available agents. The companies are also exploring
a ribozyme-based telomerase inhibitor with apoptotic activity, as well
as the ability to shorten telomeres (BW 2001). Isolating anticancer drugs
targeted at telomerase inhibition is a global effort, one considered crucial
to understanding and subsequently overcoming cancer.
Telomerase inhibitors are exciting potential therapies against cancer
(Cairns et al 2002; Mokbel 2003). Several human clinical
trials are expected in the year 2004. A Phase II clinical trial for individuals
fighting metastatic cancer using a vaccine that contains a telomerase
peptide (piece of a telomerase protein) is currently underway at the National
Cancer Institute: http://clinicaltrials.gov/ct/show/NCT00016640?order=1
Although much of this work is still in the research phase, there is evidence
that high-dose green tea extract and retinoid compounds may inhibit the
telomerase enzyme that allows cancer cells to proliferate out of control
( L'Allemain 1999; Pendino et al 2003) . You may consider one or both
of the following potential telomerase-inhibiting therapies available right
now:
- Vesanoid (all-trans retinoic acid) is a drug already approved to treat
certain cancers ( Ozpolat et al 2001) . Based on its potential telomerase-inhibiting
property, you may want to ask your oncologist to prescribe an individualized
dose for you.
- High-potency green tea extracts are available as dietary supplements.
A dose used by some cancer patients is five 350-mg capsules of green
tea (95%) extract with each meal (3 meals per day). Each capsule should
be standardized to provide a minimum of 100 mg of epigallocatechin gallate
(EGCG). It is the EGCG fraction of green tea that has shown the most
active anticancer effects. These high-potency green tea extract capsules
are available in decaffeinated form for those who are sensitive to caffeine
or who want to take the less stimulating decaffeinated green tea extract
capsules in their evening dose. The brand name of the 95% green tea
extract is Super Green Tea Extract Caps.
For information regarding telomerase-inhibiting drug clinical trials,
call the National Cancer Institute (NCI) at (800) 422-7237 or visit the
NCI's clinical trials Web site.
One company that may start clinical trials in 2004 is Geron
Corporation.
Stem Cell Transplants
Many of the most respected cancer centers in the United States are using
stem cells rather than bone marrow for transplants. According to the Fred
Hutchinson Cancer Research Center ( Seattle , WA ), stem cell transplants
are substantially more effective for certain high-risk patients, particularly
patients with blood borne tumors who are beyond first remission or who
have experienced refractory relapse.
In a multicenter trial, 168 patients between the ages of 12-55 with various
blood malignancies (leukemia, lymphoma, and myelodysplasia) were randomized
to receive either bone marrow or peripheral blood stem cell transplants
from HLA-identical sibling donors (Stephenson 2000). The trial was stopped
prematurely because a safety monitoring committee determined there was
a statistically significant difference in outcome between the two groups.
An analysis of 138 of the patients showed that engraftment of platelets
and neutrophils was more rapid by about a week in patients who received
stem cells. (Engraftment refers to the interval when the donor's marrow
cells "attach" to the transplant patient's site and begin to
produce healthy cells.) This is momentous because infection looms as a
major threat to survival among transplant patients; thus, hastily restoring
blood cell production and the efficiency of the immune system is paramount.
Even more impressive were the differences in survival; the 2-year survival
rate was 45% among patients with bone marrow transplants compared to 70%
among patients with stem cell transplants. The survival advantage was
most apparent in patients with more advanced disease. Data were insufficient
to determine whether stem cells offer similar advantage over bone marrow
for patients with less advanced cancers.
A stem cell transplant involves replacing the diseased marrow with healthy
stem cells that match the recipient's. The transplanted stem cells travel
through the recipient's blood to the marrow spaces where they begin to
grow, producing healthy new blood cells. This occurs after massive amounts
of cytotoxic agents have been administered in a courageous attempt to
kill the cancer. Unfortunately, the agents that kill cancer cells also
kill bone marrow, a spongy tissue in the cavities of large bones that
produces blood cells. Without bone marrow, stem cell activity ceases and
subsequently so does production of platelets (cells necessary for blood
coagulation), white blood cells (cells essential to fight infections and
cancer), and red blood cells (cells required for oxygen transport). Without
a healthy supply of these vital cells, life expectancy is extremely short.
Not all recipients survive the intensive pretransplant chemotherapy or
radiation treatment, which (until recently) were considered the only curative
phases of the procedure. Other complications (apart from infections and
nonengraftment) include graft-versus-host disease (white blood cells in
the marrow fight the patient's body) and relapse (recurrence of the original
disease). To find out if you are eligible for this stem cell therapy,
contact the Fred Hutchinson Cancer Research Center ( Seattle ) at (800)
804-8824.
Peripheral Blood Stem
Cell Transplant Program
The Peripheral Blood Stem Cell Transplant Program allows patients to
restore their own supply of blood cells degraded during chemotherapy.
Apheresis, a process that withdraws blood and circulates it through a
machine, removes the stem cells. Remaining components of the blood are
then returned to the patient. The harvested stem cells are stored at a
very low temperature, and (after high-dose chemotherapy or radiation therapy)
the cells are thawed and returned to the patient through a central venous
catheter. Once the stem cells are reinfused into the bloodstream, they
return to the bone marrow and begin producing mature red blood cells,
white cells, and platelets.
Allogeneic stem cells (donated by another person) are more likely to
muster an immune attack against the cancer than autologous stem cells
(those harvested from the patient). According to Richard E. Champlin,
M.D., chairman of the Department of Blood and Marrow Transplantation at
the University of Texas M.D. Anderson Cancer Center, physicians found
that allogeneic transplantation harbored unexpected benefits, that is,
immunoreactivity against the cancer. In some cases, the graft versus malignancy
effect proved curative.
In the past, the threat of graft versus host disease limited the number
of patients who were able to undergo allogeneic transplantation but advances
in immunosuppressive therapies and cell manipulation techniques have steadily
increased the numbers (Wright 2000). Treatment-related mortality rate
is about 20% for allogeneic transplants, with the hospital stay about
4 months; autologous transplants have less than a 5% treatment-related
mortality and require hospitalization of about 1 month. Transplantation
studies are currently being expanded to include ovarian, breast, lung,
and renal cell cancers.
For aged and very ill patients, reliance upon high-dose chemotherapy
has changed to emphasis upon immune modulation generated by the donor
cells. The process, referred to as a minitransplant, allows for a graft
versus malignancy effect with the chemotherapeutic drug limited to a low-dose
application. A minitransplant can now be performed in senior patients
with comorbid conditions, such as hepatitis or cardiac and lung abnormalities.
Myeloablative regimens (bone marrow removal) are still used for younger
patients and nonablative regimes are used for older or badly compromised
patients.
The success rate of transplants varies, but M.D. Anderson Cancer Center
reported the results of 13 patients with low-grade lymphoma who underwent
a minitransplant: All 13 survived and are in remission. Survival variables
include the specific disease, the stage of the disease, and the age and
condition of the patient. Typically, the survival rate (measured at 2-3
years) is in the range of 40-60%. The Peripheral Blood Stem Cell Transplant
Program is ongoing. Contact the M.D. Anderson Cancer Center information
line at (800) 392-1611.
Umbilical Cord Blood
Transplants
Umbilical cord blood, a source of cells for transplant, has been life-saving
to children who are without an acceptable donor. In about a 4-year time
frame, M.D. Anderson Cancer Center has performed 25 umbilical cord blood
transplants, all from mismatched donors, on pediatric patients (most with
advanced acute leukemia). After a median follow-up of 22 months, 14 of
the young patients were alive, and 12 were in remission. (Chalaire 2000).
Fatal complications in umbilical cord blood transplants exceed 30% in
the first 100 days.
Umbilical cord blood transplants, unlike bone marrow transplants, can
tolerate mismatches in HLA (as many as 2-6 antigens), but unfortunately
(if the mismatch is large) it increases the time of engraftment (the point
when the donor's marrow cells have "attached" to the transplant
patient's site and start to produce healthy cells). In addition, umbilical
cord blood contains about 10 times fewer cells than bone marrow. The period
of engraftment is thus extended to 40-60 days, as compared to 10-20 in
bone marrow transplants. During this period of pancytopenia (a marked
reduction in the numbers of the formed blood cells), life-threatening
infections are a significant threat. Thus, recipients (until recently)
have been restricted to children and low-weight adults (Chalaire 2000).
A new protocol, that is, combining umbilical cord blood from two or three
donors, appears to amend blood cell shortages, making future transplants
available to more individuals in diverse age groups.
According to Dr. Champlin, "The important message is that the whole
field of blood and marrow transplantation is probably the most dynamic
area in all of medicine, where advances in chemotherapy, immunosuppressive
agents, genetic therapy, and cellular therapy are all coming together."
For more information regarding transplants, contact Dr. Richard E. Champlin
at (713) 792-3618 or Dr. Ka Wah Chan at M.D. Anderson Cancer Center (713)
792-7751.
Suppressing Proinflammator
Cytokines
There is a growing body of evidence showing that the net biological response
of pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines affects the outcome of several
degenerative diseases, including cancer (Dinarello 1997). Cytokines are
one of a large group of proteins secreted by various cell types. These
relatively small peptides are involved in cell-to-cell communication,
coordinating antibody/T-cell immune interactions, and amplifying immune
reactivity. The broad family of cytokines includes colony stimulating
factors (as G-CSF and GM-CSF), interferons, interleukins, tumor necrosis
factor, and macrophage activating and inhibiting factors.
Some cytokines were named for the cellular modulating property with which
they were initially associated. For example, tumor necrosis factor has
anticancer properties, causing death (necrosis) to certain tumors. But,
in inflammatory diseases TNF-alpha (like IL-1) can increase cellular responsiveness
to growth factors, inducing signaling pathways that lead to proliferation.
In addition, by acting synergistically with epidermal growth factors,
TNF-alpha can induce expression of a number of oncogenes, as well as several
potentially damaging interleukins (ISU 2001).
Illustrative of TNF-alpha's capriciousness, short-term culture with tumor
necrosis factor increases apoptosis (programmed cell death), but extended
culture with TNF-alpha suppresses it, probably through induction of IL-8
(Dunican et al. 2000). In vitro , TNF acts as an antiangiogenic;
in vivo it assumes the nature of an angiogenic, unless redirected by interferon-gamma,
another cytokine (Frater-Schroder et al. 1987).
Tumor necrosis factor (TNF) is secreted by macrophages, monocytes, neutrophils,
T-cells, and natural killer cells (following stimulation by bacterial
lipopolysaccharides). (Lipopolysaccharide is a major component of the
cell wall of Gram-negative bacteria.) Production of TNF (also induced
by oxidative stress) can activate nuclear factor-kappaB (NF-kB), a transcription
factor. NF-kB, so named because of its cellular location, is normally
maintained in an inactive state due to inhibitory molecules. Once activated,
NF-kB becomes a potent stimulus to cytokine production. Agents that act
at various levels, including antioxidants to repress the production of
free radicals, as well as suppressants of TNF and/or NF-kB production,
can assist in regulating cytokine production (Martin 2002; Pathfinder
Encyclopaedia 2002).
Interleukins (one arm of the cytokine family) are not created equally.
Although some show promise in cancer control, that is, IL-2, IL-7, IL-12,
IL-15, IL-18, interferon alpha, interferon gamma, GM-CSF, IP-10, and Flt-3
ligand, others can have a deleterious effect. For example, IL-6 attacks
the skeletal system and induces telomerase (an enzyme delivering immortality
to cancer cells) ( Sotiriou et al. 2001 ); IL-8 inhibits apoptosis and
is one of the strongest promoters of inflammation ( Harada 1994 ); IL-10
suppresses NK cell and macrophage function ( Ho et al 1994) ; IL-13 suppresses
T-cell mediated immunity and may be involved in the progression of Hodgkin's
disease ( de Waal Malefyt et al. 1995; Skinnider et al. 2001) ; IL-4 activates
B-cells (promoting their proliferation) while inhibiting the positive
effects of IL-2 ( Kay et al 2003) ; IL-9 can increase IL-6 levels ( Cavaillon
1990)
It is important to note that the production of proinflammatory cytokines
occurs rapidly following trauma or invasion of the body by disease-causing
organisms. But, inflammation is not an efficient means of tumor surveillance.
Inflammation, in fact, significantly works against the cancer patient
by contributing to weight loss, inhibiting beneficial interleukins, suppressing
cell-mediated immunity, and promoting angiogenesis (CIC 2000).
Once an infection or injury stimulates production of IL-1 or TNF-alpha,
these two proinflammatory compounds can further stimulate each other,
as well as IL-6. In addition, IL-1 and TNF-alpha trigger the production
of free radicals, which encourage the production of more proinflammatory
cytokines. According to Jack Challem (reporting in Let's Live Magazine),
the proinflammatory reaction essentially feeds on itself, setting the
stage for chronic inflammation. Although a cytokine response is (at times)
essential, excessive production of proinflammatory cytokines or the production
of cytokines in the wrong biological context is regarded as poor indicators
of stability and even survival among individuals with degenerative disease
(Grimble et al. 1998).
Researchers at the University of Colorado Health Sciences Center explain
that the cytokine system is self-regulating through the action of anti-inflammatory
cytokines, opposing cytokines, and cytokine receptor antagonists. If cytokine
regulation becomes deranged (with cytokine numbers favoring those considered
inflammatory), the risks of morbidity and mortality markedly increase.
Imbalance of proinflammatory and anti-inflammatory cytokines (deregulation)
is strongly linked with cardiovascular disease and arthritis and, as the
following list indicates, with cancer as well (Arend 2001; Kurzrock 2001).
IL-6 is elevated in the following cancers:
- Brain Tumor: IL-6 appears involved in tumor progression in some glioblastomas,
that is, tumors of the cerebrum (the largest and uppermost section of
the brain) or spinal cord (Sasaki et al. 2001).
- Breast Cancer: IL-6 levels are nearly 10 times higher in patients
with metastatic breast cancer. Elevated IL-6 levels are the most distinguishing
factor separating healthy controls from women with breast cancer (Benoy
et al. 2002).
- Chronic Lymphocytic Leukemia: Elevations in IL-6 and IL-10 correlate
with adverse disease features and short survival in leukemia patients
(Fayad et al. 2001).
- Colorectal Cancer: IL-6 is reported to be responsible for loss of
lean body mass during cancer cachexia in colon-26 adenocarcinoma (C-26)-bearing
mice (Fujita et al. 1996). Data also suggest that carcinoembryonic-secreting
tumors (such as colon cancers) induce the production of IL-6 and that
IL-6 stimulates tumor cell growth at metastatic sites (Belluco et al.
2000).
- Gynecological Cancers: Higher IL-6 levels are found in women with
gynecological cancers, making them less responsive to chemotherapy (Scambia
et al. 1996). Consistent elevations in IL-8 and IL-6 are observed in
ovarian cancer, the latter proving a negative prognosticator regarding
outcome (Penson et al. 2000).
- Lung Cancer: Increased levels of serum IL-6 are found in patients
with lung cancer and appear part of a systemic inflammatory response
syndrome (Dowlati et al. 1999).
- Lymphoma: Vascular endothelial growth factor (VEGF), an angiogenesis
promoter, and IL-6 levels are often higher in patients with aggressive
lymphoma. Disease-free survival rates for patients displaying high levels
of VEGF or IL-6 are poor, but the prognosis becomes worse if VEGF/IL-6
elevations coexist (Niitsu et al. 2002).
- Multiple Myeloma: IL-6 is an important cytokine in myeloma cell growth
and proliferation. Close cell-to-cell contact between myeloma cells
and the bone marrow stromal cells triggers a large amount of IL-6 production,
which supports the growth of malignant cells, as well as protecting
them from apoptosis. Elevations in IL-6 are deemed (by some) highly
predictive of survival (Blade et al. 2002; Hussein et al. 2002).
- Obstructive Jaundice: Elevations in TNF-alpha and IL-6 are observed
in patients with malignant obstructive jaundice, especially those with
a poor immediate prognosis (Puntis et al. 1996).
- Pancreatic Cancer: IL-6 and IL-8 play a role in several pancreatic
diseases, including pancreatic cancer (Blanchard et al. 2001).
- Prostate Cancer: Prostate cancer cells produce factors that increase
IL-6, a known activator of bone resorption (Garcia-Moreno et al. 2002).
- Renal Cell Carcinoma: IL-6 is implicated in osteoclastic bone resorption
and hypercalcemia, factors associated with metastatic renal cell cancer
(Paule 2001).
Important information was released in 2002 regarding the impact of too
little sleep upon IL-6 production. Researchers found that getting adequate
sleep lessened IL-6 production and exposure of tissues to its potentially
detrimental actions. Sleep deprivation caused a 40-50% average increase
in IL-6 (in both men and women) and a 20-30% increase in tumor necrosis
factor in men. Dr. Alexandros Vgontzas (professor of psychiatry at Pennsylvania
State University) stated at the annual meeting of the Endocrine Society
(June 22, 2002) that 8 hours of sleep is not a nice bonus but a necessity
if one is concerned with good health. Considering the risks imposed by
over-expression of proinflammatory cytokines, every precaution should
be implemented to preserve equilibrium between pro- and anti-inflammatory
cytokines. Thus, if insomnia is a problem, please consult the Insomnia
protocol for assistance in overcoming this disorder (Vgontzas et
al. 1999; 2001).
Therapies that influence the tumor and its microenvironment are being
aggressively pursued with the goal of converting active malignancies to
chronic disease states, with the patient maintaining a normal lifestyle
(Hussein et al. 2002). Much of current research, thus, focuses upon modulation
of the family of proinflammatory cytokines with anti-inflammatory drugs,
cytokine receptor antagonists, and nutrients (Di Girolamo et al. 1997;
Grimble et al. 1998).
There are natural agents and prescription drugs that suppress proinflammatory
cytokines. Many nutrients are broad-spectrum cytokine inhibitors, meaning
they are capable of inhibiting several proinflammatory cytokines. Although
relying upon a single nutrient (as a cytokine inhibitor) is not recommended,
it is not necessary to incorporate the full list of inhibitors into a
therapeutic program.
The following list comprises dietary supplements that suppress inflammatory
cytokines:
- DHEA inhibits TNF-alpha by 98%
and IL-6 by 95% (Kipper-Galperin et al. 1999).
- Alpha Tocopherol (Vitamin E) significantly
lowered levels of C-reactive protein and IL-6 at a dosage of 1200 IU
a day (Devaraj et al. 2000).
- DHA and EPA may reign supreme as an inhibitor
of dangerous cytokines. IL-6 is potentiated when endothelial cells are
stimulated. Omega-3 fatty acids restrain stimulating factors, such as
TNF-alpha, IL-4, or lipopolysaccharides. Void of stimulation, endothelial
cells are inhibited in their production of IL-6 (Khalfoun et al. 1997).
Fish oil inhibited IL-1 and TNF-alpha by =90% (James et al. 2000). It
should also be noted that psychological stress induces the production
of proinflammatory cytokines, such as TNF-alpha, IL-6, and IL-10. Increasing
omega-3 PUFAs lessened the proinflammatory response to psychological
stress (Maes et al. 2000). DHA and EPA can be obtained directly from
fish oil concentrates or indirectly from perilla or flax oils.
- N-Acetylcysteine (NAC) inhibited the
production of IL-6 and IL-8 induced by TNF-alpha or lipopolysaccharides
(Munoz et al. 1996; Gosset et al. 1999).
- Vitamin K inhibited IL-6 production by
lipopolysaccharide-stimulated human fibroblasts. Fibroblasts are recognized
as rich sources of cyto-kines (Reddi et al. 1995).
The transcription factor (NF-kappaB) is implicated in several types of
malignancies. Once activated, NF-kB is responsible for an onslaught of
proinflammatory cytokines. Generally, suppression of NF-kB correlates
well with inhibition of various damaging cytokines, including IL-6 and
IL-8. NF-kB can be inhibited by:
- Alpha-Lipoic Acid, antioxidants that eliminate
reactive oxygen species, also block NF-kB. Lipoic acid is particularly
effective, completely inhibiting NF-kB at a fifth of the dosage required
by N-acetyl-cysteine (Suzuki et al. 1992).
- Alpha Tocopherol Succinate (Vitamin E)
prevents monocytic cell adhesion to cytokine-stimulated endothelial
cells by inhibiting the activation of NF-kappa B (Erl et al. 1997).
- Curcumin blocks NF-kB activation and
a generation of proinflammatory cytokines (Jobin et al. 1999).
- Feverfew contains a lactone or chemical
compound called parthenolide according to Newmark et al. (2000).
- Researchers at Children's Hospital Medical
Center ( Cincinnati , OH ) determined that parthenolide inhibits nuclear
factor-kB activity (Sheehan et al. 2002).
- Genistein, an isoflavone in soy, inhibits
both basic and inducible NF-kB activation (Tabary et al. 1999).
- Green Tea, the EGCG fraction, displays
a potent inhibitory effect on NF-kB expression in hypoxic cells (Yang
et al. 1998; Muraoka et al. 2002).
- Quercetin has the ability to inhibit
NF-kB and inflammatory mediators produced by it (Ishikawa et al. 1999).
- Silymarin, a bioflavonoid, potently suppresses
NF-kB, a key in inflammatory and immune reactions (Saliou et al. 1998).
- Stinging Nettle (standardized plant extracts
from the leaves of stinging nettle, IDS23) reliably inhibits NF-kB (Riehemann
et al. 1999).
- Vitamin C inhibits the activation of
NF-kB by multiple stimuli, including IL-1 and TNF-alpha (Bowie et al.
2000).
Note: For
specific information about the nutrients detailed in the list, refer to
the Cancer Adjuvant Therapy protocol.
Comments on These Findings
The fact that many antioxidants are strong inhibitors of NF-kB activation
appears to explain another of the pathways antioxidants utilize to defend
against cancer. Various chemotherapeutic agents increase expression of
both good and bad cytokines. Thus, questions regarding safe usage of natural
agents that elicit production of both pro- and anti-inflammatory cytokines
arise.
Most of our knowledge regarding proinflammatory cytokines (such as IL-1
or TNF-alpha) is derived from experiments in which humans or animals have
been injected with either a single or a combination of inflammatory cytokines
(Dinarello 1997). However, in models of inflammation where several cytokines
are produced, specific blockade of either IL-1 or TNF-alpha (or both)
results in a reduction in the severity of inflammation. This may explain
the success when using agents that lift expression of many of the family
of cytokines, both pro- and anti-inflammatory in nature.
It is possible to test one's blood level of proinflammatory cytokines
such as TNF-alpha, interkeukin-6 (IL-6), interleukin-8 (IL-8), and interleukin-1(b).
For information regarding cytokine blood testing, call (800) 208-3444.
Although there are many supplements that can suppress proinflammatory
cytokines and inhibit the expression of NF-kB, the following are the ones
most commonly used by cancer patients:
Fish oil: 1300 mg DHA and 500 mg EPA a day to suppress inflammatory cytokines.
(Note: This potency of DHA and EPA can be obtained by taking 8 capsules
a day of a product called Super GLA/DHA.)
- DHEA: 15-75 mg a day to suppress inflammatory
cytokines. Refer to DHEA Replacement
Therapy protocol for precautions.
- Curcumin (with Bioperine): 3600 mg a
day to mitigate NF-kB activation and to inhibit protein kinase C. (Note:
This potency can be obtained by taking four capsules of Super Curcumin
with Bioperine once a day with a heavy meal containing fat.)
- Green Tea Extract (95%): 1500 mg 3 times
a day to mitigate NF-kB activation and to inhibit the telomerase enzyme.
(Note: This potency can be obtained by taking 5 Super Green Tea Extract
capsules 3 times a day.)
- Genistein: 2700 mg a day to inhibit protein
kinase C and to mitigate NF-kB activation. (Note: This potency can be
obtained by taking 5 Ultra Soy Extract capsules 4 times a day.)
- Tocopheryl Succinate (dry vitamin E):
400-1200 IU a day to mitigate NF-kB activation and to inhibit protein
kinase C.
SUMMARY
The cancer patient has a wide range of treatment choices to inhibit molecular
mechanisms that cancer cells utilize for survival and propagation. It
is interesting to note that nutrients such as green tea extract, curcumin,
and tocopheryl succinate function in several different ways to inhibit
tumor cell proliferation.
For a more thorough description of how certain dietary supplements may
be of benefit to the cancer patient, refer to the Cancer
Adjuvant Therapy protocol .
Note:
Data were collected (in part) from the work of Dr. Frank McCormick, chief
scientific officer at Onyx Pharmaceuticals, and Dr. Allen Oliff, executive
director for cancer research, and Dr. Jackson Gibbs, senior director of
cancer results, both at Merck Research Laboratories.
Product availability
Super
GLA/DHA, Mega
EPA, tocopheryl
succinate capsules (vitamin E), vitamin
C, alpha-lipoic
acid, quercetin,
DHEA, Ultra
Soy, Super
Curcumin w/Bioperine, Super
Green Tea Extract, silymarin
, and Silibinin
Plus can be ordered by calling (800) 544-4440 or by ordering online
at www.lef.org.
Staying Informed
The information published in this protocol is only as current as the
day the manuscript was sent to the printer. This protocol raises many
issues that are subject to change as new data emerge. Furthermore, cancer
is still a disease with unacceptably high mortality rates, and none of
our suggested regimens can guarantee a cure.
The Life Extension Foundation is constantly uncovering information to
provide to cancer patients. A special website has been established for
the purpose of updating patients on new findings that directly pertain
to the published cancer protocols. Whenever Life Extension discovers information
that may benefit cancer patients it will be posted on the website www.lefcancer.org.
Before utilizing the cancer protocols in this book, we suggest that you
check www.lefcancer.org to see
if any substantive changes have been made to the recommendations described
in this protocol. Based on the sheer number of newly published findings,
there could be significant alterations to the information you have just
read.
Alternatively, call 1-800-226-2370 and ask a Health Advisor if your topic
of interest has been updated on the website - www.lefcancer.org. |