| 
Thrombosis Prevention
Thrombosis: from the Greek word
thrombos, meaning clot
An abnormal blood clot inside a blood vessel is called thrombosis. Thrombosis
has been described as coagulation occurring in the wrong place or at the
wrong time. The end result of thrombosis is an obstruction of the blood
flow. Since the leading cause of death in the Western world is the formation
of an abnormal blood clot inside a blood vessel, it is important for healthy
people to take steps to prevent thrombosis. For those with risk factors
for developing thrombosis, aggressive actions must be taken to protect
against stroke, heart attack, kidney failure, pulmonary embolus, etc.
As noted above, thrombi are clots that form in a blood vessel or in
the wrong place: in an artery, a vein, or in the chambers of the heart.
Thrombi in the arteries form under high pressure and flow conditions and
are composed of platelet aggregates bound together by intrinsic fibrin
protein strands. Clots in veins form under low flow conditions, are composed
predominantly of red cells with few platelets, and contain a large amount
of interspersed fibrin strands.
These thrombi may remain static in the vessel. However, clots can also
become mobile or embolize. If a clot travels from a lower extremity vein
to the lungs, the result is a pulmonary embolism and/or a pulmonary infarction
(lung cell death). Similarly, if a clot moves from the heart or the carotid
artery to the brain, it causes a stroke. If a clot travels to a position
that occludes, or blocks, the coronary artery, it can develop into a heart
attack (myocardial infarction, or MI). Certain conditions such as irregular
heart rhythms (e.g., atrial fibrillation) and valvular diseases (e.g.,
mitral stenosis) cause atrial chamber enlargement and inefficient atrial
chamber contractions. This increases the risk of clots forming in the
atria that can mobilize to the brain and cause a stroke.
The prevention of thrombosis is essential in order to significantly
reduce heart disease, cancer, and stroke mortality. Cardiovascular disease
remains the leading cause of death at approximately 1 million deaths yearly.
This is about twice the incidence of yearly cancer deaths. Of these cardiovascular
deaths, coronary artery disease represents approximately 51%, while strokes
represent 16%. These diseases involve thrombosis in their evolution and
make up a significant percentage of all cardiovascular deaths (American
Heart Association 1997). In addition, thrombosis is a common killer of
cancer patients. Therefore, it becomes paramount to optimize the prevention
of thrombosis in order to reduce the high incidence of death from cardiovascular
as well as other diseases.
SYMPTOMS
The symptoms of thrombosis depend on where the clot forms. During a
heart attack, which sometimes occurs because a clot lodges in a coronary
artery, the onset of associated symptoms is usually sudden in nature.
If the coronary artery involved is a minor vessel and the vessel is occluded
(blocked) by the clot at its terminal end, the heart attack may be without
any symptoms at all. However, when the clot is large and suddenly occludes
the left main coronary artery, the entire blood supply to the left ventricle
is suddenly cut off and the heart attack is massive and abruptly fatal.
Branches of the left or right main coronary arteries can be occluded by
embolisms or, more commonly, by small clots that form on the wall of a
coronary artery and mix with oxidized LDL and fibrinogen to occlude the
vessel, forming what is called an atheroma, and narrowing the lumen of
the involved coronary artery.
This occlusion often causes the classic symptoms of a sudden heart attack:
angina-related chest pain, shortness of breath, cold and clammy perspiration,
cold extremities, overwhelming anxiety, nausea, profound weakness, dizziness,
difficulty concentrating, chest fluttering, and palpitations or other
irregular heart beats. The classic chest pain felt during a heart attack
resembles a heavy, crushing, constricting sensation. This pain can originate
in the chest, the left or right arm, the shoulders, or even the jaw. The
pain often extends from the chest down the left arm. However, the extension
of pain can move from the chest to the right arm or even to the jaw. When
associated with an on-going heart attack, the pain tends to last 10-15
minutes rather than 1-3 minutes prior to the heart attack.
In cases where the occlusion is less severe or in cases of impaired
nerve supply (e.g., as in diabetic neuropathy), a heart attack can occur
without any symptoms and even present to the emergency room with a normal
EKG. In this situation, the heart attack is diagnosed by identifying positive
cardiac enzymes in the blood. If classic heart attack symptoms manifest,
the most important initial step the victim can take is to chew on 1 whole
aspirin tablet. The antiplatelet actions of aspirin can sometimes forestall
a full-blown heart attack.
The symptoms associated with a thrombotic stroke are varied, depending
on whether the stroke occurs from a sudden embolism or gradual clot formation.
In a cerebral embolic stroke, the symptoms are rapid in onset and often
peak within a few seconds. Victims may experience seizures and a headache
on the affected side due to the sudden onset of symptoms. In a cerebral
thrombotic stroke, the onset is over minutes or hours and occasionally
the stroke progresses in stages over days or weeks.
The symptoms that occur during a stroke depend upon the region of the
brain that is injured. For example, when the region supplying the eyes
(the retinal region) is involved, patients experience transient blackouts
and the sense that a shade is being pulled over their eyes. When the cerebrum
is involved, contralateral monoparesis, hemiparesis, localized tingling,
numbness, hemianopic visual loss, aphasia, and (rare) losses of consciousness
can occur. When the vertebrobasilar region is involved, patients experience
bilateral visual disturbances (dim, gray, blurred vision, or temporary
total blindness called diplopia). Vertebrobasilar episodes cause symptoms
to be induced by abrupt position changes while carotid episodes do not.
When the labyrinth or medulla is involved, vertigo, unsteadiness, nausea,
and vomiting occur. When the brainstem is involved, patients experience
slurred speech, dysarthria, dysphagia, numbness, weakness, and all four-limb
paresthesia. "Drop" attacks from sudden loss of postural tone
are symptoms of a stroke that is basilar in origin.
The symptoms associated with the onset of a pulmonary embolism or infarction
can be nonspecific and often vary in frequency and intensity. This depends
upon the extent of pulmonary vascular occlusion, the functional strength
of the heart before the embolism occurred, and the size of the emboli.
Small emboli, or microemboli, may be asymptomatic. However, if symptoms
occur, they tend to develop abruptly over a few minutes, including sudden
shortness of breath or breathlessness with or without a cough or wheezing,
rapid breathing, anxiety, and restlessness. Often at the time of pulmonary
embolism, high blood pressure exists within the pulmonary arterial vasculature.
If this is the case, when the embolism occurs, dull chest pain may occur.
In a massive pulmonary embolism, right heart failure may develop with
fluid in the abdominal and lower extremities. There may be lightheadedness,
unconsciousness, and seizures due to a drop in cardiac output from the
failing heart. The face often turns white and bluish (cyanosis).
SILENT STROKES
Several studies have shown that the incidence of "silent"
strokes in the elderly is very high. Over time, these "silent"
strokes lead to memory loss and other neurological problems, of particular
concern for people who are at risk for stroke.
An article in the journal Neurology found that 28% of the 3324 older
participants in the Cardiovascular Health Study had evidence of silent
infarcts discovered on cranial magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). The authors
also found that high blood pressure, thickness of common and internal
carotid walls, and the presence of atrial fibrillation were associated
with an increased risk of stroke in those with silent infarcts (Bernick
et al. 2001).
THE BLOOD CLOTTING
SYSTEM
The blood clotting system is activated when blood vessels are damaged,
exposing collagen, the major protein that connective tissue is made from.
Platelets circulating in the blood adhere to exposed collagen on the cell
wall of the blood vessel and secrete chemicals that start the clotting
process as follows:
- Platelet aggregators cause platelets to clump together (aggregate).
They also cause the blood vessels to contract (vasoconstrict), which
reduces blood loss. Platelet aggregators include adenosine diphosphate
(ADP), thromboxane A2, and serotonin (5-HT).
- Coagulants such as fibrin then bind the platelets together to form
a permanent plug (clot) that seals the leak.
Fibrin is formed from fibrinogen in a complex series of reactions called
the coagulation cascade. The enzymes that comprise the coagulation system
are called coagulation factors, which are numbered in the order in which
they were discovered. They include factor XII, factor XI, factor IX, factor
X, factor VII, and factor V. The activation of the coagulation factors
results in the formation of thrombin, which acts as a cofactor for the
conversion of fibrinogen into fibrin.
After the leak has been sealed with a blood clot, the body responds
with another set of chemical messengers that oppose the actions of these
chemicals. These include:
- Platelet aggregation inhibitors and vasodilators, such as nitric
oxide and prostacyclin, which is also known as prostaglandin I2 (PGI2)
- Plasminogen activators that promote the breakdown of fibrin, such
as tissue plasminogen activator (t-PA)
- Anticoagulants that inhibit enzymes in the coagulation cascade, such
as antithrombin III (activated by heparin) and proteins C and S
As you can see, the blood clotting system is quite complex. In the healthy
body, a balance is created between the opposing chemicals--for example,
coagulants versus anticoagulants; vasodilators versus vasoconstrictors;
and platelet aggregators versus platelet aggregator inhibitors. The beauty
of nutritional supplements is that they support the natural mechanisms
of the body and allow the body to maintain its own equilibrium (homeostasis).
THROMBOSIS RELATED
TO ATHEROSCLEROSIS (HARDENING OF ARTERIES)
It is generally accepted that platelet adherence to plaques on the linings
of arteries is part of the atherosclerosis cascade. Platelet adherence
is worsened by excess fibrin. Platelets release a platelet-derived growth
factor, causing the smooth muscle cells on the walls of arteries to proliferate.
The resultant smooth muscle cells have an increased permeability to platelets
and lipids, especially LDL-cholesterol. As LDL increases, it penetrates
further into the arterial wall. Plaque forms in the arterial wall as a
benign neoplastic growth (a monoclonal mutation). Excess fibrin, free
radicals, chronic inflammation, homocysteine, oxidized LDL, and environmental
hydrocarbons, etc. aggravate this mutation.
In the free radical hypothesis, lipid peroxides damage the arterial
walls, further enhancing wall permeability, as well as additionally increasing
the oxidation of lipids, especially LDL. These free radicals invade the
arterial wall and activate cell proliferation and abnormal cell duplication.
The newly mutated cells migrate into the arterial wall and induce plaque
formation. This cell proliferation increases the surrounding clot growth
or thrombus formation. T-cell antibodies regulate this process. The resulting
lesions are atheromatous plaque. The surrounding thrombi form primarily
from modified smooth muscle cells, LDL, and fibrin.
Naturally occurring thrombolytic enzymes that dissolve clots are generated
in the endothelial cells of blood vessels. As people age, production of
these enzymes slows and the blood is more prone to coagulation. This results
in clotting. However, clots can form at any age.
CAUSES
Thrombosis can be caused by one or more of the following events:
- Injury to the cells that line the heart, arteries, and veins (endothelium)
- Sluggish blood flow, thatcontributes to venous thrombosis, usually
affects the veins of the lower extremities. Venous thrombi may cause
one-sided edema of the ankle and foot, but often are asymptomatic until
they embolize.
- Alterations in arterial blood flow that give rise to arterial thrombosis
- Hypercoagulability (thick blood) which can also cause thrombosis
- Excess fibrinogen
- Excess platelet aggregation, adhesiveness, and/or activity
Although anticoagulants (such as Coumadin and heparin) are the conventional
treatment of choice for thrombosis prevention, thrombi which arise solely
from hypercoagulability are considered to be uncommon. There are quite
a few risk factors for hypercoagulable states: myocardial infarction,
prolonged bed rest or immobilization, tissue damage (e.g., burns, surgery,
fractures), cardiac failure, cancer, acute leukemia, myeloproliferative
disorders, heart valve replacement, disseminated intravascular coagulation,
thrombotic thrombocytopenia, homocysteinuria, smoking, hypercholesterolemia,
atrial fibrillation, cardiomyopathy, nephrotic syndrome, late pregnancy
post-delivery, oral contraceptives, hyperlipidemia, lupus anticoagulant,
sickle cell anemia, and thrombocytosis.
Blood stasis and endothelial injury, however, may be a common underlying
mechanism for many of these risk factors (Table 1).
| 1. Underlying Causes of Thrombosis |
| Endothelial injury |
Trauma from accidents, surgery, etc.
Following myocardial infarction
On ulcerated plaques in advanced atherosclerosis
From toxins in cigarette smoke
High cholesterol
Homocysteine
Bacterial toxins or endotoxins
Immune complex deposition
Presence of inflammatory mediators: cytokines, macrophages
Viral infections
Drugs |
| Sluggish venous blood flow |
Prolonged bed rest, immobilization, or
reduced physical activity (movement is required to pump the blood
through the veins back to the heart)
Cardiac failure resulting in decreased cardiac output, particularly
right-sided heart failure
Nephrotic syndrome
Disseminated cancer
Oral contraceptives |
| Alterations in arterial blood flow |
Myocardial infarction
Rheumatic heart disease, which leads to blocking of the mitral valve
Cardiac arrhythmias, including atrial fibrillation with related atrial
chamber enlargement
Atherosclerosis (lipid deposits with smooth muscle cell proliferation
and inflammatory mediators that clog the arteries)
Aneurysms (abnormal dilations of arteries) |
| Hypercoagulability (thick blood) |
Genetic disorders, including deficiencies
of antithrombin III, protein C, or protein S, and fibrinolysis defects
Oral contraceptives, causing an increase in plasma fibrinogen, prothrombin,
and clotting factors VII, VIII, and X
Disseminated intravascular coagulation due to secretion of factors
that activate coagulation
Factor X
Systemic lupus due to an antibody known as lupus anticoagulant
Autoantibodies against anionic phospholipids (cardiolipin) |
Cancer Patients
In cancer patients, disorders related to blood clotting are frequently
observed. The biological processes leading to coagulation are probably
involved in the mechanisms of metastasis. About 50% of all cancer patients,
and up to 95% of those with metastatic disease, show some abnormalities
(a prethrombotic state) in the coagulation-fibrinolytic system. Thromboembolic
complications are seen in up to 11% of cancer patients, and hemorrhage
occurs in about 10%. Thromboembolism and hemorrhage, as a whole, are the
second most common cause of death after infection (Ambrus et al. 1975;
Lip et al. 2002).
In one study, subclinical changes in the coagulation-fibrinolytic system
were frequently detected in lung cancer patients. Five conventional tests
and a new standard of blood coagulation were prospectively recorded in
a series of 286 patients with new primary lung cancer: platelet count
(P); prothrombin time (PT); partial thromboplastin time (PTT); fibrinogen
(F); and d-dimer of fibrin (DD). A prethrombotic state--depicted by a
prolongation of PT, PTT, and increase of d-dimer of fibrin--was significantly
associated with an adverse outcome (van Wersch et al. 1991; Gabazza et
al. 1993; Buccheri et al. 1997).
Anticoagulant treatment of cancer patients, particularly those with
lung cancer, has been reported to improve survival. These interesting,
although preliminary, results of controlled trials lend some support to
the argument that activation of blood coagulation plays a role in the
natural history of tumor growth. Studies compared the effectiveness of
standard heparin with low molecular weight heparin (LMWH) in the treatment
of deep vein thrombosis (DVT). In both studies, mortality rates were lower
in the patients randomized to LMWH. The analysis of these deaths reveals
a striking difference in cancer-related mortality (Green et al. 1992;
Hull et al. 1992; Prandoni et al. 1992; Sciumbata et al. 1996; Hejna et
al. 1999).
Cancer-related mortality with standard heparin was 31% versus 11% with
low molecular weight heparin. This difference cannot solely be attributed
to thrombotic or bleeding events. Because large numbers of cancer patients
were included in the studies, it seems unlikely that there were more patients
with advanced tumors in the standard heparin group than in the low molecular
weight heparin group. Although it also is possible that standard heparin
increases cancer mortality, such an adverse effect has not been previously
reported. These considerations suggest that low molecular weight heparin
might exert an inhibitory effect on tumor growth (Collen et al. 2000;
von Tempelhoff et al. 2000; Mismetti et al. 2001; Prandoni 2001).
If your oncologist does not or will not test for thrombotic risk factors,
contact the Life Extension Foundation at (800) 544-4440.
CONVENTIONAL PREVENTION
AND TREATMENT
Preventing thrombosis is essential. Inside a healthy circulatory system,
the body constantly prevents clotting. Coagulation/anticoagulation is
a "mechanism" that the body must maintain in perfect balance.
If this process fails, our lives can be in danger in a matter of minutes.
To function optimally, the body must keep blood flowing well in all
vessels, regardless of size. When a leak (or damage) occurs in an artery
or vein, the body must encourage the coagulation aspect of this balance
to seal the leak. However, when there is a significant disturbance or
a clot in the blood flow, the consequences are often lethal.
Because so many factors can contribute to coagulation and therefore
should be considered for prevention, it is difficult for conventional
medicine to control them all. Mainstream medicine can exert control on
some crucial steps in the coagulation cascade, but it may often fail to
influence them all.
PRESCRIPTION DRUGS
Several prescription drugs address different parts of the coagulation/anticoagulation
system:
- Coumadin (warfarin) inhibits the synthesis of vitamin K-dependent
coagulation factors such as Factors II, VII, IX and X and anticoagulant
proteins C and S.
- Aspirin inhibits platelet aggregation by interfering with thromboxane
synthesis.
- Ticlopidine (Ticlid) inhibits platelet aggregation by interfering
with the binding of fibrinogen to the platelet membrane. Ticlopidine
is a prescription drug that may be of particular value as an alternative
to aspirin. Ticlopidine is often considered in patients that have a
high risk of thrombotic stroke and are intolerant to aspirin.
- Heparin (administered intravenously) increases the activity of antithrombin
III, which prevents the conversion of fibrinogen to fibrin. Heparin
is not absorbed by the gastrointestinal (GI) tract and must be administered
intravenously. It is usually only used in emergency situations (e.g.,
after a stroke).
- Tissue plasminogen factor (t-PA) activates plasmin which breaks apart
fibrin. t-PA is used in emergency situations to dissolve blood clots.
Streptokinase is another tissue plasminogen factor drug. Both of these
drugs are administered intravenously in emergency thrombotic situations
(e.g., ischemic stroke or MI).
Platelet Aggregation Inhibitors
(Platelet Anti-Aggregation Drugs)
Aspirin
More than any other medication, aspirin is used alone for the prevention
of recurrent strokes and transient ischemic attacks (TIAs). Aspirin acts
to inhibit blood clotting by reducing platelet aggregation (clumping),
thereby preventing the formation of platelet plugs. Aspirin inhibits cyclooxygenase,
which facilitates the production of thromboxane A2 (TA2). TA2 is a potent
inducer of platelet aggregation and vasoconstriction. In humans, platelet
cyclooxygenase can be completely inhibited with aspirin at doses as low
as 30 mg daily. A study compared the use of aspirin with warfarin in the
prevention of recurrent ischemic strokes: over a 2-year period, it was
found that aspirin, as well as warfarin, protected against stroke recurrence
and death (Mohr et al. 2001). Warfarin is prescribed for stroke recurrence
prevention in many patients who have had an ischemic stroke. Therefore,
aspirin is a reasonable, equally effective approach for some people, but
for persons with artificial heart valves and certain types of atrial fibrillation,
Coumadin has been shown to be more effective than aspirin in preventing
stroke (Hurlen et al. 2002).
Other Conventional Platelet Aggregation
Inhibition Drugs
There are a number of other drugs that act as platelet aggregation inhibitors,
including dipyridamole, ticlopidine, and clopidogrel. As noted above,
aspirin can provide comparable platelet aggregation inhibition and related
risk reduction.
Anticoagulants
Coumarin Derivatives
Derivatives of Coumarin (e.g., generics warfarin and dicumarol) interfere
with the rate of synthesis of blood clotting factors II (prothrombin),
VII, IX, and X. As a result, prothrombin and partial thromboplastin times
are significantly altered by anticoagulants, but are not altered by antiplatelet
agents such as aspirin. Patients taking Coumarin derivatives are monitored
for PT and PTT times to optimize dosing and avoid excessive bleeding.
Coumadin (warfarin) is the most frequently prescribed drug for thrombosis
prophylaxis (prevention). It is an anticoagulant drug that was originally
isolated in 1939 from sweet clover. Interestingly, Coumadin is the active
ingredient found in many commercial rat poisons and insecticides. It works
by interfering with the synthesis of vitamin K-dependent coagulation factors.
Coumadin is used as a prophylaxis for myocardial infarction, stroke, arterial
thromboembolism, and deep venous thrombosis. It is also used in patients
with prosthetic heart valves.
Coumadin prolongs both PT and APTT, but PT is the one used to guide
treatment. However, the new standard is the International Normalization
Ratio (INR) which is described below. Bleeding is the primary adverse
effect of Coumadin therapy. Bleeding is related to the intensity of anticoagulation,
length of therapy, the patient's underlying clinical state, and the use
of other drugs that can affect blood coagulation or interfere with Coumadin
metabolism.
Minor bleeding from Coumadin therapy usually begins with ecchymoses
(purple patches on the skin). Then the mucous membranes are affected,
causing epistaxis (nosebleed) and subconjunctival hemorrhage (bleeding
under the mucous membranes covering the eyes and inner eyelids). Purple
toe syndrome is also associated with Coumadin therapy. Hematuria (blood
in the urine) may also occur. Major bleeding complications usually involve
gastrointestinal (GI) and intracranial bleeding.
Coumadin has an extremely long list of contraindications and drug interactions
(see the Cerebral Vascular Disease/Thrombotic Stroke protocol for a complete
list). Of particular concern is its use in elderly patients because they
are more susceptible to the effects of anticoagulants and have an increased
risk of hemorrhage. Several common drugs interact with Coumadin, including
acetominaphen, cimetidine, lovastatin, thyroid hormones, and estrogens
and oral contraceptives.
Caution: Do
not take aspirin or nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs (NSAIDs), such
as ibuprofen (e.g., Motrin, Advil, Nuprin, etc.), ketop (e.g., Orudis,
Orudis KT, Oruvail), naproxen (e.g., Naprosyn, Aleve, Anaprox), or other
over-the-counter products while taking Coumadin, except under the supervision
of your doctor. Over-the-counter NSAIDs increase the risk of bleeding.
Consult your physician before taking any new prescription or over-the-counter
product. Always take Coumadin in the evening, preferably between 5 p.m.-7
p.m.
Combining Coumadin with Antiplatelet
Agents
As has been previously described, Coumadin interferes with specific coagulation
factors that can induce a thrombotic event. Coumadin is classified as
an "anticoagulant" agent.
Aspirin, fish oil, vitamin E, and garlic inhibit platelet adhesion and
platelet aggregation and are classified as "antiplatelet" agents.
The inhibition of blood platelets' ability to adhere and/or aggregate
also decreases the likelihood of thrombosis.
In a perfect world, an individualized program would be designed to deliver
the optimal combination of anticoagulation and antiplatelet agents to
provide the broadest protection against thrombosis without inducing hemorrhage.
There is much debate and confusion about the interactions between dietary
nutrients and prescription antithrombotic medications regarding clot formation.
The concern expressed in some studies involves potential interactions
between Coumadin and antiplatelet agents such as ginkgo biloba, green
tea, vitamin E, garlic, and fish oil (Heck et al. 2000). There has been
apprehension that certain supplements put the patient at risk for bleeding
problems by adding to the overall effects of Coumadin.
As a result of this concern, some doctors advise patients who are taking
Coumadin to avoid any dietary supplement that could possibly cause increased
bleeding. A problem with this ultra-cautious approach is that it deprives
the patient of nutrients they may need to sustain life. It also prevents
the use of antiplatelet agents that act on hemostatic mechanisms, separate
from those of Coumadin, to reduce more effectively the risk of thrombosis.
There are major medical publications that confirm the importance of lowering
the incidence of cerebrovascular stroke and heart attack by such a two-pronged
approach using an agent with antiplatelet activity, for example, Coumadin
(Fasey et al. 2002; Hurlen et al. 2002).
A patient taking Coumadin has to be concerned that any food, drug, nutrient,
or other substance they put into their body may not only increase the
bleeding time, but also affect Coumadin metabolism, which may either increase
or decrease the effect of Coumadin on the International Normalized Ratio
(INR). The inherent variability that occurs in each individual taking
Coumadin makes it difficult to provide general guidance. For instance,
the underlying medical condition determines the degree of desired anticoagulation.
No studies have correlated optimal anticoagulant doses of Coumadin, as
measured by the INR reference range, with optimal doses of multiple antiplatelet
agents, as measured by the template bleeding time (TBT).
The template bleeding time is done in a physician's office where a template
device nicks the skin and the number of minutes it takes for blood flow
to stop is assessed by a nurse or lab technician. The "normal"
template bleeding time is up to 9 minutes. A bleeding time (BT) of 4-5
minutes might indicate increased thrombotic risk, although a BT over 9
minutes may indicate an increased hemorrhagic risk. However, what is really
important in this setting is the patient context, as discussed below.
As it relates to antiplatelet agents like fish oil and garlic, a BT
of 4-5 minutes could suggest a benefit of taking higher amounts of these
agents, whereas a BT over 9 minutes in a patient already on an antiplatelet
agent might indicate that antiplatelet agent doses are having a biological
effect and further dose increases should be avoided. The problem patients
face today is that there are no standards that document the ideal balance
between Coumadin and antiplatelet agents such as fish oil, garlic, vitamin
E, etc. Too much Coumadin and/or antiplatelet agents can cause hemorrhage,
whereas too little Coumadin and/or antiplatelet agent(s) can cause thrombosis.
In this setting or context, as with many medical issues, balance is the
key concept. The approach that the meticulous physician uses to achieve
this balance is called "titration." There is an art to titrating
doses to where the "happy medium" is reached. This is embraced
in the key medical concept of therapeutic index which relates to the equation:
TI (Therapeutic Index) = Therapeutic Benefits ÷
SideEffects of Therapy.
In an ideal setting, a physician would carefully monitor the INR and
the TBT to measure precisely the optimal level of anticoagulant and antiplatelet
agents, respectively, in an individual patient. For instance, a patient
with a heart valve replacement may have a desired INR range of 2.5-3.0,
while an optimal template bleeding time may be between 7-9 minutes. If
these tests were routinely conducted, a more scientific determination
of the ideal intake of Coumadin, fish oil, garlic, vitamin E, etc. could
be made.
Some early reports indicated that CoQ10 may reduce the anti-coagulant
efficacy of Coumadin (Spigset 1994). These reports have been contradicted
by a more recent study showing that CoQ10 does not affect Coumadin’s
anticoagulation mechanisms (Engelsen et al. 2003).
Heparin
Heparin inhibits thrombosis (clotting) via inactivating factor X and by
inhibiting the conversion of prothrombin to thrombin. Activation of factor
X is the major rate-limiting step in the coagulation cascade. By inhibiting
the activation of the fibrin-stabilizing factor by thrombin, heparin prevents
formation of a stable fibrin clot. Heparin also decreases the levels of
triglycerides by releasing lipoprotein lipase from tissues. The resultant
hydrolysis of triglycerides causes increased blood levels of free fatty
acids.
Exanta® -- A Novel Drug on the
Horizon
A new drug application for Exanta was filed with the FDA in the fourth
quarter of 2003. Exanta (ximelagatran) is a novel drug with potential
to revolutionize anticoagulant management. It is the first oral anticoagulant
drug in over 50 years—since warfarin (Coumadin) — to reach
late-stage clinical development. Current clinical trials are investigating
the efficacy ximelagatran for treatment of venous thromboembolism and
atrial fibrillation to prevent stroke. Ximelagatran is a specific, reversible,
direct inhibitor of the clotting factor thrombin. It inhibits free and
clot-bound thrombin and has a half-life of 1.7 to 2.5 hours (Samama et
al. 2002). Ximelagatran has significant advantages: oral administration;
minimal monitoring; active immediately; a short half-life; and no known
pharmacokinetic food or drug interactions (Petersen et al. 2003). Because
it has a predictable blood-thinning effect, the frequent monitoring and
dose adjustments required for warfarin are not needed for ximelagatran.
Its short half-life allows ximelagatran to be discontinued a few hours
before surgery. Bleeding events are also low. Studies report impressive
results:
- • ESTEEM II (Efficacy and Safety
of the Oral Thrombin Inhibitor Ximelagatran in Combination
with Aspirin, in PatiEnts with REcent
Myocardial Damage): ESTEEM II is a placebo-controlled,
double-blind, multicenter (191 hospitals), multinational (18 countries)
study that assessed 1883 patients with recent MI for 6 months. Study
participants were given oral ximelagatran (24, 36, 48, or 60 mg) or
placebo twice daily. All participants received aspirin (160 mg) daily.
All-cause deaths, non-fatal MIs, and severe recurrent ischemia for ximelagatran
and placebo were compared. After 6 months, oral ximelagatran combined
with aspirin significantly reduced the risk of major cardiovascular
events (24% compared to aspirin alone) with rare major bleeding events
and no serious, clinically adverse outcomes related to the drug (Brown
2003; Wallentin et al. 2003).
- • SPORTIF III (Stroke Prevention
by ORal Thrombin Inhibitor
in Atrial Fibrillation): SPORTIF III is a randomized,
open-label, parallel-group study (3407 patients; 259 sites; 23 countries)
to investigate ximelagatran as an alternative to warfarin to prevent
thromboembolism and stroke in subjects with non-valvular atrial fibrillation
(NVAF). In addition to NVAF, subjects had at least one additional stroke
risk factor: previous MI, TIA, systemic embolism, hypertension, left
ventricular dysfunction, age 75, or age 65 with coronary artery disease
or diabetes mellitus. The objective was to establish the non-inferiority
(as good as, no compromise) of ximelagatran compared to warfarin. Endpoints
were incidence of stroke and systemic embolic events (death, MI, TIA,
bleeding with treatment ended). Fixed-dose ximelagatran (36 mg) was
given twice daily. Patients were treated for an average of 17 months.
Twice-daily fixed-dose ximelagatran compared favorably with dose-adjusted
warfarin in preventing stroke and systemic embolism events in AF. Despite
lack of coagulation monitoring and the fixed-dose regimen, bleeding
events were lower for ximelagatran than for warfarin, and there was
no significant difference in all-cause mortality between the two treatment
groups. The results of SPORTIF III suggest that ximelagatran can offer
an alternative to warfarin and its complications without compromising
patient safety or efficacy (Halperin et al. 2003; Saunders 2003).
- • THRIVE III (THrombin Inhibitor
in Venous Thromboembolism). THRIVE
III is a double-blind, multicenter, randomized trial that enrolled 1233
patients who had received anticoagulant therapy for 6 months for venous
thromboembolism. The patients were randomly assigned to receive extended
secondary prevention of venous thromboembolism with 24 mg of oral ximelagatran
(612) or placebo (611), twice daily for 18 months, with no monitoring
of coagulation. Symptomatic recurrent venous thromboembolism occurred
in 12 subjects in the ximelagatran group and in 71 subjects in the placebo
group (all-cause death, 6 vs. 7; bleeding, 134 vs. 111; major hemorrhage,
6 vs. 5 with no fatalities). For individuals who discontinue anticoagulant
treatment with warfarin after 6 months because the risk of bleeding
outweighs the risk of recurrence, long-term treatment with ximelagatran
offers clinically significant reduction of recurrent venous thromboembolism
without coagulation monitoring and dose adjustments (Barclay 2003; Schulman
et al. 2003).
Compared to warfarin, ESTEEM II, SPORTIF III, and THRIVE III studies
all reported an increased incidence of elevated liver enzymes in the early
months of ximelagatran treatment. The lowest dose of ximelagatran (24
mg) elevated liver enzymes in 6.5% of patients compared to placebo (1.2%).
Elevations were seen in 12 to 13% of patients at higher doses (36, 48,
60 mg). Elevated enzyme levels were not associated with specific clinical
symptoms and they decreased toward baseline levels as treatment continued
or when it was discontinued (Brown 2003; Saunders 2003).
Arixtra® (fondaparinum, fondaparinux sodium) is another synthetic
antithrombotic drug with a defined mechanism of action, specifically to
inhibit factor FXa (a mediating factor in thrombin formation, the final
factor in the blood clotting process). It has a half-life of about 17
hours. Fondaparinux inhibits free FXa, but not FXa bound to prothrombinase
(Samama et al. 2002). Because Arixtra binds exclusively to only factor
Xa which is essential to the clotting process, it ensures a highly predictable
antithrombotic effect (Organon/Sanofi-Synthelabo 2002). Arixtra is the
first synthetic antithrombotic drug used during hip fracture, hip replacement,
or knee replacement surgery to reduce the risk of a pulmonary embolism
(received FDA approval for hip fracture and hip and knee replacement surgery
on December 7, 2001).
Laboratory Tests for Patient Response
to Anticoagulants
It is extremely important to regularly evaluate a patient's response to
Coumadin (or any other anticoagulant). This ensures that excess bleeding
does not occur due to improper dosing of the medication. The standard
blood test to assess coagulation status is the PT test using the INR as
a standard unit of measurement. This blood test enables your physician
to adjust the dose of Coumadin to provide optimal anticoagulation benefits
without inducing serious bleeding.
The target INR for a person taking Coumadin varies depending on the
type of disorder that puts the patient at risk for thrombosis. For some
disorders, the ranges are between 1.6-2.5, although others may extend
up to 3.5. Although test results can vary considerably between individuals,
the INR becomes a very important number to evaluate. If, for instance,
you significantly overcoagulate and your INR levels significantly exceed
4.5, your physician can prescribe vitamin K to bring your INR levels into
a safe range. Some physicians fail to prescribe vitamin K and just tell
the overcoagulated patient to stop the Coumadin. Failing to prescribe
vitamin K during an acute overcoagulation state (INR over 4.5) puts a
patient in serious jeopardy.
Additionally, as noted earlier, if you are taking an anticoagulant drug
such as Coumadin or heparin, you must be very careful about what you eat
and what medicines you take as well as being diligent about having your
blood checked regularly. This is even more essential if you take a combination
of drugs for other conditions or take over-the-counter medications such
as aspirin. With the concomitant use of natural therapies and aspirin,
the need for weekly or biweekly blood monitoring increases even more.
The two most important markers or references to monitor for those taking
other drugs and/or antiplatelet agents with Coumadin are the INR reference
range and the TBT test.
For those taking Coumadin, prothrombin blood tests using the INR reference
ranges are recommended weekly or biweekly. For those with serious diseases
such as cancer, in addition to using INR reference ranges, the following
supplementary blood tests might be considered every 30-90 days to measure
thrombotic risk more precisely:
- PTT
- Fibrinogen
- D-dimer of fibrin
How PTs and INRs Are Calculated
When a fibrin clot forms, the time measured in seconds is referred to
as the prothrombin time (PT). Thromboplastin agents used for testing come
from various sources with varying degrees of sensitivity. This is important
information because the result can have a detrimental effect on the management
of the anticoagulant therapy.
To standardize potential differences in sensitivity between reagents,
manufacturers assign an International Sensitivity Index (ISI) to each
batch of reagent. The ISI is then compared to a working reference reagent
preparation. The INR is a mathematical calculation that corrects for the
variability of PT results due to the variable sensitivities of the thromboplastin
agents used by various laboratories.
INR = (patient PT/control PT) × ISI (International Sensitivity
Index)
THROMBOTIC RISK FACTORS
Homocysteine
Homocysteine is a toxic compound formed in the body from the amino acid
methionine. Several studies have shown that homocysteine increases blood
coagulation by inhibiting tissue fibrinogen activators. The result is
increased levels of fibrinogen and fibrin (de Jong et al. 1998; Selhub
et al. 1998; Coppola et al. 2000; Durand et al. 2001; Kuch et al. 2001).
In order to reduce blood homocysteine levels, adequate amounts of folic
acid, vitamin B12, and vitamin B6 are usually required. High homocysteine
levels have been shown to be a risk factor for cardiovascular disease,
including atherosclerosis, heart attack, and stroke. Ideal levels of homocysteine
are under 7 micromoles/L of blood.
For more information about homocysteine, see the Cardiovascular
Disease protocol.
Fibrinogen
Fibrinogen is the precursor to fibrin, a coagulant protein that binds
platelets together to form a blood clot. It has a role in normal and abnormal
clot formation (coagulation) in the body. During coagulation, fibrinogen
reacts with thrombin, releasing four small fibrinopeptides that produce
fibrin, which in turn creates an insoluble fibrin network generally referred
to as a scab.
Fibrinogen also participates in the cellular phase of coagulation. Fibrinogen
promotes platelet aggregation, which can lead to diminished blood flow
and reduced delivery of oxygen to the body. Fibrinogen can also cause
blood platelets to bind together, initiating abnormal arterial blood clots.
An article in the journal Neurology described a study of cardiovascular
laboratory tests in 136 patients with acute stroke, 76 patients with comparable
risk factors for stroke, and 48 healthy controls. Statistical analysis
found that prior stroke and fibrinogen levels predicted new events in
stroke patients. After 1 year, fibrinogen levels remained elevated in
stroke survivors. The researchers concluded that fibrinogen levels are
associated with increased risk of recurrent vascular events (Beamer et
al. 1998).
The Life Extension Foundation recommends the measurement of fibrinogen
as part of a cardiovascular risk assessment. The normal reference range
for fibrinogen is 200-400 mg/dL. Optimally, fibrinogen should be 200-300
mg/dL.
Atherosclerosis
Once symptomatic atherosclerosis has developed, a person is at significant
risk for stroke, heart attack, and peripheral arterial occlusion. The
occlusive event (stroke, MI, etc.) tends to develop at sites of preexisting
narrowing (stenosis). Atherosclerotic plaques can rupture and expose tissue
factor-rich plaque contents to the blood, initiating thrombus formation.
Inflammation
Chronic inflammation is associated with a variety of chronic diseases,
including cardiovascular disease. C-reactive protein (CRP) is a sensitive
indicator of inflammation that rises before the erythrocyte sedimentation
rate. CRP is a marker of systemic inflammation and unstable arterial plaque,
both of which are indictors of increased thrombotic risk. Certain pro-inflammatory
immune cytokines cause elevated CRP. These cytokines may be suppressed
by taking supplements such as the DHA fraction of fish oil, the hormone
DHEA, vitamin K, and nettle leaf extract.
An article in the journal Thrombosis Research described a study of patients
with acute thrombotic stroke prior to treatment. The patients with elevated
CRP also had significantly elevated plasma levels of thrombin-antithrombin
complex, plasmin-antiplasmin complex, and d-dimer of fibrin. When compared
to those with normal levels, platelet aggregation induced by ADP was also
significantly higher in patients with elevated CRP. The authors hypothesized
that the activation of the blood coagulation and platelet aggregation
system may be related to elevated CRP levels in stroke patients (Tohgi
et al. 2000). A feature article in the May 2002 issue of Scientific American
further emphasized the link between chronic inflammation and the evolution
of atherosclerosis and coronary artery disease (Libby 2002).
Measuring CRP levels (using a high-sensitivity C-reactive protein blood
test) is highly recommended by the Life Extension Foundation (see Table
2 for the normal and optimal range of CRP).
Lipoprotein(a)
Lipoprotein(a) is an altered form of LDL cholesterol that has a structure
nearly identical to plasminogen, a protein that forms plasmin. Plasmin
dissolves fibrin. Unfortunately, lipoprotein(a) inhibits the breakdown
of fibrin by competing with plasminogen. Lipoprotein(a) was found to be
a key component in blood clots, plaque formation and coronary heart disease
(CHD) (Rath et al. 1989; Beisiegel et al. 1990).
Linus Pauling's theory of heart disease focused on the adverse effects
of lipoprotein(a) on the cardiovascular system. Pauling and Rath proposed
that lipoprotein(a) acted as a surrogate (replacement) for vitamin C (Rath
et al. 1990a). They also proposed that a deficiency of vitamin C resulted
in the increased production of lipoprotein(a), which both hardened the
arteries and caused blood clots (Rath et al. 1990b). Linus Pauling recommended
the use of high doses of pure vitamin C and lysine to both prevent and
treat cardiovascular disease. Niacin, CoQ10, serine, and regular aerobic
exercise have also been shown to lower lipoprotein(a) (Cohn 1998; Singh
et al. 1999; Batiste et al. 2002).
Hypothyroidism
The endocrine system is a complex mechanism in which each organ impacts
the function of other organs. A low-functioning thyroid (hypothyroidism)
would therefore impact other systems, including the cardiovascular system.
Hypothyroidism is associated with increased cholesterol levels, atherosclerosis,
and increased homocysteine (Carantoni et al. 1997; Diekman et al. 1998;
Nedrebo et al. 1998; Hussein et al. 1999; Hak et al. 2000; Kahaly 2000;
Diekman et al. 2001). The effect of hypothyroidism on the blood clotting
system is currently controversial and is the focus of several studies
(Chadarevian et al. 1998; Muller et al. 2001).
For additional information about hypothyroidism, see the Thyroid Replacement
Therapy protocol.
COMPREHENSIVE LABORATORY
TESTING FOR CARDIOVASCULAR RISK
The Life Extension Foundation recommends that all of its members be
checked for cardiovascular risk with both conventional laboratory tests
and new markers such as CRP.
| 1. Standard Reference Ranges
and Optimal Levels |
| Blood Test |
Standard Reference Range |
Optimal Levels |
| Cholesterol |
100-199 mg/dL |
180-200 mg/dL |
| LDL cholesterol |
0-129 mg/dL |
Under 100 mg/dL |
| HDL cholesterol |
35-150 mg/dL |
55-150 mg/dL |
| Triglycerides |
0-199 mg/dL |
40-100 mg/dL |
| Glucose |
65-109 mg/dL |
70-100 mg/dL |
| Homocysteine |
5-15 micromol/L |
Under 7.0 micromol/L |
| Fibrinogen |
200-460 mg/dL |
200-300 mg/dL |
| CRP |
Up to 4.9 mg/L |
Under 2 mg/L; preferably under 1.3 mg/L |
DHEA |
Men: over 80 mcg/dL
Women: over 35 mcg/dL |
Men: 400-500 mcg/dL
Women: 350-430 mcg/d |
Furthermore, optimal ranges of these laboratory tests are much narrower
than the standard reference ranges used in conventional medicine. It is
important to emphasize that the "average" person has a high
risk of developing a thrombotic-related disease. For health-conscious
people, this dismal fate is unacceptable.
CONSULTING YOUR PHYSICIAN
When over-the-counter supplements, such as aspirin, vitamins, herbs,
and oils are used as primary antithrombotic therapy, the risk of undesirable
side effects is reduced significantly. However, although over-the-counter
medications such as aspirin and natural therapies come with a lower risk
of hemorrhaging, they should not be substituted for prescription medication
if you are at a high risk for thrombosis. Some common conditions that
cause a high risk of thrombosis include atrial fibrillation, valvular
replacement, recurrent or chronic deep venous thrombosis, pulmonary embolism,
and cancer.
Because appropriate therapeutic dosing is crucial and the associated
risks can be life-threatening in all circumstances that require anticoagulation
therapy or antiplatelet therapy, your physician must be consulted if you
desire to make any substitutions to your medication. Because medications,
such as Coumadin and heparin, have very narrow therapeutic ranges, anyone
on these medications should have his or her blood tested frequently for
prothrombin using the INR as a reference range. Once the effective dose
is achieved, blood testing is recommended every 1-2 weeks to monitor the
medication blood levels and to avoid overdosing, which could lead to hemorrhaging.
In addition to the INR values, template bleeding time should also be closely
monitored if any over-the-counter drugs or natural supplements that affect
the clotting cascade are added to the regimen. Some of these supplements
include vitamin E, ginkgo biloba, CoQ10, garlic, ginseng, green tea, vitamin
C, vitamin A, policosanol, Dong Quai, white willow, ipriflavone, and vinpocetine
(periwinkle).
NUTRITIONAL SUPPLEMENTS
The nutritional supplements listed below have been scientifically studied
specifically for their ability to reduce the risk of thrombosis. The bulk
of the research focuses on inhibiting platelet aggregation. The supplements
are divided into several broad categories based on their primary actions:
- Cholesterol-lowering supplements
- Natural platelet aggregation inhibitors
- Homocysteine-lowering supplements
- Anti-inflammatories
- Antioxidants
- Sulfur-containing compounds
Note: The
supplements in the natural blood thinners category could easily have been
put into other categories. Ginkgo and vitamin E, for instance, are very
powerful antioxidants. Essential fatty acids are also known for their
anti-inflammatory actions. However, their blood-thinning effects are much
more important in the prevention of thrombosis.
Other protocols contain further information on specific topics. (For
research on supplements that increase fibrinolysis, see the Fibrinogen
section of the Cardiovascular Disease
protocol.)
Cholesterol-Lowering Supplements
Policosanol
Policosanol is a cholesterol-lowering agent derived from sugar cane wax.
In some cases, it can normalize cholesterol, as well as prescription drugs,
doing so without side effects.
The efficacy and safety of policosanol has been shown in numerous clinical
trials. It has been used by millions of people in other countries. Policosanol
can lower LDL cholesterol as much as 20% and raise protective HDL cholesterol
by 10%. This compares favorably with some cholesterol-lowering drugs that
can cause side effects such as liver dysfunction and muscle atrophy (Mas
et al. 1999).
Policosanol works by blocking the synthesis of cholesterol. It may not
inhibit the HMG-CoA enzyme like the "statin" cholesterol-lowering
drugs. Instead, it may inhibit a different enzyme involved in cholesterol
synthesis. However, its exact mechanism is not known. Like statin drugs,
policosanol helps stop the formation of atherosclerotic lesions, which
was proven in studies using rabbits fed a diet designed to create high
cholesterol (Noa et al. 1995).
Policosanol inhibits the formation of clots and may work synergistically
with aspirin in this respect. In a comparison of aspirin and policosanol,
aspirin was better at reducing one type of platelet aggregation (clumping
together of blood cells) and policosanol was better at inhibiting another
type. Together, policosanol and aspirin worked better than either one
alone (Arruzazabala et al. 1997; Stusser et al. 1998).
An article in the journal Pharmacology Research described a randomized,
double-blind, placebo-controlled study of policosanal and aspirin. Participants
received either policosanol (20 mg daily), aspirin (100 mg daily), a combination
of both, or placebo for 7 days. The effects on platelet aggregation are
summarized above (Arruzazabala et al. 1997). A related effect is that
significant reductions in the level of thromboxane (a blood vessel-constricting
eicosanoid produced by platelets) occur in humans after 2 weeks of policosanol
(Carbajal et al. 1998).
| Reduction of Platelet Aggregation
by Aspirin and Policosanol |
| Induced by |
Policosanol |
Aspirin |
Combination |
| ADP |
37.3% |
* |
** |
| Epinephrine |
32.6% |
21.9% |
57.5% |
| Collagen |
40.5% |
61.4% |
71.3% |
* No significant reduction
** Value not reported |
The normal dose of policosanol is 10-20 mg taken at bedtime. Cholesterol
levels should be measured regularly because both high and low cholesterol
levels are considered unhealthy. Consider using aspirin (81 mg daily)
in combination with policosanol.
Aged Garlic
Aged garlic has become a well-known, popular supplement for the cardiovascular
system. Garlic has been found to increase the synthesis of nitric oxide,
a chemical messenger that inhibits platelet aggregation and vasodilates
blood vessels (Das et al. 1995; Dirsch et al. 1998; Kim-Park et al. 2000;
Kim et al. 2001).
An article in the journal Nutrition described a randomized, double-blind
study of aged garlic on normal, healthy individuals. The researchers found
that aged garlic inhibited platelet adherence and aggregation. Higher
doses (7.2 grams daily) had a more profound effect than lower doses (2.4
grams daily) (Steiner et al. 2001).
The specific effects of aged garlic have been the subject of several
studies. Aged garlic has been shown to inhibit platelet aggregation by
ADP, epinephrine, and collagen, although one study found that it did not
affect ADP-induced aggregation (Steiner et al. 1998; Rahman et al. 2000).
Another study examined the effects of consuming one fresh clove of garlic
every day on men. After 26 weeks of garlic consumption, there was an approximate
20% reduction of serum cholesterol and about 80% reduction in serum thromboxane
B2, a stable metabolite of thromboxane A2. Recall that thromboxane A2
is a platelet aggregator and vasoconstrictor secreted by platelets (Ali
et al. 1990, 1995).
Niacin
Niacin (vitamin B3) causes peripheral vasodilation (flushing) within about
20 minutes. Large doses of niacin (up to 6 grams daily) have been found
to lower cholesterol, raise HDL, and lower LDL and VLDL lipids. The safest
form of niacin is inositol hexa-nicotinate in the dose of 1600-2400 mg
daily. Individuals taking continuous high-dose niacin therapy need to
have their blood levels monitored for elevations in liver enzymes and
uric acid.
An article in the American Heart Journal described the Arterial Disease
Multiple Intervention Trial (ADMIT), a multicenter, randomized, placebo-controlled
trial to assess the feasibility of an antioxidant therapy on coagulation.
Patients with peripheral artery disease randomly received low-dose Coumadin,
niacin, an antioxidant vitamin cocktail, or placebo. Unexpectedly, the
niacin treatment resulted in a significant decrease in fibrinogen (Chesney
et al. 2000).
Natural Platelet Aggregation Inhibitors
Ginkgo Biloba
Ginkgo biloba extract is made from the leaves of the oldest living tree.
Ginkgo biloba has a long history of medicinal use. It has become a very
popular herb to help improve memory, particularly in the elderly.
Ginkgo biloba has been shown to inhibit platelet aggregation induced
by platelet-activating factor (PAF), but not by oxidative stress (Akiba
et al. 1998).
An article in the journal Thrombosis Research described a study of the
effects of ginkgo biloba in combination with ticlopidine when used to
treat rats with experimentally induced thrombosis. The combination of
ginkgo biloba (40 mg/kg daily) and a small dose of ticlopidine (50 mg/kg
daily) was shown to be comparable to a large dose of only ticlopidine
(200 mg/kg daily). The combination also prolonged bleeding time by 150%
and consistently decreased the thrombus weight (Kim et al. 1998).
Essential Fatty Acids
Essential fatty acids are found in healthy oils, such as flax, borage,
perilla, and fish oils. Essential fatty acids are termed "essential"
because they are necessary for life. Essential fatty acids, including
DHA (docosahexaenoic acid) and EPA (eicosapentaenoic acid), are known
to inhibit platelet aggregation and are included as potential contraindications
for use with anticoagulant (warfarin) therapy. The contraindication is
actually more of a strong caution to avoid thinning the blood too much.
What this means is that if a patient on Coumadin does take fish oil supplements,
the TBT test should be done in addition to checking the INR reference
range.
Several studies examined the antiplatelet mechanisms of essential fatty
acids like EPA and DHA and showed they inhibited collagen- and arachidonic
acid-induced platelet aggregation. No effects were seen in thrombin-induced
aggregation. The mechanism was related to the ability of these fatty acids
to suppress thromboxane A2 formation by inhibiting cyclooxygenase-1 (Ikeda
et al. 1998; Akiba et al. 2000).
An Australian study found that omega-3 fatty acids (those rich in alpha-linolenic
acid, such as flaxseed and perilla oils) were more effective than omega-6
fatty acids (those rich in linoleic acid, such as sunflower oil) (Allman
et al. 1995). This same result was also reported in a German study which
found that an omega-3 to omega-6 ratio of 15:1 caused a significant decrease
of collagen-induced platelet aggregation (Stroh et al. 1991).
Vitamin E
Vitamin E (tocopherol) is a potent antioxidant that has been shown to
increase prostaglandin I2 synthesis, one of the platelet aggregation inhibitors
and vasodilators. Vitamin E is depleted by estrogen, birth control pills,
and chlorine.
A study found that vitamin E was able to inhibit collagen-induced platelet
aggregation at concentrations achievable in blood after supplementation.
The researchers also isolated a mechanism by which vitamin E blunts hydrogen
peroxide formation, which then mediates arachidonic acid metabolism and
phospholipase C activation in platelet aggregation induced by collagen
(Pignatelli et al. 1999).
Caution: If
vitamin E is used with Coumadin, the template bleeding time test should
be done by the physician to guard against risk of hemorrhage.
Vitamin K
Vitamin K plays a unique role in the clotting system by contributing to
both coagulation and anticoagulation. Vitamin K is a precursor of coagulation
factors II, VII, IX, and X. Vitamin K is also a cofactor for the synthesis
of proteins C and S. Protein C is a proteolytic enzyme that acts as an
anticoagulant by inactivating clotting factors V and VIII and by increasing
production of tissue plasminogen activator.
An article in the journal Lancet recommended that asymptomatic patients
on Coumadin should consider low-dose vitamin K if blood-clotting time,
as measured by the INR, is 4.5-10.0. The article described a multicenter,
double-blind, placebo-controlled, randomized trial in which patients received
either a placebo or 1 mg of vitamin K orally. Patients given vitamin K
had a more rapid decrease in the INR than those given placebo, and fewer
of them had bleeding episodes during the follow-up period. The authors
concluded that low-dose vitamin K therapy rapidly lowers INR values in
patients taking Coumadin and may be effective in preventing hemorrhage
(one of the common side effects of Coumadin therapy) (Crowther et al.
1998, 2000).
Vitamin K counteracts the action of Coumadin and is strictly contraindicated
in patients on anticoagulant drug therapy. The Life Extension Foundation
recommends the use of 10 mg daily of vitamin K in healthy individuals.
Lowering Homocysteine
Homocysteine has slowly become accepted in conventional medicine as a
risk factor for cardiovascular disease. Clinical research has shown that
some vitamins (folic acid and vitamins B6 and B12) are very effective
at lowering homocysteine levels. It has been proposed that homocysteine
activates the blood clotting system by damaging endothelial cells.
An article in Thrombosis Research described a study of 11 persons with
high homocysteine levels who had atherosclerosis. After an 8-week treatment
with folic acid (5 mg daily, orally), vitamin B6 (300 mg daily, orally),
and vitamin B12 (1000 mcg weekly, intramuscularly), homocysteine levels
dropped from an average of 20 to 10. Vitamin treatment was also associated
with a significant decrease in the markers of thrombin formation, including
thrombin-antithrombin III complexes and prothrombin fragment 1+2 concentrations
in peripheral venous blood. Bleeding time became prolonged by about 60
seconds (Undas et al. 1999).
The Life Extension Foundation strongly recommends that homocysteine
levels be measured. Supplementation with vitamins B6 and B12 and folic
acid are recommended to lower homocysteine levels.
Anti-Inflammatories
Curcumin
Curcumin is the Latin name for the common yellow spice known as turmeric.
Curcumin is commonly used for its anti-inflammatory effects. Curcumin
has also been shown to lower cholesterol.
Research has examined the mechanism of the antiplatelet action of curcumin
(turmeric). Curcumin was shown to inhibit platelet aggregation induced
by ephedrine, ADP, platelet-activating factor (PAF), collagen, and arachidonic
acid. Curcumin acted most strongly against aggregation by PAF and arachidonic
acid. The mechanism appeared to be related to curcumin's inhibition of
thromboxane A2 (Shah et al. 1999). Curcumin should be taken with meals
to avoid the possibility of gastric irritation. The daily dose for most
people is 900 mg with 5 mg of bioperine to enhance assimilation.
DHEA
DHEA has been shown to inhibit inflammatory cytokines (Straub et al. 2000).
With reduced inflammation, less platelet aggregation and LDL migration
into the vessel walls occurs. This can lead to less thrombus formation
and atherosclerosis. DHEA also competitively inhibits cortisol, the other
main adrenal steroid (Boudarene et al. 2002). If cortisol levels are high,
DHEA may be depleted leading to immune deficiencies and reduced muscle
mass. High cortisol also worsens responses to stress.
Nettle Leaf (Urtica Dioica)
In Germany, nettle leaf is an herb with a long tradition of use as an
adjuvant remedy in the treatment of arthritis. It has also been used extensively
in the treatment of allergies. Nettle leaf extract has been found to contain
a variety of active compounds, such as cyclooxygenase and lipoxygenase
inhibitors, and substances that affect cytokine secretion (Obertreis et
al. 1996a; 1996b; Teucher et al. 1996).
Cytokines are proteins that carry messages between cells and regulate
immunity and inflammation. Two cytokines, tumor necrosis factor alpha
(TNF-a) and interleukin-one-beta (IL-1b), are examples of pro-inflammatory
cytokines (Pinto et al. 1999). These cytokines have been found to be elevated
in patients with allergies and arthritis. In animal models, it was shown
that inhibition of TNF-a results in decreased inflammation, while inhibition
of IL-1b effectively prevents cartilage destruction (Probert et al. 1995).
Nettle leaf reduces TNF-a levels by potently inhibiting the genetic
transcription factor that activates IL-lb and TNF-a. This pro-inflammatory
transcription factor, nuclear factor kappa beta ( NF-kb), is known to
be elevated in chronic inflammatory diseases and is essential to activation
of TNF-a. Nettle leaf is also thought to work by preventing degradation
of the natural inhibitor of NF-kb in the body (Riehemann et al. 1999).
In vessels, reduction of inflammatory cytokines (such as TNF-a) also reduces
platelet aggregation and the tendencies toward thrombus formation.
Antioxidants
Quercetin and Catechin
Quercetin and catechin (from green tea) are bioflavonoids with strong
antioxidant properties. Quercetin is primarily used for its beneficial
effects on allergies.
An article in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition found that
catechin and quercetin inhibited collagen-induced platelet adhesion. The
authors proposed that the effects may be due to the ability of catechin
and quercetin to decrease hydrogen peroxide production (Pignatelli et
al. 2000). Quercetin may also inhibit platelet aggregation by its antioxidant
properties (Xie et al. 1996).
Another study examined the inhibition of thrombin-induced platelet aggregation
by a semisynthetic derivative of quercetin. The authors found that quercetin
inhibited platelet aggregation by reducing calcium mobilization and influx
(Liu et al. 1999, 2000).
Green Tea
Green tea has become very popular for the prevention and treatment of
a wide range of diseases. Green tea protects the cardiovascular system
and might prevent cancer.
A study in the journal Thrombosis Research examined the effects of green
tea tannins and epigallocatechin on platelet aggregation. Both substances
inhibited platelet aggregation induced by ADP and collagen in rats. They
also inhibited platelet aggregation induced by ADP, collagen, and epinephrine
in human blood samples (Kang et al. 1999).
In rabbits, Japanese researchers found that green tea inhibited aggregation
of platelets. The researchers noted that epigallocatechin suppressed collagen-induced
platelet aggregation. Epigallocatechin also inhibited platelet aggregation
induced by thrombin and platelet-activating factor (PAF) (Sagesaka-Mitane
et al. 1990).
Tomatoes
Lycopene, found in tomatoes, has been shown to have strong antioxidant
properties. Lycopene may be particularly effective in blocking the oxidation
of LDL cholesterol.
An article in the journal Platelets described a study of fruits and
their effect on human platelet aggregation in vitro. Researchers found
that tomato extract inhibited both ADP- and collagen-induced aggregation
by up to 70%. The antiplatelet components were found to be concentrated
in the yellow fluid around the seeds in tomatoes. Grapefruit, melon, and
strawberry were also found to have antiplatelet activity, but to a lesser
extent (Dutta-Roy et al. 2001).
Grape Juice
Grapes have gained popularity as a result of several studies that found
that consuming 1 cup of red wine daily had beneficial effects on the cardiovascular
system. Grapes contain proanthrocyanadins, which are concentrated in the
seeds and skin and impart the blue color. Studies have shown that the
antioxidant power of grape seed-skin extract is 50 times greater than
vitamin E and 20 times greater than vitamin C.
An article in the journal Circulation described a study that
examined the effects of purple grape juice on platelets. Laboratory tests
(in vitro) found that purple grape juice inhibited platelet aggregation,
increased nitric oxide production, and decreased superoxide formation.
The researchers then conducted a study with 20 healthy subjects who consumed
7 mL/kg daily of purple grape juice for 14 days. Purple grape juice supplementation
inhibited platelet aggregation, increased platelet nitric oxide production,
and decreased superoxide formation. The authors proposed that purple grape
juice may have beneficial effects in cardiovascular disease (Freedman
et al. 2001).
An article in the journal Nutrition described a study in which 10 healthy
subjects drank 5-7.5 mL/kg daily of purple grape juice, grapefruit juice,
or orange juice for 1 week. Drinking purple grape juice reduced platelet
aggregation by 77%. Orange and grapefruit juice had no effect. The authors
proposed that the flavonoids in grape juice may decrease the risk of thrombosis
(Keevil et al. 2000).
Sulfur-Containing Compounds
N-Acetyl-L-Cysteine
The amino acid N-acetyl-L-cysteine (NAC) inhibits platelet aggregation
by several mechanisms, including:
- Increasing the antiplatelet aggregating effects of L-arginine, which
promotes endogenous synthesis of nitric oxide (Anfossi et al. 1999,
2001). Increases in nitric oxide cause arterial vasodilation increasing
blood flow to the heart and brain in coronary artery disease or cerebral
ischemia. However, in doing so, nitric oxide generates the free radical
nitric peroxide, which is best quenched by gamma tocopherol, a fraction
of vitamin E. A recommended protocol for arterial vasodilation includes
the use of gamma tocopherol (200-400 IU) in combination with L-arginine
(1800-3600 mg) 2-4 times daily, and NAC (250 mg) 3 times daily. This
combination may lower blood pressure as well.
- Affecting platelet-derived growth factor, a key player in fibrosis
(Durante et al. 1999; Okuyama et al. 2001).
NAC is an antioxidant that is helpful in breaking up pulmonary and bronchial
mucus. NAC is also a precursor of glutathione.
Onions
Onion juice has been shown to reduce in vitro human platelet aggregation.
To retain their health benefits, onions should be eaten raw or lightly
steamed because high heat deactivates the active ingredients.
The antiplatelet aggregation action of onions is attributed to sulfur
compounds called thiosulfonates. The strongest thiosulfonates are allicin,
propyl propane thiosulfonate, and ethyl ethane thiosulfonate. All three
of these thiosulfonate compounds were shown to be significantly more potent
platelet aggregators than aspirin at nearly equivalent doses (Briggs et
al. 2000).
In a study using 9-week-old rats, the antithrombotic effects of Welsh
onion juice was examined. Two days after treatment (2 g/kg daily), the
raw Welsh onion juice consumption significantly lowered systolic blood
pressure, prolonged bleeding time, and diminished platelet adhesion as
compared to controls. The authors also found that boiled onion juice had
no effect (Chen et al. 2000).
An article in the journal Nutrition described a study in dogs in which
onion juice was administered 20 minutes after the coronary arteries were
mechanically damaged (narrowed). Treatment with onion juice reversed the
induced cyclic flow reduction within 2.5-3 hours in all five of the treated
dogs. The authors concluded that onion juice might help prevent platelet-mediated
cardiovascular disorders, but also noted that the effects might be greater
in dogs than in humans (Briggs et al. 2001).
Exercise
The effects of exercise on fibrinogen levels have been extensively studied.
Several studies demonstrate that regular exercise lowers fibrinogen levels
and reduces the risk of thrombosis (El-Sayed et al. 1999; 2000; Koenig
et al. 2000; Imhof et al. 2001; Verissimo et al. 2001).
Regular exercise is also well known to provide a host of other health
benefits, particularly for the cardiovascular system.
Prevention of blood clots is a complex task involving maintenance of
a fine balance between the process of coagulation and anticoagulation.
Patients on prescription medications (e.g., Coumadin), as well as those
who combine Coumadin with over-the-counter anti-inflammatories or aspirin,
need close monitoring, in particular weekly or biweekly testing of their
prothrombin using the INR and the TBT test. Patients taking supplements
(such as vitamins, herbs, or oils) should also have their thrombotic risk
factors evaluated in the same way. However, close monitoring of coagulation
balance is usually not necessary in people who are otherwise healthy.
Caution: Never
change an anticoagulation medication without physician approval: thrombosis,
bleeding, and sudden death can occur.
The Life Extension Foundation recommends a comprehensive approach to
preventing thrombosis with a full assessment of cardiovascular health
(including the presence of hypertension and atherosclerosis) and levels
of homocysteine, fibrinogen, and cholesterol. A thrombosis prevention
protocol fits well with an overall approach to wellness including a healthy
diet and regular exercise. Smoking is a well-known risk factor for chronic
disease and should be avoided.
Thrombosis prevention involves several diverse mechanisms. Several laboratory
tests are recommended to assess the cardiovascular system and guide appropriate
treatment, including cholesterol and triglyceride levels, homocysteine,
template bleeding time, fibrinogen, and CRP (see the protocols on Medical
Testing, Cardiovascular Disease, Stroke, and Diabetes for specific recommendations).
The following supplements have demonstrated antithrombotic action by
lowering cholesterol, fibrinogen, and homocysteine; suppressing inflammation;
and by inhibiting platelet aggregation.
- Low-dose aspirin is widely recommended to help prevent abnormal platelet
aggregation, thus reducing heart attack and stroke risk. The Life Extension
Foundation recommends Healthprin, which contains 81 mg of enterically
coated aspirin. One tablet daily is recommended for its anticlotting
and anti-inflammatory effects. Some people may require more than 81
mg of aspirin daily, which can be determined by a TBT.
- Garlic inhibits thrombosis by multiple mechanisms. Garlic is available
in supplement form as Kyolic one-per-day caplets that supply 1000 mg
of odorless garlic. One to two caplets daily is suggested. Another form
of garlic is Pure-Gar Caps (900 mg garlic powder) or Pure-Gar with EDTA
(a chelating agent). Two to four of these garlic capsules are recommended
daily.
- Essential fatty acids GLA (from borage oil), DHA and EPA (from fish
oil). The most efficient way of obtaining all three of these antithrombotic
fatty acids is to take 6 capsules a day of a supplement called Super
GLA/DHA.
- Vitamin E is an antioxidant and platelet aggregation inhibitor. The
recommended dose for most people is 400 IU of alpha tocopheryl succinate,
200 mg of gamma tocopherol, and at least 50 mg of tocotrienols. Vitamin
E with gamma tocopherol is essential when taking arginine, nitroglycerin,
iso-sorbide mononitrate, or other nitrate medications.
- Homocysteine can also be lowered by vitamins B6 and B12 and folic
acid. For vitamin B6, 100-750 mg daily is recommended. Folic acid should
only be taken in the dose of 800-2400 mcg with at least 1000 mcg of
vitamin B12 to prevent masking a B12 deficiency. Trimethylglycine also
lowers homocysteine levels (see the Cardiovascular Disease protocol
for more information). TMG tablets contain 500 mg of trimethylglycine.
One to five tablets daily are recommended. TMG Powder is also available.
One scoop contains 500 mg of trimethylglycine. Two to five scoops daily
are recommended.
- Fibrinogen levels may be lowered by taking at least 2000 mg of vitamin
C; 1000 mg of niacin; and 2000 mg of bromelain or by using a fish oil
supplement that provides 5600 mg of EPA and 3200 mg of DHA.
- Curcumin is well known for its anti-inflammatory action. It has also
been shown to inhibit platelet aggregation. One 900-mg capsule with
5 mg of bioperine daily is recommended for healthy people. Curcumin
should be used with caution in patients with biliary tract obstruction
because it stimulates secretion of cholesterol bile acids from the liver
through the bile duct into the intestines. High doses of curcumin on
an empty stomach may contribute to stomach ulcers or gastric irritation.
- DHEA has been shown to suppress certain inflammatory cytokines that
cause elevated levels of CRP. Typical dosing for men and women is 25-50
mg daily. Refer to DHEA Replacement Therapy protocol for information
and precautions.
- Nettle leaf extract reduces inflammatory cyto-kines, which increase
platelet aggregation that can lead to thrombosis. A dose of at least
1000 mg daily is suggested.
- Quercetin is an antiplatelet agent. About 100-500 mg daily of highly
absorbable water-soluble quercetin is suggested.
- Green tea inhibits several factors involved in abnormal platelet
aggregation. Green tea extract is available in 350-mg capsules and in
300-mg decaffeinated capsules for persons who are sensitive to caffeine.
Two to four capsules daily is recommended for healthy people. Higher
amounts may be taken to further reduce thrombotic risk. Green tea is
best taken with meals. Green tea is also available in bulk leaf or in
tea bags for those who want to brew and drink the tea.
- Tomatoes have been shown to inhibit platelet aggregation. Lycopene,
the main constituent of tomatoes, is a powerful antioxidant. Lycopene
is available in supplement form: 10-30 mg a day is suggested.
- Policosanol has been shown to lower cholesterol, inhibit platelet
aggregation, and prevent thrombosis. Policosanol Tabs usually contain
10 mg of policosanol. To achieve optimal cholesterol levels, the normal
dose is usually 10-20 mg taken daily at bedtime. Monitor cholesterol
levels regularly because levels below 150-180 can be dangerous.
PRODUCT AVAILABILITY
Policosanol,
Super Ginkgo
Extract, Vitamin
E, Gamma
E Tocopherol/Tocotrienols, Essential
Fatty Acids (Super
GLA/DHA, perilla
oil, flaxseed
oil), DHEA,
trimethylglycine,
methylcobalamin
(B12), folic
acid, vitamin
B6, vitamin
C, bromelain,
Kyolic Garlic,
Pure-Gar,
Super K,
Healthprin
(low-dose aspirin), quercetin,
curcumin,
green
tea extract, Super
Lycopene, grape
seed-skin extract, and Life
Extension Mix are available by calling (800) 544-4440 or by ordering
online.
|